Marios Pizza

- 596 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590

## Introduction / Overview

For decades, Mario's Pizza in Westbury has stood as one of Long Island’s most reliable and beloved pizzerias. As a true local institution, Mario's has cultivated a reputation among New Yorkers for delivering not just authentic New York-style pizza, but also a full array of Italian-American classics, all served with impressive value and generous portions. Located centrally in Nassau County, it’s a destination for hungry customers seeking quality, consistency, and a comfortable, familiar dining experience.

This establishment has deep roots in the Long Island community, with the family committed to providing top-quality meals and great service for over 48 years—a significant achievement in the highly competitive New York pizza landscape. The focus here is on classic preparation, with dough made fresh daily in-house and a dedication to using 100% real cheese across their menu. This commitment to fresh ingredients is noticeable in every bite, from their traditional Neapolitan and Sicilian pies to their inventive gourmet specialties.

Customers consistently praise Mario’s for its "awesome selection and great quality food," noting that the portions are generous and the value is excellent. Whether you are craving a simple, perfect cheese slice, or a hearty Italian entree, Mario's Pizza offers a comprehensive menu that ensures there is something to satisfy every member of the family or office. It’s more than just a slice shop; it is a full-service Italian kitchen beloved by the Westbury area.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Mario's Pizza boasts a highly convenient location for the Long Island community, making it easy to access for dine-in, pick-up, or delivery. The restaurant is situated on a major Nassau County thoroughfare:

The specific address is 596 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, USA.

The location on Old Country Road places it right in the middle of a bustling commercial area, easily reachable by car from various points across Long Island. It is close to major shopping destinations and business complexes, making it a perfect spot for a quick lunch break or a convenient dinner stop after a busy day. While parking availability may vary during peak hours, the Westbury location is well-known and frequented by locals, often serving as a landmark itself. Furthermore, its proximity to major parkways allows for efficient travel and smooth access for delivery drivers covering a wide local area. For New Yorkers in the surrounding neighborhoods like Garden City, Carle Place, and Hicksville, Mario's is a quick drive away, solidifying its status as a neighborhood essential.

---

## Services Offered

Mario’s Pizza offers a full suite of services that cater to the fast-paced life of Long Island residents, ensuring that their delicious Italian-American fare is available whenever and wherever it is needed.

• Dine-In Service: Providing a casual, clean area for customers to sit, eat, and enjoy their meal fresh from the oven, offering that nostalgic pizza parlor experience.
• Takeout and Pick-Up: Fast and efficient service for customers ordering ahead by phone or online for quick retrieval.
• Delivery: Extensive delivery services available through their own staff and popular third-party apps, ensuring fast and reliable food delivery to homes and offices throughout the Westbury area. Office complexes frequently use this service, attesting to its speed and dependability.
• Online Ordering: Customers can easily view the full menu and place orders digitally for both pickup and delivery, providing a seamless and modern ordering experience.
• Catering Services: Mario’s specializes in catering, offering full-service options for any event or party size. Their catering menu includes half and full trays of appetizers, salads, pasta dishes (like Baked Penne and Lasagna), and entrees (such as Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Rollatini), making them an ideal "party helper" for local gatherings.
• Gluten-Free and Specialty Options: The menu includes options like Gluten Free Crust Pizza and Cauliflower Crust Pizza to accommodate various dietary preferences, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice.
• Wide Menu Selection: From classic New York slices and gourmet pizza to Italian hero sandwiches, paninis, calzones, robust pasta casseroles, chicken, veal, and seafood entrees, they offer an extensive, traditional Italian-American dining experience.

---

## Features / Highlights

Mario's Pizza has several distinctive features that have secured its place as a Westbury favorite, highlighting its dedication to quality, tradition, and customer experience.

• Iconic Specialty Pizzas: The selection of gourmet pies is a major draw. Notable favorites praised by customers include the Caesar Salad Pizza (described as "actually really good") and the spicy and savory Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Other unique offerings include the Penne Alla Vodka Pizza and the Grandma Pizza.
• Generous Portions and Value: A consistent highlight in customer feedback is the "portions and value." Customers often note that "one slice was enough," indicating that the size of their portions is substantial, offering great bang for your buck, a key concern for local families.
• Extensive Gourmet and Classic Menu: Unlike many slice shops, Mario’s offers a huge variety of choices. Beyond pizza, they excel with classic Italian-American entrees like Chicken Parmigiana, Shrimp Francaise, and Veal Marsala, earning praise for the quality of these cooked dishes as well.
• The Nostalgic Experience: Many loyal patrons refer to it as "the pizza of my youth," confirming that Mario's has remained a consistent, comforting, and high-quality spot that evokes positive, lifelong memories for Long Islanders.
• Friendly Front-of-House Staff: Customers specifically mention that "the guys at the front are super nice," indicating a warm, professional service experience that makes ordering a pleasure.
• Commitment to Freshness: The use of 100% real cheese and dough made fresh daily on the premises underpins the quality of their primary product, the pizza.

---

## Contact Information

Whether you are ordering your favorite specialty slice or arranging a large catering order, here is the essential contact information for Mario's Pizza in Westbury:

Address: 596 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, USA

Phone: (516) 997-3000

Mobile Phone: +1 516-997-3000

---

## What is Worth Choosing

For New York locals searching for a reliable, high-quality Italian meal on Long Island, Mario's Pizza in Westbury is unquestionably worth choosing for several compelling reasons that resonate with the regional dining culture. You should choose Mario’s when you need a place that perfectly balances a time-honored tradition of pizza-making with an expansive, modern menu that suits all occasions.

Firstly, the sheer variety offered makes it an easy choice for any outing or order. Few pizzerias can deliver a spot-on classic Neapolitan pie, a crowd-pleasing Buffalo Chicken slice, and a full-scale Chicken Parmigiana dinner with equal quality. The rave reviews for their specialty pizzas, particularly the unexpected success of the Caesar Salad Pizza, show their willingness to innovate while maintaining quality, proving they are masters of their craft.

Secondly, the outstanding value and generous portions are critical for local New York families and businesses. Mario’s delivers on the promise of a satisfying meal that does not break the bank. Their reputation for fast, friendly service is another significant factor, with office staff relying on them for frequent deliveries due to their efficiency. The sense of community and nostalgia that patrons feel—the feeling that this is "the pizza of my youth"—solidifies its position as a cultural touchstone in Westbury.

Finally, the commitment to fresh, real ingredients, coupled with decades of consistent service since 1969, establishes Mario's as a pillar of Long Island’s culinary scene. Choosing Mario's Pizza means opting for an authentic, time-tested Italian-American experience that has earned its reputation through consistent quality and a deep understanding of what local New Yorkers truly crave.

Marios Pizza

596 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, USA