Martino's Pizza of Elmont

- 1411 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003

For decades, New York residents have known that the best Italian food, especially pizza, often comes from long-standing, family-run local establishments. Martino's Pizza of Elmont is the quintessential example of this tradition on Long Island. Operating since 1984, this institution in Nassau County is celebrated for delivering not just pizza, but a full-spectrum dining experience that also includes robust pasta dishes and fresh seafood. Customers describe Martino’s as a "hidden gem of Elmont" and a source of "life-changing pizza," demonstrating its deep and loyal roots within the community.

This is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a “family place,” both literally and figuratively. Martino's prides itself on being family-owned and family-run, creating a welcoming environment where "everybody knows everyone." This commitment to a friendly, personal touch enhances the dining experience, making every visit feel like a return home. Their dedication to quality starts with the ingredients: all dishes are prepared with the Freshest Vegetables and Fish, the Finest quality Meats and Pasta, and are complemented by their Fresh Made Sauces and Imported Spices. Their pizza is a work of art, featuring a crispy, soft-textured dough, selected San Marzano tomatoes, and whole milk mozzarella cheese. They meticulously prepare their dough several times a day to maintain optimal freshness, body, flavor, and that desired airy texture, ensuring that the pizza is truly "old school New York Pizzeria pizza done right."

Martino's Pizza of Elmont is conveniently located at 1411 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003, USA. The prominent address on Hempstead Turnpike makes it easy to find and access for residents across Elmont and neighboring Long Island communities. Its location is a reliable anchor for authentic Italian food in Nassau County.

While specific on-site details regarding physical accessibility are not fully explicit, the restaurant caters to a broad range of customers through its robust service models. For customers visiting the location, the Hempstead Turnpike address provides a straightforward destination. As a well-established local fixture, the business hours are generally convenient, serving customers from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM Sunday through Thursday, and 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, though note that they are Closed on Tuesdays. This consistent schedule ensures that high-quality Italian food is available nearly every day of the week.

Martino’s Pizza of Elmont is committed to making its extensive menu accessible to everyone, whether they choose to dine in or enjoy their meal at home. Their service options leverage modern convenience while maintaining a high standard of food preparation.

• Delivery: The restaurant is known for its efficient delivery services, frequently ranking among the most popular pizza delivery spots in all of Elmont. Customers can easily order through major third-party platforms for convenience.
• Takeout: Perfect for those who prefer to pick up their order and enjoy it at home, their full menu of pizzas, pastas, and entrees is available for takeout.
• Catering and Large Orders: The extensive menu, which includes Specialty Pies and Seafood Medleys (including an option serving two for $65.95), suggests they are well-equipped to handle larger family orders or event catering needs, though this should be confirmed with the restaurant directly.
• Diverse Menu Options: Given their designation as a pizza, pasta, and seafood restaurant, they offer dining options suitable for lunch and dinner.
• Hours of Operation: Open six days a week, serving customers from late morning until 10 PM or 11 PM.

Martino's menu is comprehensive, covering every facet of classic Italian-American cuisine, with several standout features and customer favorites that have earned it a strong local reputation.

• World-Class Pizza Varieties: The core of their business is pizza, offering traditional Napoletan (The Regular Pie, 18 inches), Sicilian (The Square), and the popular Grandma Pie. Specialty pies are a major highlight, including the unique Taco Pizza (chopped meat, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese), Penne Alla Vodka Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pie, Margherita Pizza, and the impressive Stuffed Pizza (eggplant, meatballs, pepperoni, ricotta, mozzarella, and ham). The regular slice is praised for having a "delicious sauce and nice crisp crust," while the Taco slice is called "hands down the best in NY" by one enthusiastic reviewer.
• Exceptional Bread Basket: A recurring point of customer praise is the bread basket, described as "the best I've had" and a "sampling of pizzas and garlic knots," demonstrating a commitment to going above and beyond even with appetizers. The Garlic Knots themselves are available as a classic snack, baked and topped with butter, garlic, and parsley.
• Extensive Signature Pasta Menu: Martino’s is equally famous for its pasta. Customer favorites include Fettuccine Alfredo and Penne Alla Vodka (often ordered together), as well as specialty dishes like Lobster Ravioli Alla Vodka with Bacon ($30.95), Gnocchi Bolognese, and Stuffed Rigatoni Alla Vodka. They offer a variety of classic Baked Pastas, including Lasagna and Baked Ziti Parmigiana.
• Italian & Seafood Entrees: The menu features high-end Italian dishes and a selection of fresh seafood, distinguishing it from standard pizzerias. Entrees include various Chicken preparations (Parmigiana, Marsala, Francese, Cacciatore, etc.), and impressive Seafood Medley (shrimp, mussels, clams, and calamari over pasta) and Surf-N-Turf (shrimp and veal). Appetizers include fresh items like Baked Clams and Calamari Fritti.
• Savory Appetizers and Rolls: They offer a wide array of smaller bites, including various Pops (Pizza, Veggie, Ricotta) and Rolls (Chicken Roll), Rice Balls, and Pin Wheels filled with pepperoni or broccoli/mushroom.

To place an order for delivery or takeout, or to inquire about their menu, here is the essential contact information for this Elmont favorite:

Address: 1411 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003, USA

Phone: (516) 352-5463

Mobile Phone: +1 516-352-5463

For New York area residents seeking a consistently high-quality Italian meal, Martino's Pizza of Elmont is an undeniable choice, particularly for those in Nassau County. What truly makes Martino’s stand out is the combination of family-run authenticity and an extensive, high-quality menu. They are not simply a pizzeria; they are a full Italian dining experience that excels in multiple categories.

Choosing Martino's means guaranteeing a meal prepared with the freshest ingredients and house-made sauces, a standard they have maintained since 1984. The pizza is recognized for its old-school excellence—a crisp yet soft crust and delicious sauce that many locals consider to be among the best. Beyond pizza, the vast selection of baked and signature pastas, like the popular Penne Alla Vodka and specialty Lobster Ravioli, ensures that any craving for classic Italian fare can be satisfied. The welcoming, family-focused atmosphere, coupled with convenient services like delivery and takeout, removes any friction, making it an ideal choice for both a quick weeknight dinner and a major family gathering, such as a Father's Day celebration, which customers have happily noted turned into a two-weekend tradition. The exceptional bread basket, which serves as an unexpected and beloved starter, epitomizes their commitment to delighting the customer at every step. Martino's is an Elmont staple, highly recommended for a truly authentic and delicious local Italian experience.

Martino's Pizza of Elmont

1411 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003, USA