Mendelsohn's Pizza

- 4418 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in the know, especially those in Brooklyn's Borough Park neighborhood, Mendelsohn's Pizza is more than just a pizza place—it's a local institution. Since its founding in 1969 by Rabbi Meir and Malka Mendelsohn, this family-owned eatery has built a reputation for its commitment to community, quality, and timeless recipes. While the name highlights its famous pizza, Mendelsohn’s offers a sprawling menu that caters to virtually every taste and dining occasion, establishing it as a go-to spot for a quick bite or a full, casual meal.

This establishment has deep roots in the New York Kosher dining scene, providing a wide array of dairy-based comfort food, salads, and more, all under Orthodox Union (OU) supervision. It has evolved significantly from a simple takeout shop to a spacious, inviting modern dining spot, but the core—the secret-recipe pizza dough, classic ziti sauce, and signature pita—remains a carefully guarded trade secret. Mendelsohn's success is a testament to its blend of keeping tradition alive while expanding its culinary offerings to meet the diverse needs of the New York community. From college students to groups and tourists, the atmosphere is consistently welcoming, casual, and cozy.

It is important to note that the ownership has recently expanded its presence on 18th Avenue with a separate, adjacent upscale establishment called Cucina Modern Kitchen, which focuses on a more refined Mediterranean-Italian table service experience. This new venture, while separate, builds on the Mendelsohn's decades-long reputation for quality in the neighborhood, ensuring that whether you want a quick slice or a sit-down dinner, the family’s culinary heritage is at your service right here in Brooklyn.

Location and Accessibility

Mendelsohn's Pizza is conveniently located in the heart of Borough Park at 4418 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA. This location is easily accessible for local residents and visitors alike, being situated near essential community hubs. The area features both free and paid street parking options, which can be a significant convenience in a busy Brooklyn neighborhood. For those relying on public transportation, the restaurant is situated not far from the subway lines serving the Borough Park area.

A key highlight of the premises is its commitment to accessibility for all patrons. The restaurant provides a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring smooth entry and exit. Furthermore, dining comfort for all is prioritized with wheelchair accessible seating and a dedicated wheelchair accessible restroom.

Services Offered

Mendelsohn's Pizza provides a comprehensive set of services to accommodate various dining preferences and busy New York schedules. These services include:

• Onsite services: Enjoy the casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere inside the spacious dining area.
• Dine-in: Full-service dining is available with comfortable seating.
• Takeout: Fast and efficient service for customers picking up their orders to enjoy elsewhere.
• Delivery: Convenient delivery is offered through various platforms to bring Mendelsohn's right to your door.
• Catering: Specialized catering services are available for group events, parties, and family gatherings.
• Counter service: Quick and friendly service for slices and fast-casual items.
• Dining options for all meals: The restaurant is popular for providing excellent choices for breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner, as well as dessert.

Features / Highlights

Beyond its primary offerings, Mendelsohn's Pizza is known for several key features that set it apart in the competitive Brooklyn dining landscape:

• Great coffee: A popular highlight, ensuring a satisfying start to the day or an excellent end to a meal.
• Serves local specialty: While famous for its New York-style pizza, the menu includes long-standing, unique recipes like their traditional ziti, famous falafel, fresh fish dishes, and secret-recipe pita.
• Extensive menu offerings: The kitchen provides a huge variety of options, including Comfort food, Healthy options, Quick bite items, a Salad bar, Small plates, and accommodating Vegan options and Vegetarian options.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is good for kids, hosts kids' birthdays, and provides high chairs and a dedicated kids' menu.
• Crowd appeal: A comfortable spot for a diverse crowd, including college students, groups, and tourists looking for authentic Kosher dining.
• Pet Policy: Dogs are allowed on the premises, both inside and outside, a welcoming policy for local dog owners.
• Flexible Payment: Accepts all major payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Contact Information

For New York residents looking to visit, order, or inquire about catering, here is the essential contact information for Mendelsohn's Pizza:

Address: 4418 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA

Phone: (718) 854-0600

Mobile Phone: +1 718-854-0600 (The number is consistent across both phone formats)

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Mendelsohn's Pizza is a decision to embrace decades of culinary tradition fused with modern, expansive offerings. It stands out in the New York food scene for its unique position as a full-service, Kosher dairy restaurant that goes far beyond the typical pizzeria model. It is particularly worth choosing for several reasons.

First, the sheer variety and quality of the menu are exceptional for a pizza shop. While the classic New York pizza, with its secret-recipe dough and sauce, is a must-try, the extensive range of other dishes is where Mendelsohn's truly shines. Customer reviews often praise the freshness of the fish, the perfectly prepared salads from the salad bar, and the great falafel, indicating a dedication to quality across the board. The inclusion of dishes like baked ziti, eggplant parmesan, and even a full sushi menu offers a unique dining flexibility.

Second, the friendly, consistent service and clean environment are frequently highlighted by long-time patrons. The professional yet friendly staff behind the counter create a welcoming environment that makes it an ideal spot for taking lunch guests or enjoying a solo meal. The constant efforts to keep the place clean contribute significantly to a comfortable dining experience.

Finally, the restaurant's commitment to accessibility and community focus makes it a highly inclusive choice. Whether you need a wheelchair accessible location, are dining with children and need high chairs, or are simply looking for a quick, wholesome meal that adheres to strict Kosher standards, Mendelsohn's Pizza is built to accommodate. The historical significance, paired with the continually evolving menu and modern ambiance (including its connection to the adjacent, upscale Cucina Modern Kitchen), cements Mendelsohn's as a foundational, reliable, and celebrated dining destination for New Yorkers in the Brooklyn area.

Mendelsohn's Pizza

4418 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA