Michaelangelos Pizzeria: Authentic New York Pizza and Italian Cuisine in Staten Island

Michaelangelos Pizzeria Introduce

For residents and visitors in the New York area craving classic Italian-American comfort food, Michaelangelos Pizzeria stands out as a reliable and comprehensive dining destination right in the heart of Staten Island. Located in the accessible Port Richmond neighborhood, this establishment goes well beyond the standard slice, offering an extensive menu that caters to every possible Italian craving, from perfectly crafted New York-style pizza to robust baked pasta dishes and hearty entrées. It proudly operates as both a traditional Pizzeria and a full-service Delivery Restaurant, ensuring that whether you are looking for a cozy dine-in experience or a convenient meal at home, Michaelangelos Pizzeria has you covered.

Known for its high-quality food, the menu is a testament to the diverse and satisfying nature of Italian-American cuisine. Patrons frequently praise the pizzas for their quality and delicious taste, confirming the business’s commitment to excellent execution of staples like a classic pepperoni pie. However, the menu’s depth is truly what sets Michaelangelos Pizzeria apart, featuring everything from delicate seafood entrées to fully loaded wraps and paninis. It is a true local favorite for lunch, dinner, and even those late-night cravings that only authentic, satisfying comfort food can fix. While the restaurant has a casual and cozy atmosphere, it maintains a professional commitment to service, striving to offer a welcoming experience for groups, locals, and solo diners alike.

Location and Accessibility

Michaelangelos Pizzeria is situated at 860 Post Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, placing it firmly within the bustling Port Richmond area. This makes it a highly convenient spot for many Staten Islanders. Post Avenue is a well-known thoroughfare, contributing to the restaurant’s visibility and ease of access.

From an accessibility standpoint, the premises offer wheelchair-accessible seating, making it an inclusive environment for all patrons in the New York region. While dedicated off-street parking specific to the pizzeria may vary, the surrounding neighborhood typically offers local street parking. For New Yorkers utilizing public transit, the location on Post Avenue is likely serviced by several MTA bus lines, providing a direct link for those traveling from other parts of Staten Island. The Port Richmond area is a key hub, making this pizzeria a simple destination to reach whether you are a local resident or commuting in for a meal. The central location is a significant benefit for a popular neighborhood business focused on takeout and delivery service.

Services Offered

Michaelangelos Pizzeria prioritizes customer convenience and offers a full spectrum of service options, ensuring their delicious food is available exactly when and where New York patrons need it:

Dine-in: Enjoy the casual and cozy atmosphere of the restaurant with dedicated table service.
Delivery: Full delivery service is provided, allowing customers to enjoy the entire menu from the comfort of their homes or offices.
No-Contact Delivery: A safe and modern option for those who prefer their orders left at the door.
Takeout: Meals can be ordered ahead and picked up quickly for a convenient stop.
Curbside Pickup: An extra layer of convenience, allowing customers to retrieve their order without leaving their vehicle.
Late-Night Food: A vital offering for New Yorkers, ensuring a hot meal is available late into the evening.
Accepts Reservations: For groups or those planning a meal in advance, reservations are accepted, enhancing planning convenience.
Catering: Comprehensive catering services are available, perfect for New York parties, office lunches, and special events.
Payment Flexibility: The restaurant accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for seamless transactions.

Features / Highlights

The overall dining experience at Michaelangelos Pizzeria is defined by the quality and sheer variety of its menu, making it a compelling choice for any Italian food enthusiast in the region:

Diverse Pizza Styles: Beyond the classic cheese pie, the restaurant offers an expansive range of Specialty Pizzas, including unique options like the Mega Hawaian Pie, Pizza Mexicana (with chorizo and avocado), and popular choices like Chicken Parm Pie and Vodka Pie.
Extensive Baked Dishes: A focus on hearty, traditional Italian favorites, such as Baked Ziti, Baked Lasagna, and Baked Stuffed Shells, offers excellent comfort food options.
Signature Pasta Selections: Patrons can choose from classic pasta preparations like Pasta Alla Vodka, Pesto Cream Sauce, and the restaurant’s own specialty, Michaelangelo's Pasta.
Full Italian Entrées: The menu features substantial Entrées and Chicken dishes, including perennial favorites like Chicken Parm, Eggplant Rollatini, and specialty plates like Chicken Marsala and Cordon Bleu Chicken.
Seafood Options: A selection of seafood dishes, such as Shrimp Scampi, Calamari, and Shrimps & Clams, provides appealing alternatives to meat-based entrées.
Sandwich and Wrap Variety: The menu offers a wide assortment of Panini and Wraps, ranging from classic Philly Cheesesteak and Club Panini to Chicken Cordon Blue, ensuring a perfect quick bite option.
Dessert Assortment: A selection of satisfying Italian desserts and treats, including Tiramisu, Cannoli (2 Pcs.), and classic Zeppoli (5 Pcs.), provides a perfect finish to any meal.
Amenities: The restaurant provides Wi-Fi access, adding to the convenience for both dine-in customers and those waiting for takeout orders.
Good for Kids: The family-friendly environment is enhanced by the availability of a dedicated Kids' Menu.

Contact Information

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering, New York customers can use the following details:

Address: 860 Post Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Phone: (718) 273-7541

What Is Worth Choosing

Choosing Michaelangelos Pizzeria means opting for a guaranteed satisfying meal rooted in authentic New York-Italian tradition. The sheer breadth of the menu—which ranges from small plates and quick bites to full, elaborate dinners—makes it an exceptionally versatile choice in the Staten Island dining scene. For a first-time visitor or a local resident, the value proposition is high: you get high-quality pizza and a complete range of Italian classics under one roof. The commitment to offering late-night food and a comprehensive suite of ordering options, including no-contact delivery and curbside pickup, demonstrates a strong focus on accommodating the busy New Yorker’s schedule.

What truly elevates Michaelangelos is the ability to satisfy multiple tastes within a group—one can enjoy a top-tier pepperoni pizza while another indulges in a decadent Lasagna Pie or a sophisticated Chicken Francese. The inclusion of unique and creative pies, such as the Mexican-inspired varieties, shows a willingness to innovate while maintaining the integrity of Italian cooking. It’s a dependable destination for consistent, classic Italian comfort food in a casual, cozy environment that feels inherently like a true neighborhood spot. When seeking an Italian meal that offers maximum variety, convenience, and quality in New York City, Michaelangelos Pizzeria delivers on every front.

Michaelangelos Pizzeria Pizza

PASTA
Butter Sauce $7.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Marinara Sauce $9.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Olive Oil & Garlic $10.75
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Tomato Sauce $11.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Meat Sauce & Oil $9.00
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Alfredo Sauce $13.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
La Carbonara $13.99
Bacon, Garlic & Wine In Cream Sauce. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
La Primavera $14.99
Broccoli, Spinach, Eggplant & Peppers. Optional Cream Or Garlic. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Michaelangelo's Pasta $15.99
Ground Beef & Vodka Sauce With Fresh Mozzarella. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Sausage (3 Pcs.) $12.99
Marinara Sauce. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Meatballs (2 Pcs.) $12.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Ravioli $9.99
With Vodka Sauce. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Mushrooms Sauce $11.99
Tomato Sauce. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Putannesa $12.99
Garlic, Marinara Sauce, Calamata Olives, Anchovies with Wine. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Broccoli, Oil & Garlic $13.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Pasta Alla Vodka $12.99
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Broccoli Rabe $14.99
Sausage, Garlic, Broccoli with Wine. Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra
Pesto Cream Sauce $12.00
Pasta Choices: Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Ziti, Linguini, Penne, Fettuccine. Whole Wheat Penne 1.00 Extra

BAKED DISHES
Baked Ziti $13.50
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread
Baked Ziti Sicilian $14.50
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread
Baked Ravioli (6 Pcs.) $10.99
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread
Baked Stuffed Shells (4 Pcs.) $9.00
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread
Baked Lasagna $11.99
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread
Baked Manicotti (3 Pcs.) $10.99
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread
Baked Tortellini $9.99
All Baked Dishes Are Served With Tomato Sauce & Bread

ENTREES
Meatball Parmesan $13.50
Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Meatball Casserole $13.50
Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Sausage Casserole $13.50
Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Eggplant Parmesan $13.50
With Tomatoes Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Eggplant Rollatini $14.50
Eggplant Rolled With Ricotta & Mozzarella. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Sausage Parmesan $13.50
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad

CHICKEN
Chicken Parm $14.99
With Tomatoes Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Chicken Fiorentina $15.99
In Vodka Sauce With Spinach. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Chicken Francese $15.99
In Lemon Juice & White Wine. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Chicken Rollatini $16.99
Ricotta, Spinach, Roasted Peppers & Mozzarella. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Chicken Marsala $15.99
Sautéed With Mushrooms In Marsala Wine. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Cordon Bleu Chicken $16.99
Ham, Provolone, Marsala Sauce Or Cheese Sauce. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Chicken Piccata $14.99
With Lemon Juice, Broccoli In White Wine. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad

SEAFOOD
Shrimp Scampi $14.99
Fresh Garlic, White Wine & Clam Sauce With Choice Of Pasta. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Calamari $16.99
Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Clams $15.99
With Marinara Sauce & Choice Of Pasta. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Shrimp Parmigiana $15.99
With Red Or White Sauce & Choice Of Pasta. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Shrimps & Clams $17.99
With Choice Of Pasta. Extra Parmigiana 1.50. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad
Fried Diavolo $20.99
Shrimp, Calamari, Mussels, Clams On Spicy Marinara Sauce. Entrées served side of pasta or sautéed or steam broccoli, broccoli rabe, spinach with mash potatoes Or Salad

DESSERTS
Zeppoli (5 Pcs.) $3.00
Cookies $0.75
homemade chocolate chip, sugar, macadamia
Fried Oreos $3.00
Chocolate Chip Brownie $2.25
Cheese Cake $4.00
Tiramisu $4.50
Cannoli (2 Pcs.) $3.50
Cold Water $1.25
Core Water $2.53

BEVERAGES
Can Soda $1.25
Coke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta Orange, Dr. Pepper, Brisk Tea, Ginger Ale, Seltzer, Hawaiian Punch, Pepsi, Lemonade
20oz. Bottle Soda $2.25
Coke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta Orange, Dr. Pepper, Brisk Tea, Ginger Ale, Seltzer, Hawaiian Punch, Pepsi, Lemonade
2 Liter Soda / Minute Maid Lemonade $3.50
Coke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta Orange, Dr. Pepper, Brisk Tea, Ginger Ale, Seltzer, Hawaiian Punch, Pepsi, Lemonade. Gatorade Orange, Cool Blue, Lime, Fruit Punch

PANINI
Burger Panini $11.00
Ground Beef & Marinara Sauce
Buffalo Grilled Chicken $11.00
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mozzarella
Fried Buffalo Chicken $11.00
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mozzarella
Philly Cheesesteak Panini $12.99
With Eggplant, Green Peppers, Onions & American White / Yellow Cheese
Grilled Vegetables $11.00
Eggplant, Red Onion, Broccoli, Tomatoes & Mozzarella
Fried Chicken $11.00
Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions & Cheese
Tuna Panini $11.00
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Cheese
Turkey $11.00
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mayo
Ham $11.00
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mayo
Club Panini $11.00
Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mayo
Grilled Chicken $11.00
Roasted Pepper, Fresh Mozzarella & Balsamic Glaze
BLT Panini $11.00
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomatoes
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Panini $11.00
Sautéed With Fresh Mozzarella
Fried Chicken & Broccoli Panini $11.00
Sautéed With Fresh Mozzarella
Fried Chicken $11.00
Onions, Mushrooms, Gravy & Mozzarella Sautéed
Fried Chicken $11.00
Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce
Fried Chicken $11.00
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella & Balsamic Dressing
Chicken Salad $11.00
Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions
Chicken Cordon Blue $11.00
Fried Chicken, Ham, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato & Onion
Chicken Parmigiana $11.00
Shrimp Parmigiana $11.50

WRAPS
Burger Wrap $10.50
Onions, Mushrooms, Gravy & Mozzarella Sautéed. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Buffalo Grilled Chicken $10.50
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mozzarella. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Fried Buffalo Chicken $10.50
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mozzarella. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap $11.99
Green Peppers, Onions & American White / Yellow Cheese. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Grilled Vegetables $10.50
Eggplant, Red Onion, Broccoli, Tomatoes & Mozzarella. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Fried Chicken & Broccoli Wrap $10.50
Sautéed With Fresh Mozzarella. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Fried Chicken $10.50
Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Fried Chicken $10.50
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella & Balsamic Dressing. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Chicken Salad $10.50
Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Chicken Cordon Blue $10.99
Fried Chicken, Ham, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato & Onion. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Chicken Parmigiana $10.50
Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
BLT Wrap $10.50
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomatoes. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Wrap $10.50
Sautéed With Fresh Mozzarella. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Tuna Wrap $10.50
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Cheese. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Turkey $10.50
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mayo. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Ham $10.50
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mayo. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Club Wrap $10.50
Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Mayo. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Grilled Chicken $10.50
Roasted Pepper, Fresh Mozzarella & Balsamic Glaze. Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Fried Chicken $10.50
Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap
Shrimp Parmigiana $11.50
Your Choice of Regular or Honey Whole Wheat Wrap

Michaelangelos Pizzeria Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Table service

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Groups
Locals

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu

Michaelangelos Pizzeria Photos

Michaelangelos Pizzeria Location

Michaelangelos Pizzeria

New York Richmond County Port Richmond Post Avenue

860 Post Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA

Michaelangelos Pizzeria Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 235 user reviews.

priceswingsislandcookiesgarlic knotspenne vodkacallchicken saladmichelangelocheesesteak

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I ordered a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was very good quality. It tasted very delicious. I am very pleased. This business does so much for the community as well. I will be supporting them in the future.
August 15 · Jasmine Robinson
Very unlikely to ever order from again. Zippos were greasy and barely had powdered sugar. Ordered 2 slices at 3:30pm and asked if I could grab the soda that goes with the 2Slice lunch special. The woman at the register aggressively answered Angry enough for the other men working in store to stop and stare me down. "I ASKED YOU IF YOU WANTED ANYTHING ELSE!! SODA IS $0.50 MORE" I just asked because it said outside 2Slice lunch special and free can soda or water. I wasn't going to go back and forth over a soda but for the cashier to be instantly raged by a question politely asked. Then to see the worst Zippo ever. Greasy and barely any sugar. Won't return or refer anyone.
March 05 · Whitney B.
Delivered the pizza 30 mins early for kids pizza party. The school is 5 mins away walking distance. They couldn’t make the delivery on time and now the kids have cold pizza. Refused to remake pizza, the only option was a refund.
June 26 · Random Youtuber
Very thin crust, but chewy and crispy.Thin coverage of cheese and sauce, making for a dry slice.No particular flavor or seasoning.The only noticeable flavor was the crust, which seems to be brushed in an oil and oregano combination.Undersized for $2.72.I'll give this one an 80. Nothing really done wrong, but nothing notable either.
July 25 · Gary Wilson
The Lasagna Pizza was specially made fresh for me. Best lasagna pizza I have ever had. Tasted like a little Italian grandma made it. OUTSTANDING. Nice people too.
May 06 · cornercracker30