Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)

- 217 East 86th St, New York, NY 10028

In a city where pizzerias are as common as yellow cabs, Mimi's Pizza on 3rd Ave & 86th stands out as a true neighborhood gem. This isn't just another pizza joint; it’s a destination for authentic, no-frills New York pizza that hits the spot every time. The atmosphere is refreshingly casual, and the focus is squarely on the food. From the classic Regular Cheese Pizza to their celebrated Grandma and Sicilian styles, Mimi's delivers on the promise of a great slice. It’s the kind of place that becomes your go-to, whether you’re rushing home from work, grabbing a quick lunch, or satisfying a late-night craving.

Mimi's offers a wide array of options, catering to every kind of pizza lover. The menu is both classic and creative, featuring traditional thin-crust slices alongside specialty pies that showcase unique flavor combinations. The quality is consistently high, with customers often praising the perfect balance of crispy crust and doughy interior, as well as the flavorful sauce and high-quality cheese. While it’s primarily a counter-service establishment, which adds to its fast-paced, urban charm, the deliciousness of the food more than makes up for it. The fact that the business is women-owned also adds to its unique character, providing a sense of community and support for a local establishment. It's a place that locals proudly call their own, and for good reason.

Beyond the pizza, Mimi's offers a full menu of Italian-American comfort food favorites. The Garlic Knots are a popular starter, and the rolls, such as the Chicken Roll and Pepperoni Roll, are perfect for a satisfying on-the-go meal. They also serve a selection of heroes, pasta dishes, and entrees, including classics like Chicken Parm and Lasagna. This diverse menu means you can get a full, sit-down quality meal in a casual, quick-service setting. The salads are fresh and provide a nice, lighter option if you're looking for something other than pizza. It's a testament to the kitchen's versatility that they can do so many things well, all under one roof. Whether you're in the mood for a slice or a full dinner, Mimi's has you covered with consistently great options.

The location of Mimi's is another key factor in its appeal. Situated in a busy part of the Upper East Side, it’s a convenient stop for locals, tourists, and students. Its proximity to public transportation makes it an easy place to pop in for a slice before or after hopping on the train. The casual and family-friendly atmosphere means it’s a comfortable place for anyone, from a solo diner to a group of friends. While seating might be limited, the option for takeout and delivery is always there, making it an ideal choice for a delicious meal at home. The outdoor seating, where dogs are allowed, adds a nice touch for those who want to enjoy their meal in the fresh air. This combination of convenience and quality is what keeps Mimi's at the top of many New Yorkers' lists.

A few customer reviews highlight the specific qualities that make Mimi's special. One review mentions the "perfectly crispy" and "slightly doughy on the inside" crust of the Sicilian slice, proving that even a non-traditional choice for a slice can be a revelation. Another customer praises the cauliflower crust, a nod to Mimi's ability to offer healthier and gluten-free alternatives without compromising on taste. The general consensus from the reviews is that the food "hits" and is "delicious." Many note that it has become their "go-to" spot in the neighborhood, a high compliment in a city with endless options. The fact that they are open late is also a huge draw for those working or out late at night, providing a reliable and tasty option when other places might be closed.

The service at Mimi's is also a point of praise. While it’s an order-at-the-counter establishment, the staff is known for being efficient and friendly, making the ordering process quick and painless. This is crucial for a place that is popular and can get busy, ensuring that the line moves fast and you get your food without a long wait. The payment options, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, make the transaction seamless and modern. The restaurant’s ability to handle a high volume of customers while maintaining quality and service is a sign of a well-run establishment. Whether you are a regular or a first-time visitor, you can expect a quick, pleasant, and satisfying experience. It's the kind of place that embodies the spirit of a great New York neighborhood eatery.

The variety of their specialty pizzas is worth exploring. From the savory Truffle Mushrooms Pizza to the creamy Spinach Artichoke Pizza, there are endless combinations to try. Their Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza is a popular choice for those who love a rich and hearty slice. For those who prefer a classic, the Margherita is made with fresh ingredients that truly shine. This versatility ensures that you’ll never get bored with the menu, and there’s always something new to discover. The ability to buy pizza by the slice is a quintessential New York experience that Mimi's perfects, allowing you to sample different options or just grab a quick, satisfying bite on the go. This flexibility is a huge part of its success and appeal to the local crowd.

Location and Accessibility

Mimi's Pizza is conveniently located at 217 East 86th St, New York, NY 10028. Its accessible location makes it a perfect stop for those in the Upper East Side. The establishment features a wheelchair accessible entrance, making it a welcoming spot for all. Parking is available in the form of both free and paid street parking, which is a great option in a busy city like New York. The location is easily reachable by public transport, making it a favorite for locals and tourists alike.

Services Offered

• Outdoor seating: Enjoy your pizza outside on a nice day.
• No-contact delivery: Get your food delivered with safety and convenience in mind.
• Delivery: Order from the full menu for at-home dining.
• Takeout: Grab your order to go for a quick meal.
• Dine-in: Sit at the counter or one of the tables and enjoy your food.

Features / Highlights

• Comfort food: Classic pizza and Italian dishes that feel like a warm hug.
• Late-night food: Open late to satisfy those late-night cravings.
• Quick bite: Perfect for a fast, delicious, and satisfying meal.
• Small plates: Appetizers like Garlic Knots and Mozzarella Sticks are great for sharing.
• Family-friendly: The atmosphere and menu are welcoming to families and kids.
• Accepts reservations: A great option for planning ahead, especially for groups.
• Women-owned: A local business with a unique identity.

Contact Information

Address: 217 East 86th St, New York, NY 10028

Phone: (646) 861-2518

What is Worth Choosing

For a first-timer, the Grandma Pizza Slice is an absolute must-try. It’s a standout on the menu, known for its perfectly crispy crust and flavorful sauce. If you’re feeling adventurous, the Denso Pepperoni Pizza with its thick-cut, cup-and-char pepperoni is a fan favorite. Those looking for a healthier option will be pleasantly surprised by the delicious Cauliflower Crust Pizza. And don't miss the Vodka Grandma, which brings a creamy and rich twist to the classic square slice. The Garlic Knots are also a perfect addition to any order. Overall, Mimi’s Pizza is worth choosing for its authentic New York style, high-quality ingredients, and a menu that offers something for everyone, making it a reliable and delicious choice in the neighborhood.

Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)

217 East 86th St, New York, NY 10028, USA