Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

- 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

For New Yorkers in search of that perfect balance of sweet and tart, a pilgrimage to Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in the waterfront neighborhood of Red Hook, Brooklyn, is an absolute must. This beloved pie shop has earned its status as a local institution, consistently delivering what many enthusiastically call the best key lime pie to be found outside of the Florida Keys. The commitment to a truly authentic, high-quality product is what sets Steve’s apart and has kept Brooklynites, and visitors alike, coming back for decades.

The story of Steve's began with its founder, a Miami native, who was frustrated by the mediocre key lime pies available in New York. The solution was simple: make it yourself, and make it right. This "do it yourself" philosophy of not cutting corners became the foundation of the business. Every pie is a testament to this principle, featuring a fresh-baked, hand-formed graham cracker crust and a zesty custard made with 100% pure, freshly-squeezed key lime juice—never from concentrate. This dedication to authentic ingredients and a time-honored recipe has fostered a local legend, a taste of sunshine and tropical flavor right on the industrial-chic Brooklyn waterfront.

Over the years, the shop has not only survived but thrived, even demonstrating remarkable resiliency after being affected by Hurricane Sandy. The family-run business, now proudly identifying as women-owned, has cemented its place in the Red Hook community, serving thousands of pies weekly to walk-in customers and wholesale partners across the city. It’s more than just a pie shop; it’s a sweet, resilient fixture of the neighborhood.

Location and Accessibility

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is perfectly situated at the end of a trip into the unique landscape of Red Hook, offering a destination point with stunning views. The shop’s location is a great spot to pause and enjoy the waterfront.

The specific address for your next key lime fix is:

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

While Red Hook can sometimes feel off the beaten path for those using the subway, the journey is absolutely worth it. The shop is located near Valentino Pier and a local park, providing a picturesque setting for enjoying your freshly-made treat. Accessibility features at the location ensure a welcoming visit for all customers:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Free parking lot available for drivers
• Free street parking options are also generally available in the area

The experience is primarily 'grab-and-go,' but with a lovely communal feel. Customers can take their pies to an attractive outdoor area featuring picnic tables right outside the shop. This allows you to immediately savor the sweet and tart flavors with an authentic Red Hook waterfront backdrop.

Services Offered

As a specialty pie shop, Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie focuses on their core product while providing convenience and variety in serving sizes and associated treats. The business prides itself on quality service and customer flexibility.

• In-store shopping and walk-in service for immediate purchases.
• Takeout options for pies to be enjoyed at home or on-the-go.
• In-store pickup service for pre-ordered items.
• Delivery service, making it possible to enjoy the pies without the trip to Red Hook.
• Onsite services including outdoor picnic seating to enjoy your pie immediately after purchase.
• Hot and cold beverages, including coffee, are offered for a complete snack.
• Acceptance of various payment methods: Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a quick visit.

Features / Highlights

What makes Steve’s a true New York point of interest is a blend of their product quality, unique menu items, and their charming, authentic location. These features solidify their reputation in the city's vast culinary landscape.

• The 'Always Freshly Squeezed' Promise: The core of the business is its unwavering use of 100% pure, freshly-squeezed key lime juice, which ensures the signature, perfectly balanced tart and sweet flavor of their pies. They never use concentrates, a key distinction from many other bakeries.
• The Famous Swingle: This innovative treat is a single-serving, 4-inch key lime tart that is frozen on a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belgian chocolate. It is the ideal grab-and-go dessert for a warm day, often cited by customers as a mandatory try.
• Artisan Crust: The pie crust is not an afterthought; it is made from scratch with a proprietary recipe of house-baked Graham cracker crumbs and pure butter, resulting in a unique texture described by patrons as a mix of 'professionally perfect and hometown rustic.'
• The Red Hook Waterfront Vibe: The industrial-chic location next to Valentino Park and Pier offers a relaxed, slightly hidden atmosphere. The outdoor picnic tables allow customers to enjoy their pies with a view of the water and the Statue of Liberty in the distance.
• Variety of Sizes: Pies are available in multiple formats to suit any occasion, from the 4-inch single-serve tarts perfect for one, to the 8-inch family size, up to the full 10-inch pie for larger gatherings.
• Commitment to Quality Ingredients: They are known for sourcing the best materials, including a special regional dairy for their sweetened condensed milk and locally sourced ingredients like honey when possible, all while prioritizing the key limes themselves.

Contact Information

Whether you're planning a visit to the Red Hook waterfront or want to place a large order for a New York event, here is the essential contact information for Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie.

• Address: 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA
• Phone: (718) 858-5333

For the most accurate daily hours of operation, especially on weekends or if weather is a factor, it is always recommended to check their official website or call the retail counterperson. They are typically open later on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, making it a great weekend stop.

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie isn't just about buying a dessert; it’s an investment in a top-tier, authentic New York culinary experience. The dedication to quality is apparent in every bite, from the excellent graham cracker crust to the creamy, perfectly balanced custard. Customers consistently praise the 'natural with just the right amount of sweetness' flavor profile. Unlike many commercial products that rely on bottled juice and artificial flavors, Steve's commitment to freshly-squeezed juice from key limes results in a custard texture that is often compared to the work of a Michelin-star restaurant.

Furthermore, supporting Steve's means supporting a resilient, women-owned business that has a deep connection to the Red Hook community. They focus on ethical business practices, from consciously sourcing their ingredients to trying to be environmentally friendly with their packaging choices. The experience of walking into the bright, tropical-orange-hued bakery, picking up a pie, and enjoying it immediately at a waterfront picnic table is a quintessentially unique Brooklyn outing. For New Yorkers who appreciate a dessert made with integrity, tradition, and a truly exceptional flavor, Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie remains the unequivocal top choice. The Swingle, in particular, is a perfect, unique, and delicious invention—a frozen key lime tart dipped in Belgian chocolate—that is guaranteed to brighten any New York day.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA