Mister Pizza Introduce
For New York residents, finding that perfect slice of pizza or a reliable source for authentic, satisfying comfort food is a serious quest. Located conveniently in the Newburgh area, Mister Pizza at 1401 NY-300 has established itself as a local favorite, delivering a consistently delicious and diverse menu with exceptional speed and service. More than just a pizza shop, this establishment is a comprehensive casual dining destination offering everything from classic New York-style pies and hefty specialty heros to fresh salads and baked pasta dishes.
Mister Pizza prides itself on providing great food that feels homemade, all while maintaining the efficiency that busy New Yorkers appreciate. Their menu is built on a foundation of quality ingredients and traditional recipes, but they also embrace modern favorites and specialty items. Customers frequently highlight the staff’s friendly demeanor and willingness to accommodate special requests, such as the effort to prepare freshly made, plant-based options even near closing time, demonstrating a high level of customer care that sets them apart in the local food scene.
The core of Mister Pizza's appeal is its ability to nail the basics—like their perfectly crispy crust—while offering an impressive array of signature pizzas. From the rich Sicilian and classic White pizza to the celebrated Chicken, Bacon, Ranch specialty pie, there is a flavor profile to suit every craving. Their dedication to a broad, comforting menu ensures that whether you're looking for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or food for a big game night, Mister Pizza is ready to serve the Newburgh community and beyond.
Mister Pizza is strategically located at 1401 NY-300 in Newburgh, NY 12550, USA, a highly accessible spot within the local area, confirmed by some sources to be within the Newburgh Mall vicinity. This location on a major state route, NY-300, makes it easy to reach by car from surrounding towns and neighborhoods across Orange County and the Hudson Valley. Its position is ideal for both a planned dine-in experience and a quick pick-up while running errands.
The restaurant is committed to ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. They offer on-site parking, which eliminates the stress of searching for a spot. Furthermore, the establishment is fully equipped with accessibility features, recognizing the need for an inclusive environment for all New York users.
- Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
- Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot
- Wheelchair Accessible Seating
Mister Pizza offers flexible and comprehensive service options designed to meet the demands of the modern diner, whether you prefer to enjoy your meal on-site or have it delivered right to your door. Their service model prioritizes convenience, speed, and safety.
- Full Service Dining Options: Available for both Lunch and Dinner.
- In-Person Dining: Offers a comfortable Dine-in seating area for a casual meal.
- Convenient Takeout: Speedy Takeout service is available for those on the go.
- Delivery Services: Provides both standard Delivery and secure No-contact Delivery.
- Curbside Pickup: Offers Curbside pickup for maximum convenience without leaving your vehicle.
- Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods including Debit Cards and NFC Mobile Payments.
Mister Pizza is more than just a standard pizza parlor due to its array of standout features, which include a remarkably diverse menu and a strong focus on customer satisfaction.
- Exceptional Pizza Variety: The menu boasts an impressive selection of over 14 distinct pizza options, including classics like Cheese Pizza and gourmet choices such as Meat Lovers, Hawaiian, and their famous Chicken, Bacon, Ranch pizza.
- Comfort Food Hub: Beyond pizza, the menu excels with a full line of classic Italian-American comfort foods, including Baked Ziti and savory Hot Heros (like the Chicken Parm and Meatball Parm), ensuring a satisfying meal for any appetite.
- Acclaimed Side Items: Customers rave about the freshly made Garlic Knots, described as the "perfect combination of softness and flavor." Other popular favorites include the Wings (10 pcs for $10.95), French Fries, and Mozzarella Sticks.
- Specialty Heroes and Rolls: The menu features unique, hearty options like the Rico Hero (Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Melted American Cheese & Mayo) and well-stuffed Buffalo Chicken Rolls and Meat Stromboli.
- Family and Kid-Friendly: Clearly designated as "Good for kids," the restaurant offers a welcoming environment for families, with crowd-pleasing items like Cheeseburgers with Fries and Hot Dogs.
- Friendly, Fast Service: Consistently praised in customer reviews for a "very friendly" crew and "fast with service," ensuring quality food is served hot and fresh without long waits.
To place an order for delivery or to inquire about catering, New York customers can use the primary contact information provided below:
- Address: 1401 NY-300, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA
- Phone: (845) 522-8250
Mister Pizza is an essential choice for anyone in the Newburgh, NY area looking for dependable, delicious, and diverse comfort food, centered around outstanding pizza. What is truly worth choosing about this restaurant is the proven commitment to customer experience, evidenced by their staff’s accommodating nature and the speed of their service—a critical factor for busy individuals in the New York region.
You can rely on Mister Pizza for a perfectly crispy crust on their pies, a feature highlighted by patrons who enjoy that ideal thin 'cracking' when they fold a slice. The breadth of their menu—from the unexpected but delightful Jamaican Beef Patty to the comforting Baked Ziti—means that even groups with wildly different cravings will find a satisfying option. Moreover, their dedication to accessibility, on-site parking, and multiple convenience-focused services like no-contact delivery and curbside pickup, make them a superior and hassle-free dining option in the Hudson Valley.
Mister Pizza Food & drink
Rolls & Calzones
- Pepperoni Roll $7.50
Served with mozzarella cheese.
- Chicken Parm Roll $8.00
- Chicken Cutlet Roll $8.00
Served with mozzarella cheese.
- Meat Stromboli $8.00
Ham, salami, pepperoni & sausage
- Buffalo Chicken Roll $8.00
Served with mozzarella cheese.
- Cheese Calzone $6.50
Made with ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Side Dishes
- Meatballs (2) $5.95
Wraps
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $9.95
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap $9.95
Buffalo chicken buffalo chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion & blue cheese
Salads
- House Salad $4.95
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, onion & shredded carrots
- Grilled Chicken Caesar $7.95
- Caesar Salad $4.95
Romaine lettuce, grated cheese
Specialty heros
- Rico $10.00
Chicken cutlet, bacon, melted American, cheese & mayo.
- Torpedo $9.00
Ham, salami, melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato & onions
- Cheesesteak $9.00
Steak, American cheese, peppers, onions & mushrooms
Appetizers
- Garlic Knots (4) $3.50
- Cheeseburgers With Fries $10.95
- Hot Dogs (1 Pc) $3.50
- Mozzarella Sticks (6) $8.95
Deep fried cheese sticks. crispy on the outside gooey on the inside. virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite served with a side of marinara sauce.
Soups
- Chicken Noodle $4.95
Baked Pastas
- Baked Ziti $11.95
- Spaghetti $8.95
Chicken with meatballs
Hot Heros
- Chicken Parm $8.95
- Meatball Parm $8.95
Mister Pizza Favourites
- Grilled Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla $8.95
- French Fries $4.00
- Jamaican Beef Patty $3.50
- Wings (10) $10.95
Mild, hot, bbq, honey bbq, golden bbq..
- Cheese Fries $5.00
- Chicken Fingers W/Fries $8.95
- Cheese Quesadillas $7.95
- Super Cheese Fries $8.00
Pizza Menu
- Sicilian $17.00
- Veggie $22.95
- Chicken Parm $22.95
- Chicken, Bacon, Ranch $22.95
- Bbq Chicken $22.95
- White $18.75
- Meat Lovers $22.95
- Chicken Cutlet $22.95
- Chicken, Bacon, Golden, Bbq $22.95
- Hawaiian $22.95
- Grandma $21.95
- Buffalo Chicken $22.95
- Cheese Pizza $14.99
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $21.95
Green salad with caesar dressing grilled chicken and cheese.
Cold Subs
- Ham & Cheese $7.95
Mister Pizza Details
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Comfort food
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Parking
- On-site parking
Mister Pizza Photos










Mister Pizza Location
Mister Pizza Reviews
baconpieprices
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I recently visited this pizza shop and had an amazing experience! Firstly, the staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. When I asked if they had any plant-based options, they were more than happy to make me a freshly made pie before closing time. It was so kind of them!Not only were the staff great, but the food was also top-notch. I couldn't resist ordering their garlic knots, and let me tell you, they were absolutely delicious. The perfect combination of softness and flavor. To wash it all down, I tried their passion fruit raspado, and it was seriously a treat for my taste buds!What impressed me the most was the efficiency of the service. Despite being a bit busy, they managed to serve our food quickly without compromising on quality. Everything was served hot and fresh!I highly recommend Mister Pizza for anyone looking for a great dining experience. I can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Keep up the excellent work!
July 30 · ThomasVery good chicken bacon ranch pizza! had a perfectly crispy crust with that perfect thin cracking as you fold it. The crew is very friendly and fast with service too would highly recommend😊
December 18 · danny phillipsThis is by far one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I am always trying to find something comparable to Bronx pizza and this place is it. Tried it by the slice while sitting in and took a pie to go. Each time the slices did not bend when making the initial fold. The sauce is delicious and the crust is perfectly crispy. When doing take out the second time we ordered garlic not. They were again perfectly crispy on the outside and a doughy master piece on the inside. 10/10 barstool sports needs to come in and rate it. That’s how good it is.
December 30 · Matthew SpellmanIf I could leave no stars, then I would. We decided to give this place a try since they claimed to be “the best pizza in Orange County”. Well, it is by far the worst. For one, it is the saltiest pizza I’ve ever eaten. Our pizza was literally an oval with the most deformed slices ever. It was cold and did NOT taste fresh by any means. The calamari is also very cold and not fresh at all. We will NEVER be ordering again.
April 12 · Stephanie DavisI bought a slice i went back for a second slice because it was so good thats what the two stars are for the taste, when i seen the flies flying around i lost my appetite i said there flies flying and one landed on top of the pizza he said it wasnt nothing he can do about it there were lots of flies the health department needs to be called.
October 06 · Cordelia Pendergrass
More restaurants near me
Chai Hing4.0 (76 reviews)5B New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Flours Pasta & Bakeshop4.0 (49 reviews)11 New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
LC Craft Beer Brittle5.0 (1 reviews)8 Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Lucas Candies4.0 (72 reviews)6 Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Mari's Cafe3.0 (3 reviews)75 Maple Ave, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Asi y Asado4.0 (79 reviews)75 Maple Ave, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Treats by Esther0.0 (0 reviews)4402 Admirals Cove Blvd, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Riverside Scoops5.0 (37 reviews)1000 Round Pointe Dr, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Harbors Cafe4.0 (85 reviews)1000 Round Pointe Dr, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Winfield Street Coffee - Croton4.0 (10 reviews)4 Veterans Plaza, Croton-On-Hudson, NY 10520, USA
Frost Boss Ice Cream Truck0.0 (0 reviews)245 N Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA
Hong Kong Kitchen4.0 (120 reviews)285 NY-303 Unit 3, Congers, NY 10920, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
DLSWEETS3.0 (1 reviews)
Tandir Rokhat4.0 (819 reviews)
Waka-Tay3.0 (578 reviews)
HALAL Z DELI & GRILL4.0 (53 reviews)
R.Jay's Pub4.0 (13 reviews)
Burger City4.0 (512 reviews)Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts
How Wine Bars Are Hosting Tastings to Introduce New Varieties
How Brunch Restaurants Are Redefining Classic Dishes with Contemporary Influences
How Brunch Restaurants Are Creating Seasonal Menus That Delight Guests
Discovering Brunch Restaurants That Cater to Dietary Preferences Without Sacrificing Taste
How Coffee Shops Are Curating Specialty Beans From Around the World
How Brunch Restaurants Are Innovating With International Flavor Combinations
