More Than A Bagel

- 1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557

When it comes to the iconic New York bagel experience, Long Island residents know that quality and freshness are non-negotiable. Tucked away in Hewlett, a classic local spot, More Than A Bagel, lives up to its name by offering a true New York bakery experience that extends well beyond a simple bagel and schmear. For those in Nassau County and the surrounding New York area, this spot has become a fixture for a quick, friendly, and delicious start to the day. It embodies the fast-paced, high-quality expectation that New Yorkers have for their morning routines.

More Than A Bagel is a local bakery that prides itself on delivering high-quality baked goods and deli items. It’s the kind of neighborhood establishment where the staff is attentive and the service is notably fast, even when juggling multiple customers. This quick service, combined with what many long-time patrons describe as consistently fresh and delicious food, has cemented its status as a local favorite. The atmosphere is clean and efficient, designed for a community that appreciates speed and a friendly face.

It is important for first-time visitors to note a key operational detail: the establishment operates on a cash-only basis, a characteristic of some classic local New York businesses. While this might be a slight deviation from modern card-centric transactions, it’s a detail worth remembering to ensure a quick and seamless transaction when you stop by. This is the kind of local gem that retains a traditional charm and focuses intensely on the product and the community.

The bakery offers a dedicated selection of items, focusing specifically on their namesake product and accompanying spreads and salads. While other establishments in the wider region may boast expansive menus with extensive hot grill selections, More Than A Bagel maintains a focused offering, suggesting a dedication to perfecting their core products. The quality of their bagels is frequently highlighted by loyal customers as getting "better and better" over the years, a testament to their commitment to their craft. Whether you are looking for a dozen fresh bagels for a family breakfast or a simple, perfectly-prepared bagel sandwich for your commute, this Hewlett location is a reliable resource.

Location and Accessibility

More Than A Bagel is conveniently situated at 1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA. Located in the heart of Hewlett in Nassau County, Long Island, the location is highly accessible for local residents and those passing through the area. Accessibility is a strong point for this neighborhood bakery, especially for those traveling by car.

The bakery is equipped with a free parking lot, a significant convenience in a densely populated region like New York, allowing patrons to easily park and run in for a quick visit. Furthermore, the premises are wheelchair accessible, ensuring that it can serve all members of the community without issue. The central location on Broadway makes it an easy pit stop for anyone heading to or from work, or simply running morning errands.

Hours of operation are designed to cater to the morning rush and lunch crowds, running from 6:00 AM to 4:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and a slightly shorter day on Sunday, closing at 2:00 PM. These early and consistent hours make it an ideal place for that essential morning coffee and breakfast run before the start of the workday.

Services Offered

As a key local bakery, More Than A Bagel provides a streamlined and high-quality set of services tailored for convenience and quick enjoyment. The service options emphasize speed and accessibility for the busy New Yorker.

• Takeout and In-Store Service: The primary modes of service, designed for customers who want to grab their order and go. Patrons frequently highlight the very quick service, which is essential for a breakfast-focused establishment.
• Delivery: The bakery offers delivery services, making it easy for local customers to enjoy their fresh bagels and deli items without leaving home or the office.
• Breakfast Dining: Although focused on a quick, in-and-out model, breakfast is the main dining option available, perfect for starting your day.
• High-Quality Offerings: The core offerings center on fresh bagels and associated items, including spreads like various types of cream cheese. They also serve coffee to complete the classic breakfast pairing.
• Catering Services: Based on public data for similar local bakeries, it is common for such establishments to offer catering for larger events, which is implied by the business model of providing dozens of bagels and other bulk items. This is perfect for business meetings, community gatherings, or family breakfasts.

Features / Highlights

What makes More Than A Bagel stand out in the competitive New York bagel market is a combination of traditional business practices, focus on core products, and stellar customer service. These key highlights are what drive repeat business and strong local word-of-mouth.

• Exceptional Bagel Quality: Customer testimonials consistently praise the freshness and superior taste of the bagels, calling them "delicious food" that "just get better and better."
• Friendly and Fast Service: The staff is repeatedly described as "super friendly" and "very kind people," providing "very fast and friendly service" even when busy. This high level of customer attention is a major draw.
• Signature Salads and Spreads: One specific item, the potato salad, has been explicitly called out by customers as "phenomenal," suggesting their deli-style side offerings are a cut above the average. They take pride in their selection of house-made salads and spreads.
• Traditional Cash-Only Operation: For some, the cash-only policy (for in-store transactions) adds to the classic, no-fuss charm of a long-standing New York neighborhood establishment. Customers are advised to be prepared for this method of payment.
• Convenient Accessibility: Offering a free parking lot and a wheelchair-accessible entrance ensures the bakery is easy for everyone to get to and enjoy without the typical parking headaches found in the area.
• Community Staple: The bakery has a history of serving the community, with many customers having patronized the shop for years, indicating a strong, trusted presence in Hewlett, NY.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or place an order, you can contact More Than A Bagel using the following information:

Address: 1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

Phone: (516) 569-9350

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing More Than A Bagel is an investment in a reliable, high-quality, and authentic local New York breakfast. While the tuna salad might be an "average" experience for some, the core product—the bagel—is consistently top-tier, and that is truly what matters most at a New York bagel shop. Patrons should absolutely choose this bakery for its foundational strength in freshly baked goods.

The primary reason to choose More Than A Bagel is simple: its exceptional and constantly improving bagels, which are the best way to start your day. Paired with this is the phenomenal and highly-rated potato salad, which, though a side, speaks volumes about the quality of their fresh, homemade deli-style offerings. For an efficient morning experience, the fast service and free, easy parking cannot be overstated. When you are on the go and need that quality boost quickly, this place is unbeatable. The customer-centric service, where staff often remember regular orders, creates a welcoming and personalized feeling that makes it feel less like a transaction and more like visiting a neighborhood friend. For locals looking for a dependable breakfast spot that embodies the traditional Long Island bakery experience, More Than A Bagel remains a top, cash-ready choice.

Whether it’s a quick stop for a bagel with a schmear before work or picking up a dozen for the office, More Than A Bagel is a Hewlett staple that continues to deliver what Long Islanders expect: excellence, speed, and a dedication to the craft of the perfect New York bagel. Stop by the location on Broadway and see why generations of customers keep coming back for what many consider to be the best bagels in the area.

More Than A Bagel

1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA