Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli

- 6 Baldwin St, Montclair, NJ 07042

## Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli: A New Jersey Institution Since 1967

For residents across North Jersey, few names in Italian deli and bakery fare evoke the same sense of tradition and quality as **Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli** in Montclair. Established in 1967, this local storefront is more than just a place to grab lunch; it’s a culinary landmark built on the foundation of authentic, old-world Italian baking. Customers who have moved away often cite Nicolo's as the "sandwich I dream about when I’m not in Jersey," making it a must-stop on any trip home.

Nicolo's excels by upholding two core pillars: freshly baked bread and generously stacked, high-quality Italian sandwiches. Their hero sandwiches are legendary, packed with premium ingredients like **Prosciutto Di Parma**, fresh mozzarella made in-house, and unique additions like **Escarole Oreganata**—a deeply savory, seasoned Italian green. Beyond the sandwich counter, Nicolo's is a full-service Italian bakery and caterer, offering everything from famous coffee cake and homemade pizza dough to large-format hot entrees and massive party subs perfect for any New Jersey gathering. The commitment to using fine imported meats, Italian cheeses, and house-made specialties ensures every item, whether a simple Italian Hero or a complex Chicken Cutlet sandwich, delivers an authentic taste that the local community has relied on for decades.

The atmosphere inside the small space is bustling, yet the staff is described as "super fast," ensuring even during the peak lunch rush that "the wait is not long." This efficiency and commitment to quality make Nicolo's an essential destination for a **quick visit** when you need a high-quality Italian meal.

## Location and Accessibility in Montclair

Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli is conveniently located at **6 Baldwin St, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA**. This location places it in a well-trafficked, yet easily reachable, part of the Montclair business district, making it a perfect spot for locals, visitors, and those needing catering services for nearby events.

The management has made significant efforts to ensure accessibility for all community members. Key features include a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**. Furthermore, parking is simplified for a quick in-and-out experience, with both a **Free parking lot** available as well as **Free street parking** on the surrounding streets. This multi-faceted parking availability is a crucial convenience for customers picking up large catering orders or just stopping by for a hero.

For on-site enjoyment, Nicolo's provides an inviting outdoor space. As noted by one local patron, there is an **"outside area (covered) with tables for enjoying your goodies on site,"** offering a pleasant environment to savor your Italian bread or famous coffee cake. The primary service model is efficient **Takeout**, with payments streamlined by accepting **Credit cards, Debit cards,** and modern **NFC mobile payments**.

## Services Offered

Nicolo's has tailored its services to meet the diverse culinary needs of the busy New Jersey community, specializing in both daily deli service and full-scale event catering.

• **Signature Deli Takeout:** The core service focuses on fast, efficient **Takeout** of their vast menu of fresh, made-to-order sandwiches and prepared Italian foods.

• **Full-Service Italian Catering:** Nicolo's provides extensive catering options for parties, corporate events, and family gatherings. Their menu includes large **Hot** entrees (Feeds 10-12) such as **Chicken Parmigiana**, **Baked Ziti**, and **Meat Lasagna**, ensuring any large event is handled with authentic, home-style cooking.

• **Specialty Party Subs:** A quintessential New Jersey catering choice, Nicolo’s offers impressive **Party Subs** ranging from 3-foot to 6-foot lengths, which feed approximately 4-6 people per foot, making them the ultimate centerpiece for any large party.

• **Cold Platters and Salads:** Catering options also feature **Cold** trays (Feeds 10-12) like fresh **Potato Salad**, **BowTie Pasta**, and the vibrant **Caprese** platter, as well as curated **Platters** like the **Cold Antipasto** and **Sandwich Platter**.

• **Bakery Specialties:** Beyond the deli, they function as a beloved bakery, offering items like the popular **Pepperoni bread**, **Coffee Cake**, and selling fresh **Pizza dough** for customers to take home.

• **Outdoor Dining:** The provision of a covered **outside area with tables** allows customers to enjoy their meals immediately in a relaxed setting.

## Features / Highlights

The enduring popularity of Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli stems from its commitment to key features that set it apart in the North Jersey food scene:

• **Legendary Fresh Italian Bread:** Nicolo's is renowned for its hard Italian bread, baked daily using traditional methods. This crusty, fresh bread is the foundation of every sandwich and a highly-demanded item on its own.

• **Perfection-Level Chicken Cutlets:** The **Chicken Cutlets** are frequently highlighted by customers as "perfection" and are prominently featured in specialty sandwiches like the **Chicken Cutlets and Broccoli Rabe** and the decadent **Chicken Cutlet, Sopressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Escarole Oreganata** ($15.75).

• **Artisanal Italian Specialties:** The deli offers a variety of premium and specialty meats and cheeses, including imported items like **Prosciutto Di Parma** and **Imported Sharp Provolone**. Their homemade additions, such as the creamy **Fresh Mozzarella** and savory **Escarole Oreganata**, elevate the sandwich experience far beyond the standard deli fare.

• **Unique Sandwich Combinations:** The menu is rich with inventive, robust combinations that speak to a true Italian-American sensibility, such as the **Roasted Pork Loin, Smoked Mozzarella, Sauté Peppers and Onions** and the classic **Italian Style Hot Dog** served on a Pitz Bread.

• **High-Volume Catering Expertise:** The extensive catering menu, featuring large trays of dishes like **Chicken Francese** and **Penne Vodka**, along with customizable **Party Subs**, solidifies Nicolo's as the expert source for feeding a crowd of 10 or more people efficiently and deliciously.

## Contact Information

For Montclair residents and New Jersey customers looking to place an order, whether for a single sandwich or a large catering tray, here is the necessary contact information:

**Address:** 6 Baldwin St, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA

**Phone (Primary):** (973) 746-1398

**Mobile Phone:** +1 973-746-1398

Due to the bustling nature of this popular local spot, it is recommended to call ahead for catering inquiries or larger orders to ensure the fastest service.

## What is Worth Choosing

For the New Jersey resident, Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli is definitively worth choosing because it embodies the quintessential, high-quality Italian-American deli experience that the state is famous for. You are not just buying a sandwich; you are getting a piece of Montclair's local history, built on a decades-old family tradition of authentic Italian baking.

The quality starts with the bread, which is fresh and crusty, providing the perfect structure for the generous fillings. What sets Nicolo’s apart is the use of signature, premium components—the perfectly cooked **Chicken Cutlets**, the imported meats, and the delicious homemade fresh mozzarella. The opportunity to customize your hero with flavorful additions like **cherry pepper spread** for heat or **Escarole Oreganata** for an authentically savory taste makes every sandwich experience unique and exceptional.

Furthermore, Nicolo's is the superior choice for catering needs in the region. Whether it’s a small holiday gathering or a large football party, the ability to order massive, feed-a-crowd **Party Subs** or large, authentic trays of **Eggplant Parmigiana** or **Ravioli** streamlines party planning. In a state where great Italian food is a source of local pride, choosing Nicolo's means choosing a cherished, community-loved deli that consistently delivers on freshness, size, and tradition. It’s a weekly staple for some and a necessary pilgrimage for others, making it one of the very best Italian delis in **North Jersey**.

Nicolo's Italian Bakery and Deli

6 Baldwin St, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA