Noble Pies

- Best Pies in New York, 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591

Introduction / Overview: Noble Pies – A Taste of Home on Tarrytown’s Main Street

For New York residents venturing into the scenic heart of the Hudson Valley, Noble Pies in Tarrytown, NY, stands out as an essential stop for high-quality, handcrafted baked goods. This establishment is more than just a Bakery; it proudly operates as a dedicated Pie shop, offering a full spectrum of delectable treats. From classic fruit pies that celebrate local produce to hearty, savory pot pies perfect for a weeknight dinner, Noble Pies has carved out a reputation for specializing in a beloved American dessert.

Located at the address famously self-proclaimed as "Best Pies in New York," this bakery lives up to the promise of delivering a truly specialized dessert experience. The focus here is squarely on the crust and filling, whether it’s the sweet nostalgia of a Hudson Valley Apple or the creamy indulgence of a Black Dirt Chocolate Cream. Customers appreciate the convenience of its location, particularly those commuting, who find it a great spot to pick up a treat before or after their journey.

Noble Pies also expands its offerings beyond traditional fruit pies. It functions as a Dessert shop and a small Cake shop, and even offers a selection of thick, creamy Ice cream that is highly recommended as the perfect accompaniment to their warm pies. The menu features a balanced mix of sweet and savory items, including Vegetable Quiche and a variety of substantial savory pot pies, making it a viable option for lunch or dinner, not just dessert.

While the vast majority of local New York customers rave about the quality of the ingredients—like the sweet, chunky filling of the Peach Pie and the highly praised crispy, pliable crust—it is important to note the nature of local business feedback. Some reviewers, while acknowledging the focus on pies, have occasionally reported inconsistencies with the baking of the crust on specific items like the Pumpkin Pie. However, the consistent positive commentary on items like the Key Lime, the rich ice cream, and the savory pot pies solidifies Noble Pies' status as a popular, reliable spot in the Westchester area.

Location and Accessibility: Easily Found on Tarrytown's Main Thoroughfare

Noble Pies is conveniently situated at 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA. Main Street in Tarrytown is a central hub for dining and shopping, offering excellent visibility and foot traffic.

One of the biggest advantages for local commuters and travelers is the shop's proximity to the Tarrytown train station, making it a perfect spot for grabbing a freshly baked slice or a whole pie on the way home. The accessibility of the location is noted by patrons as a significant plus.

Regarding accessibility for all customers, the shop offers a crucial amenity for New York patrons visiting by car:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot is available, ensuring easier access for those with mobility needs.

The central Main Street location ensures that whether you are a Westchester resident or a tourist exploring the Hudson Valley, Noble Pies is an effortless and rewarding stop to include in your day's itinerary.

Services Offered: Takeout, Delivery, and a Quick Visit Stop

Noble Pies focuses on efficient and convenient service models that cater to the on-the-go lifestyle of New York customers and the desire for quality home entertaining:

• Off-Premise Services: Offers three core services for customers who prefer to enjoy their goods at home: Delivery, In-store pickup, and standard Takeout.
• Dining Pace: Caters perfectly to a Quick visit, ideal for grabbing a slice of pie, a cup of coffee, or a whole pie without a long wait.
• Payment Convenience: Accepts modern payment methods for speed and ease, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Catering to Immediate Needs: The ability to purchase a Fresh Slice Of Pie (both sweet and savory) provides an excellent option for immediate cravings or a quick, fulfilling lunch.

Features / Highlights: Handcrafted Pies and Savory Meals

Noble Pies stands out in the competitive New York bakery scene due to several unique features and commitments to quality:

• Specialization in Pie: Unlike general bakeries, Noble Pies dedicates its focus to pies, offering distinct categories: Sweet Pies (e.g., Pineapple Paradise, Mixed Berry), rich Cream Pies (Key Lime Pie, Black Dirt Chocolate Cream), and hearty Savory Pies.
• Showcase of Local Flavor: Features pies that celebrate the region, such as the signature Hudson Valley Apple pie, utilizing local ingredients where possible.
• Savory Lunch/Dinner Options: Offers substantial savory selections that work as full meals, including the popular Buffalo Chicken Pot Pie, Shepherds Pie With Beef, and Vegetable Curry Pie, available as both whole pies ($34.00) and convenient slices (approx. $8.95).
• Highly Praised Texture: Customers frequently highlight the quality of the baking, with one review specifically noting the delicious crust as "crispy on the top with a pliable texture."
• Exceptional Extras: The shop offers high-quality pairings, including Coffee to enjoy with a slice and praised Ice cream that is described as "thick and creamy" and is highly recommended to accompany a warm pie slice.
• The Whipped Cream Advantage: The accompanying whipped cream receives enthusiastic mentions from customers ("a plus plus plus!"), often recommended as a must-add to any sweet pie order.

Contact Information: Connect with Noble Pies in Tarrytown

For ordering the perfect pie for your next gathering or checking on daily savory pie slices, use the following contact information:

Address: Best Pies in New York, 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone: (914) 418-5649

What is Worth Choosing: Savory Comfort or Fruit-Filled Bliss

For a New York customer seeking comfort and quality, Noble Pies offers two compelling paths that are equally worth choosing.

First, the Sweet Pies are the main event. Choosing the Hudson Valley Apple or the seasonal Strawberry Rhubarb is a great choice for experiencing the flavor profile that has earned the bakery its acclaim. Patrons specifically endorse pies with a distinct filling, such as the Peach Pie, which delivers a delightful balance of sweetness, fruit chunks, and that perfect crust. The Cream Pies, particularly the Black Dirt Chocolate Cream or the refreshing Key Lime Pie, offer a richer, chilled alternative. No matter which sweet slice you choose, adding the highly recommended, house-made whipped cream is considered essential by local fans.

Second, the Savory Pies are an unmissable part of the Noble Pies experience. These are not mere side dishes but substantial, full-flavored meals. The Buffalo Chicken Pot Pie is a unique and robust comfort food option, and the classic Chicken Pot Pie or the herb-infused Shepherds Pie With Beef provides a quick, convenient, and satisfying lunch or dinner. The ability to grab these as individual slices ($8.49 - $8.95) makes them ideal for a grab-and-go meal near the Tarrytown train station.

In essence, Noble Pies is worth choosing because it delivers a specialized, focused product that resonates with the desire for authentic, handcrafted quality. It’s the local Westchester spot that perfects the pie, making it an excellent choice whether you're bringing dessert to a gathering or simply craving a savory slice of high-quality comfort food.

Noble Pies

Best Pies in New York, 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA