OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

- Pier 5, 334 Furman St, Brooklyn Heights, NY 11201

For anyone in New York City with a serious sweet tooth, finding the perfect ice cream is a quest. Thankfully, the search often leads to OddFellows Ice Cream Co., a beloved local institution known for its imaginative and delectable frozen treats. Located at Pier 5 in Brooklyn Bridge Park, OddFellows is far more than your average ice cream shop; it’s a destination where classic flavors meet culinary creativity. It’s the kind of place that turns a simple dessert run into an exciting flavor adventure, making it a favorite among Brooklyn residents and visitors alike.

OddFellows has built its reputation on a foundation of both quality and innovation. While they offer comforting classics like Vanilla, Chocolate, and Coffee Crunch, they also venture into truly unique territory with flavors like Olive Oil Jelly Donut and Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio. This commitment to both the familiar and the surprising ensures that there is always something new to try, keeping customers coming back for more. Whether you’re an adventurous eater or a traditionalist, OddFellows has a scoop (or two) for you. The shop’s ability to create such a wide array of flavors is what sets it apart and makes it a standout in New York’s competitive dessert scene.

The experience at OddFellows is all about the joy of discovery. A customer review highlighted this perfectly, mentioning that even with limited evening options, they "had great and unique flavors!" and praised the "awesome" Mango Sticky Rice flavor with "specks of sticky rice inside!" This kind of attention to detail and texture is what transforms a simple scoop of ice cream into a truly memorable dessert. It’s a testament to the brand's dedication to craftsmanship and quality, using real ingredients to create an authentic and flavorful experience.

However, it's worth noting that the experience can vary. One review mentioned a less-than-perfect experience, citing a disliked flavor and a minor issue with service. This is a good reminder that taste is subjective, and it's always best to follow your own instincts when choosing a flavor. While the service might have room for improvement at times, the overall quality and unique offerings are what keep the crowds coming. The shop's popularity, especially during peak hours, can lead to some flavors selling out, so it's best to go with an open mind and be ready to try something new.

In the end, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is a quintessential New York dessert spot. It’s a place that reflects the city's diverse and innovative spirit, offering a little bit of everything for everyone. From vegan options like Vegan Coconut Caramel Chip to rich, classic flavors, OddFellows ensures that no one is left out of the fun. So, whether you’re looking for a quick scoop on a hot day or a delightful treat after a walk through Brooklyn Bridge Park, OddFellows is a destination you’ll want to visit again and again.

Location and Accessibility

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. enjoys a prime location at Pier 5, 334 Furman St, Brooklyn Heights, NY 11201, USA. This puts it right in the heart of Brooklyn Bridge Park, offering customers not only delicious ice cream but also breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline, the Statue of Liberty, and the iconic Brooklyn Bridge.

Getting to OddFellows is part of the fun. The shop is easily accessible via a variety of transportation methods. For those using the subway, the nearest stations are Borough Hall (2, 3, 4, 5, R lines) and Jay St-MetroTech (A, C, F, R lines), both of which are a pleasant walk through the beautiful Brooklyn Heights neighborhood and down to the waterfront. The NYC Ferry also has a stop at Pier 6, making it a scenic and convenient option.

If you prefer to bike, Brooklyn Bridge Park has dedicated bike paths and racks, making OddFellows a great stop on a cycling tour of the waterfront. The location is perfect for families enjoying a day at the park's playgrounds or for anyone looking for a sweet treat after a walk or run along the promenade.

Services Offered

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. focuses on a streamlined and enjoyable customer experience.

• Takeout: The shop operates primarily as a takeout establishment, allowing you to grab your favorite flavor and enjoy it while exploring the scenic surroundings of Brooklyn Bridge Park.

Features / Highlights

OddFellows stands out for several key reasons that make it a local favorite.

• Unique and Creative Flavors: The shop is famous for its wide array of innovative flavors that go far beyond the basics. From savory-inspired options like Olive Oil to surprising combinations like Chocotorta, there's always something new to explore.
• Vegan Options: OddFellows is inclusive of various dietary needs, offering delicious vegan flavors such as Vegan Coconut Caramel Chip, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a treat.
• Classic and Soft Serve Options: For those who prefer the familiar, OddFellows provides classic flavors like Vanilla and Chocolate, along with soft serve, giving customers a choice between traditional scoops and a creamy, swirled delight.
• Coffee Offerings: In addition to ice cream, OddFellows also serves coffee, making it a great spot for a pick-me-up or an affogato-style treat.
• Prime Location: Situated in Brooklyn Bridge Park, the shop offers a perfect backdrop for enjoying your dessert, with stunning views and a lively atmosphere.

Contact Information

Ready to stop by for a scoop? Here’s the information you need.

Address: Pier 5, 334 Furman St, Brooklyn Heights, NY 11201, USA

What is worth choosing

In the bustling landscape of New York City, choosing an ice cream shop can be overwhelming. OddFellows Ice Cream Co. at Pier 5 stands out for compelling reasons that make it a must-visit destination. The most significant draw is the sheer creativity of their flavors. While many shops offer the standard fare, OddFellows pushes the boundaries, creating unique and memorable tastes that you won't find anywhere else. The Olive Oil and Pecan Sticky Bun flavors are a testament to their innovative spirit, inviting you to step outside your comfort zone and be rewarded with a truly unique dessert experience.

Beyond the exciting flavors, the quality of the product is consistently high. The Mango Sticky Rice review, which praised the texture and authentic ingredients, highlights the shop's commitment to crafting a quality product. Whether it’s a classic scoop or a more adventurous one, you can expect a rich, creamy, and flavorful treat. This focus on craftsmanship ensures that even if you choose a flavor you don't love, the quality of the ice cream itself will still be top-notch.

The location is another key factor. Situated within Brooklyn Bridge Park, OddFellows offers more than just a sweet treat—it offers an experience. You can enjoy your ice cream with one of the most iconic backdrops in the world, making it a perfect spot for a date, a family outing, or a solo moment of relaxation. The combination of delicious dessert and beautiful scenery is unbeatable. It’s the kind of place you plan a visit around, not just a quick stop.

Furthermore, OddFellows is a place that accommodates a variety of tastes. They understand that not everyone wants a wild flavor, which is why they still offer delicious classics. Their commitment to providing vegan options also makes them a great choice for those with dietary restrictions. The presence of coffee is an added bonus, offering yet another reason to visit and perhaps enjoy an affogato or a simple coffee alongside your scoop. In a market full of choices, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. distinguishes itself by offering a truly unique, high-quality, and well-rounded experience that is worth seeking out.

OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

Pier 5, 334 Furman St, Brooklyn Heights, NY 11201, USA