Papa Johns Pizza in New Hyde Park, NY: Your Go-To for Epic Crusts, Wings, and Late-Night Delivery in Nassau County

Papa Johns Pizza Introduce

For residents across Long Island and the adjacent Queens neighborhoods, when the craving for a quick, reliable, and deeply satisfying pizza experience hits, the Papa Johns Pizza location at 909 Hillside Avenue in New Hyde Park, NY, is a well-established destination. This particular location holds a unique place in the company's history, having celebrated the opening of the 4,000th Papa John's restaurant globally in 2012 right here in New Hyde Park. This history underlines its significance as a key food service provider in Nassau County, committed to delivering on the brand's enduring promise of "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza."

Beyond its brand recognition, this Papa Johns excels by offering a dynamic menu that caters to diverse New York tastes, from classic favorites to the latest culinary innovations. It is a full-service pizza restaurant that operates primarily through convenient service options—delivery and takeout—making it the quintessential spot for easy lunch, dinner, and even late-night food needs. The atmosphere is consistently casual, and the service is structured for quick bites and comfort food, ideal for solo diners, families, and catering group events alike. The New Hyde Park location specifically addresses the busy lives of New Yorkers by offering both traditional pizza masterpieces and a compelling line of specialty items, including the indulgent Epic Stuffed Crust and the locally appealing New York Style Crust, cut into oversized, foldable slices.

The menu selection is comprehensive, extending far beyond the typical pizza joint offerings. Patrons can explore everything from savory Papadias (flatbread-style sandwiches) and diverse wing flavors—including Honey Chipotle and Garlic Parmesan—to a variety of desserts like Double Chocolate Chip Brownies and OREO® Cookie Papa Bites. While the promise of quick service and convenience is a hallmark, prospective customers should note that, as with any high-volume takeout and delivery venue, service quality can occasionally fluctuate, as indicated by varied customer feedback. However, for a massive menu, strong deals, and ultimate convenience in the New Hyde Park area, Papa Johns remains a top choice for consistent and affordable comfort food.

Location and Accessibility

The New Hyde Park Papa Johns Pizza is conveniently situated on Long Island’s well-trafficked Hillside Avenue, ensuring it is a visible and easily reached spot for both pickup and delivery operations serving a wide area of Nassau County and nearby Queens.

The physical address is:

909 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA

Accessibility and convenience for the local New York customer base are paramount at this location:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures ease of access for all community members.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated, convenient parking spaces are available.
Free Parking Lot and Free Street Parking: A highly valuable feature in the busy suburban New York area, alleviating the stress of finding and paying for parking.
Multiple Ordering Options: The primary model supports Delivery, No-contact delivery, and Takeout, maximizing convenience for customers who prefer to eat at home, host a party, or grab a quick meal on the go.

The location is perfectly set up to serve the community throughout the day and well into the night, a key service for those looking for late-night food.

Services Offered

This Papa Johns Pizza location focuses on maximum convenience, speed, and variety through its service model.

No-Contact Delivery and Standard Delivery: Providing safe and convenient delivery options across the New Hyde Park service area.
Takeout/Carryout: Available for customers who prefer to pick up their orders directly.
Late-Night Food Service: Menu options are available late, including Cinnamon Pull Aparts, Oreo Papa Bites, and wings, catering to customers needing a quick bite late in the evening.
Catering: Offers comprehensive solutions for group events, parties, and business lunches with Group Suggestions or Create Your Own options.
Full Menu of Sides and Desserts: Includes Papa Bites, Breadsticks, Wings, and various dipping sauces to complement any pizza order.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.
Free Wi-Fi: Available to customers on-site.

Features / Highlights

The New Hyde Park Papa Johns is highlighted by several key menu innovations and customer conveniences that set it apart.

Innovation in Crusts: Known for offering a diverse range of specialty crusts beyond the Original, notably the highly-praised Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust and the regional nod to the New York Style Crust, which features oversized, foldable slices.
Signature & Specialty Pizzas: Offers a wide array of specialized pies, including the Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, The Works Pizza, and the popular Shaq-A-Roni Pizza, catering to nearly every flavor profile.
Expansive Side Menu: A significant highlight is the full lineup of sides and non-pizza meals, such as ten varieties of bone-in and boneless Wings, savory Papadias, and the customizable Papa Bowls.
Focus on Comfort and Speed: The restaurant is categorized for providing "Comfort food" and a "Quick bite," making it an efficient option for daily meals.
Good for Kids: The menu variety, including classic cheese and pepperoni, sides, and desserts, makes it a reliable choice for families and "Good for kids."
Promotional Value: The brand is generally recognized for offering "Good deals" and a variety of coupons and specials that enhance affordability for local customers.

Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or carryout, or for general inquiries, New Hyde Park residents can use the following contact details:

Address: 909 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA

Phone: (516) 437-8000

Mobile Phone: +1 516-437-8000

What is Worth Choosing

When ordering from the Papa Johns in New Hyde Park, Long Island, a few items and services truly stand out and offer the best experience based on the menu and brand popularity.

The most exciting choices revolve around the crust innovations. For those seeking an indulgent, cheesy experience, the Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza is a standout. This premium option takes the classic stuffed crust—made with fresh, never-frozen dough filled with melty cheese—and infuses it with Papa Johns’ signature garlic flavor both in the crust itself and a drizzle on top, offering a rich flavor profile that is distinct and satisfying.

Alternatively, for New Yorkers who appreciate the regional classic, the New York Style Crust is a top choice. This crust is hand-stretched thinner than the original, providing a texture that is slightly crispy on the outside and chewy inside, and is deliberately cut into oversized slices that can be folded—perfect for a grab-and-go meal that pays homage to the local pizza tradition.

Beyond pizza, the selection of Wings is a worthwhile addition. With ten different flavor and style combinations, from Unsauced Roasted to the popular Honey Chipotle Boneless Wings, they offer an excellent complement to any pie. Don't forget to customize your order with one of the brand's many Dipping Sauces. The Special Garlic Sauce is a must-have, a signature that elevates the flavor of any crust, especially the breadsticks and the plain Epic Stuffed options. The Papadias are also highly recommended for a quick, single-serving lunch, with the Philly Cheesesteak Papadia being a hearty and flavorful choice. Ultimately, choosing this Papa Johns is about embracing convenience and menu innovation, ensuring a satisfying meal is just a quick order away, day or night.

Papa Johns Pizza Food & drink

Create Your Own
Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza $19.24
Choose your favorite toppings and cheese up your crust. Epicness is now even easier. Indulge in your favorite pizza paired with a pillowy, savory, cheese-filled crust.
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza $20.24
Epic Stuffed Crust meets your favorite garlic sauce flavor. The Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust pizza has our signature garlic flavor stuffed into and drizzled on the cheesy crust. Served with our Special Garlic Dipping Sauce — the flavor that inspired it all!
Create Your Own Pizza $12.99
Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!
Garlic 5-Cheese Crust Pizza $18.24
Our original dough coated in garlic-parmesan sauce and seasoned with an Italian 5-cheese blend, including parmesan, romano, asiago, fontina and provolone on the crust.
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust $9.74
Our Ancient Grains Gluten-Free Crust is thin, crispy and layered with signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and your favorite toppings.
New York Style Crust $16.24
NY Style pizza is more delicious than ever when it’s made with Papa Johns fresh, never frozen dough. Oversized, foldable slices with just the right balance of crust and your favorite toppings.

Extras
Pepperoncinis $0.99
Our signature whole pepperoncini peppers are subtly sweet, medium-heat and grown in the Mediterranean regions.
Banana Peppers $0.50
Some people go bananas for Papa John’s banana peppers. Perhaps because they’re as flavorful as they are colorful. Our real banana peppers are brined with vinegar to keep them bright yellow.
Jalapeño Peppers $0.92
With honest and authentic ingredients like our jalapeno peppers, great taste comes naturally to Papa John’s. Fresh sliced and packed in a spicy brine with turmeric spice, the real Jalapeno Peppers are perfect when you want just a little extra pizzazz on your pizza.
Special Seasonings $0.50
Special Seasonings
Parmesan Cheese $0.50
Parmesan Cheese
Crushed Red Pepper $0.50
Crushed Red Pepper
Anchovies $1.50
Anchovy fillets

Wings
Honey Chipotle Boneless Wings $11.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken lightly breaded, oven-baked, and tossed in our honey chipotle sauce that's the perfect blend of sweet and spicy. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Unsauced Roasted Wings $10.49
No sauce? No worries. We’ll make your bone-in wings just the way you like them: oven-baked and unsauced so they’re unbelievably tender and tasty. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
BBQ Boneless Wings $11.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken lightly breaded, oven-baked, and tossed in our thick and bold smokehouse-style BBQ sauce. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Buffalo Wings $10.49
Kick it up a notch with our oven-baked bone-in wings tossed in satisfyingly spicy buffalo sauce with just the right amount of heat to enhance our juicy wings. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
BBQ Wings $10.49
We never just wing it with Papa Johns BBQ wings. Our made-to-order, bone-in wings are oven-baked and covered in a thick and bold smokehouse-style BBQ sauce. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Buffalo Boneless Wings $11.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken lightly breaded, oven-baked, and tossed in our satisfyingly spicy buffalo sauce with just the right amount of heat. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Unsauced Boneless Wings $11.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken lightly breaded and oven-baked. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Honey Chipotle Wings $10.49
A perfect blend of sweet and spicy, honey chipotle sauce adds a savory flavor to our bone-in, oven-baked wings. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings $11.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken, lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown. Tossed in our savory garlic parmesan sauce. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Garlic Parmesan Wings $10.49
Bone-in wings are oven baked and tossed in garlic parmesan sauce.

Drinks
Schweppes Ginger Ale $3.45
Schweppes Ginger Ale
Pepsi $3.45
Pepsi
Mug Root Beer $3.45
Mug Root Beer
Pepsi Zero Sugar $3.45
Pepsi Zero Sugar
Aquafina $2.40
Aquafina
Mountain Dew $3.45
Mountain Dew
Diet Pepsi $3.45
Diet Pepsi
Lipton Brisk Sweet Tea Lemon $3.45
Lipton Brisk Sweet Tea Lemon
Starry $3.45
Starry
Crush Orange $3.45
Crush Orange

Papa Bites
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites $5.99
Eight sweet bites of OREO® Cookie wrapped in our original fresh dough and drizzled in icing. Baked fresh and served with cream cheese icing dipping sauce on the side.
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites $5.99
Eight savory bites of flavorful chicken and parmesan cheese, wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with original pizza dipping sauce on the side.
Jalapeño Papa Bites $5.99
Eight spicy bites of flavorful jalapeños, creamy alfredo sauce, and our signature cheese wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with ranch dipping sauce on the side.

Sides
Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks $6.99
Fresh dough baked to a golden brown then topped with our Special Garlic sauce and Parmesan cheese. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping.
Cheesesticks $7.99
Original fresh dough covered with Special Garlic sauce, topped with mounds of real cheese made from mozzarella, then baked to a cheesy, gooey goodness. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping!
Original Breadsticks $6.49
You can’t live by bread alone. On the other hand, some can’t live without our breadsticks. Fresh dough baked to a golden brown. Served with Original Pizza sauce for dipping.
Garlic Knots $5.99
Eight Garlic Knots made with fresh dough and garlic Parmesan seasoning, served with original pizza sauce. Share a Papa Johns side that’s sure to please.
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites $5.99
Eight savory bites of flavorful chicken and parmesan cheese, wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with original pizza dipping sauce on the side.
Jalapeño Papa Bites $5.99
Eight spicy bites of flavorful jalapeños, creamy alfredo sauce, and our signature cheese wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with ranch dipping sauce on the side.
Tuscan 6-Cheese Cheesesticks $8.99
Enjoy a taste of Tuscany with our fresh dough covered in Special Garlic sauce and smothered in an authentic six-cheese blend of real cheese made from Mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, provolone and Fontina. Sprinkled with our blend of Italian herb seasonings for an extra dash of flavor. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping.

Dipping Sauces
Cream Cheese Icing $0.50
Cream Cheese Icing
Original Pizza Sauce $0.50
Original Pizza Sauce
Buffalo Spicy Sauce $0.50
Buffalo Spicy Sauce
Barbeque Sauce $0.50
Barbeque Sauce
Special Zesty Sauce $0.92
Special Zesty Sauce
Honey Mustard Sauce $0.50
Honey Mustard Sauce
Spicy Garlic Sauce $0.50
Spicy Garlic Sauce
Ranch Sauce $0.92
Ranch Sauce
Cheese Sauce $0.50
Cheese Sauce
Blue Cheese Sauce $0.50
Blue Cheese Sauce
Special Garlic Sauce $0.50
Special Garlic Sauce

Desserts
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie $6.99
A decadent delight for chocolate lovers. This cakey on the outside, fudgy in the middle brownie is filled with rich chocolate chips, baked fresh and cut into nine squares, then served warm.
Cinnamon Pull Aparts $6.99
Bite-sized sweet roll pieces covered in cinnamon and sugar, topped with cinnamon crumbles then baked to a gooey goodness and drizzled with sweet cream cheese icing.
Chocolate Chip Cookie $6.99
Save room for dessert. Papa Johns' family-size Chocolate Chip Cookie is baked fresh, cut into 8 slices and served warm.
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites $5.99
Eight sweet bites of OREO® Cookie wrapped in our original fresh dough and drizzled in icing. Baked fresh and served with cream cheese icing dipping sauce on the side.

Papadias
Create Your Own Papadia $7.00
Pizza sauce, cheese and up to three favorite toppings. Served with garlic dipping sauce.
Italian Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich with Alfredo sauce, cheese, Italian sausage, salami and banana peppers. Served with original pizza dipping sauce.
Philly Cheesesteak Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich with Philly sauce, cheese, steak, onions and green peppers. Served with garlic dipping sauce.
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich made from original fresh dough and loaded with grilled chicken, onions, our signature cheese plus our 3-cheese blend, buttermilk ranch sauce, and buffalo sauce. Served with ranch dipping sauce.
BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich with grilled chicken, bacon, onions, cheese, and BBQ sauce. Served with BBQ dipping sauce.

Most Popular
Cheese Pizza $12.99
Simple, yet simply delicious. Real cheese made from mozzarella on top of our signature pizza sauce with your choice of crust, then baked to a golden brown. It has just what you want, and nothing you don’t.
Pepperoni Pizza $12.99
Your choice of crust covered with our signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and pepperoni. With a pepperoni in almost every bite, it's one of our most popular pizzas.
Sausage Pizza $12.99
Our signature pizza sauce layered with sausage and real cheese made from mozzarella for a taste you’ll crave. Your choice of crust.

Papa Bowls
Create Your Own Papa Bowl $8.49
No crust. Just your favorite pizza toppings in a bowl. Delicious vegetables, savory meats, melty cheeses, and our signature sauces are baked to piping hot perfection. Choose from our carefully crafted flavors or create your own. *Italian Seasoning contains gluten

Newly Added
Epic Stuffed Crust $19.24
Epic Stuffed Crust
New York Style Crust $16.24
NY Style pizza is more delicious than ever when it’s made with Papa Johns fresh, never frozen dough. Oversized, foldable slices with just the right balance of crust and your favorite toppings.
Shaq-A-Roni Pizza $19.24
Extra cheese and extra pepperoni on an extra large New York style pizza cut into 8 oversized, foldable slices. Served with our Special Garlic Sauce and a pepperoncini.
Garlic 5-Cheese Crust Pizza $18.24
Our original dough coated in garlic-parmesan sauce and seasoned with an Italian 5-cheese blend, including parmesan, romano, asiago, fontina and provolone on the crust.
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust $20.24
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust

Late Night
Cinnamon Pull Apart $0.00
Cinnamon Pull Apart
Oreo Papa Bites $0.00
Oreo Papa Bites
8 Piece Buffalo Wings $0.00
8 Piece Buffalo Wings

Pizza
Super Hawaiian Pizza $15.99
Get a taste of the tropics. This super delicious pizza is loaded with sweet, juicy pineapple tidbits, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, hickory-smoked bacon, a three-cheese blend, and real cheese made from mozzarella on our signature sauce and original fresh dough.
The Works Pizza $15.99
It’s everything you want on a pizza – and then some. A heaping helping of pepperoni, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, spicy Italian sausage, fresh-cut onions, crisp green peppers, mushrooms, ripe black olives, and real cheese made from mozzarella. When you’re hungry for a hearty pizza, the Works always works.
BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza $15.99
We had you at bacon, right? It gets even better. Smoky Southern-style BBQ sauce adds a tangy twist to this irresistible pizza topped with grilled chicken, hickory-smoked bacon, fresh-cut onions, and real cheese made from mozzarella. Round one up today.
Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza $15.99
Crafted with fresh cream and Parmesan and Romano cheeses, our 2-Cheese Alfredo sauce is deliciously creamy. We top it with fresh baby spinach, fresh-cut Roma tomatoes, real cheese made from mozzarella, plus classic Italian seasoning for an extra dash of flavor.
The Meats Pizza $15.99
A masterpiece of hearty, high-quality meats including pepperoni, savory sausage, real beef, hickory-smoked bacon, and julienne-cut Canadian bacon, all topped with real cheese made from mozzarella.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza $15.99
Whether you’re a native Philadelphian or still waiting to visit the City of Brotherly Love, “youse” can enjoy an elevated form of the classic Philly cheesesteak in this original tribute to the king of hot sandwiches, the Papa John’s Philly Cheesesteak pizza. Considered by its fans to be one of the best Papa John’s pizza varieties, this meaty and cheesy triumph will keep the party going all night long. For a flavorful treat that would satisfy even the Philly Phanatic, try the Philly Cheesesteak pizza from Papa John’s.
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza $15.99
Just when you think our pepperoni pizza couldn’t get any tastier, we craft the ultimate masterpiece. Our original fresh dough is covered with signature pizza sauce, 30% more pepperoni than our traditional pie, a blend of Parmesan and Romano, and real cheese made from mozzarella, all sprinkled with classic Italian seasoning.
Garden Fresh Pizza $15.99
All your favorite veggies together on a delightfully delicious pizza. Loaded with crisp green peppers, fresh-cut onions, mushrooms, ripe black olives, vine-ripened Roma tomatoes, and real cheese made from mozzarella.
Shaq-A-Roni Pizza $19.24
Extra cheese and extra pepperoni on an extra large New York style pizza cut into 8 oversized, foldable slices. Served with our Special Garlic Sauce and a pepperoncini.
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza $15.99
Aloha! You’re on island time with the Hawaiian BBQ Chicken pizza. Smothered in smoky BBQ sauce, it’s topped with grilled chicken, hickory-smoked bacon, real cheese made from mozzarella, plus fresh-cut onions, and sweet, juicy pineapple tidbits for a taste of the tropics.
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza $15.99
Experience the authentic taste of Italy! Layered with signature pizza sauce and an authentic blend of Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, Fontina, provolone, and real cheese made from mozzarella. Baked hot and fresh then finished with classic Italian seasoning.
Zesty Italian Trio Pizza $15.99
A tasty trio of zesty Italian sausage, salami, and pepperoni, plus banana peppers, a three-cheese blend, and real cheese made from mozzarella on our signature sauce and original fresh dough. Sprinkled with classic Italian seasoning for an extra dash of flavor.
Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza $15.99
We’re bringing the heat with more of the bold buffalo flavor you love. Our original crust is covered in a new buffalo sauce with a hint of buttery richness and a tangy, craveable kick. Piled high with grilled chicken, hickory-smoked bacon, fresh-cut onions, and real cheese made from mozzarella.

Papa Johns Pizza Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Table service

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Papa Johns Pizza Photos

Papa Johns Pizza Location

Papa Johns Pizza

New York Nassau County New Hyde Park Hillside Avenue

909 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA

Papa Johns Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★3.5 from 236 user reviews.

pricepiequick servicetoppingscheese stickscheese pizzachicken wingschilli flakesmeat pizzareceipt

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Great experience & quick service. Good deals. Will be coming back. Dominis will forever be my first choice tho. Try to catch up Papa Johns.
June 19 · San “Paranoid”
We gave this store multiple opportunities before we gave a bad review. Today has been the worst service. Ordered 2 pies, bone-in chicken wings and garlic knots. The toppings look like it was thrown into the air and had it land on the pizza. It was cooked so fast the bottom was burnt and the toppings were raw. When I told them I ordered the wings they said they don't have. The wings were replaced without my knowledge into boneless wings that were so dry. I'm sick of the service they provide and how they treat people. My last and final time eating here. I would highly discourage anyone to ever order from here.
July 20 · Shawn
I got 2 large pizzas cheese pizza was ok meat pizza very less meat. Asked the guy at counter for some chili flakes he gave me 1 pkt I said 2 pizza and 1 pkt he said it cost us money. His attitude was like you are getting pizza for free from here. Papa John's corporate office don't care about customer reviews or concerns. The attitude is like If you want you buy or else go somewhere else. It's a shame big company papajohns is ignoring customers.
July 10 · Abey k
Very subpar undercooked food. We got the garlic stuffed cheese pizza with spicy sausage and pepperoni. Wasted some 31$ for the undercooked pizza. There was hardly any cheese in the stuffed crust. It had raw dough at places and some parts were burnt.We also got the chicken wings which tasted better but were so tiny in size that it was not worth the money.
February 22 · Shilpa Kaur
Pizza was not cooked and the guys are super rude. Even they gave me open box of pizza and asked me to close by myself. Be careful guys they are not clean worst branch.
November 05 · Abdul Qadir