Pezzi Pizza Inc: Your Go-To Local Italian Spot in Sea Cliff, NY

Pezzi Pizza Inc Introduce

Welcome to Pezzi Pizza Inc, a true staple in the Long Island dining scene, nestled right in the charming community of Sea Cliff, NY. For residents across the North Shore and beyond, Pezzi Pizza Inc is much more than just a pizzeria—it’s a long-standing local favorite celebrated for its commitment to high-quality Italian-American cuisine, generous portions, and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. From a quick slice to a full family dinner, this establishment has perfected the art of comforting, flavorful Italian food, making it a must-visit spot for anyone in the New York area seeking an authentic, satisfying meal.

Since its inception, Pezzi Pizza Inc has built a reputation for its classic approach to pizza and pasta, all while maintaining a welcoming, casual environment that is perfectly suited for lunch breaks, casual dinners, or gathering with a group. They proudly serve up those essential Italian dishes that feel like home, using fresh ingredients and recipes that have kept customers coming back for years. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through the beautiful Sea Cliff area, Pezzi Pizza Inc promises a delicious, dependable, and delightfully Italian experience.

The dedication to fantastic flavor is evident across their extensive menu. Locals consistently rave about the quality, noting that the food is always prepared with care and never compromises on taste—even simple side dishes like their sautéed spinach are favorites. This focus on consistency and flavor, coupled with an accommodating and efficient service model, solidifies Pezzi Pizza Inc’s status as a premier local Italian restaurant in the competitive New York dining landscape.

Location and Accessibility

Pezzi Pizza Inc is conveniently situated at 500 Glen Cove Ave in Sea Cliff, NY 11579, making it easily reachable for patrons throughout Nassau County and the surrounding Long Island communities. The location is easily accessible by car, and visitors will appreciate the thoughtful amenities put in place to ensure a smooth visit for everyone.

For drivers, the restaurant offers both a free private parking lot and free street parking, eliminating the typical hassle of finding a spot in a busy area. This focus on guest comfort extends to its physical accessibility features, ensuring that the dining experience is inclusive for all. Pezzi Pizza Inc features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, a wheelchair-accessible restroom, and wheelchair-accessible seating options, making it a truly welcoming spot for every member of the community.

The establishment's prime position on Glen Cove Avenue makes it a simple, central stop for residents of Sea Cliff, Glen Head, Glen Cove, and other neighboring Long Island towns, solidifying its role as a neighborhood hub for authentic Italian fare.

Services Offered

Pezzi Pizza Inc understands the varied needs of its local New York clientele, offering multiple service options to suit any occasion, from a quick meal to a catered event. Their services are designed for convenience and quality, ensuring every customer gets their favorite Italian dish exactly how they want it.

Dine-in: Enjoy the casual and cheerful atmosphere of the restaurant, perfect for both solo diners and groups. The dining space is often described as feeling like "a little slice of Italy," complete with charming décor.

Takeout: Fast and efficient service for those who want to grab their order and enjoy it at home or elsewhere. The staff is known for being attentive and ensuring orders are accurate and ready when promised.

Delivery: Offering both standard delivery and no-contact delivery options for the ultimate convenience across the local area.

Catering: Pezzi Pizza Inc is available to cater special occasions, providing generous and high-quality Italian-American dishes for family events, parties, and corporate gatherings.

Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, making it easier for groups or families to plan their visit without a long wait.

Features / Highlights

What makes Pezzi Pizza Inc stand out in the competitive New York food scene is a combination of its excellent cuisine, reliable service, and commitment to being a true community establishment. Customers frequently highlight several key elements that define the Pezzi Pizza Inc experience:

Exceptional Pizza Crust: Reviewers consistently praise the pizza, specifically noting the crispy bottom crust and the flavor of fresh ingredients, such as oregano, which adds a memorable touch to the classic slice.

Specialty Pizzas: While the classic cheese and Sicilian slices are perfect, the restaurant is highly regarded for its specialty pies, including the crowd-pleasing Buffalo Chicken and BBQ Chicken pizzas.

Extensive Menu Variety: Beyond pizza, the menu is massive, featuring a deep bench of Italian-American classics like baked pasta dishes (Baked Ziti, Lasagna, Manicotti), a range of calzones and rolls (Buffalo Roll, Stromboli), and a dozen different types of pasta (Penne, Spaghetti, Linguine) with various sauce options, ensuring there's something for every craving.

Homemade Quality Appetizers and Salads: Fan-favorite starters include the Garlic Knots, Fried Calamari, and a selection of fresh, hearty salads like the Crispo Salad (with fried chicken) and the Pezzi's Salad (with pepperoni and mozzarella).

Fast Service: The staff is known for their efficiency and cordiality, ensuring a quick bite for lunch or a fast turnaround on takeout and delivery orders.

Dessert Selection: A delectable array of authentic Italian desserts is available, including Tiramisu, Cannoli, and Homemade Italian Cheesecake, offering the perfect conclusion to any meal.

Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The casual environment, clean restrooms, and availability of high chairs make it an excellent choice for families dining out.

Contact Information

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering services, you can reach Pezzi Pizza Inc using the following details:

Pezzi Pizza Inc

Address: 500 Glen Cove Ave, Sea Cliff, NY 11579, USA

Phone: (516) 671-7222

Mobile Phone: +1 516-671-7222

What is Worth Choosing

Pezzi Pizza Inc offers New York locals compelling reasons to choose them for their next Italian meal. What truly sets them apart is the potent combination of high-quality, authentic food and a service ethos that treats every customer like family. Their long-standing presence in Sea Cliff is a testament to the consistency of their cooking—the pizza is a definitive highlight, known for its non-greasy, perfectly crispy base. Ordering a whole specialty pie, such as the Buffalo Chicken Pizza or a Grandma's Pizza, is an essential experience for any Long Islander.

Beyond the pizza, their extensive menu ensures that everyone—from those needing a quick, satisfying Baked Ziti lunch to those seeking a full, comforting Italian dinner—leaves happy. The commitment to fresh, quality ingredients is apparent in everything, from the flavor of the house-made sauces on their pasta dishes to the satisfying warmth of their diverse soup selection like the Pasta E Fagioli or Tortellini E Chicken. For a great family value that never sacrifices flavor, or for a reliable, fast, and friendly spot for a great slice, Pezzi Pizza Inc is unequivocally the local choice for classic Italian-American food in Sea Cliff.

***

Pezzi Pizza Inc Food & drink

Calzones & Rolls
Cheese Calzone $11.75
Choose your favorite sauce to dip your calzone – Bleu Cheese, Creamy Italian, Ranch, Tomato, BBQ, Buffalo, or Chipotle. Enjoy a Pizza Pocket filled with a cheesy, ricotta-mozzarella filling with optional toppings and extra cheese.
Buffalo Roll $12.90
Diced chicken breast baked with Mozzarella, coated in famous Buffalo sauce. Choose from blue cheese, ranch, or creamy Italian dressing. Add toppings like bacon or sausage for extra flavor.
Chicken Roll $11.75
Crispy fried chicken roll with gooey mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and optional toppings like bacon, pepperoni, and black olives. Baked golden brown and served with your choice of sauce.
Side Sauce (Small 2 Oz.) $1.00
Buffalo Rollatini $6.50
Pizza dough stuffed and rolled with our signature “Oven Baked Buffalo Chicken and Grande’s Mozzarella cheese. Baked to a golden brown Crust.
Broccoli Roll $11.75
Broccoli & Mozzarella Cheese
Spinach Roll $11.75
Spinach Ricotta & Mozzarella cheese
BBQ Roll $12.90
Oven baked diced chicken breast tossed in famous barbecue sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese. Choose from a variety of sauces and additional toppings to customize your BBQ Roll.
Stromboli Roll $12.30
Savory assortment of ham, salami, provolone, pepperoni, mozzarella, all baked to perfection. Sprinkled with sesame seeds. Options include various sauce choices, extra cheese, and additional toppings.
Rice Ball $8.10
Savory rice balls, lightly fried until golden brown.open face with gooey melted Grande’s Mozzarella.Served with a side of zesty marinara dipping sauce for a flavorful appetizer.
Sausage & Pepper Roll $11.75
Sausage, Green Pepper, Onion Pizza Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese
Side Sauce (Large 4 Oz.) $2.50

Drinks (2LT)
Fanta Orange $5.10
Refreshing and bubbly orange soda with a citrusy tang.
Sprite $5.10
Refreshing lemon-lime soda.
Coke $5.10
Classic and refreshing carbonated beverage.
Diet Coke $5.10
Zero-calorie, carbonated refreshing beverage with a crisp, clean taste. Ideal choice for those seeking a calorie-free alternative.

Salads
Caprese $18.60
Fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato & roasted pepper with side of Balsamic Dressing
Cold Antipasto $19.15
Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber,Red Onion, Prosciutto, Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese And Pickled Giardiniera Vegetable . Customize your Cold Antipasto salad with a variety of veggies (Artichokes, Olives) and proteins (Grilled Shrimp, Bacon). Choose from a selection of cheeses and dressings to make it your own.
Pasta Salad $19.15
Penne Pasta, Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato,Black Olives,Mozzarella, Salami, Ham,Pecorino Romano And Balsamic Vinegar. Customize your pasta salad with a variety of fresh veggies, protein options like grilled chicken or shrimp, and a selection of cheeses. Choose from a range of flavorful dressings to top it off.
Gorgonzola Salad $19.15
Mesculine lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber, artichokes hearts, black olives & shaved imported gorgonzola cheese with our famous house balsamic dressing on the side
Greek Salad $15.90
Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Imported Feta & Black Olives.
Grilled Chicken Caesar $19.75
Romaine Lettuce Pecorino Romano And Croutons Tossed With Our Signature Caesar Dressing Topped With Freshly Grilled Marinated Chicken Breast
Grilled Shrimp Caesar $22.15
Freshly grilled shrimp on a bed of romaine, Pecorino Romano, and croutons, coated in our signature Caesar dressing. Customize your salad with veggies, proteins, and cheese options.
Crispo Salad $19.75
Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Shredded Mozzarella And Fried Chicken With Our Famous House Creamy Dressing On The Side
Pezzi's Salad $17.10
Customize Pezzi's Salad with your choice of additional veggies like artichokes, olives, or jalapenos. Add protein like grilled chicken or bacon. Finish with cheese options like feta or provolone and dressing of your choice.
Caesar Salad $15.30
Customize your Caesar salad with fresh veggies like artichokes and cucumbers, protein options such as grilled chicken or bacon, and your choice of cheese and dressing for a flavorful and satisfying meal.
Tossed Salad $14.95
Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber,Red Onion, Green Peppers & Shredded Carrots With A Side Of Our Famous Creamy House Dressing Customize your Tossed Salad with a variety of fresh veggies like artichokes, mushrooms, and jalapenos. Add flavorful proteins such as grilled shrimp or crispy bacon. Choose from a selection of creamy dressings.

Desserts
Coppa Caffe $10.35
Fior di latte gelato with rich coffee and pure cocoa swirl.
Tiramisu $10.50
Layers of espresso drenched sponge cake divided by mascarpone cream, dusted with cocoa powder.
Chocolate Fudge Cake $8.35
Decadent chocolate cake with fudgy frosting. Rich, irresistible dessert to satisfy chocolate cravings.
Cappuccino Cake $8.35
Alternated layers of espresso drenched chocolate sponge cake and coffee cream, decorated with cocoa powder
Coppa Stracciatella $10.35
Decadent chocolate chip gelato drizzled with chocolate syrup, dusted with cocoa powder, and sprinkled with hazelnuts. Rich, creamy, and indulgent dessert option.
Vanilla Ice Cream (1 Scoop) $3.00
Chill out with a single scoop or more of creamy, velvety vanilla ice cream. Perfect ending to any meal or simply enjoy on its own. Always a classic favorite.
Tartufo $9.60
Classic vanilla and chocolate gelato separated by a cherry and sliced almond covered in cinnamon, finished with a chocolate coating.
Cannoli $7.50
Chocolate Souffle $10.75
Moist chocolate cake with a heart of creamy rich chocolate, served with vanilla ice cream.
Homemade Italian Cheesecake $8.35
Coconut Sorbet $10.15
Creamy Coconut sorbetto served In A natural fruit Shell
Lemon Sorbet $10.15
Tantalizing lemon sorbet served in natural fruit shell.

Sodas (20 Oz)
Diet Coke $3.60
Crisp, refreshing soda with zero calories.
Coke $3.60
Classic, refreshing soda with a crisp, bubbly taste. A perfect companion to any meal or enjoyed on its own for a sweet, fizzy treat.
Sprite $3.60
Option: Regular, Zero Sugar, Cranberry, CherryBubbly and refreshing soda with a hint of lemon-lime flavor. Available in Regular, Zero Sugar, Cranberry, and Cherry options. Great for a thirst-quenching treat.
Caffeine Free Diet Coke $3.60
Refreshing and bubbly diet soda with a bold taste and zero caffeine. Great alternative for those looking to cut back on caffeine without sacrificing flavor.
Cherry Coke $3.60
Sweet and tangy cherry-infused cola with a fizzy finish.
Diet Coke (Caffeine Free) $3.60
Caffeine-free soda with a crisp, refreshing taste.
Cherry Coke 0 $3.60
A refreshing and fizzy blend of cherry and Coke flavors, perfect for those looking for a sweet and tangy beverage with zero calories to accompany their meal.

Side Orders
Primavera Vegetables $17.50
Sautéed fresh garlic-infused carrots, green & yellow zucchini, and mushrooms in Sicilian extra virgin olive oil. Fragrant, flavorful primavera vegetables.
Broccoli With Garlic $11.75
Tender broccoli florets sautéed with fragrant fresh garlic in Sicilian extra virgin olive oil. Aromatic and wholesome.
Side Of Sauce (4 Oz ) $1.75
Spinach $13.15
Tender spinach sautéed in Sicilian extra virgin olive oil with fresh garlic.
Meatball $10.80
Homestyle meatballs in Grandma's tomato sauce.
Grilled Chicken $10.75
Grilled to perfection, our marinated chicken breast cutlets are juicy and flavorful. Savor every bite of this grilled chicken dish.
Sausage $10.80
Hearty sausage smothered in our Family recipe tomato sauce. Succulent, flavorful, and comforting.
Broccoli Rabe $16.75
Tender broccoli rabe sautéed with fragrant fresh garlic and Sicilian extra virgin olive oil.

Pizza
10" Personal Cheese Pizza $13.15
Personal cheese pizza with a variety of toppings to choose from, like pepperoni, bacon, and artichokes. Option for whole wheat crust available. Perfectly sized for one.
16" Large Cheese Pizza $23.95
Choose your favorite toppings to customize a 16" large cheese pizza. Options include anchovies, bacon, chicken, ground beef, ham, meatballs, pepperoni, sausage, broccoli, and more. Try our specialty toppings like BBQ Chicken or Baked Ziti.
Sicilian 16" X 16" $27.50
Choose your favorite toppings to customize this big and flavorful Sicilian pizza. Options include anchovies, bacon, chicken, ground beef, pepperoni, artichoke, and more for a delicious feast.
12" Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza $19.95
Savor a flavorful 12" Gluten-Free Rice flour Cheese Pizza or with cauliflower crust. Customize your pizza with a variety of delicious toppings like anchovies, bacon, chicken, pepperoni, and more.

Pasta
Penne $20.20
Tortellini $20.85
Rigatoni $20.20
Choose your pasta, protein, vegetable, cheese, and sauces.
Spaghetti $20.15
Linguine $20.75

Appetizers
Mussels Marinara $17.95
Tender mussels steamed open in their natural juices, served in a flavorful marinara sauce.
Fried Calamari $19.15
Crispy fried calamari served with marinara sauce and fresh lemon wedge. Juicy tentacles and tubes fried to perfection.
Mussels Luciano $17.95
Tender mussels steamed in their natural juice, bathed in a white wine and lemon sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks (6) $12.00
Crispy fried sticks oozing with melted mozzarella. Served with a tangy house-made tomato sauce.
Fried Zucchini $14.50
Crispy golden zucchini sticks served with marinara sauce. Flavorful and satisfying appetizer or side dish.
Pepperoni Chips $4.80
Crispy pepperoni and melty mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough, sprinkled with sesame seeds. Add extra sauce for even more flavor. Bite-sized and irresistible.
Clams Posillipo (6) $16.75
Succulent Little Neck clams steamed in theirs natural juices with white wine, lemon, and plum tomato. Savory and aromatic.
Shrimp Cocktail (5) $16.75
Black tiger shrimp served chilled, accompanied by a tangy cocktail sauce for dipping. Five succulent pieces perfect for a refreshing start to your meal.
Garlic Bread $7.15
Tantalizing garlic butter & herb baked semolina bread.
Garlic Knots (6) $4.80
Butter-garlic herb seasoned pizza dough knots, served with extra sauce for dipping. Aromatic, flavorful, and comforting appetizer perfect for sharing.
Baked Clams (6) $16.75
Succulent Little Neck Clams stuffed with savory breadcrumbs, garlic, and herbs, baked to golden-brown perfection. Served with lemon wedges. Perfect appetizer to kick off your meal.

Soups
Tortellini E Chicken $9.55
Homestyle chicken noodle soup with tortellini for an Italian twist. Hearty, flavorful broth with juicy chicken pieces and tender tortellini. A comforting and satisfying choice.
Stracciatella Romana $11.50
Creamy and comforting egg drop soup with fresh spinach.
Pasta E Fagioli $9.55
Hearty cannellini beans and ditalini pasta in flavorful vegetable broth.
Chicken Noodle Soup $9.55
Mom's Chicken Noodle Soup
Tortellini In Brodo $9.55
Savory cheese filled tortellini and green peas in a flavorful chicken broth. Comforting and wholesome.
Minestrone Soup $9.55
Hearty vegetable soup with ditalini pasta in a flavorful broth. Aromatic and comforting.
Lentil Soup $9.55
Veggie-packed lentil soup with ditalini pasta in a flavorful vegetable broth. Wholesome and comforting.

Slices
Sicilian Slice $5.45
Customize your Sicilian Slice with a variety of sauce options like Side Bleu Cheese or Side BBQ Sauce. Add extra toppings such as Bacon, Green Pepper, or Chicken Parmigiana for a flavorful twist.
Cheese Slice $4.95
Choose your favorite cheese slice with a side of Bleu Cheese, Creamy Italian, Ranch Dressing, Tomato Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, or Chipotle Sauce. Customize with anchovies, bacon, chicken, and more.

Baked Dishes
Baked Manicotti (3) $18.55
Baked Stuffed Shells (5) $19.75
Baked Ravioli (6) $18.00
Baked Ziti Siciliana $19.20
Ziti Ricotta Fried Eggplant And Mozzarella
Baked Lasagna (Meat) $19.25
Layers of chopped meat, sweet Italian sausage, and a blend of cheeses in our flavorful, homestyle lasagna. Add grilled shrimp or prosciutto for a juicy twist. Optional vegetable, protein, sauce, and cheese additions available.
Baked Ziti With Ricotta $18.50
Baked Ziti (No Ricotta) $17.35
Baked ziti with a choice of flavorful additions like grilled shrimp, artichokes, and mushrooms. Customize with options for extra sauce or different types of cheese like Parmesan.

Gold Peak Iced Tea
Lemon $3.75
Diet Lemon $3.75
Unsweetened $3.75
Peach $3.75

Pezzi Pizza Inc Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Pezzi Pizza Inc Photos

Pezzi Pizza Inc Location

Pezzi Pizza Inc

New York Nassau County Sea Cliff Glen Cove Avenue

500 Glen Cove Ave, Sea Cliff, NY 11579, USA

Pezzi Pizza Inc Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 173 user reviews.

buffalo chickenpricepieitalianBBQgarlic knotsslicediningvodkashrimp

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Just in and out quick for a slice but boy what a nice slice, you could taste the fresh oregano. That's the part that really made me smile. I definitely will be back. That's very nice pizza.
August 14 · CE Behr
From Diane Kaufmann: Dear Everyone at Pezzi Pizza in Sea Cliff NY,I have lived here for over 30 years; just go to Pezzi Pizza! You can bring it home and save it for the next day's as they serve good and large portions. I am on strong medication and sometimes my taste changes as a side effect from medication- but eating the meat balls, pasta dishes, soups and salads help to keep my spirits up! And the food is always fantastic and never sacrifices on flavor. The side dishes of spinach have been one of my favorites as well as the beet salad. I have eaten almost everything on the menu over the years, and I am thankful for the Pezzi family not only for their kindness to my situation over the years but the care they have for every customer and the care they place on the quality of the food they serve.They are wonderful people and I wish them continued success always. I am Thankful to have known them and have them in my life as I consider them my honorary family. Through the years they also have been there for our families' special occasions for which they catered. I hope you will go to Pezzi Pizza when you can and enjoy everything you order. Thank you, Dk.
June 27 · Kristyn Clemons
Thank you so much for such delicious Pizza. Best Chicken tikka Pie i ever had. Highly recommend it.
September 03 · s s
The best pizza 🍕 joint in Glen Head.No question about it. Great variety.Slices, calzones, pinwheels.Only negative are the prices.
May 29 · Shib
Ordered a Sicilian pie for delivery.Under. Cooked ,sauce no taste .Disgusting pie made with no self respect.
August 25 · patrick crowley