Pierogi Boys

- 445 Albee Square W, Brooklyn, NY 11201

In the sprawling, culinary melting pot of New York City, there's a special place for food that offers both comfort and a taste of home. Pierogi Boys, located in the bustling DeKalb Market Hall, is a destination for exactly that. Specializing in Polish cuisine, this restaurant has quickly become a local favorite for its dedication to hand-making authentic pierogi with traditional recipes passed down through generations. Far from a generic food stall, Pierogi Boys offers a genuine and satisfying experience that has converted even the most skeptical diners into "potato-cheese believers."

The brand's philosophy is rooted in quality and tradition. They pride themselves on not owning a freezer, ensuring that every pierogi is made fresh, on-site, every day. This commitment to freshness is evident in every bite, from the perfectly cooked dough to the flavorful fillings. Pierogi Boys also takes a conscientious approach to sourcing, using GMO-free, unbleached flour from Vermont, local produce, cage-free eggs, and humanely-raised, hormone-free meats. This focus on premium ingredients elevates their dishes and sets them apart from the competition.

Beyond the food itself, Pierogi Boys offers a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere. The trendy, casual vibe attracts a diverse crowd, from college students and groups to solo diners and tourists. The brand is also proudly LGBTQ+ friendly, creating a space where everyone can feel comfortable enjoying a hearty, delicious meal. With a commitment to quality ingredients, an authentic menu, and a great atmosphere, it's no surprise that Pierogi Boys has cemented its place as a go-to for comfort food in Brooklyn.

Pierogi Boys is located within the DeKalb Market Hall at 445 Albee Square W, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA. This location places it in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, a major commercial and cultural hub. The DeKalb Market Hall is known for its diverse selection of food vendors, and Pierogi Boys fits right in as an authentic and celebrated addition.

The restaurant's location in a food hall offers excellent accessibility. It is a very short walk from major subway lines at the DeKalb Avenue station, including the B, D, Q, N, R, and W trains, making it incredibly easy to get to from almost anywhere in the city. The area is also served by numerous bus lines, and for those who choose to drive, paid street parking is available. The restaurant itself is committed to accessibility, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, ensuring that all guests can comfortably enjoy their meal. The bustling environment of the market hall also makes it a great spot for a quick bite during lunch or a casual dinner with friends.

Pierogi Boys offers a focused yet comprehensive menu of traditional Polish and Eastern European comfort foods, complemented by a range of services designed for convenience.

• Dine-in and Takeout: The restaurant provides seating for those who want to enjoy their meal at the market hall's communal tables. For those on the go, takeout is a popular option, praised by customers for its fast service.

• Delivery: Pierogi Boys also offers delivery, making their delicious pierogi and soups accessible to a wider audience in the Brooklyn area.

• Catering: They provide catering services for special events, allowing you to bring the authentic taste of Polish cuisine to your next gathering. As one website states, "We understand food brings people together."

• Diverse Menu Offerings: The menu includes a variety of pierogi (Potato & Cheese, Sauerkraut & Mushroom, Meat), mixed platters, sides like Polish Kielbasa and various soups, and a selection of drinks, including Polish beer and wine. The menu caters to different dietary needs with vegetarian and vegan options available.

The seamless combination of these services ensures that customers can enjoy the food of Pierogi Boys in the way that best fits their needs.

Pierogi Boys is celebrated for a number of features that contribute to its glowing reputation in the NYC food scene.

• Hand-made Freshness: The restaurant's policy of not owning a freezer and hand-making every pierogi on-site is a significant highlight. This commitment guarantees an unparalleled level of freshness and quality that customers can taste in every bite.

• Iconic Potato & Cheese Pierogi: As one reviewer passionately wrote, the Potato & Cheese Pierogi is a "carb-filled epiphany." The perfectly balanced dough and creamy filling, topped with savory bacon, caramelized onions, and chives, make it a must-try dish that has earned a devoted following.

• Unique and Authentic Soups: The menu offers a variety of traditional soups, including a popular Ukrainian Borscht praised for being "vibrant, soul-warming, beet-powered brilliance." Another standout is the tangy and creamy Ogórkowa (Pickle Soup), which is a delicious and unique offering.

• Fast and Friendly Service: The fast service and casual, trendy atmosphere are highlights, making it a perfect spot for a quick, delicious lunch or a casual dinner with friends. The staff is often described as friendly and sweet, contributing to the overall positive experience.

• Inclusive and Welcoming Atmosphere: The restaurant is known for being LGBTQ+ friendly and a safe space, welcoming a diverse crowd. This inclusivity makes it a comfortable dining spot for everyone.

To get a taste of this Brooklyn gem, you can find Pierogi Boys at the following contact information.

Address: 445 Albee Square W, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Phone: (929) 368-2768

What is truly worth choosing about Pierogi Boys is its authentic, handmade approach to comfort food that feels both high-quality and deeply satisfying. For locals and tourists alike, this is not just another restaurant; it’s a culinary experience that feeds the soul. The centerpiece of their menu, the Potato & Cheese Pierogi, is a perfect example of their excellence. The dough is "perfectly thin but strong enough" to hold the creamy, cheesy filling, and the savory toppings complete a dish that is consistently lauded by customers. While there may be some debate on the "authenticity" of certain flavors, as one Polish reviewer noted about the Sauerkraut & Mushroom pierogi, the passion for their craft and the quality of their ingredients are undeniable. The Ukrainian Borscht is also a major draw, praised for its rich, earthy flavors that feel like a "love letter" to Eastern European cuisine. The convenience of being located in a major food hall, combined with fast service and accessible features, makes Pierogi Boys an easy and excellent choice for a quick lunch or a hearty dinner. The option for delivery also means you can enjoy their soul-warming comfort food from the comfort of your own home. Ultimately, Pierogi Boys offers a unique and delicious dining experience that is both authentic and approachable, a perfect addition to New York City's diverse and exciting food landscape.

Pierogi Boys

445 Albee Square W, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA