Pints N Pies Introduce
For New Yorkers searching for specialty frozen desserts that cater to a variety of dietary needs and high standards of quality, **Pints N Pies** stands out as a unique destination in Brooklyn. Located in the heart of the borough, this ice cream shop has carved a niche for itself by focusing heavily on two distinct, premium product lines: an extensive selection of **Dairy-Free** (Pareve) desserts and a line of premium **Dairy Ice Cream** that adheres to strict Kosher standards, specifically **Chalav Yisroel, Yashan, and Pas Yisroel**. This dual focus ensures that whether you have dietary restrictions or simply prefer the highest standards of Kosher preparation, Pints N Pies has an indulgent, creamy treat waiting for you.
Pints N Pies goes far beyond the simple scoop. Their offerings are centered around spectacular, ready-to-serve desserts like elaborate ice cream pies, multi-layered cakes, and specialty logs. The commitment to crafting high-quality, homemade-tasting products is evident in customer feedback, which frequently highlights the soft, creamy texture and delicious flavor profiles, particularly of the dairy-free options. The shop offers a casual, welcoming atmosphere perfect for a quick visit, making it an ideal spot to stop by and satisfy a craving or pick up a dessert for your next event.
The innovation here is in the dessert format. Instead of focusing solely on the scoop-and-cone model, Pints N Pies offers dozens of flavors transformed into impressive centerpiece desserts. The flavor variety is staggering, ranging from comfort classics like Vanilla, Chocolate, and Mint Chip to specialty options like Lotus, Ferrero Rocher, Tiramisu, Halava, and Cinnamon Toast Crunch, all available across their different product categories. This comprehensive selection makes it a go-to choice for New Yorkers planning parties, holidays, or any occasion that calls for an extraordinary frozen treat.
Pints N Pies is conveniently located on a major thoroughfare in South Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for customers across the borough and beyond. The specific address is:
2083 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA
The 11223 zip code encompasses the Gravesend area, a vibrant neighborhood known for its local businesses. Being situated directly on Coney Island Avenue provides excellent visibility and ease of travel. Customers utilizing public transportation can typically find bus routes with stops very close to the location, and the area is also accessible from nearby subway lines, connecting it to the larger NYC transit network.
The shop prioritizes a welcoming environment for all patrons, as evidenced by its commitment to accessibility. A significant highlight is the **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, ensuring that all members of the community can visit the shop comfortably. For those driving, **Paid street parking** is generally available in the vicinity, though customers are advised, as with any bustling Brooklyn street, to allow for a few extra minutes to secure a spot. This balance of a central location and essential accessibility features solidifies Pints N Pies as a user-friendly local favorite.
Understanding the needs of busy New Yorkers, Pints N Pies offers flexible service options focused on convenience and speed for their specialty desserts:
- **Delivery:** The ultimate convenience for large orders or for customers who cannot leave home, allowing Brooklyn residents to have cakes, pies, and logs brought directly to their door.
- **In-store pickup:** A quick and efficient option for pre-ordered items, perfect for customers who are already running errands or passing by the Coney Island Ave location.
- **Takeout:** While the primary focus is on packaged goods like pints and pies, customers can stop by for immediate purchases of their wide array of pre-made, high-quality frozen desserts.
While the atmosphere is casual, ideal for a **Quick visit**, the emphasis is clearly on grabbing your impressive frozen dessert and taking it home. The accepted payment methods—**Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**—also ensure a smooth and modern transaction process.
Pints N Pies has positioned itself as more than just an ice cream shop; it is a specialty frozen dessert bakery with a clear focus on inclusivity and premium quality:
- **Extensive Dairy-Free Menu (Pareve):** A major highlight is the vast selection of **DAIRY-FREE ICE CREAM PIES, CAKES, LOGS, and PINTS**. This makes it an invaluable resource for individuals with lactose intolerance, dairy allergies, or those adhering to Kosher dietary laws requiring Pareve desserts.
- **Premium Kosher Dairy Options:** The shop offers a dedicated line of Dairy Ice Cream Pies which are certified with the highest standards, specifically **Chalav Yisroel, Yashan, and Pas Yisroel**. This detail is crucial for segments of the New York community with strict Kashrut requirements.
- **Dessert Focus:** Unlike conventional scoop shops, the business specializes in elaborate frozen formats—pies, cakes, and logs—making them ideal for celebrations and impressive gifting.
- **"Great Dessert" Reputation:** As confirmed by its highlights, the shop is recognized for providing an exceptional dessert experience, backed by customer reviews praising the creamy, homemade taste.
- **Family-Friendly Environment:** The shop is noted as being **Good for kids**, welcoming families to find sweet treats for all ages.
- **Unique Flavor Range:** The menu boasts a creative and comprehensive selection of flavors, ensuring that even the most adventurous palate can find a new favorite, from classic combinations to inventive options like Tiramisu Pie and Knafe Log.
The combination of specialty products and catering to specific dietary needs establishes Pints N Pies as a distinct and highly valuable culinary resource in the Brooklyn landscape.
To place an order for a custom ice cream cake, arrange a delivery, or inquire about current stock, customers can reach Pints N Pies using the following information:
Address: 2083 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA
Phone: (347) 236-3316
Mobile Phone: +1 347-236-3316
Pints N Pies is the definitive choice for New Yorkers who demand both quality and accommodation in their frozen desserts. What is truly worth choosing here is the unparalleled commitment to inclusivity without compromising on indulgence. If you’ve ever struggled to find an exceptional, creamy **dairy-free ice cream** that tastes genuinely homemade, Pints N Pies is your answer—as one customer noted, the texture is "so soft and creamy, can’t believe it’s dairy free!" The famous Lotus Pie, a popular flavor, is a prime example of their high-caliber creations.
Furthermore, for the community adhering to strict Kosher dietary laws, the selection of premium **Dairy Pies** that are explicitly **Chalav Yisroel, Yashan, and Pas Yisroel** provides peace of mind and access to celebratory desserts that meet the highest standards. You are not just buying ice cream; you are purchasing a beautifully crafted frozen centerpiece—a cake, a pie, or a log—that is guaranteed to be a hit. The specialized nature of their product, focused on these show-stopping formats, ensures a memorable experience, whether you are hosting a large gathering or simply treating your family to a spectacular end to the week. For a New York local, Pints N Pies is the solution for all specialty, high-end frozen dessert needs.
Pints N Pies Vibe
DAIRY-FREE ICE CREAM PIES
Dairy-Free Ice cream pies
- Lotus Pie $35.00
Lotus Ice Cream in Graham crust
- Oreo Pie $35.00
Dairy Free Oreo Ice cream in Oreo pie crust
- S'mores Pie $35.00
Dairy-Free S'mores ice cream in graham pie crust
- Peanut Butter Pie $35.00
Dairy-Free Peanut Butter ice cream in Oreo Pie crust
- Mint Chip Pie $35.00
Dairy-Free Mint chip ice cream in Oreo Pie crust
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch Pie $35.00
- Tiramisu Pie $35.00
- Cookie Dough $35.00
- Chocolate Oreo Pie $35.00
- Salted Caramel Pie $35.00
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie $35.00
- Strawberry Ice Cream Pie $35.00
Strawberry non dairy ice cream pie
- Nutella Pie $35.00
- Rocky Road Pie $35.00
- Dulce De Leche Pie $35.00
- Halava Pie $35.00
- Fruity Pebbles Pie $35.00
- Cappuccino Chip Pie $35.00
- Spumoni Pie $35.00
Spumoni Ice cream Pie (Almond/Pistachio/Chocolate)
Dairy-Free Premium Pies
- **NEW** Neapolitan Premium Pie $40.00
3 layer pie- Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate in vanilla crust. Topped with whip cream, chocolate sauce and sprinkles
- Strawberry Shortcake Premium Pie $40.00
- Ferraro Rocher Pie $40.00
- Twix Premium Pie $40.00
- Banana Cream Pie $40.00
9" Dairy-Free Ice Cream Cakes (2 layer)
Dairy-Free Round 9" Ice cream Cakes
- Lotus/Oreo $44.00
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 12-18ppl. 2 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.
- Peanut Butter/Oreo $44.00
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 12-18ppl. 2 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.
- Lotus/Peanut Butter $44.00
- Oreo/Mint Chip $44.00
- Vanilla/Chocolate $44.00
Dairy-Free Vanilla and Chocolate Ice cream cake.
- Ferrero Rocher/Oreo $44.00
- Oreo/Cookie Dough $44.00
- Oreo/S'mores $44.00
- Pistachio/Chocolate $44.00
- Salted Caramel/Oreo $44.00
- Dulce De Leche/Oreo $44.00
- Oreo/Cinnamon Toast Crunch $44.00
- Mint Chip/Peanut Butter $44.00
- Nutella/Chocolate $44.00
- Oreo/Chocolate Peanut Butter $44.00
- Oreo/Nutella $44.00
- Chocolate/Peanut Butter $44.00
- Oreo/Chocolate $44.00
9" Dairy-Free Ice Cream Cakes (3 layer)
- Neapolitan (Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate) $55.00
Classic flavors Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate non dairy Ice cream cake.
- Oreo/Lotus/Peanut Butter $55.00
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 15-25ppl. 3 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.
- Strawberry Shortcake 3 Layer Cake $55.00
Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert cake Vanilla and Strawberry sorbet topped with Strawberry cookie crumbs.
- Oreo/Mint Chip/Cookie Dough $55.00
Dairy-Free Ice Cream Logs
- Strawberry Shortcake
- Lotus/Oreo
Dairy-Free Ice Cream log
- Twix Log $49.00
12" Twix log (vanilla non dairy ice cream with caramel, chocolate and shortbread)
- Peanut Butter/Oreo
- Dubai Log $65.00
Pistachio non dairy ice cream with katafi and pistachio coated in premium chocolate shell.
- Lotus/Peanut Butter
- Spumoni
Spumoni non dairy Log- 3 flavors- almond/pistachio/chocolate
- Fruity Pebbles Treat Log $45.00
12" Fruity pebbles treat log with non dairy fruity pebbles ice cream.
- Rice Krispy Treat Log $45.00
12" Rice Krispy treat log with Vanilla non dairy ice cream
- Ferrero Rocher Log
- Oreo/Mint Chip
- Lotus
- Halava Log $49.00
- Knafe Log $49.00
7" Dairy-Free Ice Cream cakes
- Lotus/Oreo $32.00
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)
- Lotus/Peanut Butter $32.00
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)
- Peanut Butter/Oreo $32.00
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)
- Vanilla/Chocolate $32.00
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)
- Oreo/Mint Chip $32.00
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)
DAIRY-FREE PINTS
Dairy-Free Pints
- Vanilla Pint $9.00
- Chocolate Pint $9.00
- Strawberry Shortcake Pint $9.00
- Cookies N Cream Pint $9.00
- Lotus $9.00
- Ferrero Rocher $9.00
- Chocolate Peanut Butter $9.00
- Cookie Dough $9.00
- Peanut Butter $9.00
- S'mores $9.00
- Pistachio $9.00
- Cappucino Chip $9.00
- Mint Chip $9.00
- Nutella $9.00
- Tiramisu $9.00
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch $9.00
- Fruity Pebbles $9.00
- Dulce De Leche $9.00
- Choc Oreo $9.00
- Rocky Road $9.00
Dairy Pies
Dairy Ice Cream pies (Chalav Yisroel, Yashan, Pas Yisroel
- Cookies N Cream $35.00
Dairy (Chalav Yisroel) Ice cream pie
- S'mores $35.00
Dairy (Chalav Yisroel) Ice cream pie
- Dulce De Leche $35.00
Dairy (Chalav Yisroel) Ice cream pie
- Nutella $35.00
Dairy (Chalav Yisroel) Ice cream pie
- Snickers Premium Pie $40.00
- Twix Premium Pie $40.00
- Cookie Dough Dairy Pie $35.00
- Toasted Almond Premium Pie (Dairy) $40.00
- Spumoni Dairy Pie $35.00
- Fruity Pebbles Dairy Pie $35.00
- Mint Chip Dairy Pie $35.00
Scoops
box of 9 dairy-free ice cream cups with topping.
- 9 Cups Per Box $31.50
Dairy-Free Ice cream cups
DAIRY-FREE POPS
Dairy-Free Pops
- 12 Assorted Pop $58.00
- Lotus Pop $4.95
- Strawberry Shortcake Pop $4.95
- Oreo Pop $4.95
- Knafe Pops $4.95
- Halava Pop $4.95
- Ferrero Rocher Pop $4.95
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch $4.95
- Peanut Butter Pop $4.95
- Nutella Pop $4.95
- S'mores Pop $4.95
- Fruity Pebbles $4.95
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Pop $4.95
- Dubai Pop $4.95
Pistachio non dairy ice cream and crispy Katafi dipped in premium chocolate and pistachio drizzle
- Twix Pop $4.95
Toppings
- Sugar Cones- 12 Per Pack $5.00
- Viennesse Crunch $3.00
- Crunch $3.00
- Colored Sprinkles $2.50
- Chocolate Sprinkles $2.50
- Chocolate Chips $3.00
- White Chips $3.50
Pints N Pies Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Highlights
- Great dessert
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Parking
- Paid street parking
Pints N Pies Photos









Pints N Pies Location
Pints N Pies
2083 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA
Pints N Pies Reviews
All of the products are absolutely delicious, and the ice cream is so soft and creamy, can’t believe it’s dairy free! It’s an interesting store, but the manager is very nice and helpful. I definitely recommend the lotus products. Will 100% be getting from Pints N Pies again.
May 09 · Aaron FriedI ordered the Lotus pie & it was delicious! It tasted really homemade. Not a commercial taste at all!I will definitely be ordering from here again & I will recommend this to all my friends
June 13 · Devorah HCute store,the mint chocolate chip pie is the best !!! But the hrs are very weird,& the person behind the counter is a liar,not truthful,& very rude,also u have to order pies In advance which is very annoying, for the 5towns they used to deliver, but now suddenly they stopped, Overall the customer service is horrible, but the pies are amazing,mainly the Mint Chip
September 23 · Rabbi ABest ice cream in the entire New York City. It also is kosher.
December 07 · adam a.- June 13 · Eddy Lalo
More restaurants near me

2085 Coney Island Ave 1st FL, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

934 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

924 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

1103 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

1202 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

1113 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

1115 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

2026 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

914 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

906 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

904 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

902 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts





