Plaza Bagels and Deli

- 73 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306

In a city world-renowned for its bagels, New Yorkers know that finding a truly great bagel shop is a serious quest, and for many on Staten Island, the search ends at Plaza Bagels and Deli. Situated in the heart of New Dorp Plaza, this establishment is a beloved local institution that delivers on both halves of its name: providing authentic, freshly baked bagels with that signature New York chewiness and a comprehensive deli menu that caters to breakfast and lunch cravings. It’s a necessary stop for anyone seeking a classic NYC breakfast experience, from a simple toasted bagel with butter to a fully loaded breakfast sandwich.

Plaza Bagels and Deli is more than just a morning stop; it’s a full-service deli offering a wide array of fresh food, salads, and creative lunch sandwiches that keep locals coming back throughout the day. The focus on quality is clear, with customers often praising the flavor and perfect texture of the bagels themselves—described as 'fluffy,' 'chewy,' and 'on point.' A true mark of quality is the fact that many patrons enjoy the bagels straight up, without any spread or filling, showcasing the excellence of the baking process.

The atmosphere is characterized by warm, friendly service and a clean environment, fostering that essential neighborhood vibe. The staff is frequently highlighted in reviews for their politeness, professionalism, and, importantly for New York City patrons, their speed and accuracy, even with highly specific and customized orders. Whether you are grabbing a quick dozen bagels for the family, picking up your morning coffee, or settling in for a satisfying deli lunch, Plaza Bagels and Deli offers a consistent and high-quality experience that solidifies its reputation as one of Staten Island’s best.

Plaza Bagels and Deli is conveniently located at 73 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306. This prime location in the New Dorp neighborhood places it in a central, accessible hub for many Staten Island residents. The New Dorp Plaza area is a well-known shopping and dining destination, making it easy to integrate a quick bagel stop into your daily errands or commute.

For accessibility, the establishment ensures a welcoming experience for all customers with a Wheelchair accessible entrance, demonstrating a commitment to serving the entire community. While specific parking details are not provided, its position within a plaza environment often suggests reasonable local parking options, which is a major convenience in this part of New York City. The central location also makes it accessible via local public transportation routes serving the New Dorp area.

Plaza Bagels and Deli has structured its service model to ensure maximum convenience and speed for the typical New York customer, whether they are rushing to work or planning a relaxed weekend breakfast.

• Takeout: Ideal for a quick visit, allowing customers to easily grab their order on the go.
• In-store pickup: Convenient for orders placed ahead of time, minimizing wait times during peak hours.
• Delivery: Offering the full menu delivered directly to your home or office, ensuring the fresh taste of Plaza Bagels is always within reach.
• NFC Mobile Payments: Supporting modern payment methods, including credit cards and debit cards, for fast and contactless transactions.

Plaza Bagels and Deli distinguishes itself through its expansive menu variety, quality ingredients, and dedication to customer favorites, making it a true New York-style deli and bagel shop hybrid.

• Freshly Baked, Authentic Bagels: Highly praised for possessing the perfect texture—a nice chewiness and fluffy interior—living up to the high standards of an NYC bagel. They offer a full dozen or half dozen of assorted bagels.
• Extensive Breakfast Menu: Featuring all the classics and more, including the popular Bacon, Egg & Cheese, Sausage, Egg & Cheese, Pork Roll, Egg & Cheese, pancakes, French toast, and the massive Hungry Man Special.
• Signature Bagel Offerings: A must-try is the Bagel With CC & Fresh Lox, which exemplifies a classic New York experience, alongside a variety of Specialty Cream Cheeses.
• Comprehensive Deli Lunch: Beyond breakfast, the shop offers a robust lunch menu including signature sandwiches like The Lane, The Plaza, The New Yorker, and the popular New York City favorite, the Chopped Cheese.
• Full Food and Salad Bar: Features fresh, ready-made options such as Rice Balls, homemade Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Fresh Mozzarella Balls, and healthy salads like the Cobb Salad and Alex's Caprese Salad.
• Full Coffee & Beverage Service: Serving fresh Coffee and a wide selection of bottled and specialty drinks, including their Plaza Bagels Ice Coffee, perfect for starting the day.
• Friendly, Accurate Service: The staff is consistently noted for their friendly conversation and 100% order accuracy, even with complex customizations, ensuring a pleasant and efficient transaction.

For New York City patrons looking to place an order, inquire about the menu, or confirm hours of operation, here is the essential contact information for Plaza Bagels and Deli:

Address: 73 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306
Phone: (718) 269-7079
Mobile Phone: +1 718-269-7079

When navigating the myriad of breakfast and lunch options in New York, Plaza Bagels and Deli stands out as the ultimate choice for several compelling reasons. Most fundamentally, its bagels are truly exceptional, meeting the stringent standards of the New York palate. Customers who have tried bagels 'all over NYC' confirm that Plaza Bagels offers a superior product—one with the essential bite and flavor that can be enjoyed perfectly plain. This core quality elevates every item on the menu, from the simplest bagel and cream cheese to the most intricate sandwich build.

What truly makes it worth choosing is the seamless combination of a top-tier bagel shop and a reliable, extensive deli. You can satisfy any craving here, from a classic breakfast platter like the Hungry Man Special to a hearty lunch option like the Chopped Cheese or one of their gourmet burgers. The unique opportunity to discover a 'mystery bag' of a dozen different bagels through innovative programs highlights their commitment to fresh variety and community engagement. Furthermore, the commitment of the staff to excellent service, including friendly conversation and flawless order execution, removes the frustration often associated with busy morning routines. Plaza Bagels and Deli is a convenient, high-quality, and friendly local spot that delivers authentic New York flavor with every order, solidifying its place as a cornerstone of the New Dorp dining scene.

Plaza Bagels and Deli

73 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA