RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

- 1005 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers seeking a culinary destination that truly lives up to the name "rare," look no further than RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster in Brooklyn's vibrant Coney Island neighborhood. This establishment positions itself as a Fine dining restaurant that defies simple categorization, successfully merging the best elements of classic American steakhouses, Italian trattorias, and a rich array of European and even Mexican culinary traditions. While officially categorized as a fine dining spot, RARE maintains a refreshingly Casual atmosphere, making it a comfortable destination for any occasion.

RARE Italy is a true culinary chameleon, appealing to diners with diverse tastes. Its expansive menu ensures there is something for everyone, whether you are craving a perfect cut of meat, fresh seafood, or comforting ethnic favorites. It's a popular choice for all daily dining periods, highlighted as popular for Lunch, Dinner, and even catering to those dining alone through Solo dining. Beyond the food, the venue also functions as a full-service Bar, contributing to a lively and engaging social atmosphere that is welcoming to Groups and locals alike. The dedication to a varied and rich experience is supported by a large range of services designed for ultimate customer convenience.

This Brooklyn fixture offers an experience built on ambition and variety, ensuring that every visit promises a unique flavor journey right on Surf Avenue.

Location and Accessibility

RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster is centrally located in Coney Island at 1005 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA. This key address places it perfectly for locals and tourists enjoying the nearby iconic attractions, such as the New York Aquarium and Luna Park, making it an ideal spot for a full-service meal before or after a day of entertainment.

The restaurant excels in providing unparalleled accessibility and convenience for all patrons. It features a critical Wheelchair accessible entrance, demonstrating an commitment to inclusivity. What truly sets RARE apart in a dense urban environment is its extensive offering of Parking options. Customers benefit from the availability of a Free parking lot, Free street parking, a Paid parking lot, Paid street parking, and even Valet parking. This massive selection of parking solutions virtually eliminates the typical stress associated with finding parking in New York City.

Furthermore, the restaurant is notably pet-friendly, with a policy of Dogs allowed both inside and outside, allowing New Yorkers to bring their furry friends along for the dining experience.

Services Offered

• Extensive Dining Periods: RARE Italy covers the full scope of a day's dining needs, offering Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, in addition to delectable Dessert offerings.
• Flexible Service Options: The restaurant is highly focused on convenience, providing Dine-in table service, Takeout, and a comprehensive Delivery service including No-contact delivery.
• Advanced Pickup and On-the-Go Service: For maximum efficiency, RARE offers unique services like Curbside pickup and a dedicated Drive-through option, catering to busy New Yorkers who need quick and easy access to their meals.
• Event and Group Services: For larger gatherings or special events, the restaurant provides full Catering services. All dining experiences benefit from comprehensive Seating and professional Table service.

Features / Highlights

• Dynamic Atmosphere and Entertainment: RARE provides more than just a meal; it offers an environment enhanced by Live music and the cozy ambiance provided by a Fireplace. The space includes a full Bar onsite and offers Wi-Fi for connected convenience.
• Inclusivity and Dietary Focus: The restaurant is committed to accommodating all guests and preferences, notably offering a Braille menu for visually impaired patrons. The menu is highly flexible, with dedicated Vegan options, Vegetarian options, and Organic dishes, in addition to a Salad bar.
• Specialized Menu and Offerings: Guests looking for value or a late bite will appreciate the availability of All you can eat options, Happy hour drinks, Happy hour food, and Late-night food. The menu also features tempting Small plates perfect for sampling.
• Beverage Program: The bar is fully equipped, offering a wide selection of Alcohol, Beer, Wine, Cocktails, and Hard liquor, alongside a full array of Coffee options.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: RARE ensures a comfortable experience for families, being deemed Good for kids and providing a dedicated Kids' menu. Crucial amenities include High chairs and Has changing table(s) for parents.
• Planning and Payments: To ensure a smooth visit, RARE Accepts reservations and, for certain times, Reservations required are noted. Payment is flexible, accepting Checks, Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries, or to utilize their extensive pickup and delivery services, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 1005 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA
• Phone (Main): (917) 924-1818
• Mobile Phone: +1 917-924-1818

What is Worth Choosing

The primary reason to choose RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster is the sheer scope and diversity of its menu, a rarity in the New York dining scene. This establishment provides a culinary journey under one roof, making it an ideal choice for groups with mixed preferences.

The Signature Steak and Lobster Experience: As the name suggests, RARE delivers on high-end protein and seafood. The Steaks section features premium cuts like the Ribeye Steak ($45.00), Filet Mignon ($38.00), and New York Steak ($38.00), alongside specialized European dishes such as Lamb Chops and Beef Stroganoff. The Lobster offerings are a clear highlight, featuring various preparations like the Whole Lobster Boiled and the decadent Baked Stuffed Lobster, appealing directly to the discerning seafood aficionado.

A Journey Through Europe and the Mediterranean: The menu is rich in European comfort food that is hard to find elsewhere. Patrons can indulge in traditional hot dishes like Homemade Dumplings (Pelmeni), Khinkali, Vareniki, and Stuffed Cabbage Rolls (Golubtsy, Dolma). More refined options include the Kiev Style Cutlet and the specialty Turkish Style Veal Liver. The Seafood selection is vast, including fresh favorites such as Chilean Sea Bass, Grilled Mediterranean Branzino, and an impressive Spanish Seafood Paella.

Italian and Mexican Fusion: The restaurant seamlessly incorporates high-quality Italian Pasta—from the classic Fettuccine Alfredo to the elaborate Linguine Pescatore—alongside a full range of popular Mexican Cuisine. You can enjoy authentically named Tacos like Carnita, Sudadero, and Lengua, or simple, satisfying Quesadillas and Wraps. This fusion of diverse cuisines guarantees that every guest, regardless of craving, will find a satisfying option.

Accessibility, Atmosphere, and Service Potential: Beyond the menu, the restaurant offers an unparalleled array of convenience features, including the unique Drive-through service and its designation as an All you can eat option. The presence of Live music and the warm glow of the Fireplace contribute to an attractive, Casual atmosphere perfect for unwinding. While some customers have experienced long waits, the stated highlight of Fast service and the noted attentive and accommodating nature of the owner and staff (especially toward families) suggest a high potential for a positive experience. Given the extensive menu and range of offerings—including Vegan and Vegetarian options—RARE represents a destination where culinary possibility is maximized.

RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

1005 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA