Salvatore's of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant

- 312 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in Nassau County and the border communities of Queens, Salvatore's of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant stands out as a beloved establishment known for its authentic Italian cuisine, extensive menu, and—most famously—its extraordinarily generous portions. This family-owned restaurant, a true gem in Elmont, has a long-standing commitment to quality, serving up traditional Italian dishes and classic pizza with a personal touch and flavor derived from family recipes.

Salvatore's is more than just a local pizzeria; it is a full-service Italian restaurant that has successfully catered to both casual diners looking for a quick slice and large groups celebrating significant life events. The ambiance is warm and inviting, striving to create a home-like atmosphere that keeps customers loyal. Their menu is vast, featuring classic pizza, a wide range of pasta dishes, salads, and traditional entrees like Chicken Parmigiana and Veal Parmigiana. They offer over 60 different pizza toppings and pies, including highly popular Sicilian styles, stuffed pizzas, and brick-oven favorites.

What truly sets Salvatore's apart in the competitive Long Island dining scene is its service model of abundance. Customers frequently note that the portions are akin to "family style," ensuring that no one leaves hungry—and most leave with leftovers. One particularly strong highlight that patrons rave about is the series of complimentary items that often accompany a dine-in meal, which may include fresh garlic knots, focaccia pizza, and sweet zeppoles for dessert, a delightful touch of hospitality. This commitment to value and a fulfilling dining experience is highly appreciated by the local New York clientele.

While the dining experience can vary—some event guests have noted service inconsistencies during peak times—the overall sentiment points to a place that offers exceptional food, value, and a setting capable of hosting special occasions. Dishes like the massive chopped salad "overloaded with prosciutto and fresh mozzarella" and the creamy Penne alla Vodka are often cited as excellent examples of the quality and size patrons can expect.

Location and Accessibility

Salvatore's of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant is conveniently located in the heart of Elmont, making it easily accessible for local Nassau County residents and those traveling from nearby Queens.

The address is: 312 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003, USA.

Meacham Avenue is a well-known local road, positioning the pizzeria well within a bustling commercial and residential area. For New York drivers, the location offers relatively easy access. Given the typical density of Long Island, this central location allows for simple pickup of takeout orders. For those planning to dine in or host an event, the restaurant’s presence in a local area suggests accessible parking, which is always a premium feature in the area. The restaurant is well-served by local transportation routes, connecting it efficiently to other parts of Elmont and the neighboring communities of Franklin Square and Floral Park. The establishment's popularity for events means it is designed to handle local traffic and customer influx for large gatherings.

Services Offered

Salvatore's of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant provides a comprehensive set of services to accommodate the diverse needs of the New York-area customer, from a single slice to full-scale catering.

• Dine-in Full-Service Restaurant: Offers table service for lunch and dinner, featuring a full menu of Italian entrees and pasta, beyond just pizza.
• Pizzeria Counter: Available for quick stops to grab pizza by the slice or whole pies for immediate consumption or takeout.
• Takeout and Delivery: Provides extensive services through various platforms, ensuring convenient meal options for those who prefer to eat at home.
• Special Event Hosting: Features a beautifully set up private area and large outdoor space with tents, suitable for various events and celebrations like birthday parties, christenings, and work dinners.
• Full Catering Menu: Offers large-format trays of appetizers (e.g., Baked Clams, Mozzarella Sticks), pastas (e.g., Penne alla Vodka), entrees (e.g., Chicken Parmigiana), and large specialty heroes for parties and corporate events.
• Reservation Recommendation: Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours or for event planning, to ensure a smooth dining experience.

Features / Highlights

The core highlights of Salvatore’s of Elmont center on its Italian authenticity, portion size, and special offerings that elevate the dining experience.

• Legendary Portions: Portions are consistently described as "massive" and "family style," ensuring exceptional value and ample leftovers for future meals.
• Complimentary Offerings: A major highlight is the inclusion of complimentary items with a meal, often including freshly baked garlic knots, focaccia, and delicious zeppoles (fried dough pastries) for dessert.
• Signature Penne alla Vodka: The Penne alla Vodka is a fan-favorite, often cited as being the "best hands down," made with shallots and a pink vodka cream sauce.
• Diverse Pizza Selection: Offers a huge variety of pizzas, including traditional, brick-oven, Sicilian, and specialty pies like the Grandma & Grandpa Sicilians (also available "drunken" with vodka sauce).
• Specialty Pasta Dishes: Menu standouts include Rigatoni Sicillano (with eggplant, basil, fresh mozzarella & ricotta) and large shrimp pasta dishes.
• Full-Service Events Space: The availability of large indoor and outdoor (tented) spaces makes it a premier local spot for hosting large parties and celebrations.
• Authentic Family Recipes: The traditional Italian dishes are prepared using authentic, family-owned recipes, ensuring a genuine taste of Southern Italian cooking.

Contact Information

For New York customers in Elmont and the surrounding areas wishing to place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering and events, please use the following contact details:

Address:

Phone:

What is worth choosing

For any local resident or visitor to the Elmont area, Salvatore's of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant is worth choosing when the goal is a substantial, authentic, and generously served Italian meal. This establishment’s reputation is built on specific dishes and an overall experience that delivers massive value.

You must choose Salvatore's if you are craving Penne alla Vodka. This dish is consistently called the best by patrons and is a flagship item, often included in their popular lunch and dinner specials. Its creamy, pink vodka sauce is a culinary comfort that few local places can match. For pizza enthusiasts, the specialty Sicilian Pies—particularly the Grandpa's Sfincione or the specialty slices like the artichoke and spinach—are essential, demonstrating the bakery's skill with dense, flavorful crusts and rich toppings.

Salvatore’s is also the ideal choice for any situation demanding a large, family-style meal. Their portions are intentionally massive; if you order an entree like Chicken Parmigiana or the massive chopped antipasto, prepare for it to feed more than one person, a valuable asset in the New York economy. The added bonus of the complimentary items—the hot Garlic Knots and the sweet Zeppoles—transforms a simple dinner into a memorable, multi-course feast.

Finally, choose Salvatore's for any major local event or party. With its dedicated event space, large catering menu, and reputation for providing substantial, delicious food for groups, it is the trusted local provider for everything from christenings to large corporate dinners. The ability to handle large volumes while maintaining the quality of Italian classics is a compelling reason to rely on this Long Island staple.

Salvatore's of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant

312 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003, USA