Sapienza Bake Shop

- 1376 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003

When New Yorkers are looking for exceptional specialty cakes and authentic Italian pastries, they often turn their attention to Long Island, where generations of family tradition have perfected the craft. Among the most trusted names in the region is Sapienza Bake Shop in Elmont, a well-established destination that has been delighting customers with high-quality confections for decades.

Sapienza Bake Shop is not just a bakery; it is a full-service dessert purveyor and a true local institution. Tracing its roots back to 1935 when the Sapienza family began baking in Queens, the current iteration in Elmont has been operating since 1973, focusing on a wide array of authentic Italian pastries, cookies, and a specialization in custom and specialty cakes. The commitment to using the best ingredients and time-honored, old-fashioned recipes ensures that every item, from a classic cannoli to a spectacular wedding cake, is of the highest quality.

This bake shop has successfully transitioned into a full-line, on-site production bakery, making it the premier place for high-end desserts for everyday enjoyment, parties, and major life events across Nassau County and the broader New York area. Whether you're craving a small treat, planning a party, or seeking the centerpiece cake for your wedding, Sapienza Bake Shop offers an extensive menu that honors its Italian heritage while embracing modern culinary trends.

For New York locals searching for a dependable bakery that blends tradition, quality, and exceptional customer service, Sapienza Bake Shop is a standout choice. Their reputation for moist cakes, creamy fillings, and beautiful, custom designs is reflected in the enthusiastic reviews from customers who rely on them for all their dessert needs, from a simple slice of cake to an elaborate multi-tiered celebration cake.

The focus on specialty and custom cakes, including decorative wedding and baby shower cakes, sets Sapienza Bake Shop apart. The staff, including decorators with competitive decorating experience, is dedicated to working with customers to bring their vision to life, ensuring a beautiful and delicious final product for any occasion.

Location and Accessibility

Sapienza Bake Shop is conveniently located in Elmont, New York, making it a highly accessible spot for residents across Long Island and the surrounding boroughs. The location on a main thoroughfare, Hempstead Turnpike, ensures easy navigation for visitors.

The bake shop is committed to ensuring that all patrons can access their delicious offerings comfortably. Accessibility features include a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot. For parking, customers benefit from the convenience of a free parking lot on the property right in front of the shop, as well as free street parking options nearby. This ease of access is a significant advantage for those looking to quickly pick up an order or browse the extensive selection of pastries and cakes.

Services Offered

Sapienza Bake Shop provides a comprehensive range of services and dining options to meet various customer needs, establishing itself as a versatile and customer-friendly establishment in the New York dessert scene.

• Specialty and Custom Cake Orders: Experts in creating all kinds of custom cakes, including stunning wedding cakes, baby shower cakes, and birthday cakes, with options for specific flavors and designs, such as cannoli cream filling and fondant decorations.
• In-Store Shopping: Customers are welcome to visit the shop to browse the display cases filled with fresh pastries, cookies, and cakes.
• Takeout and Quick Visits: Ideal for a quick stop to grab a coffee, a slice of cake, or a box of cookies for home.
• Delivery: For added convenience, the bakery offers local delivery service options.
• Curbside Pickup and In-Store Pickup: Facilitating quick and easy retrieval of orders placed in advance.
• Full Dessert Menu: Offering an extensive selection of cakes, cheesecakes, Italian pastries, and gourmet cookies made on-site.
• Fill Your Own Cannoli Kits: Providing a fun and interactive option for customers to enjoy the signature cannoli cream and shells at home.
• Breakfast Offerings: A dining option for those looking to start their day with a delicious baked good and coffee.
• Wholesale: The shop also has a history of wholesale distribution of its fine Italian pastries.

Features / Highlights

The quality and breadth of Sapienza Bake Shop’s menu, combined with its strong community presence, make it a local favorite. Several items and aspects of the business consistently receive high praise from New York customers.

• Authentic Italian Pastries: Known for traditional favorites like the Large Cannoli (a classic crunchy shell filled with world-famous cannoli cream), Lobster Tails (flaky pastry with French cream filling), Napoleon, and Sfogliatella. The Fill Your Own Cannoli Kit is a celebrated novelty item.
• Signature Cakes and Cheesecakes: High-demand cakes include the Pineapple and Strawberry Cake (often ranked highly liked by customers), Red Velvet Cake with cream cheese filling, Chocolate Mousse Cake, Cannoli Cake (Vanilla cake with cannoli cream filling and toppings), and the unique Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake.
• Gourmet Cookies: The bakery is famous for its authentic Italian cookies, especially the 1 Lb Rainbow Cookies (Tri-Color cookies) and Assorted Sandwich Cookies (butter cookies with raspberry jelly), which are frequently cited as must-buy items.
• Party and Single-Serving Desserts: A variety of smaller treats are available, such as slices of Chocolate Mousse Cake, Red Velvet Cake, and Strawberry Mousse Cake, as well as Pastry Cups like Tiramisu Cup, Chocolate Mousse Cup, and Strawberry Mousse Cup.
• Generational Heritage: The bake shop has a rich history dating back to 1935 in Queens, with the current Elmont location established in 1973, now being run by the third generation of the Sapienza family, ensuring consistent quality and traditional recipes.
• Custom Cake Expertise: Highly regarded for their expertise in custom and decorative cakes for major events, with staff members possessing award-winning decorating skills.
• Inclusive Environment: The establishment is noted for being LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace, creating a welcoming environment for all members of the community.

Contact Information

Whether you need to place a custom cake order, inquire about the seasonal selection, or simply want to stop by for a treat, here is the essential contact information for Sapienza Bake Shop:

Address: 1376 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003, USA

Phone: (516) 352-5232

What is Worth Choosing

For Long Islanders and New York residents seeking a top-tier bakery experience, Sapienza Bake Shop consistently delivers on its promise of quality and tradition. The shop’s ability to flawlessly execute both simple, everyday indulgences and complex, custom-designed celebration cakes is what makes it a local institution worth choosing.

If you are planning an event, the specialty cakes—like the moist Red Velvet Cake, the classic Chocolate Mousse Cake, or the celebrated Cannoli Cake with its unique filling—are guaranteed crowd-pleasers. Customers often rave about the personalized experience, noting how helpful staff members like Andrew are in selecting the perfect flavors and designs for birthdays and other milestones. The positive feedback highlights not only the beautiful presentation but also the delicious, moist quality of the sponge and the wonderful taste of specialty fillings like cannoli cream.

For a more casual visit, the authentic Italian pastries and cookies are an absolute must-try. The Large Cannoli is a highly recommended staple, praised for its fresh, crunchy shell and perfectly creamy, not-too-sweet filling. The 1 Lb Rainbow Cookies are considered the 'GOAT' (Greatest of All Time) by many local fans, offering a perfect blend of almond cake layers and chocolate. Moreover, the single-serving options, such as the Strawberry Cheesecake cup or the Tiramisu Cup, provide a rich, satisfying dessert for a quick visit or a coffee break. The availability of convenient services like free on-site parking and delivery options further enhances the customer experience, making Sapienza Bake Shop a hassle-free choice for high-quality desserts in the Elmont area of Long Island. The long-standing family history ensures that when you choose Sapienza, you are getting authentic recipes passed down through generations, promising an unforgettable taste of classic New York Italian baking.

Sapienza Bake Shop

1376 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003, USA