Sbarro Brooklyn Flatbush Ave: Authentic XL NY Pizza, Stromboli, and Family-Friendly Dining

Sbarro Introduce

Sbarro at 2509 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn, NY, is more than just a fast food stop; it is a full-fledged Italian-American establishment classified as a Pizza restaurant, Caterer, Fast food restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pasta shop, Pizza delivery, and Pizza Takeout service. This comprehensive set of classifications immediately highlights its versatility, catering to virtually every dining need, from a quick solo lunch slice to a large group meal or event catering. Located within the bustling Kings Plaza area, Sbarro embodies the New York spirit of offering quality food with speed and convenience.

The restaurant offers a wide range of comfort food, focusing on its signature XL NY Pizza, classic pastas like Baked Ziti and Spaghetti with Meatballs, and the ever-popular Stromboli. This variety ensures that whether a customer is seeking a 'Quick bite' or a full 'Dinner' experience, their appetite can be satisfied. The dining environment is categorized as both Casual and Trendy, providing a relaxed yet modern atmosphere suitable for a diverse crowd, including Groups and Tourists. Crucially, Sbarro has embraced modern logistics by offering No-contact delivery, Delivery, and Takeout, alongside the option to Dine-in, ensuring maximum flexibility for the time-conscious New Yorker. The commitment to inclusivity is also evident through extensive accessibility features and child-friendly amenities.

Location and Accessibility for Brooklyn Users

The Sbarro restaurant is strategically located at 2509 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234, USA. This address places it within the highly trafficked Kings Plaza area, a major commercial hub in the Mill Basin neighborhood of Brooklyn. For local users, the proximity to a central shopping destination makes it an exceptionally convenient stop before or after errands, shopping, or commuting.

Accessibility at this location is a major highlight, setting it apart as a fully inclusive dining destination in New York City. The restaurant offers a comprehensive suite of accessibility features, ensuring that all patrons can visit comfortably:

Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Furthermore, the practicalities of parking are addressed, with options for both Free street parking and a Paid parking lot, accommodating various travel methods common in the New York area. This dedication to physical access, combined with its prime location on a major thoroughfare like Flatbush Avenue, ensures Sbarro is an easily reachable and welcoming spot for the entire Brooklyn community.

Services Offered

Sbarro offers a multi-faceted service model that caters to a wide variety of customer preferences, blending traditional Italian dining with modern fast-food efficiency:

Comprehensive Meal Service: Dining options cover Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, with comfortable Seating provided within a Restroom-equipped amenity space.
Flexible Fulfillment Options: The restaurant provides No-contact delivery, standard Delivery, Takeout for quick pickup, and Dine-in for a full, sit-down meal.
Full Menu Diversity: Offerings include Pizza, Pasta (like Baked Ziti and Spaghetti with Meatballs), Stromboli, Fresh Salads, Sides, and Drinks, encompassing a range of Italian and fast-food staples. The menu includes Vegetarian options.
Catering Services: The classification as a 'Caterer' and 'Pasta shop' indicates the capability to handle large orders for events, meetings, or family gatherings, a crucial service for group planning.
Modern Payment Methods: Transactions are quick and easy, accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features and Highlights

Sbarro’s highlights include its signature menu items, welcoming atmosphere, and strong commitment to convenience and family dining in Brooklyn.

Signature XL NY Pizza and Stromboli: The restaurant is known for its authentic XL NY Slice, made with fresh, hand-stretched dough, San Marzano-style sauce, and 100% whole milk mozzarella. The Stromboli is a customer favorite, described as "marvelous" and a must-try.
All-Day and Late-Night Availability: Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and specifically offering Late-night food, Sbarro meets the needs of New Yorkers regardless of their schedule.
Family and Group Friendly: The designation as "Good for kids," the availability of High chairs, and a dedicated Kids' menu make it an excellent choice for family outings. The atmosphere is also suitable for accommodating Groups.
Accessibility Commitment: The extensive list of wheelchair-accessible features (entrance, parking, restroom, seating) is a major distinguishing factor and a strong service commitment to the community.
Diverse Offerings: The menu successfully blends familiar 'Comfort food' with 'Quick bite' and 'Small plates' options, along with dedicated 'Vegetarian options,' ensuring broad appeal.
Customer Experience Feedback: A highly positive review noted the quality of the food ("finger licking"), specifically praising the BBQ wings and the favorite Stromboli, despite long lines, which suggests consistent demand. However, a significant critical review pointed out a highly negative experience with a specific slice, alleging "No mozarella, no any kind of cheese, no tomato sause," which highlights a potential inconsistency in quality control that customers should be aware of.

Contact Information

For New York patrons in Brooklyn, the factual contact details for the Sbarro location are:

Address: 2509 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234, USA

Phone: (718) 258-3869

Mobile Phone: +1 718-258-3869

What is Worth Choosing Sbarro

Sbarro at the Flatbush Avenue location is worth choosing for the New York customer who values convenience, accessibility, and a variety of classic Italian-American comfort food. You are selecting a destination that excels in offering flexibility, whether you need a quick XL NY slice for solo dining during your lunch break, a full family dinner with a kids' menu and high chairs, or a large order catered for a group. The comprehensive accessibility features—including dedicated parking and seating for wheelchairs—make it a standout choice for patrons requiring ease of access. While the polarized customer reviews suggest that the quality of specific slices might occasionally be inconsistent, the overall reputation is built on delivering satisfying, late-night-available comfort food and highly praised items like their famous Stromboli. By accepting modern payments and offering no-contact delivery, Sbarro is perfectly positioned as a highly efficient, family-friendly, and all-inclusive pizza and Italian food hub in the heart of Brooklyn.

Sbarro Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Paid parking lot

Sbarro Photos

Sbarro Location

Sbarro

New York Kings County Mill Basin Flatbush Avenue

2509 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234, USA

Sbarro Reviews

An average rating of ★3.8 from 851 user reviews.

baked zitibathroomroasted chickenchicken parmesancoldmalldiningstrombolimeatballmac and cheese

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

An ordinary 99-cent pizza is more delicious than Sbarro! No mozarella, no any kind of cheese, no tomato sause! What these guys are doing?!
September 15 · Erkan Boztas
The line was long but the food always finger licking..always love visiting this location ... BBQ wings bite size too small for the marvelous taste 😋 n definitely Stromboli my favorite
November 09 · Alizon Charles
I love Sbarro’s restaurant. However, today I was disappointed when I ordered a spinach and tomatoes pizza pies from Sbarro’s. When DoorDash delivered the pizza (with my name written on it), I received a pizza with red peppers, onions, green peppers, olives and mushrooms. Plus, I’m not a big fan of mushrooms and olives. Again, I love Sbarro’s but the workers need to pay more attention to the instructions on all online food orders.
August 14 · Tyrell Paul
The pizza's taste was unlike any other that I usually eat in my home country but it was tasty. The surroundings were clean and I loved that there was a roomy and comfortable seating area for dining.
March 18 · Kathy Ann Halls
While I was waiting to place my order, a woman came to the counter and asked if the tables could be cleaned off. The counter guy said to give him a minute and it would be done. I proceeded to order a chicken parmesan hero, which btw was tasteless. I only ate half of it and that was only because I hadn't eaten anything all day. But the worst part of this whole experience was the bathroom. I hadn't been to the bathroom in a few hours and I had a long ride home on the bus. However, when I opened the ladies bathroom door it was so disgusting and stink. I swear the urge to urinate left me immediately. I backed out of the bathroom. A woman was coming in as I was backing out. She asked me what was wron?. I said it's disgusting and left. Whoever manages that Sabarro in Kings Plaza needs to do a better job with cleanliness.The tables need to be bused and wiped down regularly and somebody definitely needs to keep up with the sanitation of that nast, grossy bathroom. How are you serving food in an establishment where the bathroom is that disgusting? I will never purchase anything from them again!!
August 24 · Donna