Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen

- 141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

## Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers who appreciate the art of the perfect smoked fish platter or a towering classic deli sandwich, Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen stands out as an essential destination. Located in the highly desirable neighborhood of Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, Shelsky’s is far more than just a typical sandwich shop; it is a modern take on the traditional Jewish appetizing counter and deli. The shop seamlessly blends the classic comfort foods and gourmet smoked fish that New York is famous for, offering a vast and unique menu.

Shelsky's has earned its reputation by specializing in a dizzying array of smoked fish—from the quintessential Eastern Gaspe Nova to unique items like Pastrami Smoked Salmon and Wild King Salmon "Bacon". This commitment to quality and variety is the cornerstone of their popular, creatively named Smoked Fish Sandwiches and Salad Spread Sandwiches. The menu is thoughtfully extensive, covering everything from simple egg sandwiches and lox-and-schmear bagels to full-scale Weekend Brunch Packages for family gatherings.

Whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite during a lunch break, meeting friends for a casual brunch, or need catering for an event, Shelsky's delivers on authenticity and flavor. The atmosphere is casual, welcoming locals and is especially popular for solo dining during breakfast and lunch hours. For the modern New Yorker seeking high-quality, authentic Jewish comfort food, Shelsky’s Of Brooklyn is a must-visit institution.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn is perfectly situated at 141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA. Court Street is a vibrant, bustling thoroughfare connecting Cobble Hill, Brooklyn Heights, and Downtown Brooklyn, making the shop highly central and easily accessible from various parts of the borough.

Its prime location in one of Brooklyn's most walkable areas means it is easy to reach by foot for local residents and professionals. For those utilizing public transportation, the shop is conveniently close to several major subway lines. The Borough Hall station (2, 3, 4, 5 lines) and the Court Street station (R line) are both within easy walking distance, making it a simple commute stop for your morning bagel or a designated lunch destination.

The shop is committed to Accessibility, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance. For drivers, both free street parking and paid street parking options are available, though as with anywhere in NYC, these can be competitive. Beyond the physical space, Shelsky's accommodates the New York lifestyle with multiple service options, including Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery service, and Onsite services. They accept major forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

---

## Services Offered

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn offers a comprehensive suite of dining and retail services, establishing them as a full-service appetizing and delicatessen:

• Appetizing Counter & Deli Retail: Selling high-quality ingredients by weight, including an unparalleled selection of Cold Smoked & Cured Fish (Eastern Gaspe Nova, Tsar's Cut Balik Salmon) and Hot Smoked & Kippered Fish (Peppered Hot Smoked Salmon), along with Delicatessen Meats (Pastrami, Corned Beef), and a variety of House Cream Cheese flavors.
• Signature Sandwiches: A vast menu of specialty sandwiches, divided into Smoked Fish Sandwiches (e.g., Peter Shelsky, The Great Gatsby), Salad Spread Sandwiches (Smoked Whitefish Salad, Chicken Salad), and classic New York Delicatessen Sandwiches (Shelsky's Hot Pastrami, Reuben).
• Breakfast and Brunch: Serving a complete line of classic Breakfast Sandwiches (including Jersey Pork Roll & Egg and Pastrami, Egg, & Cheese), as well as custom Sandwich with a Schmear/ Butter using their freshly baked bagels and bialys.
• Full-Service Catering: Offering several curated Weekend Brunch Packages (like A Brooklyn Schmear Brunch and Big Macher Brooklyn Brunch), along with the option to order large quantities of bagels, spreads, meats, and their Ashlawn Farm Coffee Box for event catering.
• Homemade Sides and Sweets: Providing a rotating selection of Soups, Salads, & Spreads (Matzo Ball Soup, Traditional Cucumber Salad, Homemade Potato Salad), and authentic baked Sweets (Chocolate Babka, Raspberry Walnut Rugelach).
• Gourmet & Specialty Items: Carrying unique retail items like Caviar and Roe (Kaluga, Osetra), imported goods (Laoganma Spicy Chili Crisp, Kewpie Japanese Mayonnaise), and a selection of classic NY sodas like Dr. Brown's Cream Soda.

---

## Features / Highlights

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn sets itself apart with several features that highlight its dedication to quality and traditional New York appetizing culture:

• Smoked Fish Expertise: The shop is famous for its expertly smoked and cured fish, offering a superior quality and selection that goes beyond what most delis provide, including rare finds like Hot Smoked Bluefish and Fancy Lake Sturgeon.
• Iconic Deli Classics: They serve authentic, high-end Jewish deli sandwiches, featuring their own Homemade Roast Beef, Classic Delicatessen Pastrami, and Corned Beef. Their Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich and Shelsky's Reuben Sandwich are cornerstone items in the NYC deli scene.
• Creative Bagel & Cream Cheese Pairings: Shelsky's bakes its own variety of bagels and bialys, and features innovative, house-made cream cheeses, including unique flavors like Chili Crisp Cream Cheese and Sichuan Peppercorn Bagels, offering a modern twist on the classic schmear.
• Inclusive Offerings: Catering to diverse needs, they offer Gluten-Free Bagels and Vegan Stockeld® Cream Cheese (made from cultured chickpeas and lentils), ensuring that even those with dietary restrictions can enjoy a classic appetizing experience.
• Gourmet Pantry: The shop functions as a small gourmet grocery, selling items like Ashlawn Farm Coffee Beans - Shelsky's Roast, Quart Of Pickled Tomatoes, and specialized imports, allowing customers to take a piece of the deli experience home.

---

## Contact Information

For orders, catering inquiries, or general information, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA (located in Cobble Hill)
• Phone: (718) 855-8817

---

## What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Shelsky's Of Brooklyn is a choice for authentic, elevated New York appetizing and delicatessen fare. For the discerning local, the shop is worth choosing for several crucial reasons that separate it from typical delis.

First and foremost, you choose Shelsky's for the unmatched quality of their smoked fish. If you are seeking the best lox, whitefish, or unique smoked salmon combinations in Brooklyn, this is the destination. Their Smoked Fish Sandwiches—like the fan-favorite Peter Shelsky or the Brooklyn Native—are complex, carefully constructed culinary experiences, not just simple spreads on a bagel. While some customers note that the portions reflect the high cost of premium ingredients, the quality of the fish is consistently described as "to die for."

Secondly, the shop offers a rare and valuable blend of appetizing and delicatessen classics. Few places in the city excel equally at both high-end lox and traditional hot pastrami. Here, you can transition seamlessly from an appetizing brunch package to a hearty Lewis'knish Bomb or a spectacular Matzo Ball Soup. The ability to get premium Classic Delicatessen Sandwiches alongside unique spreads and sides like Latkes and Pickled Herring Salad makes it a complete cultural and culinary experience.

Finally, the sheer convenience and breadth of services—Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery, and especially the full Catering menu—makes Shelsky's the ideal source for everything from a quick individual lunch to a massive spread for a holiday or corporate event. For true New York comfort food that respects tradition while embracing modern flavors, Shelsky's Of Brooklyn is the clear choice.

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen

141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA