Smokey Island Grille

- 436 Sutter Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212

For New Yorkers craving a taste of the Caribbean islands without leaving the borough, look no further than Smokey Island Grille. Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, this Jamaican restaurant has become a local go-to spot, bringing the rich, vibrant, and comforting flavors of the tropics right to the Brownsville neighborhood. Whether you're a long-time resident of the city or just exploring the vibrant culinary landscape of Brooklyn, Smokey Island Grille promises an authentic and casual dining experience centered around classic Caribbean and Jamaican fare.

The restaurant specializes in the kind of hearty, soulful cooking that Jamaica is famous for, focusing on deeply seasoned meats, warm pastries, and satisfying meals that truly hit the spot. It's the perfect place to grab an energizing breakfast, a filling lunch, or a comforting dinner, with a menu designed to cater to a variety of tastes and dining preferences. The casual atmosphere makes it a welcoming stop for families, individuals grabbing a quick bite, or anyone looking to enjoy the genuine hospitality that often comes with a classic neighborhood Caribbean spot. Smokey Island Grille aims to be more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary gateway to the island, right here in the bustling energy of New York City.

Brooklyn is a melting pot of global cuisines, and the vibrant Jamaican food scene is one of its most cherished cultural assets. Smokey Island Grille contributes significantly to this legacy, offering a carefully curated menu that showcases the staples of Jamaican cooking. From the flaky, savory goodness of their patties to the wholesome warmth of their porridges and soups, the menu reflects a deep respect for traditional island recipes. New Yorkers who value authenticity and flavor will find a lot to love here, making it a worthy addition to your list of must-try local eateries.

Smokey Island Grille is conveniently located at 436 Sutter Ave in Brooklyn, New York, with the zip code 11212. This address places it squarely in the Brownsville neighborhood, a vibrant and dynamic community within the borough. For local New Yorkers, the restaurant's location offers easy accessibility, whether you're traveling from other parts of Brooklyn or venturing in from another borough.

The Brownsville location is particularly appealing for those seeking genuine, community-focused Caribbean and Jamaican cuisine outside of the more crowded or heavily commercial areas of the city. The accessible street address means it’s simple to find, whether you’re driving or utilizing New York’s excellent public transit system. Being a neighborhood staple, the grille is embedded within the local life, making it a familiar and reliable choice for a great meal. The presence of the restaurant provides a consistent source of comfort food and island flavors to the Brownsville community and beyond, inviting patrons from all over the city to stop by and sample their offerings.

Smokey Island Grille offers a comprehensive range of services designed to meet the busy schedules and varied needs of New Yorkers. Whether you're looking for a quick meal on the go, a relaxed dine-in experience, or a meal delivered right to your door, the options ensure convenience is a priority.

Services Offered:

• Dine-in: Customers can enjoy their meal in the casual, comfortable atmosphere of the restaurant.
• Takeout: Convenient option for patrons who wish to pick up their food and enjoy it elsewhere.
• Delivery: For maximum convenience, the restaurant offers delivery services, bringing authentic Jamaican food right to homes and offices across the service area.
• Accepts major payment methods including Credit Cards and Debit Cards.

The true highlights of Smokey Island Grille lie in its authentic Jamaican menu offerings, commitment to classic comfort food, and its role as a welcoming, casual neighborhood spot. The dining experience is tailored for everyday life in New York, offering quick, satisfying meals for all times of the day.

Features / Highlights:

• Authentic Jamaican & Caribbean Cuisine: The core of the menu is built on traditional, flavorful Caribbean recipes, ensuring an authentic island experience.
• The Essential Jamaican Patty Selection: A wide variety of the iconic Jamaican savory pastry is available, including Mild Beef, Spicy Beef, Chicken, Soya, and Vegetable Patty, catering to different preferences and dietary needs.
• The Classic Combo: Coco Bread & Patty: A highlight for many aficionados, the signature Coco Bread & Patty combines a warm, soft, and slightly sweet Jamaican Coco Bread with a savory patty filling to create a perfect handheld sandwich.
• Diverse Roti Menu: Catering to the wider Caribbean tradition, the grille offers Roti with various savory fillings such as Curry Goat, Oxtail, Stew Chicken, Curry Chicken, Jerk Pork, Curry Shrimp, and Vegetable Stir Fry.
• All-Day Dining: Serves Breakfast (including Callaloo & Saltfish and Llama Bean & Saltfish), Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, making it a reliable choice throughout the day.
• Comfort Food Focus: The menu emphasizes comforting, hearty, and satisfying "comfort food," often served as a quick bite or small plates.
• Variety of Desserts: A sweet selection including Red Velvet Cake, Carrot Cream Cake, Apple Pie, Cheesecake, Double Layer Chocolate Cake, Banana Bread, and Jamaican Rum Cake.
• Casual Atmosphere: The restaurant maintains a casual atmosphere that is family-friendly and good for kids, promoting a relaxed dining environment.
• Popular for Solo Dining: An ideal spot for New Yorkers seeking a flavorful and quick meal on their own.
• Homemade and Tropical Beverages: Featuring unique island beverages like Sorrel Ginger Juice, Homemade Carrot Juice, Peanut Punch, and D&G Soda alongside classics like Iced Tea and Lemonade.

For those planning a visit, placing a takeout order, or seeking delivery, here is the essential contact information for Smokey Island Grille:

Address: 436 Sutter Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212, USA

Phone: (718) 676-0955

Mobile Phone: +1 718-676-0955

For New York City residents, particularly those in Brooklyn and the wider surrounding areas, choosing Smokey Island Grille is an excellent decision for several compelling reasons, rooted in both the food and the service structure.

Firstly, the restaurant serves as a reliable and authentic source of Jamaican and Caribbean comfort food. In a city where quick and tasty meals are essential, the grille excels by offering traditional, flavorful dishes that feel homemade. The selection of patties alone makes it a destination, providing options for every palate, from the classic Spicy Beef to the Soya and Vegetable alternatives. Pairing one of these with the soft, slightly sweet Coco Bread is a quintessential Caribbean experience that is hard to beat for a fulfilling lunch or snack.

Beyond the patties, the diverse Roti menu—featuring fillings like savory Curry Goat and Stew Chicken—gives customers a broader taste of Caribbean cuisine, moving beyond standard fare. This versatility, combined with their offering of wholesome items like Cornmeal Porridge for breakfast and hearty Seafood or Chicken Soups, ensures there is a comforting, quick, and satisfying choice for any time of day. New Yorkers on the go will appreciate the convenience of this varied menu, whether they need a quick bite to hold them over or a full, warm meal.

Secondly, the service structure at Smokey Island Grille is perfectly adapted for the demands of NYC life. The availability of delivery, takeout, and a casual dine-in space means patrons can enjoy their meal however they prefer—a necessity for the city's fast-paced environment. It is particularly noted as a good option for solo dining, highlighting its efficiency and welcoming nature for individuals. The family-friendly atmosphere also makes it a simple, hassle-free option for those dining with children.

While customer experiences can sometimes vary, with some reviews pointing out inconsistencies in specific dishes like the oxtail, the sheer breadth of the menu and the focus on traditional staples like the patties and coco bread remain major draws. Choosing Smokey Island Grille is choosing a piece of Brooklyn’s vibrant Caribbean culinary heritage, offering an authentic, flavorful, and convenient dining option that is deeply rooted in the local community. For anyone in the New York area seeking genuine Jamaican flavors and a casual, reliable meal, Smokey Island Grille on Sutter Avenue is a highly recommended stop to satisfy that island food craving.

Smokey Island Grille

436 Sutter Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212, USA