Strange Delight

- 63 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Strange Delight is a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn’s Fort Greene neighborhood, offering a fresh and elevated take on New Orleans-inspired seafood. It’s a place that manages to channel the spirit of the Crescent City without relying on clichés, instead focusing on a laid-back, convivial atmosphere and a menu that is a heartfelt "love letter" to the seafood dishes of Louisiana. The restaurant, with its contemporary design and welcoming facade, stands out as a destination for those seeking a unique and memorable dining experience. It's a spot that has quickly become one of the most exciting seafood places to open in New York in recent years, drawing in locals and visitors alike with its distinct flavors and thoughtful approach to classic dishes.

The menu at Strange Delight is a well-curated celebration of the sea, with a special emphasis on oysters. You'll find these bivalves prepared in a variety of styles, from raw with a classic mignonette to "charbroiled" in a former pizza oven, which caramelizes the outside while leaving the interior juicy and sweet. This specific preparation is a loving nod to New Orleans institutions, as are the Oysters Rockefeller, which take inspiration from the classic version at Galatoire's. But the menu's brilliance doesn't stop at oysters. Strange Delight has perfected the seafood tower, offering a version for one person as well as a shareable platter. These towers and platters can feature everything from local cold oysters and shrimp cocktail to smoked fish dip and shrimp and crab remoulade, providing a comprehensive taste of the menu's best offerings.

Beyond the shellfish, the restaurant is also lauded for its hefty and delicious sandwiches, often referred to as "loaves," which are served on soft milk bread. The fried shrimp loaf, in particular, has garnered a reputation as an impressive piece of culinary architecture, with perfectly fried shrimp and layers of crisp vegetables. Other menu standouts include the light and wonderfully sweet hush puppies with Steen’s butter, as well as the richly savory blackened swordfish belly. The kitchen's commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients shines through in every dish, and the laid-back, friendly service adds to the overall warmth of the experience. It's a place where you can feel the energy of the bustling kitchen and the friendly buzz of the bar, making it a truly engaging spot to dine.

The atmosphere at Strange Delight is designed to be approachable and fun. While the dining room has a tranquil, sunlit vibe, the front bar area is more lively, offering a chance to watch the chefs at work. The space is cozy and trendy, making it a great choice for a date night, a celebratory meal, or a casual lunch. The restaurant is also noted for being an inclusive and welcoming space, being family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safe space, which contributes to its reputation as a community-oriented establishment. The location's proximity to major venues like the Brooklyn Academy of Music and the Barclays Center also makes it an excellent choice for a pre-show or post-game meal, though reservations are highly recommended, especially on days with big events. The combination of its flavorful menu, lively yet comfortable atmosphere, and excellent service makes Strange Delight a must-visit in Fort Greene.

Location and Accessibility

Strange Delight is located at 63 Lafayette Avenue in Brooklyn, NY 11217, placing it in the popular Fort Greene neighborhood. The restaurant is conveniently situated near several major Brooklyn landmarks, including the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM) and the Barclays Center, making it a great destination for those attending performances or sporting events. Parking in the area can be a mix of free street parking and paid street parking. The restaurant itself features a front room with an open kitchen and an oyster counter, as well as a quieter back dining room with booths for larger groups, offering different vibes for different occasions.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: The primary service, with seating available in both the front and back of the restaurant.
• Table Service: The restaurant provides table service, ensuring a comfortable and well-attended dining experience.
• Catering: Strange Delight offers catering services for events and gatherings, bringing their unique flavors to your special occasion.
• Brunch: A brunch menu is available on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday from 11:30 AM to 3:30 PM.
• Dinner: The main dinner service runs Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 5:00 PM to 9:30 PM, and on Friday and Saturday until 10:30 PM.
• Reservations: Reservations are accepted and recommended, especially for dinner, to secure your spot at this popular eatery.
• Small Plates: The menu is structured around small plates and shareable items, perfect for a communal dining experience.

Features / Highlights

• Great Cocktails: The cocktail program is a standout, with creative and well-made drinks, including New Orleans-inspired classics like the Hurricane and Sazerac.
• Fast Service: The staff is known for being attentive and quick, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable dining experience.
• Creative Menu: The menu offers a unique blend of New Orleans and contemporary seafood, with inventive dishes like Spicy BBQ Oysters and Smoked Trout Roe & Hush Puppies.
• All-Seafood Menu: The restaurant's exclusive focus on seafood means there are no other types of meat served, a clear sign of their specialization and dedication.
• Inclusive Atmosphere: Strange Delight is LGBTQ+ friendly, a transgender safe space, and family-friendly, creating a welcoming environment for all.
• Unique Preparations: Oysters are prepared in a former pizza oven, a testament to the restaurant's creative and flavorful cooking methods.
• Dessert: Every meal is capped off with a complimentary dessert, a thoughtful and delightful touch.

Contact Information

Address: 63 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

Phone: N/A

What is worth choosing

For those planning a visit, the food at Strange Delight is the primary reason to go. The seafood is consistently praised for being fresh and full of flavor. The charbroiled oysters are a must-try, offering a rich and savory experience that many describe as the best they've ever had. For those who enjoy a heartier dish, the fried shrimp loaf is a fan favorite and a true standout, praised for its perfect balance of crispiness and flavor. The hush puppies are also highly recommended, described as "delightful" and served with a delicious, buttery honey. The "Smoked Fish Dip" is another highlight, often cited as a crave-worthy dish that's perfect for starting your meal.

Beyond the specific dishes, the "Tower Service" is a great way to sample a variety of the restaurant’s best offerings, especially if you're dining with a friend. It allows you to build your own tasting experience, with flavorful options like the punchy pimento dip and the well-balanced side salad. The cocktail menu is also a huge draw, with drinks that are properly boozed and never overly sweet. The service, as mentioned by several patrons, is excellent, with a warm and attentive staff that adds to the welcoming vibe. While it may not be the cheapest option, the quality of the ingredients, the inventive menu, and the overall experience make Strange Delight a worthwhile choice for a special occasion or when you're looking to treat yourself to some of the best seafood Brooklyn has to offer.

Strange Delight

63 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA