Sugar Hill Creamery

- 1642 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029

Welcome to Sugar Hill Creamery, a small, Black-owned, and women-owned business that has quickly become a beloved destination for ice cream lovers in New York City. Located in the vibrant neighborhood of East Harlem, this artisanal ice cream shop is a true gem, celebrated for its unique flavors, high-quality ingredients, and commitment to the community.

More than just a place to get a sweet treat, Sugar Hill Creamery is a testament to the passion and creativity of its founders. Every scoop is a small-batch, handmade creation that reflects a thoughtful process and a dedication to crafting exceptional ice cream. The result is a product that customers consistently describe as "hands down one of the best" they've tasted in the city.

The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and trendy, making it the perfect spot for a quick visit or a leisurely treat. The shop fosters a welcoming environment for everyone, proudly identifying as a safe space for families and the LGBTQ+ community. This commitment to inclusivity, combined with its fantastic offerings, makes Sugar Hill Creamery a standout in New York's competitive dessert scene.

Sugar Hill Creamery is situated at 1642 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029. Located in East Harlem, the shop is a convenient stop for locals and tourists exploring the neighborhood. The location is easily accessible by public transportation and is a great destination for a quick visit while enjoying a day in the city.

The shop is designed to be accessible to all customers. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating, ensuring that everyone can comfortably enjoy their visit. For those traveling by car, there is free street parking available, which is a rare and welcome convenience in this bustling part of New York City.

• Dine-in: The shop offers seating for customers who wish to relax and enjoy their ice cream in the casual and trendy atmosphere.
• Takeout: For those on the go, the takeout service is a quick and efficient option.
• Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: Enjoy Sugar Hill Creamery's delicious ice cream from the comfort of your home with their delivery and no-contact delivery options.
• In-store pickup: You can place an order ahead of time and pick it up at the shop, making for a seamless and quick transaction.
• Wi-Fi: Free Wi-Fi is available, making it a great spot for a solo dining session or a quick work break.
• Payments: The shop accepts a variety of convenient payment methods, including major credit cards and debit cards.

• Handmade, Small-Batch Ice Cream: The core of the Sugar Hill Creamery experience is the ice cream itself. Each batch is made by hand with care, resulting in a rich, creamy texture and vibrant flavor that sets it apart.
• Unique and Rotating Flavors: While they have constant classics, the flavors frequently change with the seasons and new creations are always on the menu. This encourages repeat visits and a sense of discovery. Examples of their inventive flavors include Chairperson of the Board (a cream cheese-based ice cream with graham crackers and blueberry jam) and Brown Bombshell (a milk chocolate ice cream with caramel swirls and pecans).
• Variety of Offerings: Beyond scoops, the menu includes specialty items like Brownie Sundaes, Ice Cream Sandwiches made with their own cookies and brownies, and a variety of shakes and floats. They also offer a selection of baked goods like their Chocolate Chip Cookies and Handmade Brownies.
• Vegan and Gluten-Free Options: The shop is inclusive of various dietary needs, offering a selection of vegan and non-dairy options, as well as gluten-free choices, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.
• Community-Focused Business: As a Black-owned and women-owned small business, Sugar Hill Creamery is a vital part of the local economy and community. The friendly staff, like the informative and polite Johamm mentioned in a review, contributes to a positive and welcoming environment.
• A Welcoming Space: The atmosphere is family-friendly and a safe space for the LGBTQ+ and transgender communities, making it a place where everyone can feel comfortable and accepted.

Address: 1642 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029, United States

Phone: (212) 634-9004

For a New Yorker seeking an ice cream experience that is both delicious and meaningful, Sugar Hill Creamery is an exceptional choice. The most compelling reason to visit is the outstanding quality of the product. The ice cream is handcrafted in small batches, and the flavors are unique and constantly evolving, ensuring that every visit offers a new and exciting taste. As one reviewer put it, this is "hands down one of the best ice creams" they’ve tasted in NYC, an unplanned delight that speaks volumes about the quality of the product. The dedication to using fresh ingredients and creating inventive flavor combinations sets it apart from larger, more commercial chains.

Beyond the ice cream, the business’s values and community focus are major selling points. By choosing to support Sugar Hill Creamery, you are directly supporting a Black-owned and women-owned small business that is dedicated to its neighborhood. The shop’s inclusive and welcoming atmosphere makes it a comfortable space for everyone, and its commitment to providing options for various dietary needs, including vegan and gluten-free choices, ensures that nobody is left out of the fun.

The staff also plays a significant role in making the experience memorable. The service is described as "good" and the staff as "very informative, polite," which contributes to the overall positive and friendly vibe of the place. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the great service and the warm atmosphere make you feel right at home.

In short, Sugar Hill Creamery is a destination that delivers on all fronts: incredible, artisanal ice cream, a wide range of delicious options, a strong sense of community, and a commitment to inclusivity. It is the perfect place to grab a quick, satisfying treat or a special dessert for any occasion.

Sugar Hill Creamery

1642 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA