There Should Always Be Cake

- 2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers who believe that life is sweeter with a daily dose of high-quality confectionery, the search for the perfect local bakery ends in the Bronx. Situated in a vibrant and accessible neighborhood, There Should Always Be Cake is more than just a place to satisfy your sweet tooth; it's a dedicated artisan bakery committed to crafting beautiful and delicious treats for everyone. This local gem specializes in everything from classic cookies and exquisite cupcakes to custom cakes for all occasions, ensuring that whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply craving a moment of sweetness, there truly should always be cake—or a cookie, or a parfait—available.

What sets this establishment apart in the competitive NYC bakery landscape is its inclusive and high-quality focus. They cater to diverse palates and dietary needs, notably offering a strong selection of vegan-friendly baked goods. As one local customer noted, finding an organic, plant-based bakery option in the Bronx is a rare and welcome discovery, and this bakery delivers on that promise. From the rich intensity of a slice of Ultimate Carrot Cake to the creamy bliss of their Cake Parfaits and Dominican-Style Ices, every item is prepared with artistry, quality ingredients, and a dedication to superior flavor and texture. For those in New York seeking a dependable, friendly, and inventive local baker, this Bronx spot is an essential choice.

The atmosphere of the bakery is designed for both a quick, satisfying visit and more personalized consultations for custom orders. The reputation for friendly service and accommodating bakers further enhances the overall experience, making every interaction as pleasant as the treats themselves. Whether you are grabbing a quick coffee and a cookie to start your day or arranging an elaborate gift box, There Should Always Be Cake offers a premium, community-focused service that New Yorkers appreciate.

Location and Accessibility

There Should Always Be Cake is conveniently located at 2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461, USA. This address places it in a busy, accessible part of the Bronx, making it a reliable destination for residents across the borough and even those commuting from other parts of New York City.

Accessibility is a key factor for any successful local business in New York. The East Tremont Avenue location is well-known and generally reachable via local bus routes, providing easy public transit options. For those driving, the location benefits from being situated in a neighborhood with more manageable street parking than the dense Manhattan or inner-borough areas, although as with any NYC location, it's advisable to factor in travel time and potential search for parking. The bakery welcomes quick visits and is set up for efficiency, allowing New Yorkers to easily pop in for a quick takeout order or in-store pickup, a necessary feature for the city's fast-paced lifestyle. The availability of delivery options further enhances accessibility, bringing the freshest baked goods directly to your door, a service truly valued in the five boroughs. The bakery is also equipped to handle modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a seamless transaction process for all customers.

Services Offered

• In-store Pickup: Convenient service allowing customers to quickly collect pre-ordered or in-stock items.
• Delivery: Bringing fresh-baked goods directly to customers in the local New York area.
• Takeout: Quick and efficient service for customers buying items from the daily selection.
• Custom Cake Orders: Personalized cakes for parties, celebrations, and special events (as implied by customer reviews on accommodating service).
• Appointment Required for Planning: Dedicated consultation time for large or custom orders.
• Offering of Coffee: Serving fresh coffee to complement the sweet treats.
• Accepts Various Payments: Credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments are accepted.

Features / Highlights

• Exceptional Vegan Options: A rare and highly-praised feature in this area of the Bronx, with items like the Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie and Vegan Nutella Chocolate Chip cookie available at $4.00. The commitment to organic vegan options is a significant draw for plant-based New Yorkers.
• Artisan Cake Parfaits and Banana Pudding: Unique dessert options perfect for an individual treat, including Tres Leches Cake Parfait, Dulce De Leche Cake Parfait, and the highly popular Banana Pudding, all priced around $4.50–$6.00.
• Unique Dominican-Style Frozen Desserts: Offering cultural flair with refreshing ices like Helado De Batata Con Coco (Dominican Style Ices), Helado De Chinola (Passion Fruit Ices), and Helado De Mango (Mango Ices) all at $2.00, providing a cool, exotic treat.
• Versatile Gift Boxes: Perfect for special occasions, including Chocolate Mix Cupcakes Gift Box and the Cookie Mix Gift Box ($32.00), which can be personalized with a message card, making gifting convenient and thoughtful.
• Variety of Classic and Unique Cookies: An extensive cookie menu that balances tradition (Chocolate Chip Cookie, $3.00) with innovation (Vegan Nutella Chocolate Chip, $4.00, and White Chocolate Cranberry Cookie, $3.00).
• High-Quality Custom Work: Praised by local customers for their artistry, great texture, and accommodating service for custom cake orders, even on short notice, confirming their ability to handle specialized requests.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about custom cakes, or simply check the daily menu, New Yorkers can use the following information:

Address: 2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461, USA

Phone: (917) 722-3556

Mobile Phone: +1 917-722-3556

For custom cakes or large orders, customers are advised that an appointment is required for detailed planning, ensuring the baker can dedicate the necessary time to fulfill every specific request. For a quick visit, simply stop by during operating hours.

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in the New York metropolitan area, particularly the Bronx and surrounding neighborhoods, There Should Always Be Cake is definitively worth choosing for several compelling reasons. The primary draw is the bakery's seamless blend of high-quality, artisanal baking with modern dietary considerations. The availability of truly delicious organic vegan options—a scarcity in this part of the city—makes it an absolute must-visit for plant-based New Yorkers. As one customer raved, the vegan chocolate chip cookie is "honestly one of the best vegan cookies I’ve ever had," proving that the plant-based offerings are not an afterthought but a point of pride.

Furthermore, the bakery offers unique items that reflect the diverse flavors of New York, such as the creamy Tres Leches Cake Parfait and the culturally inspired Helado De Chinola (Passion Fruit Ices). This variety ensures that every visit can bring a new, exciting flavor experience. Whether you are planning a large party and need a highly-complimented custom cake or just need a spontaneous afternoon pick-me-up of Brownies ($3.50) or a cup of fresh coffee, this bakery is equipped to serve every need with professionalism and a friendly neighborhood touch. Its commitment to accommodating custom work, even on short notice, as attested by local feedback, demonstrates a level of customer service that builds loyal patronage. By choosing There Should Always Be Cake, New Yorkers are choosing a local business that provides world-class quality, culinary diversity, and true community convenience right in the Bronx.

There Should Always Be Cake

2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461, USA