Tommaso: The Legacy of Authentic Italian Dining Reopens on 18th Ave, Brooklyn

Tommaso Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For decades, the name

Tommaso

has been synonymous with old-school, authentic Italian dining in South Brooklyn. After closing its original, storied 86th Street location, this beloved Italian restaurant has triumphantly continued its legacy at a new address in the heart of Bensonhurst. Now situated at 6916 18th Ave,

Tommaso

is more than just a place to eat; it is a culinary institution that has carried forward the traditions, family recipes, and commitment to hospitality established by its late founder, Thomas Verdillo, who was known for making every customer feel like family.

The new location seeks to recreate the cherished atmosphere of its predecessor, providing a unique blend of being Historic yet Romantic and Upscale, while maintaining a Cozy and welcoming feel. It’s a versatile dining spot, perfectly suited for an intimate dinner, a celebratory gathering for Groups, or a relaxing Solo dining experience. The menu is a testament to genuine Italian cuisine, offering a vast selection of homemade dishes that have delighted generations of New Yorkers.

Tommaso

is celebrated for its full-service dining experience, which includes a remarkable Great wine list, Great cocktails, and often features Live music, enhancing its unique appeal as a destination. The restaurant proudly caters to both Locals who grew up on the original recipes and Tourists seeking an authentic taste of Brooklyn's rich Italian-American heritage. Whether you are craving classic pasta, such as

Spaghetti Bolognese

, or a sophisticated entrée like

Ossobuco

Double Cut American Lamb Chops

Tommaso

promises a meal that is both generous in portion and rich in flavor, securing its spot as a must-visit in the 11204 area.

Location and Accessibility

Tommaso

has established its new home at 6916 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA. This location keeps the restaurant firmly rooted in the vibrant, highly accessible commercial corridor of Bensonhurst, a neighborhood steeped in Italian-American culture and history.

Accessibility:

The restaurant demonstrates a commitment to making its classic dining experience available to all patrons. It features a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring a welcoming environment for guests with mobility needs.

Dining Options:

The restaurant is equipped for all types of gatherings and meals:

Dine-in for the full atmosphere and table service experience.
Takeout for those preferring to enjoy the quality food at home, with customer reviews noting the 'perfection to-go' of their pickup service.
Catering services are available for special events and parties, allowing customers to bring the taste of
Tommaso
to their own gatherings.

Planning Your Visit:

Given its popularity and status as a culinary destination,

Tommaso

Accepts reservations. Making a reservation is highly recommended, especially for Dinner and weekend visits, to secure seating and ensure a seamless experience. Metered parking is common in the area, and public transit is readily available along 18th Avenue.

Services Offered

Tommaso

provides a comprehensive, high-quality dining experience built around authentic Italian cooking and refined service:

Authentic Italian Menu:
Offering an extensive menu of authentic Italian cuisine for Lunch and Dinner, including a wide array of
Antipasti
, traditional
Pasta
dishes (e.g.,
Fettuccini W/ Wild Boar
and
Pappadella W/ Rabbit
), and substantial
Entree
s.
Full Bar Service:
Featuring a fully stocked Bar onsite with offerings including Alcohol, Beer, a selection of thoughtfully crafted Cocktails, and Hard liquor to complement any meal.
Premium Beverage Selection:
The menu highlights a Great wine list, which is carefully curated to pair with the classic Italian fare, alongside Great coffee and a full selection of non-alcoholic options.
Flexible Meal Accommodations:
The menu includes Vegetarian options and is also celebrated for its focus on Comfort food and Small plates, providing flexibility for all diners. Dessert options are also available, often lauded as Great dessert.
Family Amenities:
To ensure a comfortable experience for families and larger Groups, the restaurant provides High chairs for children and ample Seating with full Table service.

Features / Highlights

The appeal of

Tommaso

goes beyond its menu, providing a dynamic atmosphere and several standout features that make it a local favorite:

Live Music Experience:
The restaurant is known for providing Live music, often featuring opera or classic Italian songs, creating a unique, Romantic and nostalgic backdrop that elevates the dining experience without being intrusive, as noted by customers.
The Legacy of Tradition:
The reopening of
Tommaso
maintains a Historic link to one of Brooklyn’s most cherished Italian family restaurants. The staff carries on the original owner’s tradition of warmth, attentive service, and using cherished family recipes, providing a true taste of old-school Italian-American hospitality.
Culinary Authenticity:
The menu is filled with classic and distinctive Italian offerings, including dishes that Serve local specialty tastes, such as the
Spiedini Romana Alla Tommaso
and
Pollo Ripieno Alla Tommaso
, giving diners a truly authentic experience.
Ambiance of Distinction:
The atmosphere is intentionally curated to be both Cozy and Upscale, featuring a classic Italian decor that’s perfect for both casual neighborhood dining and significant celebrations.
Seamless Takeout Quality:
Even for customers choosing Takeout, the quality is maintained. Patrons rave about the fresh, non-greasy
Calamari
and the expertly prepared dishes like the
Grilled Chicken Parm
, ensuring that the five-star quality travels home.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers in the Brooklyn area interested in making a reservation or placing an order:

Address:

6916 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA

Phone:

(718) 484-0028

Mobile Phone:

+1 718-484-0028

What is Worth Choosing

The new

Tommaso

on 18th Avenue is worth choosing for any New Yorker seeking a genuine, high-quality, and experience-driven Italian meal that honors a beloved Brooklyn tradition.

What truly sets

Tommaso

apart is the combination of Live music and a Romantic atmosphere, creating a perfect date-night or celebration setting that transports diners away from the hustle of the city. The staff’s attentive service and ability to guide diners through the classic cuisine ensures a truly memorable experience, making you feel like a welcomed member of the family.

From a culinary perspective, the menu offers significant depth beyond standard Italian fare. Discerning diners can enjoy rich, sophisticated dishes like

Ossobuco

and

Pappadella W/ Rabbit

, alongside celebrated favorites such as the massive and juicy

Chicken Parm

. Even the spicy

Arrabbiata sauce

on the

Cheese Ravioli

is noted for its exceptional flavor and heat, proving the kitchen’s dedication to bold, authentic tastes. For those with a refined palate and an appreciation for a great glass of wine or well-made cocktail, the full bar and Great wine list are added bonuses.

In short, for an evening of Authentic Italian food, heartfelt service, and a vibrant, yet cozy ambiance—where the legacy of Brooklyn's past meets the excellence of modern dining—

Tommaso

is the premier destination in Bensonhurst. We highly recommend utilizing the Accepts reservations feature, particularly for a weekend visit, to ensure you can enjoy the full experience.

Tommaso Food & drink

Antipasti
House Cured Gravlax & Cod Salad $12.00
Baby Meat Balls In Ragu $10.00
Scungilli In Hot Sauce $13.00
Mixed Green, Bread, & Veggie Salad $10.00
Escargot $11.00
baked snails
Fegato D'anatra $16.00
fois gras
Prosciutto & Mozzarella $12.00
Baby Scallops In Shell $15.00
available oct-june
Spiedini Romana Alla Tommaso $12.00
Roast Peppers $12.00
w/ anchovies
Duck Sausage $12.00
w/ lentils
Spinach $9.00
w/ olive oil & garlic
Asparagi Con Parmigiano Reggiano $9.00
Broccoli Rape $9.00
Escarole Saute $9.00
Hot Pepper Lovers Only $6.00

Pasta
Pasta Dish, Entree Size
Spaghetti Bolognese $17.00
Gnocchi Four Cheese / Sorrentina $17.00
Spaghetti $17.00
w/ pistachio sauce
Orecchiette Con Broccoli&sausage $17.00
Fettuccini W/ Wild Boar $17.00
Tagliatelle Genovese $17.00
Pasta Alla Carbonara $19.00
Pappadella W/ Rabbit $19.00
Linguine $17.00
w/ white or red clam sauce
Paccheri $19.00
w/ prosciutto, onion, &tomato
Fusilli In Eggplant, Olive&basil $17.00
Summertime Pasta $19.00

Entree
Baked Salmon $26.00
Roasted Monkfish $28.00
Whole Maine Lobster $26.00
by size, any style
Linguine $26.00
w/ shrimp fra diavolo
Dentice Veglia Di Natale $26.00
Gamberoni Agrodolce $28.00
Baccala Della Nonna $24.00
Ossobuco $30.00
Spiedini All Siciliana $28.00
Costoletta Di Vitello Valdostana $30.00
Costoletta Di Vitello Ferri $30.00
Braised Short Rib $26.00
Grilled Rib Eye Steak $30.00
brooklyn style
Double Cut American Lamb Chops $32.00
Pollo Ripieno Alla Tommaso $24.00
Duck Toscana $28.00
Fegato Alla Padovana $26.00
Duck Confit $30.00

Tommaso Details

Service options
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Live music
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Historic
Romantic
Upscale

Crowd
Groups
Locals
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs

Tommaso Photos

Tommaso Location

Tommaso

New York Kings County Bensonhurst 18th Avenue

6916 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA

Tommaso Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 363 user reviews.

schoolmusicfood and servicepianochicken parmpotatoeswine listvealclamappetizer

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Absolutely incredible dining experience. This gem is apparently a transplant of a prior location, but carries with it a series of traditions and recipes that delighted the taste buds of our group of 10.The service was attentive and answered questions about the cuisine, guiding us across a series of Italian classics and family-owned recipes.The food was amazing. Our table had a splash of assorted classics, from a massive, juicy Chicken Parm to flavorful Salmon to succulent pork chops with spicy peppers in brown sauce (pictured). Our entire party loved our meal and the entire experience was hugely positive.On Saturday night there was also live music, which set a fantastic backdrop for our dining experience (without being too loud - just right).We are already talking about our next meet up for another night of outstanding Italian food.
September 13 · Michael Cronin
We haven’t had a sit-down at Tommaso on 18th Ave just yet, but their pickup game is top-tier — this was our second time grabbing food, and once again, they delivered perfection to-go!Cheese Ravioli — I had it swimming in their Arrabbiata sauce — and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. Arrabbiata means “angry,” but this sauce was the good kind of angry — spicy, hot, and full of flavor. Basically, my tastebuds got yelled at… in the best possible way. 10/10!Calamari — Crispy, fresh, golden perfection. Not greasy, just pure seafood happiness with a squeeze of lemon and dipped in their red sauce.Grilled Chicken Parm — Juicy, cheesy, saucy — they nailed it again. Accompanied with vegetables and potatoesLooking forward to finally sitting down for a meal, but for now, Tommaso’s takeout is making dinner at home feel like a five-star experience.
June 28 · Fatma Bazahy
Meal started with delicious cheesy rice balls. Meatballs were soooo tender. Chicken parmigian and carbonara entree were delicious. This will be my new go to - can’t wait to return. Saturday had live music!
September 13 · Crystal Laurence
I came from the 86th street location, I was so happy they made a new restaurant at 18 Ave. I love eating the shrimp pasta with crab sauce. Very delicious. I brought my kids to eat here. And there was many options for them. The dessert is very tasty, my kids loved it.
July 13 · Rufina García
Delicious food, great service, and a warm atmosphere! The chicken parmesan was full of flavor, and the rice balls were crispy outside, creamy inside. The staff was friendly and attentive, and the cozy vibe made for a great dining experience. Highly recommend!
July 11 · Nicole Ricca