West New York Pizza

- 5404 Park Ave, West New York, NJ 07093

Introduction / Overview

For residents of North Jersey searching for that quintessential New York-style slice without crossing the Hudson, look no further than West New York Pizza. Located right on Park Avenue in West New York, NJ, this local favorite has established itself as a go-to destination for authentic, high-quality pizza and a comprehensive menu of classic Italian-American comfort food. It’s a proudly Latino-owned establishment that serves up a casual and welcoming atmosphere, making it a true neighborhood staple for lunch, dinner, or a quick bite.

West New York Pizza is renowned for its commitment to the authentic New York pizza experience. This means you can expect a perfectly thin, crispy crust that’s foldable—a hallmark of the style—paired with tangy, fresh sauce and quality mozzarella. Customers frequently rave about the classic slices, highlighting the 'crispy and no flop' quality, which is the ultimate seal of approval for New York-style aficionados. However, the menu extends far beyond the traditional cheese pie, offering a wide array of specialty pizzas, hot heroes, freshly made pasta, and family-sized catering options, ensuring there’s something delicious for everyone in the community.

The restaurant is a popular spot with the local crowd and is designed to be a great choice for all demographics, including families. Reviewers often mention the pleasant and attentive staff, which contributes to a very positive and friendly dining experience. Whether you’re stopping by after a local sports practice at Coviello Field, as one customer mentioned, or hosting a large gathering at home, West New York Pizza is poised to satisfy your craving for delicious Italian comfort food right here in New Jersey.

Location and Accessibility

West New York Pizza is conveniently situated at 5404 Park Ave, West New York, NJ 07093, USA. This prime location on a major thoroughfare makes it easily accessible for local residents and those traveling from surrounding North Jersey towns. The accessibility is further enhanced by the provision of free street parking, a highly valued amenity in a bustling urban area like West New York, which allows customers to comfortably visit for dine-in, takeout, or curbside pickup.

As a true neighborhood spot, it caters to the everyday needs of the community. For those who prefer to relax at home, the establishment offers robust delivery and no-contact delivery options, ensuring their hot, fresh pizza and entrees can be enjoyed virtually anywhere in the area. The restaurant’s atmosphere is consistently described as casual, making it an ideal place for a relaxed meal. With seating available, including a pleasant outdoor seating area, customers have a choice of enjoying their meal on-site or taking it to go. Its position in the heart of West New York means it is easily integrated into a day of local shopping or activities.

Services Offered

• Dine-in Service: Casual indoor seating for lunch and dinner.
• Outdoor Seating: A pleasant option for enjoying a meal outside.
• Delivery: Fast and convenient delivery service for the local area.
• No-Contact Delivery: An option for contactless meal drop-off.
• Takeout: Quick and easy order pickup service.
• Curbside Pickup: Customers can pick up their orders without leaving their vehicle.
• Catering: Extensive catering menu available for large groups, parties, and events, including full trays of pasta, entrees, and appetizers.
• Online Ordering: Simple and efficient process for placing orders remotely.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: High chairs are available, and the menu is good for kids.
• Payment Options: Accepts major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

• Authentic New York-Style Thin Crust Pizza: Known for its crispy, foldable crust, a favorite feature mentioned by many customers.
• Extensive Pizza Menu: Offers a variety of specialty pies like the fan-favorite CBR - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie ($22.95), Buffalo Chicken Pie ($20.95), Penne Alla Vodka Pie ($24.95), and unique options such as Pizza Cubana ($23.95) and the Drunken Grandma ($33.95) square pie.
• Hearty Italian Entrees and Comfort Food: Beyond pizza, the menu features classic entrees like Chicken Parmesan Entree ($21.95), Chicken Marsala ($22.95), and Shrimp Scampi ($22.95).
• Appetizers and Sides: Delicious starters like Garlic Knots ($6.45), fresh CHICKEN WINGS ($15.95), MOZZARELLA STICKS ($12.95), and homemade Eggplant Rollatini ($15.95).
• Full Pasta Selection: Includes all the favorites such as Baked Ziti ($18.95), Meat Lasagna ($19.95), Pasta Alfredo ($17.95), and Penne Alla Vodka ($17.95).
• Game Day Specials: Offers themed deals and specials perfect for watching sports, such as the TOUCHDOWN DEAL ($47.95) and the SUPERBOWL MANIA ($84.95).
• Vegetarian Options: The menu clearly features numerous vegetarian-friendly dishes, including the Vegetable Pie ($21.95), Caprese Salad ($15.95), Pasta Marinara ($16.95), and Eggplant Parmesan Dinner ($21.95).
• Latino-Owned Business: The restaurant proudly identifies as a Latino-owned establishment, contributing to the rich local community.
• Welcoming Atmosphere: A casual environment popular with locals, known for its friendly, attentive service.

Contact Information

The dedicated team at West New York Pizza is ready to take your order or answer any questions you may have. The following contact information is provided for your convenience:

Address: 5404 Park Ave, West New York, NJ 07093, USA

Phone: (201) 305-5299

What is Worth Choosing

For residents in the New Jersey area, West New York Pizza offers a compelling combination of authenticity, variety, and convenience that makes it a highly worthwhile choice. The cornerstone of the restaurant’s appeal is, of course, the pizza. Patrons specifically seek out the classic New York-style slices for the thin, crispy crust and quality toppings. The Margherita Pie ($20.95), praised for its fresh mozzarella and crushed tomatoes, and the popular Buffalo Chicken Pie ($20.95) are excellent entry points to experience their quality.

Beyond the main course, the menu is a haven of classic comfort food, making it an ideal dinner solution for individuals, couples, or large families. The extensive pasta menu, from Spaghetti W/ Meatballs ($19.95) to the rich Meat Lasagna ($19.95), ensures a satisfying meal. Furthermore, the selection of Hot Heroes, such as the generously-sauced Chicken Parmesan Hero ($15.95) and the classic Philly Cheesesteak Hero ($15.95), are perfect for a hearty lunch or quick dinner. For those planning a gathering, the specialized catering menu, which includes options like PENNE ALLA VODKA (Catering - $56.00) and Trays of Chicken Francese (Catering - $61.00), provides an effortless way to feed a crowd with high-quality Italian food.

The customer-centric service, which includes diverse options from dine-in seating and fast delivery to catering and a great selection of Game Day Specials, positions West New York Pizza as more than just a pizzeria—it’s a reliable local eatery. The emphasis on high-quality ingredients, from fresh mozzarella on the Caprese Salad ($15.95) to the robust flavor in their Chicken Marsala ($22.95), guarantees a delicious meal every time. By supporting this local, Latino-owned business, customers are not only getting a fantastic meal but also contributing to the vibrant community spirit of West New York, NJ.

West New York Pizza

5404 Park Ave, West New York, NJ 07093, USA