Anthony's Paninoteca

- 3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308

**Anthony's Paninoteca**, a true culinary gem nestled in Staten Island, has quickly become a must-visit destination for New Yorkers seeking an elevated, authentic Italian sandwich experience. This is not your average deli; patrons consistently describe the offerings not just as sandwiches, but as **gourmet meals**. The shop prides itself on using only the **finest ingredients**, with everything made fresh daily, reflecting a deep commitment to quality that resonates with the demanding palate of NYC residents.

The shop’s reputation is built on its mastery of Italian flavors and techniques, particularly the use of **schiacciata bread**. This traditional Tuscan flatbread, similar to focaccia but often crispier and denser, provides the perfect, authentic base for their creations. Customers who have tried schiacciate in Florence, Italy, rave that Anthony’s versions "go toe to toe, if not better than the 'famous panini' shops in Firenze," declaring them to be among the **best sandwiches on the East Coast of the U.S.**

The menu is an impressive lineup of both hot and cold heroes, paninis, and schiacciate, often featuring witty, local-inspired names. Highlights include the acclaimed **PANINO MORTADELLA ($24.00)** with burrata and pistachio pesto, and the hot specialty **#25 DO IT FOR JOHNNY ($21.50)**, loaded with roast beef, fresh mozzarella, and a rich gravy. This commitment to quality and distinct, flavorful combinations ensures that the higher price point is always justified, offering exceptional value for a truly gourmet product. As one patron stated, "You 1000% get what you pay for."

Beyond the extensive menu, Anthony's Paninoteca offers compelling **daily specials** that draw a consistent local crowd. These rotate offerings, such as **Pork Cutlet Milanese Hero** on Mondays, **Pastrami on Rye** on Deli Day, and the highly anticipated **Crispy Porchetta** on Thursdays, showcase the depth of their culinary skill, which includes curing and smoking meats in-house. The establishment also caters to different dietary preferences, offering options like the **PANINO CAPRESE ($19.00)** for a vegetarian choice, and various salads and smaller plates.

The atmosphere inside the shop is described as **casual and cozy**, providing a welcoming environment to enjoy a quick bite or a satisfying meal. The service model focuses on **counter service** and **fast service**, acknowledging the New York need for efficiency. This dedication to excellence in both product and service is why many locals consider Anthony’s Paninoteca an instant classic.

Anthony's Paninoteca is conveniently located in a prime area of Staten Island, making it an easy-to-find spot for the community. The shop is situated in the Great Kills neighborhood, a location known for its local businesses and residential accessibility.

3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308

The location on Amboy Road is a major thoroughfare, enhancing its accessibility for drivers. The shop understands the practical needs of New York patrons and offers excellent parking solutions:

• Free parking lot: Provides easy, off-street parking, a major convenience in NYC.
• Free street parking: Additional options are available nearby.
• Paid street parking: Further options ensure that finding a spot is rarely an issue.

While the restaurant’s physical location is a bit of a trek for those in the North Shore or other boroughs, its exceptional reputation means that many New Yorkers are willing to make the journey, or simply opt for the convenient delivery service.

To best serve its busy New York customer base, Anthony's Paninoteca provides a variety of service options:

• Takeout: Orders can be picked up quickly via the efficient counter service model.
• Delivery: Standard delivery is available, ensuring the gourmet sandwiches can reach customers even in the North Shore.
• No-contact delivery: A safe, modern option for customers who prefer minimized interaction.
• Dining Options: Serves both **Lunch** and **Dinner**, fitting into the daily schedule of busy New Yorkers.
• Counter Service: The primary method for ordering and pickup, contributing to the **fast service** highlight.
• Catering: Offers catering services, perfect for local business lunches, parties, or large family gatherings, with a variety of deep trays and specialty sandwich platters.
• Dessert: Features housemade sweets like the **EEEEETSCON SICILIAN CANNOLI ($5.50)** to round out the Italian meal.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods, including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.

Anthony's Paninoteca stands out from the competition through its focus on authenticity and signature items:

• **Authentic Schiacciata Bread:** The signature, Tuscan-style flatbread that provides the foundation for the Panino sandwiches, elevating them to a true **local specialty** and a highlight often compared favorably to famous Italian shops.
• **Housemade and Cured Meats:** Dedication to quality is evident as the shop cures and smokes meats in-house for specials like Pastrami and Porchetta, ensuring unmatched freshness and flavor.
• **Signature Hot Sandwiches:** Features massive, complex creations with names like **#28 PHIL LEOTARDO ($25.00)** and **#31 STATEN ITALY A LA VODKA ($21.00)**, showcasing creative Italian-American flair.
• **Gourmet Cold Heroes:** The menu boasts an extensive list of cold heroes and paninis, including the acclaimed **#20 THE GODFATHER ($25.00)** and the **#5 MUFFULETTA ($21.00)**, which has been praised for rivaling the New Orleans original.
• **Popular Daily Specials:** A rotating schedule of must-try items, such as the **Crispy Porchetta** on Thursdays and **Pastrami on Rye** on Deli Day, keeps the menu exciting and encourages regular visits.
• **Diverse Sides and Small Plates:** Offers a wide selection of fried Italian specialties, including various types of **Riceballs** and **Sicilian Croquettes**, perfect for a **quick bite** or enjoying **small plates**.
• **Cozy and Casual Atmosphere:** Maintains an inviting, unpretentious environment that feels community-oriented and welcoming to everyone, including those considered **good for kids**.

For Staten Island users and those in the New York region looking to contact the shop, here is the necessary information:

Address: 3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308

Phone: (914) 458-5645

Mobile Phone: +1 914-458-5645

New York patrons are encouraged to call ahead for large orders, especially for **catering** or during peak **lunch** times, although online ordering and delivery are also highly efficient and widely used.

What makes Anthony's Paninoteca the definitive choice for a **sandwich shop** in New York is the marriage of **authentic Italian tradition** with a commitment to local, gourmet quality. The heart of the menu—the **schiacciata**—offers a truly distinctive experience that sets it apart from all competitors, delivering a taste of Florence right to Staten Island. Customers consistently affirm that the high-quality, generously stuffed sandwiches are **worth every penny**, providing an unparalleled depth of flavor and satisfaction.

New Yorkers should choose Anthony's Paninoteca for the chance to try a sandwich that has been hailed as one of the best on the entire East Coast. Whether you opt for a hot hero like the **#21 ANTHONY'S** with homemade roast pork, or a cold masterpiece like the **PANINO MORTADELLA** on that famous schiacciata bread, you are choosing an elevated **comfort food** experience crafted with passion and expertise. It is the place to go when you desire a filling, high-quality meal that is far superior to a generic deli sandwich, and it fully delivers on its promise of being a gourmet destination.

Anthony's Paninoteca

3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308, USA