Bayville Deli

- 261 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709

For Long Island residents, especially those on the North Shore, the local deli is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it is a community hub, a morning ritual, and the reliable source for the quintessential New York hero or a perfect slice of pizza. Bayville Deli, located in the scenic village of Bayville, NY, encapsulates this essential New York experience by expertly combining the best of a traditional Long Island deli counter with the convenience and quality of a neighborhood pizzeria takeout spot. This dual identity makes it an indispensable fixture for locals and a highly recommended stop for anyone visiting the beautiful Long Island Sound area.

Known locally as Bayville Deli & Pizzeria, this establishment has positioned itself as a comprehensive food destination. It’s an Asian-owned, small business dedicated to providing diverse, hearty fare, from robust breakfast options served all day to an extensive selection of specialty heroes and a full menu of pizza slices and pies. Its commitment to serving the community is evident in its wide-ranging offerings, catering to every meal requirement, whether you need a quick coffee and egg sandwich before work or a full pie for a family dinner.

The atmosphere of a Long Island deli is built on familiarity and efficiency, and Bayville Deli is no exception. It is designed for a quick visit, prioritizing speedy service, which is a necessity for the fast-paced lives of New York commuters and local workers. However, speed does not come at the expense of variety or flavor, as the extensive menu demonstrates an understanding of the region's diverse culinary preferences, blending classic Italian-American deli favorites with quality pizza options.

Accessibility is a key feature of this location, which is a significant benefit for all customers. The business provides practical accommodations and ease of access essential for a public-facing New York establishment. Specific accessibility features include a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot. Furthermore, parking is never a concern, as customers benefit from both a free parking lot and free street parking options, providing a hassle-free experience often hard to find in denser parts of Nassau County. This focus on accessibility and convenience underscores Bayville Deli's role as a true community resource.

• Full Breakfast Menu Served All Day: Offering everything from simple Egg & Cheese On A Roll and Egg Wrappers to the substantial Hungryman Breakfast Hero, ensuring a hearty start to any day, regardless of the time.
• Hot and Cold Specialty Heroes & Sandwiches: An extensive menu featuring classic NY combos and unique signature creations like 'The Don' (Chicken Cutlet with Red Sauce and Melted Mozzarella), 'Off The Boat' (Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Sundried Tomato), and the 'REUBEN'.
• Pizza Pies & Slices: Serving fresh pizza for takeout, including popular varieties like Regular Pizza (18"), Sicilian, Margherita, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, available as both full pies and individual slices.
• Pizza Rolls and Knots: Specialty items like the Chicken Roll and Garlic Knots are available for a perfect portable lunch or snack.
• Beverages: A selection of bottled beverages, including various Pure Leaf Teas, Hals Seltzer, Yoohoo, and Red Bull.
• Takeout and Delivery Service: Catering to the busy New York lifestyle, the deli offers both in-person takeout and reliable delivery services.
• Payment Convenience: Accepting various payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments, for quick and easy transactions.
• On-site Amenities: Providing essential amenities such as a Restroom (including a gender-neutral restroom) and Wi-Fi access for customers.

• Signature Hero Collection: The menu boasts a series of playfully named, hearty heroes, such as 'The GodSon', 'The Capo', 'The Underboss', and 'The Lumberjack Hero' (Pepper Turkey, Melted Swiss Cheese, Bacon & Russian Dressing), which are deeply rooted in regional deli culture and represent substantial meal options.
• Diverse Pizza Offerings: The pizza selection is exceptional for a deli, including classic New York and Sicilian styles, along with specialty slices like Grandma Slice, Margherita Slice, and Chicken Bacon Ranch. The commitment to fresh, quality toppings is highlighted in the customer mention of a slice with "Spinach, fried chicken, and fresh chunks of tomato."
• Asian-Owned Small Business Identity: Identifying as an Asian-owned, small business provides a unique cultural dimension to the local food landscape, contributing to the diversity of entrepreneurship in the Bayville community.
• Focus on Accessibility: Beyond just parking, the provision of a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, along with a gender-neutral restroom, demonstrates a commitment to being an inclusive, modern community resource.
• All-Day Breakfast Availability: The convenience of ordering breakfast items like the Egg Platter, French Toast, or the Bacon Egg & Cheese at any time of day is a significant benefit for individuals with non-traditional schedules.
• Ideal for a Quick Visit: The operation is geared toward efficiency and quick service, making it an excellent stop for busy locals needing lunch on the go or a grab-and-go dinner solution.

Address: 261 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
Phone: (516) 628-2063
Mobile Phone: +1 516-628-2063

While one customer noted the pricing as "insane" for a high-end item like the chicken cutlet on a roll—a sentiment common in high-cost Long Island—it’s important to view this in the context of the quality, preparation, and portion size typical of a New York specialty sandwich, such as the loaded American Combo Hero or the massive Hungryman Breakfast Hero. The value is found in the substantial, satisfying, and authentically prepared meal.

The seamless execution of both the deli counter and the pizzeria makes it a winning choice. Where else can you grab a well-constructed, overstuffed hero like the Long Island Lightening alongside a fresh, innovative pizza slice like the Spinach, Chicken, and Tomato creation lauded by another customer? This dual expertise eliminates the need to choose between your deli craving and your pizza desire.

Moreover, Bayville Deli’s dedication to logistical ease, from abundant free parking to multiple payment methods and robust delivery/takeout options, demonstrates an understanding of modern consumer needs. Whether you are a Bayville "lifer" in search of your routine Bacon Egg & Cheese, a visitor craving a New York slice before heading to the beach, or simply in need of a substantial, expertly crafted sandwich like 'The GodFather' (Roast beef & Melted Mozzarella on a Toasted hero), Bayville Deli offers a reliable, accessible, and delicious solution right in the heart of the village. It is a vital piece of the local landscape, providing the kind of classic, hearty, and efficient service that defines the essential Long Island food experience.

Bayville Deli

261 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, USA