Benvenuto's

- 35 Secor Rd, Mahopac, NY 10541

Introduction / Overview

Benvenuto's in Mahopac, NY, stands as a versatile and authentic fixture for Italian cuisine in the New York region, expertly catering to local diners as a full-fledged Italian restaurant, a dedicated Pizza restaurant, and a highly efficient Delivery Restaurant. This establishment defies simple classification, offering customers the duality of a casual spot to grab a slice or a convenient takeout order, complemented by the surprise of a separate, "very nice dining room" in the back, perfect for a relaxed and traditional sit-down meal. It has earned its reputation as an "Excellent local Italian" spot, easily accessible for those in the Hudson Valley area.

The menu at Benvenuto's is expansive, designed to satisfy any craving for classic Italian Comfort food. Begin your meal with a selection from the Appetizers, which includes crowd-pleasers like Fried Calamari ($16.95), Shrimp Cocktail ($15.95), and Eggplant Rollatini ($13.95). Their soup selection is comforting, notably featuring the highly praised Pasta Fagioli Soup ($7.95), known for its rich flavor and "generous amounts of garlic," alongside Stracciatella Soup and Lentil Soup. For lighter fare, the Salads menu offers options such as the Antipasto Salad ($13.95) and the Tricolore Salad ($13.95).

Central to the Benvenuto's experience are the classic entrées. The Pasta offerings are extensive, featuring favorites that New Yorkers seek out, including Penne A La Vodka ($19.95), Lasagna Bolognese ($20.95), and specialty seafood pastas like Linguine White Clam Sauce ($23.95) and Lobster Ravioli ($23.95). The kitchen demonstrates mastery over protein preparations with a lengthy list of Pollo (Chicken) and Veal dishes. Customers can choose from popular preparations such as Pollo Parmigiana ($20.95), Pollo Francese ($23.95), Veal Marsala ($24.95), and Veal Piccata ($24.95). The Seafood menu is equally impressive, culminating in the rich Zuppa Di Pesce ($30.95), a delightful combination of shrimp, calamari, mussels, and clams.

The Brick Oven Pizza program is a major draw, extending far beyond the standard Cheese and Margherita. Specialty pies include the savory Chicken Marsala Pizza, the robust Meat Lovers Pizza, and the unique Penne A La Vodka Pizza. The Square Thin Crust Pizza section features the must-try Grandma Pie ($24.95). Catering to all dietary needs, Benvenuto's proudly offers both Gluten Free Cheese Pizza ($16.45) and Cauliflower Crust Cheese Pizza ($15.45). The atmosphere is consistently described as Casual and Cozy, making it a favorite among Families, Groups, Locals, and Tourists.

Location and Accessibility

Benvenuto's is strategically situated for easy access by residents and travelers throughout the New York region, particularly those utilizing the Taconic State Parkway.

The specific address is: 35 Secor Rd, Mahopac, NY 10541, USA.

The restaurant has prioritized accessibility to ensure a comfortable visit for all guests, offering numerous accessibility features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance, providing a smooth path into the restaurant.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot, with dedicated spaces conveniently located for ease of access.
• Wheelchair accessible restroom facilities, maintained for comfort and compliance.
• Wheelchair accessible seating options available in the dining areas.

Services Offered

Benvenuto's offers comprehensive service options to cater to a diverse clientele and their varying preferences:

• Dine-in service with comfortable Seating and professional Table service in the dedicated dining room, popular for Lunch and Dinner.
• Reliable Delivery service, bringing the full menu—from pasta to pizza—right to your door.
• Quick and efficient Takeout service for customers picking up their orders.
• Extensive Catering options for both Appetizers Catering and full meal service (Pasta Catering, Pollo Catering), suitable for any large event or gathering.
• Full Bar onsite, offering a selection of Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine, with a Great beer selection and Great wine list highlighted.
• Planning assistance through the acceptance of reservations, ensuring tables for Groups and families.
• Late-night food availability for those looking for a later dining option.

Features / Highlights

The key features that distinguish Benvenuto's in the competitive New York dining landscape include its commitment to quality, speed, and menu depth:

• Dual-concept dining: seamlessly combines a casual Pizza restaurant environment with a refined, full-service Italian restaurant dining room.
• Authentic and diverse menu with numerous Veal, Pollo, and Seafood preparations in traditional Italian styles (Francese, Marsala, Piccata).
• Emphasis on quality pizza with a Brick Oven Pizza section, featuring unique creations and specialty Square Thin Crust options.
• Noted for Fast service, making it an excellent choice for a Quick bite or a business lunch.
• Accommodations for dietary needs, including Small plates, Vegetarian options, and specialty pizza crusts (Gluten Free, Cauliflower Crust).
• Excellent beverage program with a great selection of Beer and Wine, and full bar capabilities for Cocktails and Hard liquor.
• Family-friendly amenities, including a dedicated Kids' menu (e.g., Spaghetti With Meatballs) and High chairs.
• Convenient and modern Payment acceptance, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Contact Information

For all inquiries, including placing a delivery order, making a reservation for the dining room, or discussing catering needs, please utilize the following details:

Address: 35 Secor Rd, Mahopac, NY 10541, USA

Phone: (845) 628-0773

Mobile Phone: +1 845-628-0773

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Benvenuto's is a decision rooted in value, authenticity, and convenience, all crucial factors for New York-area diners. It’s "Reasonably priced" while maintaining a high quality of cuisine, a rare and appreciated balance. The establishment's versatility is a major draw: you can satisfy a simple pizza craving or indulge in a full Italian feast without changing locations. Customer reviews consistently reinforce the quality, praising the "very nice flavors" of the pizza and the exemplary preparation of side dishes like the "cooked to perfection" broccoli rabe.

For local patrons, the location "just off the Taconic Pkwy" is a logistical benefit, complemented by the ease of Free parking. The comprehensive service options—Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery—ensure that Benvenuto's fits seamlessly into any lifestyle or schedule. Furthermore, the commitment to a Cozy, Family-friendly atmosphere, coupled with features like a Bar onsite and acceptance of reservations, solidifies its role as a premier local destination. From the richness of the Lasagna Bolognese to the satisfying crunch of a fresh Brick Oven Pizza, Benvenuto's truly delivers an authentic, accessible, and highly enjoyable Italian experience in the Mahopac area.

Benvenuto's

35 Secor Rd, Mahopac, NY 10541, USA