Betty Bakery

- 211 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Brooklyn, New York, Betty Bakery offers a unique and satisfying culinary experience that goes far beyond your average coffee shop. While it provides the essential morning brew, this beloved local spot truly shines as a destination for exceptional, freshly baked goods, particularly its famous Australian-style savory pies. Identifying as a Latino-owned business, Betty Bakery is a welcoming neighborhood establishment that combines a touch of retro charm with a focus on high-quality, comforting fare. Whether you are a long-time Brooklyn resident or just visiting the Prospect Park area, this bakery and pie shop promises a delicious stop for every craving, morning, noon, or night.

The bakery’s unique blend of offerings—from the flaky, rich savory pies reminiscent of traditional Australian, British, and New Zealand cuisine, to the decadent, classic American-style cakes and cupcakes—establishes it as a multifaceted gem. It’s a place where the community gathers for a quick, delicious bite or a sweet indulgence, all within a casual and cozy atmosphere. The dedication to comfort food and prepared meals makes Betty Bakery an indispensable stop for anyone looking for quality, handcrafted food in the borough.

The core of the Betty Bakery experience is its inventive and delicious menu, highlighted by a strong focus on both sweet and savory pies. Locals often seek out the Australian-style savory pies, a flavorful, hearty dish that’s hard to find executed with this level of authenticity elsewhere in New York. From the classic Beef Shepherd’s Pie, with its herbed mashed potato topping, to the rich and savory Steak & Cheese, the pies provide a perfect comfort meal. The Cumin Lamb pie and the Brazilian Chicken, described by customers as a "splash of a sunrise," showcase the bakery's commitment to diverse and robust flavor profiles.

For those with a sweet tooth, the bakery is equally renowned. Offerings like the Valrhona Chocolate cake, Red Velvet cake, and classic fruit pies such as Classic Apple and Dutch Apple are celebrated by patrons for being perfectly balanced and not overly sweet. The array of classic treats, including homemade Twinkies, Ring Dings, Rice Crispy Treats, and Lemon Coconut Bars, tap into a comforting nostalgia that is a hallmark of the "Betty" brand.

The atmosphere at Betty Bakery is intentionally casual and cozy, making it an ideal spot for solo dining, a family outing, or a casual lunch with friends. With local art adorning the walls and a community board by the door, the bakery embodies a true neighborhood feel. Customer reviews frequently praise the warm, friendly service and the overall inviting vibe, despite some noting the small seating area. It is clearly a place that is family-friendly and is a self-identified transgender safespace, showcasing its commitment to being a truly inclusive spot in the community.

The popularity of Betty Bakery for its breakfast and lunch options highlights its appeal as an all-day dining destination. The breakfast pies, such as the Moroccan Breakfast, are a unique and hearty way to start the day. The convenience of a quick bite, combined with a quality coffee selection, makes it a favorite among busy New Yorkers.

The savory pies are notably popular and can be purchased fresh or frozen to enjoy later, which many local New Yorkers appreciate for stocking their freezers with easy, quality meal options. The price point, typically around $9 to $13 for a savory pie, reflects the hand-crafted, high-quality nature of the ingredients and the Australian-style preparation, which includes a flaky, buttery crust.

The menu's international flair, with influences ranging from Brazilian to Moroccan, sets Betty Bakery apart from traditional New York bakeries. The Brazilian chicken pie, with its Cuban-inspired sofrito, is one such example of the global influences that elevate the menu. The Steak & Cheese pie, with braised short rib seasoned with rosemary and thyme, shows the care and depth of flavor in each offering.

The constant stream of positive feedback for the savory pies and select sweets, such as the carrot cake and red velvet, underscores the bakery's consistent quality. Even customers who initially came in looking for other specific items, like the "curly brunettes" cookie, left delighted with their finds. The staff is often mentioned as being great with recommendations, ensuring that every customer finds the perfect treat or meal.

Betty Bakery also takes pride in its selection of beverages, which includes great coffee and a variety of teas. While the specific lavender matcha mentioned in one review was unavailable, other options like the hibiscus tea are noted as wonderful. For those who require milk alternatives, the staff is accommodating, though customers should be aware of potential 'add-on' costs.

The atmosphere and offerings are clearly aimed at creating a memorable and delicious experience. The delightful "old timey quirky music" contributes to the charming environment, making a visit to Betty Bakery feel like a pleasant escape in the middle of Brooklyn. It’s a place that fosters community, good food, and great conversation.

For those seeking a bakery that does more than just sweets, or for anyone who appreciates a truly authentic, savory pie, Betty Bakery is a must-visit. Its commitment to quality comfort food, its inclusive atmosphere, and its unique, globally-inspired menu make it a truly special establishment in the New York food scene. It’s a place where one can satisfy a deep craving for a hearty meal or a sweet dessert with equal success.

Location and Accessibility

Betty Bakery is conveniently located in the Prospect Park West area of Brooklyn, making it a great stop for park visitors and local residents alike.

Address: 211 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

The bakery maintains a "quaint hole in the wall" aesthetic, with a few seats inside and a table for outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying a coffee and pastry on a nice day. For accessibility, the location offers a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring ease of access for all community members.

Services Offered

• No-contact delivery
• Delivery
• Takeout
• Dine-in (limited seating available)
• Outdoor seating (dogs allowed outside)
• Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert options
• Prepared foods and quick bites
• Custom cakes and specialty orders (available at their main location, as implied by customer reviews)
• In-person payment via Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments

Features / Highlights

• Australian-style Savory Pies: A signature offering, with popular varieties like Steak & Cheese, Beef Shepherd's, Brazilian Chicken, and Cumin Lamb.
• Exceptional Desserts: Known for "Great dessert" options, including the highly praised Red Velvet and Valrhona Chocolate cake, as well as nostalgic treats like Twinkies and Ring Dings.
• Great Coffee: A reliable source for a quality coffee and espresso experience.
• Inclusive Atmosphere: Identified as family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safespace, creating a welcoming environment for all.
• Diverse Cuisine: Blending Coffee shop, Bakery, Australian, British, New Zealand, and Latino-owned influences.
• Vegan and Vegetarian Options: Offers vegetarian options and comfort food to suit various diets.

Contact Information

Address: 211 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (718) 246-2402

What is Worth Choosing

Betty Bakery is worth choosing for several key reasons that set it apart in the dense New York bakery landscape. First and foremost is the unique and authentic savory pie selection. For those in New York who crave the hearty, flaky, and richly-filled Australian-style savory pies—a rarity in the area—Betty Bakery is the definitive choice. The Steak & Cheese and Brazilian Chicken pies, with their tender, seasoned fillings and buttery crusts, are often cited as must-try items. The availability of condiments like Cholula hot sauce and HB sauce further enhances the experience, appealing to those who appreciate authentic pie shop flair.

Beyond the savory offerings, the dessert quality is consistently rated as excellent. New Yorkers searching for classic, moist, and not-too-sweet cakes should head to Betty Bakery for the Red Velvet and Valrhona Chocolate options. The balance of flavors in their sweet pies and cakes receives frequent high praise. The bakery provides the perfect blend of sweet indulgence and savory satisfaction, catering to a wider range of tastes than most specialty shops.

Finally, choosing Betty Bakery supports a Latino-owned, community-focused business with a demonstrably inclusive and friendly atmosphere. The casual, cozy setting, complemented by thoughtful service and great recommendations from staff members like Noah, makes every visit a pleasant, personal experience. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick breakfast, picking up a frozen dinner pie, or treating yourself to a nostalgic Ring Ding, Betty Bakery delivers quality, comfort, and character right in the heart of Brooklyn.

Betty Bakery

211 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA