Cake and Cone

- 306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073

Introduction / Overview

For over six decades, Cake and Cone has stood as an iconic destination for dessert lovers in East Rutherford, New Jersey. Established in 1954, this beloved local institution has built a reputation on serving up high-quality, homemade frozen treats, embodying the classic charm of a traditional ice cream parlor. It's more than just a place to grab a cone; it's a nostalgic experience that has created sweet memories for generations of Bergen County residents. Known for its commitment to fresh, premium ingredients and churning ice cream in small batches daily, Cake and Cone offers a delightful escape into the world of rich, creamy indulgence. Whether you’re looking for a simple scoop, a spectacular sundae, or a custom celebratory cake, this local favorite promises a scoop of happiness for everyone.

Cake and Cone prides itself on an extensive menu that caters to every craving. From classic vanilla and chocolate hard ice cream, celebrated for its velvety texture and deep flavor, to an array of innovative and customer-favorite specialty flavors, the selection is vast and tempting. Beyond traditional cones and cups, the menu shines with its decadent sundaes, hand-packed pints and quarts perfect for home enjoyment, and specialty fried treats that have become signature items. The shop captures an authentic, friendly vibe, often described by patrons as a great "mom and pop" spot, perfect for a quick visit or for families and groups gathering for a sweet treat. While the operational style evokes old-school charm, the service is known for being quick and efficient.

The true cornerstone of the Cake and Cone experience, however, lies in its dual dedication to both classic and unique offerings. They serve creamy soft serve alongside their famous homemade hard ice cream, ensuring there is a style for every preference. Their homemade ice cream flavors include rich selections such as Nutella Ice Cream, Pistachio, and the widely acclaimed Salted Monster (a mix of salted caramel and cookies). This dedication to variety, quality, and community spirit is why Cake and Cone remains a treasured gem in the New Jersey dessert landscape.

Location and Accessibility

Cake and Cone is conveniently situated at 306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA. This prime location in Bergen County makes it easily accessible for local patrons and those traveling from surrounding towns. For drivers, the venue offers ample parking, specifically including a wheelchair accessible parking lot, which contributes to a seamless and stress-free visit.

The atmosphere of the shop itself is a key part of its appeal. It’s noted for its casual and trending environment, often featuring an old-school pickup window that adds to its nostalgic charm. While the service options include efficient Takeaway, the shop also provides a comfortable and inviting place to stay. Patrons can enjoy their treats at the old school ice cream parlor seating with tables conveniently located outside, perfect for enjoying a warm New Jersey evening with friends, family, or even for a moment of quiet, solo dining.

Accessibility is a priority for Cake and Cone, as demonstrated by the provision of a wheelchair accessible entrance. The shop is great for groups and is particularly good for kids, making it a fantastic destination for community outings and family treats. The combination of easy access, dedicated parking, and a welcoming, classic ambiance ensures that Cake and Cone is a reliable and enjoyable stop for all dessert lovers in the North Jersey area.

Services Offered

Cake and Cone offers a comprehensive range of delicious frozen treats and dessert-related services. Below is a detailed list of their extensive menu and general services:

• Ice Cream and Cones/Cups: Featuring both homemade hard ice cream (made in-house in small batches) and soft serve. Sizes include Kiddie, Regular, and Large options available in cups and cones, as well as Regular and Large Waffle Cones. Hard ice cream comes in a wide variety of flavors including Salted Monster, Nutella Ice Cream, Pistachio, Moose Tracks, and classics like Very Vanilla and Chocolaty Chocolate.
• Signature Sundaes: A diverse menu of sundaes including Medium and Large sizes for both soft serve and hard ice cream. Options include the classic Banana Split and highly-praised decadent creations like the Fried Oreo Sundae and Funnel Cake Sundae. Customers can customize their sundaes with over 20 different toppings, including Hot Chocolate Fudge, Hot Caramel, and various candies and nuts.
• Specialty Treats (The Munchies): Unique fried desserts that set them apart, such as Fried Oreos, Fried Nutter Butters, and a standalone Funnel Cake.
• Ice Cream Cakes: Custom-made ice cream cakes are available for all occasions (birthdays, graduations, holidays), with cake bases consisting of chocolate and vanilla ice cream with fudge and crunchies. Sizes include 6-inch (serves 4-6), 8-inch (serves 10-12), and Small Sheet Cakes (serves 20-24). Cakes can be personalized with messages and border colors.
• Shakes, Floats, and Other Drinks: Includes Large and Small Milkshakes, Large Malt Shakes, and Large Soda Floats. They also offer a variety of bottled beverages like Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Gatorade, Snapple, and an old-fashioned Egg Cream (no ice cream).
• Hand Packed Items: Convenience options for at-home enjoyment, including Pints and Quarts of both hard and soft serve ice cream, 6 Pack Ice Cream Sandwiches, Chocolate Chip Sandwiches, and Dipped Bananas.
• Other Frozen Offerings: The menu also boasts Italian Ices (available in Small, Medium, Large, and Extra Large sizes), Slushies (in flavors like Blue Raspberry and Cherry), and Frozen Yogurt & No Sugar Added Flavors.
• Payment Options: Customers can pay using Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for a fast and modern checkout process.

Features / Highlights

Cake and Cone stands out in the crowded New Jersey dessert scene thanks to several distinguishing features and customer favorites. These highlights underscore why this establishment has remained a staple since 1954:

• Decades of Homemade Quality: Operating since 1954, Cake and Cone has over 60 years of experience serving the Bergen County community, solidifying its status as an authentic, long-standing local favorite. They prioritize homemade hard ice cream, churning in small batches daily to ensure peak flavor and creamy texture.
• The Signature Salted Monster Flavor: This unique flavor has garnered significant praise from customers, described as a MUST try. It features a delicious blend of salted caramel and cookies, consistently rated as some of the best ice cream in the area.
• Innovative and Decadent Fried Treats: Going beyond the traditional parlor fare, the shop offers specialty 'Munchies' like Fried Oreos and Fried Nutter Butters, which can be enjoyed on their own or as part of a lavish sundae, such as the Fried Nutter Butter Sundae.
• Full Ice Cream Cake Service: Offering custom ice cream cakes in various sizes (6-inch, 8-inch, Small Sheet) that are perfect for any party or celebration. The standard cake features chocolate and vanilla ice cream with fudge and crunchies, allowing for personalized messages and colors.
• Family-Friendly and Accessible Environment: The location is welcoming to all, with an atmosphere that is both Casual and appealing to Groups and Children. Key accessibility features include a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking, plus outdoor seating for a comfortable experience.
• Extensive Menu Variety: With over 15 homemade hard ice cream flavors, the option of creamy soft serve, Italian ices, frozen yogurt, shakes, floats, and coffee, there is literally something for every single palate, making it a reliable choice for families and large groups.

Contact Information

For patrons looking to reach out, place a custom cake order, or inquire about current flavors, here is the essential contact information for Cake and Cone:

Address: 306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

Phone: (201) 933-2589

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Cake and Cone, the expansive menu can be wonderfully overwhelming, but several items are particularly noteworthy and highly recommended by locals.

Firstly, you absolutely must sample one of the homemade hard ice cream flavors. The intense creaminess and premium ingredients elevate the experience far above standard store-bought ice cream. The hands-down favorite is the Salted Monster—a truly delicious combination of salted caramel and cookies. Its popularity is well-earned and often cited as the best ice cream flavor in the entire area. Other must-try hard ice cream options include the rich Nutella Ice Cream and the smooth, nutty Pistachio.

For those who want a truly indulgent experience, turning your treat into a sundae is the way to go. The Funnel Cake Sundae offers a unique carnival-like treat, combining a classic dessert with your choice of ice cream and toppings. Alternatively, for a deep-fried indulgence, the Fried Oreo Sundae is a customer favorite that perfectly blends hot, crispy fried Oreos with cool, creamy ice cream and hot fudge. These specialty sundaes capture the playful and abundant spirit of the shop’s offerings.

If you are planning an event, choosing a custom Ice Cream Cake from Cake and Cone is a decision that guarantees a crowd-pleaser. Known for their classic composition of chocolate and vanilla ice cream layered with fudge and crunchies, these cakes provide a celebratory centerpiece that is always a hit. The reasonable pricing for cakes, from the 6-inch to the Small Sheet, offers excellent value for a high-quality, memorable dessert.

Finally, for a simple, refreshing treat, don't overlook their Italian Ices or a nostalgic Egg Cream. Whether you are craving the smooth soft serve, a traditional banana split, or the most unique flavor on the menu, Cake and Cone delivers a quality, reasonably priced dessert that stands the test of time and tradition in New Jersey. The combination of old-school charm, efficient service, and genuinely delicious treats makes any choice here a worthwhile one.

Cake and Cone

306 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA