Cara Mia

- 3935 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783

For New Yorkers seeking an authentic, cozy, and highly-regarded Italian dining experience on Long Island, **Cara Mia** in **Seaford, NY**, is a must-visit destination. This exceptional establishment, located right in the heart of Nassau County, expertly combines the warmth of traditional Italian hospitality with a menu that is both classic and creatively modern. More than just an **Italian restaurant**, Cara Mia also operates as a sophisticated **Cocktail bar**, making it the perfect venue for everything from a family dinner to a **Romantic** evening out.

The culinary philosophy at Cara Mia is centered on high-quality ingredients and richly flavored, comforting Italian staples. The menu offers a comprehensive selection that begins with mouthwatering **Appetizers** such as the inventive **Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Eggrolls** ($14.00) and the classic **Burrata & Prosciutto** ($17.00). The pasta selection is particularly notable, featuring classics like **Penne alla Vodka** ($18.00) alongside house specialties such as the creamy, highly-praised **Gnocchi Bolognese** ($24.00) and the signature **Cavatelli Cara Mia** ($22.00).

Customer reviews consistently praise the extraordinary quality of the food. One enthusiastic patron noted that "Amazing does not even describe the food here," specifically highlighting the perfection of the **gnocchi in bolognese cream sauce**. Beyond the impressive culinary execution, the **Atmosphere** is a significant part of the draw. The restaurant is described as having a "Nice atmosphere," blending a **Casual** and **Cozy** feel with a decidedly **Trendy** vibe. Whether you are enjoying the lively indoor setting or opting for the delightful **Outdoor seating**, the environment is curated for a memorable experience.

The exceptional service truly sets Cara Mia apart from the typical Long Island dining spot. The staff's commitment to creating a "beautiful experience" is often highlighted, as evidenced by a review where the server, Danielle, was singled out for her incredible attentiveness and warmth. This level of personalized care makes guests feel genuinely welcomed and embodies the finest traditions of New York hospitality. Cara Mia is clearly **Popular for** both a casual **Lunch** and a special **Dinner**, appealing to **Groups** while also welcoming those seeking **Solo dining** enjoyment.

Offering full **Accessibility** (including wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, restroom, and seating), a superb selection of beverages, and a dedication to quality from the first appetizer to the final **Dessert**, Cara Mia ensures a delightful and comfortable experience for every New Yorker who walks through its doors.

Cara Mia is conveniently located in the thriving Long Island community of **Seaford, NY**, making it easily accessible for residents across Nassau and western Suffolk Counties. The address is:

3935 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783, USA

Its position on Merrick Road, a major Long Island thoroughfare, ensures simple navigation for drivers. A significant advantage for New York patrons is the availability of convenient parking. The restaurant offers a **Free parking lot** and also benefits from **Free street parking**, mitigating the common challenge of parking in the area. Furthermore, Cara Mia is commendable for its full commitment to accessibility, offering:

• **Wheelchair accessible entrance**
• **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**
• **Wheelchair accessible restroom**
• **Wheelchair accessible seating**

This level of attention to accessibility ensures that all members of the Long Island community can comfortably enjoy the dining experience.

Cara Mia offers a broad spectrum of services designed for maximum customer convenience and a superior dining experience:

• **Flexible Dining Options:** Provides **Dine-in** service in a **Cozy, Romantic, and Trendy** setting, along with the option of enjoying a meal on the charming **Outdoor seating** area.
• **Off-Premise Convenience:** Offers robust **Takeout** and **Delivery** services for enjoying authentic Italian food at home.
• **Reservations:** **Accepts reservations**, with **Dinner reservations recommended**, to ensure a table, especially for **Groups** and during peak hours.
• **Full Beverage Service:** Features a well-stocked **Bar onsite** and provides a full range of **Offerings** including **Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor,** and a **Great wine list**.
• **Coffee and Dessert:** Known for both **Great coffee** and **Great dessert**, completing the full dining cycle.
• **Happy Hour:** Offers **Happy hour drinks**, providing a great value proposition for early evening visits.
• **Family-Friendly Amenities:** Is classified as **Good for kids**, offering **High chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' menu**.
• **Payment Acceptance:** Facilitates easy transactions by accepting **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**.
• **Table Service:** Provides attentive **Table service** for all dining options.

The distinct features and highlights of Cara Mia solidify its reputation as a premier Italian restaurant on Long Island:

• **Acclaimed Pasta Dishes:** Famous for its incredible pasta, including the customer-favorite **Gnocchi Bolognese** ($24.00) with its creamy sauce, and sophisticated choices like **Black Linguini** ($26.00) and **Linguini White Clam Sauce** ($25.00).
• **Creative Appetizers:** The starter menu showcases creativity and tradition, from the unique **Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Eggrolls** ($14.00) to classic, perfectly executed **Fried Calamari** ($15.00).
• **Full Beverage Program:** Not just a restaurant, but also a **Cocktail bar** with a focus on **Great cocktails** and a **Great wine list**, offering a diverse selection of **Hard liquor** and **Beer**.
• **Authentic Comfort Food:** The menu is rich in classic Italian **Comfort food** such as **Lasagna** ($21.00), **Spaghetti & Meatballs** ($18.00), and a variety of homemade soups like **Pasta E Fagioli** and **Stracciatella** (both $8.00).
• **Exceptional Service and Atmosphere:** Distinguished by "service on point" and a genuinely warm, attentive staff. The dual atmosphere—simultaneously **Cozy** and **Trendy**—is perfect for every occasion, from a casual stop to a **Romantic** dinner.
• **Health-Conscious Options:** Provides **Healthy options** and **Small plates**, catering to lighter appetites or those seeking a more balanced meal.
• **Serves Local Specialty:** The restaurant also highlights its use of **local specialty** items, integrating regional tastes into its offerings.

To plan your visit, make reservations, or arrange for takeout or delivery from Cara Mia in Seaford, please use the contact details below:

Address: 3935 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783, USA

Phone: (516) 804-9280

Mobile Phone: +1 516-804-9280

For New Yorkers on Long Island, choosing Cara Mia is a choice for quality, ambiance, and impeccable service, making it stand out among the multitude of Italian dining options:

• **The Unforgettable Food Quality:** The primary reason to choose Cara Mia is the exceptional food, which patrons describe as "Amazing." From the creamy **Gnocchi Bolognese** to the expertly prepared seafood dishes and generous portions of **Lasagna**, the consistency and depth of flavor are what truly draw customers in. This is Italian dining executed with passion and precision.
• **Perfect Ambiance for Any Occasion:** Cara Mia masterfully balances a **Casual, Cozy** feel with a **Trendy** and **Romantic** atmosphere. Whether you need a sophisticated setting for a business **Dinner**, a lively spot for **Groups**, or a quiet corner for a date, the restaurant’s environment is flawlessly adaptable. The option for **Outdoor seating** is an added bonus, especially on pleasant New York evenings.
• **World-Class Hospitality:** The service is a key differentiator. The staff's genuine warmth and dedication to making the meal a "beautiful experience," as highlighted by customer shout-outs, mean patrons receive **Table service** that is truly "on point." This attentive, welcoming approach is essential for a high-quality dining experience.
• **Full Beverage and Dessert Program:** This is a complete dining destination. Beyond the food, the presence of a full **Bar onsite** boasting **Great cocktails** and a **Great wine list** ensures the perfect pairing for any dish. The reputation for **Great dessert** and **Great coffee** means the meal is always concluded on a high note.
• **Convenience and Accessibility:** The free, easy parking (both lot and street) and the full **Wheelchair accessible** infrastructure remove barriers to dining. Combined with the option for **Delivery** or **Takeout**, Cara Mia offers supreme convenience to its Long Island community.

Cara Mia is where New York's Long Island residents go for memorable, high-quality Italian cuisine backed by service excellence and a superb atmosphere—a true gem in Seaford.

Cara Mia

3935 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783, USA