Cull & Pistol

- 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011

Nestled inside the vibrant and bustling Chelsea Market, Cull & Pistol is a premier seafood restaurant that has quickly become a favorite for both New Yorkers and visitors. This veteran-owned establishment offers an authentic and high-quality dining experience centered around the freshest seafood available. Unlike many restaurants that feel disconnected from their ingredients, Cull & Pistol is directly connected to The Lobster Place, ensuring a constant supply of top-tier, fresh catches. The name itself is a nod to lobster grading—a "cull" has one claw, and a "pistol" has none—a detail that speaks to their deep knowledge and love for seafood. This dedication is evident in every dish, from perfectly cooked lobsters to some of the best oysters in the city.

The atmosphere at Cull & Pistol is a perfect blend of cozy and trendy. Despite its location within a busy market, the restaurant provides a charming, intimate space that feels like a hidden gem. It’s an ideal spot for a leisurely lunch, a romantic dinner, or a special occasion. Patrons rave about the impeccable service and the staff's passion for the menu. They are known for providing excellent recommendations, which truly enhances the dining experience. The restaurant is celebrated for serving up local specialties and seasonal dishes, highlighting the best that the region and beyond have to offer. It’s a place where every dish is not only delicious but also a work of art, with beautiful plating that is a feast for the eyes as well as the palate.

Cull & Pistol is located at 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA. Its unique setting within the Chelsea Market makes it a destination in itself. While this location adds to its charm, it's also noted that you "have to weave your way through the busy Chelsea Market to find it." For many, this journey is part of the experience, offering a chance to soak in the market's lively atmosphere before arriving at the restaurant. The market is very accessible via public transportation, with numerous subway lines and bus routes serving the area. This makes it a convenient spot for New Yorkers from all over the city.

Accessibility is a key priority for the restaurant. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that all guests can easily enter and enjoy their meal. The establishment also has a wheelchair-accessible restroom and seating, which demonstrates its commitment to inclusivity. The layout and service are designed to be accommodating and efficient. The restaurant also has a gender-neutral restroom, further highlighting its commitment to being a welcoming space for everyone. While the market itself can be crowded, the restaurant’s staff does an excellent job of managing reservations and wait times to make sure guests are seated as quickly as possible.

• Dine-in: Enjoy a full-service dining experience with table service in a cozy and charming setting.
• Takeout: For those on the go, a separate takeout option is available from the adjacent Lobster Place Seafood Hall.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations and recommends them, especially for dinner, as there is often a wait due to its popularity.
• Catering: Cull & Pistol offers catering services, allowing you to bring their delicious seafood to your private events.
• Happy Hour: A special happy hour with discounted oysters and drinks is offered on weekdays, making it a perfect spot for an after-work get-together.

• Veteran-Owned Business: Cull & Pistol proudly identifies as a veteran-owned business, adding a unique and meaningful layer to its identity.
• Exceptional Freshness: The restaurant's direct connection to The Lobster Place guarantees that all seafood, from the oysters to the lobsters, is incredibly fresh.
• Award-Winning Oysters: Known for having some of the best oysters in the city, with a top-tier raw bar selection that includes various local and regional varieties.
• Diverse Drink Menu: The bar offers a great selection of beers, cocktails, and wines, with special highlights on local craft beers, unique cocktails like the **Japan G&T**, and a great wine list.
• Cozy and Charming Atmosphere: The smaller, intimate setting creates a welcoming and cozy vibe that stands out from the bustling market outside.
• Serves Local Specialties: The menu features local and regional specialties, including oysters from the New York area and local craft beers.
• Inclusive Environment: The restaurant is family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safe space, making it a comfortable and accepting place for a diverse crowd.

Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA

Phone: (646) 568-1223

Mobile Phone: +1 646-568-1223

Choosing Cull & Pistol for your next seafood meal in New York is an excellent decision, and several key factors make it a standout choice. The most compelling reason is the unparalleled freshness of the seafood. As one reviewer noted, "Everything is fresh and cooked to perfection." This is not just a claim; it's a reality backed by its relationship with The Lobster Place. This is where you go for a taste of the ocean that is as authentic as it gets. The **Lobster Rolls**, both hot and cold, are a must-try, though at a premium price. They are a classic New England staple done to perfection, served with Old Bay fries that are a perfect complement. The **Grilled Lobsters** are also a standout, grilled and basted with a lemon-thyme butter that brings out the natural sweetness of the meat.

Beyond the lobster, the menu offers a wealth of incredible options. The raw bar, with its selection of the "best oysters in the city," is an experience in itself. From the briny **Merasheen Bay** to the local **Widow's Hole**, there's an oyster for every preference. For cooked dishes, the **Grilled Spanish Octopus** and **Butterflied Grilled Branzino** are highly recommended. A reviewer specifically praised these dishes for being "plated beautifully, arrived promptly, and tasted just as good as it looked." The **Market Fish** is another fantastic choice, as it's always an "amazing choice" that highlights the freshest catch of the day. The **New England Clam Chowder** is a comforting classic that shouldn't be missed, especially on a chilly day.

Finally, the overall experience is what sets Cull & Pistol apart. The staff's dedication to providing "excellent" service and "great recommendations" makes a huge difference. Their knowledge of the menu and passion for seafood elevate your meal from good to great. The cozy and charming atmosphere, while small, provides an intimate setting that makes your meal feel truly special. This, combined with the convenience of being located within Chelsea Market, makes Cull & Pistol a genuine gem. It’s a place where you can feel confident that you are getting the highest quality seafood and service, making it well worth the effort of navigating the market crowds to find it.

Cull & Pistol

75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA