Donna Margherita

- 1304A 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10065

Nestled on the bustling streets of the Upper East Side, Donna Margherita stands as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine in New York City. For New Yorkers who appreciate a genuine taste of Italy without the transatlantic flight, this restaurant offers a culinary journey that is both heartwarming and delicious. From the moment you step inside, the cozy and casual atmosphere welcomes you, making you feel right at home. It’s a place that captures the essence of a traditional Italian trattoria, where the food is the star and every guest is treated like family.

Donna Margherita is more than just a place to eat; it's a celebration of Italian tradition and flavor. The menu is a meticulously crafted selection of classic dishes, from fresh pasta to perfectly baked pizzas, all made with high-quality ingredients. The commitment to authenticity is evident in every bite, as noted by customers who compare the pizza favorably to what they've had in Italy. This dedication to tradition is what sets Donna Margherita apart, earning it a reputation as a hidden gem for those in the know. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or settling in for a leisurely dinner, the experience is consistently exceptional.

The restaurant's women-owned status adds another layer of community pride to its identity. It’s a place where passion for food and hospitality shines through in every detail, from the impeccable service to the thoughtful recommendations from the staff. This personal touch creates a dining experience that feels both professional and incredibly warm. The team's enthusiasm for the food is contagious, enhancing the overall enjoyment of the meal. This is particularly true for those who appreciate the story and effort behind their food, as Donna Margherita brings a piece of Italy to the heart of New York.

What makes Donna Margherita a standout choice for New Yorkers is its ability to cater to a variety of occasions and preferences. It’s a fantastic spot for a solo dining experience, a friendly group gathering, or a family outing. The menu is designed to please a diverse crowd, with offerings ranging from healthy options and small plates to hearty comfort food. The restaurant’s popularity for both lunch and dinner is a testament to its versatility and consistent quality. Whether you’re craving a classic Spaghetti Carbonara or a unique Tartufata pizza, Donna Margherita delivers a memorable and satisfying meal every time.

In a city filled with countless dining options, Donna Margherita distinguishes itself by prioritizing authenticity, quality, and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere. The fact that dinner reservations are recommended speaks to its popularity among locals who have discovered this culinary treasure. It's a place where you can relax, enjoy a great glass of wine from their extensive list, and savor food that tastes like it was prepared in a traditional Italian kitchen. For anyone in New York looking for an authentic and exceptional Italian dining experience, Donna Margherita is a must-visit destination that lives up to its well-earned reputation.

Located at 1304A 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10065, USA, Donna Margherita is easily accessible in the Upper East Side. Its address on 2nd Avenue makes it a convenient spot for local residents and those visiting the neighborhood. The area is well-served by public transportation, and for those driving, both a paid parking lot and paid street parking are available nearby. This ensures that patrons have multiple ways to reach the restaurant without hassle, whether they are coming from within the borough or from further afield.

The restaurant's commitment to accessibility is a notable feature. It offers a wheelchair accessible entrance and wheelchair accessible seating, making it a welcoming dining option for all guests. This thoughtful design ensures that everyone can enjoy the cozy atmosphere and delicious food with ease. The availability of outdoor seating also adds a flexible dining option, allowing guests to enjoy their meal in the fresh air, a particularly popular feature during good weather. This combination of convenient location, a variety of parking options, and inclusive accessibility makes Donna Margherita a practical and inviting choice for a wide audience.

Services Offered

• Outdoor seating: Enjoy your meal al fresco in the charming outdoor dining area.
• Delivery: Have authentic Italian food delivered directly to your home.
• Takeout: For a convenient meal on the go, a quick and efficient takeout service is available.
• Dine-in: Experience the warm and cozy ambiance with full table service.
• Catering: A great option for events and gatherings, bringing the taste of Italy to your special occasion.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, and they are recommended, especially for dinner.
• Table service: Enjoy attentive and friendly service throughout your dining experience.

Features / Highlights

• Fast Service: Known for quick and efficient service, ensuring you get your food without a long wait.
• Great Coffee: The perfect way to end your meal, with high-quality coffee available.
• Great Wine List: A curated selection of wines to perfectly complement your Italian meal.
• Women-owned: The restaurant is proudly identified as women-owned, supporting a local, independent business.
• Authentic Italian Cuisine: The food is renowned for its authenticity, with fresh ingredients, some sourced from Italy.
• Family-friendly and LGBTQ+ friendly: A welcoming and inclusive environment for all guests, including families and members of the LGBTQ+ community.
• Variety of Offerings: From healthy options and organic dishes to comfort food and small plates, there's something for everyone.

Contact Information

Address: 1304A 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10065, USA

Phone: (212) 772-1169

What is worth choosing

Choosing Donna Margherita for your next meal in New York City is a decision you won't regret, and there are several compelling reasons why it stands out. First and foremost, the authenticity of the food is a major draw. As highlighted by a customer review, the pizza is on par with what you'd find in Italy, with a perfect crust and vibrant, fresh ingredients. The use of imported Italian products, as noted in the review, elevates every dish to a new level, ensuring that you get a true taste of Italy with every bite. The menu is diverse, offering everything from classic pastas like Lasagna and Spaghetti Carbonara to unique pizzas like the Tartufata and specialty main courses like the Short Ribs Donna Margherita. This variety ensures that whether you're craving a light pasta or a hearty main, you'll find something delicious.

The restaurant’s atmosphere and service are also key reasons to visit. The environment is described as casual, cozy, and trendy, making it a comfortable place for any occasion. A real customer review raved about the "impeccable" and "warm" service, with a server who made them feel "like family." This personal touch and genuine enthusiasm from the staff contribute significantly to the overall dining experience, making it much more than just a meal. The fact that the restaurant is LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space further highlights its inclusive and welcoming nature, making it a place where everyone can feel comfortable and respected.

Finally, the practical benefits make Donna Margherita an excellent choice. The fast service ensures that you get your food promptly, which is a great bonus in a city known for its fast-paced lifestyle. The availability of outdoor seating offers a pleasant option for dining on a nice day, and the great wine list provides the perfect pairing for your meal. The fact that it is a women-owned business is an important factor for many who prefer to support local and independently owned establishments. In essence, Donna Margherita provides a perfect blend of high-quality, authentic food, a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere, and a convenient location with great service, making it a truly exceptional dining destination in New York City.

Donna Margherita

1304A 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10065, USA