Five Guys

- 265 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801

For residents and visitors across the New York metropolitan area, especially on Long Island, Five Guys at 265 N Broadway in Hicksville, NY, represents the pinnacle of premium, customizable American fast-food. Recognized nationwide as one of the "three major hamburgers" in the U.S., this establishment elevates the classic burger and fries experience by focusing on fresh, quality ingredients and a commitment to customization.

Five Guys stands out from the typical fast-food landscape by adhering to a few key principles: they use fresh ground beef for their hand-formed patties, they never use freezers in their kitchens (only coolers), and they cook their signature, boardwalk-style fries exclusively in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil. This dedication to freshness and a transparent preparation process gives their food a distinctively clean and delicious flavor profile. The Hicksville location provides a casual yet energetic atmosphere, welcoming everyone from solo diners to large groups.

The core of the menu revolves around their celebrated burgers, which are available in four main styles—Hamburger, Cheeseburger, Bacon Burger, and Bacon Cheeseburger—each also offered as a "Little" version for a single patty option. Beyond burgers, the menu includes high-quality options like the Kosher Style Hot Dog (an all-beef dog, split and grilled lengthwise) and various sandwiches, including a popular Grilled Cheese and a substantial Veggie Sandwich. To finish, their handspun Milk Shakes offer a classic American dessert.

The Five Guys location in Hicksville is situated at a highly accessible spot in Nassau County: 265 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801. Its positioning on North Broadway ensures it is easy to reach for lunch or dinner, whether you are coming from nearby Long Island Expressway access points or traveling locally within the Hicksville area.

Accessibility is a top priority at this establishment. The restaurant features a fully compliant setup, including a dedicated wheelchair accessible entrance and a clean, easily navigated wheelchair accessible restroom. For drivers, the experience is designed for convenience, offering multiple parking solutions. Patrons benefit from a dedicated on-site parking lot, complemented by free street parking options, making a quick stop or an extended dining experience hassle-free.

The interior is casual and designed to accommodate various crowds, including a welcoming environment for groups and families. The restaurant is noted as being good for kids, providing amenities like high chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu. While waiting for your custom-made meal, you can enjoy the iconic Five Guys tradition of complimentary in-shell roasted peanuts, which are typically stacked and available throughout the dining area.

The Hicksville Five Guys is set up to provide maximum convenience, catering to both traditional dine-in guests and those seeking rapid, off-site consumption.

• Dine-in Service: Available for Lunch and Dinner, offering Seating and efficient Counter Service in a casual atmosphere.
• Takeout Options: Patrons can order for standard Takeout or utilize the highly convenient Curbside Pickup option.
• Delivery and Safety: The restaurant provides standard Delivery and enhanced safety via No-Contact Delivery.
• Offerings: Specializing in Quick Bites for individuals and Groups on the go.
• Family & Children: The space is Good for kids, and High Chairs are available for young patrons, supported by a specialized Kids' menu.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment forms, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and swift NFC mobile payments.
• Amenities: A clean Restroom is available for all patrons.

What truly sets Five Guys apart from other fast-food restaurants in the New York area are the features that define their dedication to a fresh and personalized dining experience.

• Unlimited Free Toppings: All burgers and hot dogs are fully customizable with any combination of over 15 free toppings, from grilled onions and mushrooms to jalapeño peppers, A1 Sauce, and more. This allows for over 250,000 ways to build a burger, including favorites like "All the Way" (mayo, lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, ketchup, and mustard).
• Fresh, Never-Frozen Beef: Their unwavering commitment to using only fresh, hand-formed ground beef (never frozen) ensures a juicy and flavorful patty every time, a key factor in their reputation for high-quality burgers.
• Fries Cooked in Peanut Oil: The boardwalk-style fries, which are cut fresh in-house daily and cooked in 100% peanut oil, are a signature highlight. They are known for being firm on the outside and having a mashed potato-like interior, available in Five Guys Style or with a generous sprinkling of Cajun Style seasoning.
• Hot Dog Variety: The all-beef hot dogs are split and grilled lengthwise, a method that caramelizes the exterior for enhanced flavor and texture, offered plain or with cheese, bacon, or both.
• Sandwich Options for Non-Meat Eaters: The Veggie Sandwich (a customizable bun filled with freshly grilled onions, mushrooms, and green peppers layered with lettuce and tomatoes) and the Grilled Cheese (with or without a veggie filling) provide great alternatives for those looking for meat-free options.

Contact Information:

Address: 265 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801

Phone: (516) 822-8022

Mobile Phone: +1 516-822-8022

For Long Island residents seeking a truly exceptional fast-food experience, Five Guys in Hicksville is worth choosing for several compelling reasons. The ability to create your perfect meal with an endless combination of fresh, free toppings is a major draw that standard burger chains cannot match. Whether you prefer a classic Cheeseburger loaded with grilled mushrooms and onions, or a Little Bacon Burger with a simple dressing of lettuce and tomato, the choice is entirely yours.

Furthermore, the quality of the accompanying fries is legendary. Fried in pure peanut oil and served in generous portions (with the regular and large sizes including an extra scoop dumped into the bag), these fries are considered by many to be the best in the fast-casual category. The attention to detail in their preparation—hand-cut daily and double-cooked—is evident in every bite. While a recent customer review noted a perceived increase in prices, the value proposition remains tied to the restaurant’s superior ingredients and customization policy. It’s an indulgence built on quality. The Kosher Style Hot Dog is also a fantastic option, grilled to a caramelized exterior for a satisfying snap. Ultimately, Five Guys offers a higher-quality take on classic American fare, making it a reliable and highly recommended spot for a consistently great hamburger, satisfying hot dog, or delicious shake in the heart of Nassau County.

Five Guys

265 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA