Gargiulo's

- 2911 W 15th St, Brooklyn, NY 11224

Introduction / Overview

For over a century, Gargiulo's has stood as a beacon of classic Italian-American fine dining in the heart of Coney Island, Brooklyn. Established in 1907, this historic landmark offers New Yorkers a truly unique and memorable culinary journey, transporting diners back to a bygone era of elegance and hospitality. Far more than just an Italian restaurant, Gargiulo's is a cherished institution, renowned for its commitment to authentic, traditional Neapolitan cuisine based on time-honored family recipes brought by the Russo family, who have proudly operated the establishment since 1965.

Stepping through the doors of Gargiulo's is often described as an experience in itself—a step into an atmosphere that is at once cozy, romantic, and distinctly upscale. The interior, with its historic charm and classic décor, provides a magnificent backdrop for everything from an intimate solo meal to a grand family celebration. Waiters in classic tuxedo attire provide professional yet friendly service, emphasizing a level of old-world class that is increasingly rare in modern New York dining.

The menu is a testament to the richness of Neapolitan cooking and classic Italian-American adaptations. It features an extensive array of offerings, from a robust selection of Antipasti like Prosciutto, Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers and Baked Clams, to hearty Primi Piatti options such as Fettuccine Verdi alla Gargiulo and Risotto Pescatore. The Secondi Piatti is equally impressive, showcasing classic preparations of Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Marsala, and an outstanding selection of fresh Pesce and Alla Griglia options, including Rib Steak, Filet Mignon, and Fresh Whole Lobster. Beyond its celebrated restaurant services, Gargiulo's is also a premier Caterer and a beloved Wedding Venue, a tradition dating back to the use of its Grand Ballroom in the early 20th century, making it a true Brooklyn staple for life's most special moments.

Location and Accessibility

Gargiulo's is conveniently located at 2911 W 15th St, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA, right in the heart of the world-famous Coney Island neighborhood. Its proximity to the boardwalk and amusement area makes it an ideal dining destination before or after enjoying the iconic attractions. Despite its historic nature, the restaurant is notably accessible, striving to accommodate all guests.

For drivers, the restaurant provides excellent amenities with both a Free Parking Lot and Valet Parking service, a major convenience in this bustling part of Brooklyn. For those utilizing public transit, its Coney Island location is well-connected. Accessibility features are well-addressed, including a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot, Wheelchair Accessible Restroom, and Wheelchair Accessible Seating, ensuring a comfortable visit for guests with mobility needs.

Services Offered

• Dine-in Service: Enjoy the full, upscale, historic dining experience with formal table service.
• Takeout: Conveniently order and pick up your favorite Italian dishes.
• Delivery: Have the renowned Neapolitan cuisine delivered right to your door.
• Catering: Full catering services are offered, leveraging decades of experience in event hosting for both on-site and off-site events.
• Private Dining Room: A dedicated space available for private parties, corporate events, and celebrations.
• Table Service: Professional, tuxedo-clad wait staff provide attentive and knowledgeable service.
• Reservations: Accepts reservations, which are highly recommended for dinner and brunch, given its popularity.
• Special Events/Venue: Functions as a celebrated Wedding Venue and hosts all manner of social functions in its historic ballrooms.
• Bar Service: A Bar Onsite serves a comprehensive menu of Beer, Wine, Cocktails, and Hard Liquor.

Features / Highlights

• Historic and Iconic Status: Operating since 1907, Gargiulo's is the oldest business still operating in Coney Island, providing a rich, "back in time" atmosphere noted by New Yorkers.
• Classic Fine Dining Atmosphere: The ambiance is described as Historic, Romantic, Trendy, and Upscale, featuring formal touches like tuxedo-clad waiters and elegant decor.
• Exceptional Beverage Program: Offers a Great Wine List featuring Imported and American Reds and Whites (e.g., Barolo, Brunello, Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon), a wide array of Champagne and Sparkling Wines, and a large selection of After Dinner Drinks (Amari, Grappa, Cognacs).
• Culinary Excellence: Specializes in Classic Neapolitan Cuisine, with a strong focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients, particularly noted for its Pesce (Seafood) dishes like Zuppa di Pesce and Lobster Tails, as well as classic Veal and Chicken preparations.
• Dessert and Coffee Focus: Known for a Great Dessert menu, including Home-Made Cannoli and Tiramisù, alongside a Great Coffee selection (Espresso, Cappuccino, Irish Coffee).
• Accessibility and Amenities: Comprehensive accessibility, including wheelchair access for the entrance, parking, restroom, and seating, plus convenient on-site amenities like a Bar, Restroom, Wi-Fi, and dedicated parking.
• Family-Friendly: Considered Good for Kids, offering a Kids' Menu and High Chairs to accommodate families.
• Service Commendation: Praised by patrons for its professional, friendly, and detail-oriented staff who offer knowledgeable menu recommendations.
• Versatile Dining Options: Available for Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Late-Night Food, catering to both Tourists and Groups.

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers seeking more than just a meal, Gargiulo's provides an immersive cultural and dining experience. What makes this institution particularly worth choosing is its ability to perfectly blend history with high-quality, authentic Neapolitan cuisine. It stands as a sophisticated anchor in the otherwise whimsical Coney Island area, offering a respite of classic elegance.

Diners should choose Gargiulo's for its unparalleled atmosphere. Customer reviews consistently highlight the experience of "going back in time" to a classy, 1960s-era fine dining establishment, complete with the charming, detailed service of the tuxedo-clad staff. This is the place to celebrate a milestone, host a romantic dinner, or impress out-of-town guests with a quintessential, historic Brooklyn experience.

On the menu, New York food lovers will be pleased with the dedication to classic dishes. The Pesce section is a must-try, with the Zuppa di Pesce and the massive, spectacular seafood pasta platter being customer favorites, often served tableside. Classic veal and chicken dishes, such as the Veal Parmigiana and Chicken Scarpariello, exemplify the rich, comforting flavors of Italian-American cooking at its finest. Finally, the truly excellent and extensive Great Wine List and the selection of homemade Desserts, particularly the Home-Made Cannoli and Tiramisù, ensure that the meal is concluded with an authentic Italian flourish. Between the historic setting, the formal-yet-friendly service, and the consistently spectacular Neapolitan fare, Gargiulo's offers an irreplaceable slice of New York history and culinary tradition.

Gargiulo's

2911 W 15th St, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA