Goody's Bagels & Spreads

- 5 Glen Cove Rd, Greenvale, NY 11548

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers, the search for an authentic, traditional bagel is a serious quest, and for those in the Long Island region, Goody's Bagels & Spreads in Greenvale, NY, is often cited as the definitive answer. This small business is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a vital culinary anchor in the community, celebrated for preserving the "old school" method of bagel making that distinguishes true New York quality.

Patrons rave about the bagels here, confirming they are still kettle-boiled—a crucial process that imparts the blistered, crispy skin and the dense, chewy interior that many Long Island residents argue is absent from modern, steamed alternatives. As one delighted customer put it, the owner is a "master at his craft," resulting in the "hands-down best bagels" they ever had.

The menu extends far beyond the basics, offering a comprehensive breakfast, lunch, and deli experience. From the expansive selection of homemade cream cheeses (including Lox Spread and Dairy Free Tofu options) and a full counter of Smoked Fish (featuring Nova, Belly Lox, and Chunky Whitefish) to their famous Breakfast Sandwiches and creative Goody's Signature Sandwiches like the Lox Of Love and The Roslyn, Goody's is a one-stop shop for high-quality, authentic New York-style fare. Whether you are grabbing a quick coffee and a bagel or stocking up for the week with a dozen bagels and deli items by the pound, Goody's is the genuine article.

Location and Accessibility

Goody's Bagels & Spreads is strategically located in the heart of Greenvale, Long Island, making it an easy and essential stop for commuters and local residents throughout Nassau County.

Address: 5 Glen Cove Rd, Greenvale, NY 11548, USA

The shop is built for convenience, supporting the dynamic pace of New York life while ensuring accessibility for all customers:

• Parking: A significant amenity for a busy Long Island location, the business provides a convenient Free parking lot, making it simple for customers to stop in for a Quick visit.
• Accessibility Features: The establishment is committed to serving everyone, featuring both a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
• Service Options: The location supports multiple methods of service for local users, including Dine-in, Takeout, In-store pickup, and Delivery, ensuring you can enjoy their food wherever you are in the New York area.

Services Offered

Goody's Bagels & Spreads offers a robust suite of services that make it a cornerstone for breakfast and lunch needs in the Greenvale region:

• Authentic Bagels & Rolls: Offers individual bagels, A Dozen Bagels ($23.00), Mini Bagels, and Flagels (Flats), all freshly made using traditional boiling techniques.
• Comprehensive Breakfast Service: Features extensive Breakfast Sandwiches (such as the classic Bacon, Egg & Cheese (BEC) and specialized items like The Stinger with Mike's Hot Honey), plus full Egg Platters, Scrambles, & Omelettes.
• Deli and Smoked Fish Counter: Provides a wide selection of Smoked Fish (Belly Lox, Nova, White Fish, etc.) and premium From the Deli meats and cheeses (Roast Beef, Honey Maple Turkey, Swiss, etc.), all available by the lb.
• Catering and Bulk Orders: Offers a Box Of Coffee ($18.99) and various salads and spreads by the lb., supporting Onsite services and catering for larger groups, with staff noted for their fantastic service.
• Specialty Salads and Spreads: Provides a huge variety of Cream Cheese & Spreads (including 13 distinct types like Lox Spread, Walnut Raisin, and Vegetable Tofu (Dairy Free)) and 12 different Homemade Salads (like Healthy Egg White & Spinach Salad and Cranberry Chicken Salad).
• Pastries and Beverages: A selection of freshly baked Pastries (muffins, croissants, Crumb Cake) and a full range of Hot & Iced Coffee and Tea options, plus popular bottled Beverages.

Features / Highlights

The features that make Goody's Bagels & Spreads a must-visit for the New York area are rooted in its commitment to quality and comprehensive offerings.

• Authentic Boiling Technique: The most crucial highlight is the dedication to "old school bagel store" quality, where they still boil them—a technique that ensures their signature fluffy chewy goodness inside and the perfect crisp crust.
• Diverse and Diet-Conscious Spreads: With 13 cream cheese and spread options, including multiple Low Cal and two Dairy Free Tofu options, Goody's ensures that every preference and dietary need is met, a unique offering in the bagel space.
• Gourmet Smoked Fish Selection: The comprehensive smoked fish menu, including high-end options like Belly Lox and Nova, positions Goody's as a reliable, high-quality purveyor of traditional bagel accompaniments.
• Exceptional Breakfast Sandwiches: Beyond the classic BEC, their specialty Breakfast Sandwiches—including the high-protein Protein Man and the creative The Goody and The Stinger—are recognized by customers as the best egg sandwiches around.
• The 'Long-Distance Freshness' Seal of Approval: A true testament to the quality is a customer review mentioning they tried freezing the bagels and then toasting them months later, finding they were still perfect, highlighting their superior freshness and dough quality.

Contact Information

For catering inquiries, large orders, or simply to check on the availability of your favorite spread, please contact Goody's Bagels & Spreads using the information below:

Address: 5 Glen Cove Rd, Greenvale, NY 11548, USA

Phone: (516) 621-7887

Mobile Phone: +1 516-621-7887

What is worth choosing

Goody's Bagels & Spreads is worth choosing because it embodies the best of Long Island's breakfast culture: genuine tradition paired with modern convenience and selection. For the discerning New York bagel consumer, the single most compelling reason to choose Goody's is the authentic, time-honored kettle-boiled process. In an area where many shops take shortcuts, this commitment to making bagels "the way they should be made" is a guarantee of superior texture and taste—the perfect crispy crust and chewy inside that defines a great bagel.

Furthermore, choosing Goody's is choosing versatility. Whether you're a commuter rushing for a Quick visit grabbing a simple Hot Coffee and a BEC, or you’re planning a family gathering and need multiple pounds of Smoked Fish and Homemade Salads, their comprehensive menu covers every need. The extensive spread selection, including both classic and health-conscious/dairy-free options, ensures no one leaves disappointed.

Finally, supporting Goody's means supporting a friendly Small business where the owner is so friendly and the staff is fantastic. This combination of exceptional, authentic food and a welcoming atmosphere solidifies Goody's Bagels & Spreads as the premier choice for the best bagels and spreads in the Greenvale and surrounding Long Island area.

Goody's Bagels & Spreads

5 Glen Cove Rd, Greenvale, NY 11548, USA