Dine Droop
Dine DroopDining Insightsrestaurants near me
New York

Dine Drooprestaurants near meNew YorkNew York CountyNew Yorkrestaurants in 3rd AvenueLittle Italy Pizza
Little Italy Pizza ico

Little Italy Pizza
- 958 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022

Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant ★4.0 (185)·$1–10

958 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

4.0
I ordered over the phone and I specifically asked for the pizza to be extra thin. I asked for a grandma pizza which is thinnest they have and it came as thick as a napoleon. I have ordered several times and this place is super inconsistent. The last 2 times the pizza was very disappointing and this last time has been the worst of all, pizza didn't seem fresh, looked reheated and had super thick dough as you can see on the pictures. The guy over the phone was rude and when he passed me over to management all he said was " we will do better next time". In sum, I would definitely not recommend ordering any of their pizza, they do not care for their customers. - frederico beija
Little Italy Pizza Overview Intro Menu Detail Photos Location Reviews
$1–10 per person Reported by 185 people$1–10$10–20$20–30

Little Italy Pizza Introduce

For many, the quintessential New York experience is a perfect slice of pizza—a meal that is both fast and incredibly satisfying. Little Italy Pizza, located in the heart of Midtown East, embodies this tradition with its wide-ranging menu and a commitment to classic flavors. While a truly great slice of pizza can be hard to come by in a city saturated with options, this pizzeria aims to deliver on that promise. It's the kind of place that appeals to both the hurried local looking for a quick bite and the tourist eager to try a classic New York staple.


Little Italy Pizza prides itself on a diverse menu that goes beyond a simple cheese or pepperoni pie. From a variety of classic and specialty pizzas to Italian specialties, pasta dishes, and heroes, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The restaurant's appeal lies in its straightforward approach: delicious comfort food served in a no-frills, casual atmosphere. The affordability of whole pies and the convenience of slices make it a popular choice for everything from solo dining to feeding a group. The restaurant is a reliable choice for a quick lunch or dinner, catering to a constant flow of customers throughout the day and into the night.


As with many popular pizzerias, there can be some inconsistency, but when Little Italy Pizza is on its game, it's a true standout. One customer raved about the "high quality tomato sauce, cheese and bread" and described the taste as "amazing!" While a single slice might be on the pricier side, the value of a whole pie is noted as being an excellent deal. The restaurant's status as a go-to spot for many in the area speaks volumes about its ability to deliver a satisfying, classic New York pizza experience.




Location and Accessibility

Little Italy Pizza is conveniently located at 958 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022. Its prime location in Midtown East makes it easily accessible for anyone in the area, whether they are on a lunch break, shopping, or simply passing through. The restaurant is situated on a bustling avenue with frequent foot traffic, and its central location makes it easy to reach via public transportation.


For customers with accessibility needs, the restaurant provides a **wheelchair accessible entrance** and **wheelchair accessible seating**, ensuring that all patrons can comfortably dine in. While street parking can be a challenge in this part of the city, there are paid parking lots and paid street parking options nearby.




Services Offered

Little Italy Pizza provides a range of flexible services to accommodate its busy clientele.

  • Dine-in: Enjoy a slice or a full meal in the casual, classic pizzeria setting.
  • Takeout: Perfect for a quick grab-and-go meal. You can walk in, grab a slice, and be on your way.
  • Delivery & No-contact Delivery: For the ultimate convenience, Little Italy Pizza offers delivery services, bringing your favorite pizza and Italian specialties right to your door.



Features and Highlights

Little Italy Pizza is a classic New York City pizzeria with several standout features that make it a local favorite.

  • Pizza by the Slice: This is a key highlight for any New York pizzeria. Little Italy Pizza offers a wide variety of its pizzas by the slice, allowing customers to try different flavors without committing to a full pie.
  • Variety of Pizza Options: The menu is expansive, with a huge selection of pizzas, including classic cheese and pepperoni, as well as specialty pies like **Vodka Sauce Pizza**, **Chicken Bacon Ranch**, and the **Grandma Pizza**.
  • Other Italian Specialties: Beyond pizza, the menu includes Italian specialties like **Garlic Knots**, **Chicken Rolls**, and **Sausage & Peppers Heroes**, providing a full Italian-American comfort food experience.
  • Late-Night Food: The restaurant is a great spot for a late-night bite, serving customers late into the evening.
  • Dietary Options: The menu includes **Gluten-Free Pizza** and a **Cauliflower Pizza**, providing options for different dietary needs and preferences.



Contact Information

For orders or inquiries, you can contact Little Italy Pizza at the details below.

  • Address: 958 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA
  • Phone: (212) 355-3434



What Is Worth Choosing?

With a menu as extensive as Little Italy Pizza’s, a few items stand out as must-tries. For those seeking a classic New York experience, the **Cheese Pizza Slice** is always a great starting point, allowing you to judge the quality of the sauce, cheese, and crust. However, the true showstopper is the **Grandma Pizza**, which is known for its thin crust and is highly recommended by fans when it's made fresh. When ordering a whole pie, the value is unbeatable, especially compared to the price of individual slices.


For those who enjoy a little more flavor, the **Vodka Sauce Pizza** and the **Lou Lou’s Spicy Pepperoni Pizza** are excellent specialty options. The **Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza**, a modern classic, is also a popular choice that combines savory and creamy flavors. Don't overlook the Italian Specialties either; the **Garlic Knots** are a delicious and classic side dish.


For people with dietary restrictions, the **Gluten-Free Pizza** and **Cauliflower Pizza** provide a great option without sacrificing the classic pizza experience. Ultimately, the best way to enjoy Little Italy Pizza is to find a fresh pie, whether it’s a classic cheese or a specialty, and savor the taste of a truly authentic New York slice.

Little Italy Pizza Menu

  • Pizza

  • White Broccoli Pizza $25.00
  • White Pizza $25.00
  • Peppers And Onions Pizza $25.00
  • Eggplant Pizza $25.00
  • Cheese Pizza $20.00

    Classic cheese pizza.

  • Sicilian White Pizza $22.00

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Cauliflower Pizza $19.00
  • Sausage Pizza $23.00
  • Fresh Mozzarella Pizza $25.00
  • Mushroom Pizza $23.00
  • Vegetable Pizza $25.00
  • Sausage Pepperoni Pizza $24.95

    Sausage and pepperoni.

  • Baked Ziti Pizza $23.00
  • Chicken Mushroom Pizza $25.00
  • Grandma Pizza $22.00

    Our home-made marinara sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, olive oil and fresh garlic.

  • White Spinach Pizza $25.00
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (Special) $25.95

    Special.

  • Chicken Pepperoni Pizza $25.00
  • Sicilian Red Pizza $22.00

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $25.00
  • Lou Lou’s Spicy Pepperoni Pizza $27.00

    Mini peps, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh tomato sauce, and square deep dish pizza.

  • Gluten-Free Pizza $18.00

    13 inch Gluten-free pizza tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

  • Meatball Pizza $25.00
  • Fresh Tomato Pizza $22.00
  • Vodka Sauce Pizza $27.00

    Vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella and basil (not vegetarian).

  • Chicken Ricotta Pizza $25.00
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $27.00
  • Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza $18.00
  • Pepperoni Pizza $23.00
  • Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza $24.95
  • Chicken Tomato Pizza $25.00
  • Hawaiian Pizza $25.00

    -pineapple, bacon and mozzarella.

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza $25.00

    -barbecued chicken, sliced red onion, roasted red peppers, cilantro, a touch of smoked gouda cheese, and mozzarella cheese coupled with our bbq sauce.

  • Appetizers

  • Mozzarella Sticks $4.99

    4 pieces of mozzarella sticks and marinara sauce.

  • Buffalo Wings $9.99

    10 pieces buffalo wings with blue cheese.

  • Drinks

  • Snapple $2.50

    Snapple

  • Soda $2.25

    20 oz.

  • Dasani Bottle $2.00

    20 oz.

  • Soda (Liter) $3.95

    2 liter.

  • Appetizers

  • Mozzarella Sticks $7.99

    4 pieces of mozzarella sticks and marinara sauce.

  • Buffalo Wings $13.99

    10 pieces buffalo wings with blue cheese.

  • Pizza by the Slice

  • Cheese Pizza Slice $4.50
  • Meatball Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Chicken Mushroom Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Peppers & Onions Pizza Slice $5.45
  • White Pizza Slice $5.45
  • BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Fresh Mozzarella Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Chicken Tomato Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Hawaiian Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice (Special) $5.99

    Special.

  • Chicken Ricotta Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Lou Lou’s Spicy Pepperoni Slice $5.99
  • White Spinach Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Mushroom Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Eggplant Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice $5.99
  • Vegetables Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Grandma Pizza Slice $4.75
  • Pepperoni Sausage Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Pepperoni Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Baked Ziti Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Fresh Tomato Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Sicilian Red Pizza Slice $4.75

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Sausage Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Sicilian White Pizza Slice $4.75

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • White Broccoli Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice $5.99

    Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.

  • Chicken Pepperoni Pizza Slice $5.45
  • Pizza

  • Sicilian Red Pizza $27.00

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza $30.00
  • White Pizza $30.00
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (Special) $33.00

    Special.

  • Hawaiian Pizza $30.00

    -pineapple, bacon and mozzarella.

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $33.00
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $30.00
  • Chicken Mushroom Pizza $30.00
  • White Spinach Pizza $30.00
  • Peppers And Onions Pizza $30.00
  • Vodka Sauce Pizza $33.00

    Vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella and basil (not vegetarian).

  • Mushroom Pizza $30.00
  • Vegetable Pizza $30.00
  • Chicken Tomato Pizza $30.00
  • White Broccoli Pizza $30.00
  • Cheese Pizza $25.00

    Classic cheese pizza.

  • Meatball Pizza $30.00
  • Pepperoni Pizza $28.00
  • Grandma Pizza $27.00

    Our home-made marinara sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, olive oil and fresh garlic.

  • Chicken Pepperoni Pizza $30.00
  • Chicken Ricotta Pizza $30.00
  • Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza $20.00
  • Sicilian White Pizza $27.00

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Baked Ziti Pizza $30.00
  • Lou Lou’s Spicy Pepperoni Pizza $33.00

    Mini peps, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh tomato sauce, and square deep dish pizza.

  • Gluten-Free Pizza $20.00

    13 inch Gluten-free pizza tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

  • Sausage Pizza $30.00
  • Sausage Pepperoni Pizza $30.00

    Sausage and pepperoni.

  • Cauliflower Pizza $22.00
  • BBQ Chicken Pizza $30.00

    -barbecued chicken, sliced red onion, roasted red peppers, cilantro, a touch of smoked gouda cheese, and mozzarella cheese coupled with our bbq sauce.

  • Fresh Tomato Pizza $30.00
  • Fresh Mozzarella Pizza $30.00
  • Eggplant Pizza $30.00
  • Pasta

  • Baked Ziti Pasta $8.95

    Ziti pasta, tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, and baked mozzarella.

  • Penne With Grill Chicken Broccoli $9.95

    Penne with grill chicken broccoli, garlic, and oil.

  • Penne Alla Vodka $8.95

    Penne pasta, pink vodka sauce with pancetta.

  • Pizza by the Slice

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice (Special) $4.50

    Special.

  • Fresh Mozzarella Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Pepperoni Sausage Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Eggplant Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Lou Lou’s Spicy Pepperoni Slice $4.50
  • Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice $4.50

    Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.

  • Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Sicilian White Pizza Slice $3.50

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Cheese Pizza Slice $2.95
  • Chicken Mushroom Pizza Slice $3.95
  • BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Grandma Pizza Slice $3.50
  • Meatball Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Sicilian Red Pizza Slice $3.50

    Sauce is on the bottom and cheese is on the top.

  • Chicken Pepperoni Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Hawaiian Pizza Slice $3.95
  • White Broccoli Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Pepperoni Pizza Slice $3.95
  • White Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice $4.25
  • Baked Ziti Pizza Slice $3.95
  • White Spinach Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Vegetables Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Peppers And Onions Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Fresh Tomato Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Chicken Tomato Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Chicken Ricotta Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Sausage Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Mushroom Pizza Slice $3.95
  • Italian Specialties

  • Cheese Calzone $9.99

    Overstuffed with the finest fresh ingredients. made fresh daily.

  • Sausage & Peppers Roll $9.99

    Sausage, sauteed peppers, and onions with mozzarella cheese and side of marinara sauce.

  • Chicken Roll $9.99

    Bursting with cheese, pepperoni. made fresh daily.

  • Broccoli Roll $9.99

    Broccoli, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, and side of marinara.

  • Spinach Roll $9.99

    Bursting with cheese, pepperoni. made fresh daily.

  • Eggplant Roll $9.99

    Bursting with cheese, eggplant. made fresh daily.

  • Garlic Knots $4.50

    5 oversized and freshly baked garlic knots. made with chopped fresh garlic, olive oil and a sprinkling of parmesan and parsley.

  • Pepperoni Roll $9.99

    Bursting with cheese, pepperoni. made fresh daily.

  • Salads

  • Caesar Salad $10.99

    Romaine lettuce with shaved parmigiana and croutons.

  • Mesclun Salad $8.95

    With gorgonzola cheese.

  • Heros

  • Chicken Parm Hero $8.50
  • Sausage And Peppers Hero $8.50
  • Eggplant Parm Hero $8.50
  • Meatball Parm Hero $8.50
  • Heros

  • Eggplant Parm Hero $10.95
  • Meatball Parm Hero $10.95
  • Sausage And Peppers Hero $10.95
  • Chicken Parm Hero $10.95
  • Italian Specialties

  • Spinach Roll $6.50

    Bursting with cheese, pepperoni. made fresh daily.

  • Sausage And Peppers Roll $6.50

    Sausage, sauteed peppers, and onions with mozzarella cheese and side of marinara sauce.

  • Chicken Roll $6.50

    Bursting with cheese, pepperoni. made fresh daily.

  • Pepperoni Roll $6.50

    Bursting with cheese, pepperoni. made fresh daily.

  • Eggplant Roll $6.50

    Bursting with cheese, eggplant. made fresh daily.

  • Garlic Knots $2.50

    5 pieces.

  • Broccoli Roll $6.50

    Broccoli, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, and side of marinara.

  • Cheese Calzone $6.50

    Overstuffed with the finest fresh ingredients. made fresh daily.

  • Drinks

  • Snapple $3.00

    Snapple

  • Soda (Liter) $5.50

    2 liter.

  • Soda $3.00

    20 oz.

  • Dasani Bottle $2.50

    20 oz.

  • Pasta

  • Penne Alla Vodka $10.95

    Penne pasta, pink vodka sauce with pancetta.

  • Penne With Grill Chicken Broccoli $10.95

    Penne with grill chicken broccoli, garlic, and oil.

  • Baked Ziti Pasta $10.95

    Ziti pasta, tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, and baked mozzarella.

  • Salads

  • Mesclun Salad $8.95

    With gorgonzola cheese.

  • Caesar Salad $6.95

    Romaine lettuce with shaved parmigiana and croutons.

Little Italy Pizza Details

  • Service options

  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Offerings

  • Comfort food
  • Late-night food
  • Quick bite
  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Amenities

  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Crowd

  • Tourists
  • Planning

  • Accepts reservations
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Children

  • Good for kids
  • Parking

  • Paid parking lot
  • Paid street parking

Little Italy Pizza Photos

Little Italy Pizza Picture 1Little Italy Pizza Picture 2Little Italy Pizza Picture 3Little Italy Pizza Picture 4Little Italy Pizza Picture 5Little Italy Pizza Picture 6Little Italy Pizza Picture 7Little Italy Pizza Picture 8Little Italy Pizza Picture 9Little Italy Pizza Picture 10

Little Italy Pizza Location

Little Italy Pizza

958 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

Little Italy Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 817 user reviews.

new york pizzacrustgarlic knotssliceshungrypizza by the slicetomato saucebreadcrumbscornmealsausage

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More restaurants near me

  • Le Cafe CoffeeLe Cafe Coffee4.0 (119 reviews)

    407 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Deshi Street FoodDeshi Street Food5.0 (1 reviews)

    Lexington Ave &, E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • MaguroMaguro4.0 (252 reviews)

    160 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Chote NawabChote Nawab4.0 (904 reviews)

    115 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Anjappar Indian CuisineAnjappar Indian Cuisine4.0 (5993 reviews)

    116 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Fast&Buy Halal FoodFast&Buy Halal Food4.0 (13 reviews)

    50 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Tsumo OmakaseTsumo Omakase4.0 (474 reviews)

    132 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • McDonald'sMcDonald's3.0 (1954 reviews)

    401 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Hill Mary Coffee ShopHill Mary Coffee Shop4.0 (57 reviews)

    118 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Tarallucci e Vino NoMadTarallucci e Vino NoMad4.0 (411 reviews)

    44 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Ground Central Coffee CompanyGround Central Coffee Company4.0 (90 reviews)

    28 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • DhabaDhaba4.0 (1730 reviews)

    108 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Dining Insights Posts