Madison Street Pizza

- 223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002

Introduction / Overview

In the vibrant and historic Lower East Side of Manhattan, a true neighborhood gem is earning a loyal following for its simple, delicious, and authentic approach to a New York staple: pizza. Madison Street Pizza, a women-owned business, offers a taste of classic comfort food in a clean, low-key spot that has a big reputation. This isn't a place with a complicated menu or a trendy gimmick; it’s a place that focuses on what matters most—high-quality ingredients and a dedication to perfecting the craft of pizza making. The result is a memorable experience that feels both genuinely New York and deeply personal.

The menu is straightforward and appealing, featuring classic pies like the 18” Cheese Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza, alongside more unique offerings like the "The Rustic Slice." But the real secret to its success lies in the details. Customers rave about the excellent texture of the crust, a key component of any great pizza. Beyond the pizzas, the menu offers a selection of appetizers, rolls, and calzones, with the Garlic Knots being a particular favorite. The owners and staff, described as incredibly friendly and inviting, create a warm, "mom and pop" atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasure. Whether you're a local resident, a family looking for a quick and easy dinner, or a solo diner grabbing a lunch break, Madison Street Pizza delivers an experience that is consistently praised for its quality, flavor, and wonderful service.

Location and Accessibility

Madison Street Pizza is located at 223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002, USA. This address places it squarely in the heart of the Lower East Side, a neighborhood known for its rich history, diverse culture, and bustling street life. The restaurant is situated in a "lowkey spot," which contributes to its charm as a hidden gem, yet it remains easily accessible. For those traveling by subway, the restaurant is a short walk from several major lines, including the F, M, J, and Z trains, making it a convenient destination from various parts of Manhattan and beyond. This prime location allows locals and visitors to easily grab a slice or a whole pie while exploring the dynamic energy of the neighborhood.

The restaurant's focus on a simple, casual atmosphere makes it a welcoming spot for everyone. It is known for its clean environment and its family-friendly crowd, making it a great place to bring kids for a meal. While specific details on accessibility are not widely publicized, its street-level location and a straightforward setup likely make it an easy stop for most patrons. The convenience of its location, combined with its welcoming atmosphere and focus on quick service, makes it an ideal choice for a variety of dining needs, whether you're looking for a leisurely lunch or a fast dinner on the go.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: Enjoy your pizza in the clean and casual atmosphere of the restaurant. It's a comfortable spot for a quick bite or a full pie with friends and family.

• Takeout: For those on the go, the takeout option is a perfect way to enjoy the delicious pizza at your office, home, or a nearby park.

• Delivery: Madison Street Pizza offers both standard and no-contact delivery, bringing their excellent pizza and other menu items right to your doorstep for a convenient and hassle-free meal.

• Curbside Pickup: For added convenience, curbside pickup is available, allowing you to grab your order quickly without having to leave your vehicle.

Features / Highlights

• Excellent Pizza and Crust: The quality of the pizza is the main highlight. Customers consistently praise the great texture of the crust and the overall excellent flavor of the pies. The attention to detail in the crust makes it stand out from the competition.

• Friendly and Inviting Service: The staff, particularly the owners, are frequently mentioned in reviews for their friendly and welcoming demeanor. This "mom and pop" feel creates a personal and inviting atmosphere that makes customers want to return.

• Delicious Garlic Knots: The Garlic Knots are a standout appetizer that has become a customer favorite. They are described as a must-try item on the menu and a perfect complement to the pizza.

• Women-Owned Business: The restaurant proudly identifies as a women-owned business, contributing to the diverse and dynamic culinary landscape of New York City.

• Casual, Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The clean, low-key, and casual environment makes Madison Street Pizza a great spot for families and groups. It’s a comfortable place to bring kids, and it’s a popular spot for locals who are looking for a reliable, no-fuss meal.

Contact Information

Address: 223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002, USA

Phone: (917) 675-6006

What is worth choosing

Choosing Madison Street Pizza is a choice to support a local, women-owned business that is dedicated to a simple but important mission: making great pizza. The most compelling reason to visit is the quality of the food itself. The rave reviews about the crust's texture and the overall excellence of the pizza are a clear indication that this is not just another pizza joint. It's a place that takes its craft seriously, from the classic Cheese and Pepperoni pies to the more unique Grandma and "The Rustic Slice" options. The pizza is consistently good, which is a rare and valuable quality in a city with so many food options.

Beyond the food, the friendly and inviting service is a major reason to visit. In a city that can sometimes feel impersonal, the warm welcome from the staff, including the owner, makes a huge difference. This personal touch creates a sense of community and makes every customer feel valued. It's the kind of place you'll want to return to, not just for the food, but for the experience. The menu is also a great value, with a variety of classic comfort foods that are perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. For anyone in the Lower East Side looking for an authentic and delicious pizza, a friendly face, and a comfortable atmosphere, Madison Street Pizza is a clear and excellent choice that truly delivers on its promise of a great pizza experience.

Madison Street Pizza

223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002, USA