Magic Bagels Inc

- 194 W Merrick Rd #5512, Valley Stream, NY 11580

For New Yorkers, the bagel is more than just breakfast—it's a way of life. The perfect bagel should have a crisp, chewy exterior and a soft, dense interior, a quality that separates the truly great bagel shops from the rest. Located in the heart of Valley Stream on Long Island, Magic Bagels Inc has established itself as a beloved local spot for residents looking to satisfy their daily bagel craving. This quaint, family-friendly shop offers a compelling menu that extends far beyond the traditional bagel and schmear, providing a quick, tasty, and satisfying experience for those on the go.

Magic Bagels Inc embraces the local, "mom-and-pop shop" atmosphere, providing a friendly and cozy setting where regulars and newcomers alike can start their day. While they focus on the core offerings of fresh bagels and creative spreads, they also feature a variety of other breakfast and lunch items that make it a convenient stop any time of the morning or early afternoon. As a dedicated local business, it aims to be a consistent part of the Valley Stream community’s daily routine, offering reliable quality and a warm welcome to everyone who walks through the door.

The shop’s commitment to providing a wide selection of flavored cream cheeses is a significant part of its appeal, allowing customers to customize their classic New York bagel experience. From traditional spreads to unique, savory, and sweet combinations, Magic Bagels Inc ensures there is a flavor for every palate. When you’re in the Valley Stream area and looking for a local establishment that specializes in the staples of a classic New York breakfast, Magic Bagels Inc is a popular choice for many.

Location and Accessibility

Magic Bagels Inc is strategically situated to serve the Valley Stream community and surrounding areas of Long Island. Its physical location is easily accessible for local residents and those traveling along West Merrick Road.

The shop's address places it in a busy, central area, making it a convenient stop for commuters, locals running errands, or anyone starting their day with a quick breakfast. Operating hours are consistent throughout the week, catering to the early-morning rush and sustaining service well into the afternoon.

Hours of Operation:

The shop maintains consistent hours seven days a week, making it a reliable destination for your daily fix:

• Sunday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM
• Monday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM
• Tuesday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM
• Wednesday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM
• Thursday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM
• Friday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM
• Saturday: 5:30 AM–4:00 PM

These extended morning-to-afternoon hours provide flexibility for customers, whether they are grabbing a bite before work or stopping in for a late lunch.

Services Offered

Magic Bagels Inc offers a broad menu that covers the essentials of a local New York-style bagel shop, catering to both quick takeaway orders and more leisurely dining (though some customer feedback suggests the interior layout can feel crowded). Their menu is built around freshness and variety, ensuring customers have numerous options for both breakfast and lunch.

• Fresh Bagels: Offerings include standard bagels, pumpernickel bagels, and mini bagels in classic flavors such as plain, poppy, sesame, everything, and onion. They also offer bialys.
• Cream Cheese Spreads: A wide and popular variety of flavored cream cheeses sold by the pound, including Plain, Light Plain, Vegetable, Light Vegetable, Olive Scallion, Lox Spread, Jalapeño, and Strawberry cream cheese.
• Muffins & Pastries: A large selection of freshly baked goods such as Blueberry Muffin, Chocolate Chip Muffin, Banana Nut Muffin, Red Velvet Muffin, Raisin Bran Muffin, Corn Muffin, Coffee Cake Muffin, Double Chocolate Muffin, Cranberry Muffin, Croissants, Cheese Danish, Chocolate Danish, Apple Turnover, and Vanilla Crumb Cake. They also carry the classic Black and White Cookie.
• Lunch Sandwiches: The menu features a selection of sandwiches and wraps, including Chicken Salad Sandwich, Tuna Salad Sandwich, Berry Nut Chicken Salad Sandwich, BLT Sandwich, ABLT Sandwich (BLT with avocado), BCLT Wrap (Bacon, grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, avocado), and Veggie Chicken Wrap.
• Smoked Fish Items: They offer lox bagel sandwiches, which are customizable with toppings like onions and avocado, as noted by customer reviews.
• Coffee and Beverages: Iced coffee is one of the available beverage options, noted positively in customer feedback.
• Take-out & Delivery: Customers can place orders for pick-up or delivery through third-party services.
• Payment Options: The location accepts NFC mobile payment and debit cards, offering modern convenience at the register.

Features / Highlights

The strengths of Magic Bagels Inc lie in its culinary focus and dedication to classic bagel shop products, creating a noteworthy spot in the Valley Stream dining scene. The following are key highlights and aspects often mentioned by patrons:

• Extensive Cream Cheese Variety: The shop is highly recognized for its extensive selection of flavored cream cheeses. For instance, the Olive Scallion cream cheese is a particular standout, praised by customers for its generous portion and heavy, authentic olive flavor.
• Freshly Baked Goods: The establishment is centered around freshly made bagels and a wide array of pastries and muffins, ensuring a quality and satisfying morning treat.
• Welcoming Atmosphere and Staff: The staff, described by customers as 'sweet and kind,' contributes to a friendly and 'cozy' mom-and-pop shop ambiance. Patrons have highlighted the staff's positive demeanor as a key factor in their enjoyable experience.
• Beyond Breakfast Staples: While bagels are the main attraction, the menu successfully expands to offer a variety of classic deli salads (like tuna and chicken salad) and lunch sandwiches/wraps, providing options for mid-day meals.
• Customizable Smoked Fish Sandwiches: The lox bagel sandwich is noted as a solid option, and the ability to customize it with fresh toppings like onions and avocado is a definite plus for smoked fish enthusiasts.

Contact Information

For those planning a visit or needing to inquire about orders, here is the direct contact information for Magic Bagels Inc in Valley Stream, NY:

Address: 194 W Merrick Rd #5512, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Phone: (516) 872-8779

Mobile Phone: +1 516-872-8779

What is worth choosing

When looking at what truly sets Magic Bagels Inc apart and makes it a destination in Valley Stream, the answer lies in its dedication to the essentials, particularly its cream cheese selection and commitment to a welcoming environment.

For the adventurous bagel lover, the wide variety of cream cheeses is the main draw. The aforementioned Olive Scallion Cream Cheese is a must-try for savory enthusiasts, celebrated for its rich flavor and generous serving. Similarly, those who enjoy a bit of heat can opt for the Jalapeño Cream Cheese. Sweet options like the Strawberry Cream Cheese also cater to a different taste preference, ensuring that every customer can find their perfect flavor pairing.

If you are looking for a more substantial meal, the Lox Bagel Sandwich is highly recommended by patrons and offers a traditional, fresh, and customizable New York favorite. The variety of Muffins and Pastries also offers excellent value and selection for a sweeter start to the day or an afternoon treat, with options ranging from the classic Blueberry Muffin to a decadent Black and White Cookie.

The professional and friendly service, often described as 'sweet and kind,' solidifies the experience. Despite some noted issues with the shop’s internal temperature and layout, the core product—fresh bagels and creative spreads—remains a strong incentive to visit. The shop successfully operates as a dependable and cheerful local provider of quality breakfast and lunch fare on Long Island.

In summary, for a neighborhood bagel shop that delivers a fresh, tasty bagel and an expansive array of cream cheese flavors in a setting that values a personal touch, Magic Bagels Inc in Valley Stream remains a compelling option for local New Yorkers.

Magic Bagels Inc

194 W Merrick Rd #5512, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA