Dine Droop
Dine DroopDining Insightsrestaurants near me
New York

Dine Drooprestaurants near meNew YorkNew York CountyNew Yorkrestaurants in Amsterdam AvenueMi Casita
Mi Casita ico

Mi Casita
- 1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031

Mexican restaurant, Delivery Restaurant ★3.0 (13)·$10–20

1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

3.0
12$ 8/10 Tinga Tostadas(3); Ingredients were freshly cut and and portion was enough to fill me up. A bit disappointing that the tostadas seem to be the Guerrero ones from the supermarket or those that you buy for 2$ where as other authentic mexican restaurants have them home madeI had a good time here! I stayed for a while due to La Rosa de Guadalupe playing lol and the good environment🌮Back to FOOD, I also had a carnitas Taco🌮Being mexican, I'd say the tortilla was little undercooked to the point of breaking by the last bite, 30 seconds would of made it just the way I like it. If youre not Mexican you probably wont mind🤷‍♂️But! Ingredients were VERY freshBeing that I didnt ask for crispy tortilla, I wont hurt the Tacos grading but I'll give it a 10/10Server was friendly and fast! - David H
Mi Casita Overview Intro Vibe Detail Photos Location Reviews
$10–20 per person Reported by 13 people$1–10$10–20$20–30

Mi Casita Introduce

In the vibrant tapestry of New York City's culinary scene, finding a place that feels like a true "home away from home" is a special discovery. Mi Casita, which translates to "My Little House," perfectly embodies this spirit, serving up authentic Mexican comfort food that warms the soul. Located in a bustling part of the city, this restaurant offers a casual, cozy, and friendly atmosphere that makes you feel welcome from the moment you step inside. It’s the kind of place you’d find in a traditional Mexican neighborhood, with a mom-and-pop shop feel where the food is always fresh and made with care.


Mi Casita is a true neighborhood gem, popular with locals and a destination for tourists seeking a taste of genuine Mexican cuisine. The relaxed vibe and friendly staff create an inviting environment for a solo meal, a family dinner, or a casual lunch with friends. Whether you're craving a hearty breakfast to start your day or a satisfying dinner after a long day of work, Mi Casita has something to offer. The restaurant prides itself on using fresh ingredients, ensuring that every dish, from the simplest taco to the most complex mole, tastes authentic and delicious. It's a place that prioritizes taste and quality over flash, making it a reliable and cherished spot for many New Yorkers.


The commitment to fresh, authentic flavors is what sets Mi Casita apart. It’s not just about serving food; it’s about sharing a piece of Mexican culture and tradition with every plate. The menu is extensive, but each item is crafted with a meticulous attention to detail that you might only find in a family-run establishment. The dedication of the small staff is evident in the taste and presentation of their dishes, and while this might occasionally mean a short wait, it is a wait that is well worth it for the delicious, home-style meal you receive. For anyone in New York looking for a genuine and heartwarming Mexican dining experience, Mi Casita is a top choice.


Location and Accessibility

Mi Casita is located at 1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA, placing it in a bustling and easily accessible part of the city. The restaurant’s address makes it a convenient stop for residents of the surrounding neighborhoods and a worthwhile destination for those coming from farther away. Its location on Amsterdam Avenue is well-served by public transportation, making it simple to get to via bus or subway. For those who live or work nearby, it’s a quick and easy walk to a delicious meal.


The restaurant is designed to be welcoming to a variety of customers. It offers wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring that everyone can comfortably enjoy a meal. The interior, described as casual, cozy, and trendy, provides a comfortable dining environment. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or planning a more relaxed meal, the location and amenities make Mi Casita a practical choice. The central location also means it's a popular spot for tourists who are exploring the area and looking for an authentic and satisfying dining experience away from the more crowded tourist traps.


The combination of a great location and a welcoming atmosphere makes Mi Casita more than just a place to eat; it's a community fixture. Its accessibility and central spot on Amsterdam Avenue mean it is perfectly positioned to serve as a go-to spot for both a daily meal and a special occasion. For anyone in New York seeking a dependable and delightful Mexican restaurant, the convenience of Mi Casita's location is a definite plus.


Services Offered

Mi Casita provides a variety of services designed to meet the needs of its diverse clientele, from quick meals to catering for events.

  • Dine-in and Takeout: Guests can enjoy their meals in the cozy and casual atmosphere of the restaurant, or they can opt for takeout to enjoy their food at home or on the go.

  • Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery services, including no-contact delivery, making it a convenient option for those who prefer to eat in. This service extends its reach to a wider audience, bringing its authentic flavors right to their doorstep.

  • Catering: Mi Casita offers a range of catering options, making it a great choice for parties, gatherings, and events. With a menu of comfort food and crowd-pleasers, it's a dependable source for delicious food for any occasion.

  • Reservations: While it’s a popular spot for walk-ins, Mi Casita accepts reservations. This is a helpful feature for planning a get-together, especially with a larger group, ensuring you have a table when you arrive.

  • Payment Options: The restaurant accepts various modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing a seamless and secure transaction experience.


Features and Highlights

Mi Casita is distinguished by several key features that contribute to its popularity and reputation as a great place to eat.

  • Authentic Mexican Menu: The menu is a highlight, offering a vast selection of authentic Mexican dishes, from classic tacos and enchiladas to lesser-known but equally delicious traditional dishes. The menu covers everything from breakfast to dessert, including homemade items like Flan.

  • Fresh Ingredients: A consistent theme in customer reviews is the freshness of the ingredients. The restaurant prides itself on using freshly cut vegetables and high-quality meats, which shines through in the taste of their food.

  • Fast Service: Despite being a small, family-run establishment, Mi Casita is known for its fast service. This makes it an ideal spot for a quick lunch break or a satisfying meal when you’re short on time.

  • Kid-Friendly: The restaurant is good for kids, offering high chairs and a kids’ menu. The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it a comfortable place for families to dine together.

  • Diverse Offerings: Beyond just Mexican food, the menu includes options like Hamburguesas (hamburgers) and a variety of beverages, including alcohol, cocktails, coffee, and traditional Mexican drinks like Horchata and Jamaica. They also provide healthy options and happy hour food specials.

  • Cozy Atmosphere: The vibe is casual, cozy, and trendy, providing a comfortable and inviting setting. The decor and overall feel contribute to a relaxed dining experience that makes you want to stay a while.


Contact Information

For reservations, takeout, or any inquiries, you can contact Mi Casita using the following details:

  • Address: 1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • Phone: (212) 234-3331


What is Worth Choosing

When deciding where to eat in New York City, Mi Casita offers a compelling choice for several reasons. The first and foremost is the authenticity and quality of the food. Unlike many of the larger chain restaurants, Mi Casita feels like a genuine, family-run establishment where the food is prepared with passion and care. The use of fresh ingredients is a recurring praise from customers, highlighting the kitchen's commitment to quality. Whether you’re ordering a classic taco, a comforting burrito, or one of their traditional Mexican dishes like Mole Rojo de Pollo, you can expect a meal that is both delicious and true to its roots.


The "mom-and-pop shop" vibe is a major part of its appeal. It's a place that feels welcoming and unpretentious. The service is friendly and fast, making it an excellent option for a quick bite without sacrificing quality. The casual and cozy atmosphere is perfect for a relaxed meal, whether you're dining alone or with a group. This friendly environment, combined with the diverse and extensive menu, means there is always something to satisfy any craving. From breakfast to dinner, the restaurant's offerings are consistently satisfying and comforting.


Additionally, Mi Casita’s value is worth noting. The prices are reasonable, and the portions are generous, providing excellent bang for your buck. For a city known for its high dining costs, finding a place that offers such quality and authenticity at a fair price is a significant win. The fact that they also offer delivery and takeout adds a layer of convenience that makes their delicious food accessible even when you don't feel like dining out. In a city full of options, Mi Casita stands out as a reliable, authentic, and heartwarming choice that truly lives up to its name, making it a worthwhile visit for any New Yorker seeking a taste of real Mexican home cooking.

Mi Casita Vibe

  • Desayunos

    Served with rice, beans and corn tortillas.

  • Omelette con Pimiento Verde, Rojo, Tomate, Cebolla y Chorizo $6.50

    Omelette served with green pepper, red pepper, tomato, onion and chorizo.

  • Huevos y Jamon con Papas Fritas $6.50

    Eggs and ham with French fries.

  • Huevos con Tocino y Papas Fritas $6.50

    Eggs with bacon and French fries.

  • Huevos con Salchicha y Papas $6.50

    Eggs with sausage and fries.

  • Huevos en Salsa Verde $6.00

    Scrambled eggs with red sauce.

  • Huevos en Salsa Roja $6.00

    Scrambled eggs with green sauce.

  • Huevos a la Mexicana $6.50

    Scrambled eggs with tomatoes, onion and jalapeno.

  • Huevos al Gusto $6.00

    Egg any style, with yellow American cheese, ham or chorizo.

  • Huevos con Cecina $7.50

    Eggs any style with salted beef.

  • Huevos Rancheros $7.50

    Two eggs sunny side up with guacamole, pico de gallo, y queso blanco on a lightly fried corn tortilla.

  • Salad (Ensalada)

    All salads are with olive oil.

  • Ensalada De La Casa (House Salad) $7.50

    Served with lettuce, onions, peppers, tomatoes, carrots and avocado.

  • Ensalad De Pollo Asado (Grilled Chicken Salad) $10.00

    With lettuce, onions, peppers, tomatoes, carrots.

  • Pollo Asado Ensalada (Grilled Chicken Breast Salad) $10.50
  • Ensalada de Camaron (Shrimp Salad) $14.00
  • Ensalada con Bistec (Steak Salad) $11.00
  • Enchiladas

    3 soft corn tortilla rolled stuffed with meal and green mole sauce topped with cotija cheese and sour cream. Served with rice and beans.

  • Enchiladas Rojas con Pollo $11.00

    Enchiladas with red sauce with chicken.

  • Enchiladas Verde con Pollo $11.00

    Enchiladas with green sauce with chicken.

  • Enchiladas Rojas con Puerco $11.00

    Enchiladas with red sauce with pork.

  • Enchiladas Verde con Puerco $11.00

    Enchiladas with green sauce with pork.

  • Enchiladas Rojas con Bistec $11.50

    Enchiladas with red sauce and steak.

  • Enchiladas Verdes con Bistec $11.50

    Enchiladas with green sauce and steak.

  • Enchiladas de Camaron $15.00

    Shrimp enchiladas.

  • Enchilada de Cecina $13.00

    Enchiladas with salted beef.

  • Enchiladas Rojas (Plain) $9.00
  • Enchiladas Rojas (Plain) $9.00
  • Tacos

    Corn tortilla stuffed with onions, cilantro, tomatoes and your choice of meat.

  • Al Pastor Taco $3.00

    Pork marinated with pineapple and onions.

  • Pollo (Chicken) Taco $3.00
  • Vegetales Taco $3.00
  • Carne Enchilada (Spicy Pork Meat) Taco $3.00
  • Chorizo (Mexican Sausage) Taco $3.00
  • Carnitas (Shredded Pork) Taco $3.00
  • Cecina (Salted Beef) Taco $3.00
  • Bistec (Steak) Taco $3.00
  • Lengua (Beef Tongue) Taco $3.50
  • Typical Mexican Dishes

    Served with rice, beans and corn tortilla and hot sauce. Extras (Optional - Choose up to 5): Extra Creme (Sour Cream) - $0.50, Extra Guacamole - $1.50, Pico de Gallo - $0.50, Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) - $1, Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) - $1.

  • Mole Rojo de Pollo $11.95

    Dark or white meat chicken with sweet and spicy ancho and poblano chili.

  • Molo Verde de Pollo $11.95

    Dark or white meat chicken with sweet and spicy ancho and tomatillo.

  • Mole Rojo de Puerco $11.95

    Pork with sweet and spicy ancho and poblano chili.

  • Molo Verde de Puerco $11.95

    Pork with sweet and spicy ancho and tomatillo.

  • Pipian de Pollo $11.50

    Pumpkin seed sauce with dark or white meat chicken.

  • Pipian de Puerco $11.50

    A thick and spicy guajillo chili sauce with chicken.

  • Chile ajo de Pureco $11.50

    A thick and spicy guajillo chili sauce with pork.

  • Chili ajo de Pollo $11.50

    A thick and spicy guajillo chili sauce with chicken.

  • MIlanese de Pollo $11.00

    Breaded breast of chicken milanese served with rice, beans and a corn tortilla.

  • Bistec a la Mexicana $12.50

    Mexican style steak with onion, tomatoes and sliced jalapenos.

  • Carne Asada (Pounded Grilled Steak) $12.50
  • Bistec Encebollado $12.50

    Pounded grilled steak.

  • Chuletas de Puerco al Gusto $12.50

    Grilled or sauteed pork chops with mole sauce or green salsa.

  • Pechuga a la Mexicana $12.50

    Con salsa de tomate, arroz y frijoles. Chicken with tomato sauce, rice and beans.

  • Chile Relleno de Queso $11.00

    Cheese stuffed poblano pepper with rice, beans and corn tortillas.

  • Pollo a la Parmellana $12.00

    Con salsa de tomate, arroz y frijoles. Chicken with tomato sauce, rice and beans.

  • Pollo Chipotle $13.00

    Pollo blando (pechuga) y salsa picante. Tender chicken breast and hot sauce.

  • Hamburguesas (Hamburgers)

  • Cheeseburger $4.50
  • Cheeseburger Superior $6.50

    Served with French fries and salad.

  • Cheeseburger Al Estilo Mexicano $7.00

    Served with French fries, salad and jalapenos.

  • Tostadas - Fried Corn Tortilla

    3 crispy flat corn tortilla layered with beans, onions, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, sour cream. Extras: Extra Creme (Sour Cream) - $0.50, Extra Guacamole - $1.50, Pico de Gallo - $0.50, Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) - $1, Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) - $1.

  • Tostada sin Carne $8.00

    Without meat.

  • Vegetales (Veggie) Tostada $10.50
  • Pollo (Chicken) Tostada $10.50
  • Tinga De Pollo Tostada $10.50

    Shredded chicken in a chipotle tomato and onion sauce.

  • Carnitas (Shredded Pork) Tostada $10.50
  • Chorizo (Mexican Sausage) Tostada $10.50
  • Cecina (Salted Beef) Tostada $12.00
  • Al Pastor Tostada $12.00

    Pork marinated with pineapple and onions.

  • Bistec (Steak) Tostada $12.00
  • Tortas - Mexican Sandwich

    All sandwiches served with beans, tomatoes, lettuce, onions, avocado, quesso cheddar and pickle.

  • MIlanesa de Pollo Torta $7.50

    Breaded chicken breast.

  • Pollo Asado Torta $7.50

    Grilled chicken.

  • Tinga de Pollo Torta $7.50

    Shredded chicken in a chipotle tomato and onion sauce.

  • Carnitas Torta $7.50

    Shredded pork.

  • Cecina Torta $7.00

    Salted beef.

  • Chorizo y Huevo Torta $7.50

    Mexican sausage and scrambled eggs.

  • Carne Enchilada Torta $7.50

    Spicy pork meat.

  • Queso Fundido Y Jamon Torta $7.50

    Melted mozzarella cheese and ham.

  • Steak and Cheese Torta $7.50

    Served with mozzarella cheese.

  • Burritos

    Soft flour tortilla rolled and stuffed with rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream, mozzarella cheese, guacamole and choice of meat. Extra Creme (Sour Cream) - $0.50, Extra Guacamole - $1.50, Pico de Gallo - $0.50, Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) - $1, Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) - $1.

  • Bistec (Steak) Burrito (12") $9.95
  • Pollo a la Brasa (Grilled Chicken Breast) Burrito (12") $9.95
  • Carnitas Burrito (12") $8.95

    Shredded pork.

  • Camaron (Shrimp) Burrito (12") $12.00
  • Queso Fundido (Melted Cheese) Burrito (12") $8.50
  • Pollo Con Mole Burrito (12") $11.50

    Spicy chicken with red mole sauce.

  • Camaron (Shrimp) Burrito (12") $12.00
  • Vegetariano Burrito (12") $9.50
  • Tinga Burrito (12") $8.50

    Shredded chicken in tomato and onion chipotle sauce.

  • Burrito de Huevo Revuelto (12") $8.50

    Scrambled eggs burrito.

  • Camaron (Shrimp) Burrito (12") $12.00
  • Vegetariano Burrito (12") $9.50
  • Tinga Burrito (12") $8.50

    Shredded chicken in tomato and onion chipotle sauce.

  • Burrito de Huevo Revuelto (12") $8.50

    Scrambled eggs burrito.

  • Burrito Al Pastor (12") $10.00

    Pork marinated meat with pineapple and onions.

  • Pollo (Chicken) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Chorizo (Sausage) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Bistec (Steak) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Carnitas (Shredded Pork) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Vegetariano (Vegetarian) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Carne Enchilada y Al Pastor Burrito (10") $6.50

    Spicy meat and roasted pork.

  • Side Orders

  • Papas Fritas (French Fries) $3.00
  • Guacamole with Chips $8.00
  • Tortilla Chips and Salsa $3.50
  • Chile en Vinagre (Pickled Jalapenos) (8oz) $2.00
  • Crema (Sour Cream) (8oz) $2.00
  • Arroz (Yellow Rice) (32 oz) $8.00
  • Frijol (Black Beans) (32 oz) $10.00
  • Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) $3.00
  • Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) $3.00
  • Arroz (Yellow Rice) (8 oz) $2.50
  • Frijol (Black Beans) (8 oz) $2.50
  • Dessert

  • Flan (Homemade) $3.50
  • Cheese Cake $4.00
  • Bebidas (Drinks)

  • Horchata $3.50
  • Seltzer $2.00
  • Sidral $2.00

    Mexican apple soda.

  • Sodas $1.25

    Choice of Coke, Diet Coke, Gingerale or Sprite.

  • Bottled Water $2.00
  • Jamaica $3.50
  • Sangria $2.00
  • Jarritos $2.00

    Choice of pineapple, grapefruit, tamarind or mandarin.

  • Jumex (Mexican Juice) $2.00
  • Sour Cream (8 oz) $2.00

Mi Casita Details

  • Service options

  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Popular for

  • Breakfast
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Happy hour food
  • Healthy options
  • Quick bite
  • Wine
  • Dining options

  • Breakfast
  • Brunch
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Trendy
  • Crowd

  • Tourists
  • Planning

  • Accepts reservations
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Children

  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu

Mi Casita Photos

Mi Casita Picture 1Mi Casita Picture 2Mi Casita Picture 3Mi Casita Picture 4Mi Casita Picture 5Mi Casita Picture 6Mi Casita Picture 7Mi Casita Picture 8Mi Casita Picture 9Mi Casita Picture 10

Mi Casita Location

Mi Casita

1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

Mi Casita Reviews

An average rating of ★3.6 from 123 user reviews.

pricetacosbeanstortillatostadasdeliveryhometortasteaksalsa

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More restaurants near me

  • El Paisano Mexican FoodEl Paisano Mexican Food4.0 (27 reviews)

    700 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Plum Vietnamese RestaurantPlum Vietnamese Restaurant4.0 (375 reviews)

    210 W 94th St, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • 94 Corner Cafe94 Corner Cafe4.0 (275 reviews)

    2518 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Mila CafeMila Cafe4.0 (379 reviews)

    694 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Dunkin'Dunkin'3.0 (271 reviews)

    687 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • 4 Corners Marketplace4 Corners Marketplace3.0 (14 reviews)

    2501 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Patis BakeryPatis Bakery4.0 (205 reviews)

    676 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Shawarma ShabaziShawarma Shabazi4.0 (430 reviews)

    668B Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • The Coffee PlaceThe Coffee Place5.0 (11 reviews)

    2496 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Gennaro RestaurantGennaro Restaurant4.0 (487 reviews)

    Gennaro Restaurant, 665 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • New AsiaNew Asia3.0 (167 reviews)

    666 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Billyu2019s Hot Dog CartBillyu2019s Hot Dog Cart4.0 (1910 reviews)

    327 Central Prk W #63, New York, NY 10025, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Dining Insights Posts