Papa's Pizza: Farmingdale's Destination for Authentic New York & Gourmet Italian Food

Papa’s Pizza Introduce

Introduction / Overview: Bringing Legit New York Pizza to Long Island

For New Yorkers on Long Island, the search for truly authentic, top-tier pizza often feels like an endless quest. Papa’s Pizza in Farmingdale puts an end to that search, delivering a quality of pizza and Italian cuisine that has earned it high praise from even the most seasoned local food critics. Described by one lifelong Queens resident as a contender for the best pizzeria on the Island—and possibly even better than established city favorites—Papa’s Pizza is a certified local gem.

Operating as both a dedicated Pizza restaurant and a full-service Italian restaurant, Papa’s offers far more than just your standard slice. Its menu is a massive celebration of Italian-American comfort food, ranging from the familiar Neapolitan Plain Pie and Sicilian Slice to an array of creative, gourmet specialty pizzas like the Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. This expansive selection ensures there’s a perfect option for every taste and craving, whether you’re looking for a Quick bite or a full three-course family meal.

Beyond the dough and cheese, Papa's excels in full Italian catering and dining, featuring generous portions of classic Entrees, Baked Pastas, and Heroes. This commitment to variety, coupled with an atmosphere that is Casual and welcoming to Family-friendly crowds and Groups, makes Papa’s Pizza a premier dining destination in Farmingdale.

Location and Accessibility: Conveniently Located on Merritts Road

Papa’s Pizza is ideally situated at 199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA, making it easily accessible for locals across the Farmingdale community and for anyone passing through Long Island's Nassau/Suffolk border region. The restaurant is strategically located to accommodate both quick in-and-out service and comfortable dine-in experiences.

Accessibility and convenience are prioritized, ensuring that all patrons can enjoy their services without hassle:

Parking: Guests benefit from both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, eliminating one of the common headaches of dining out in the New York metropolitan area.
Mobility: The establishment is committed to universal access, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating.
Technology & Amenities: For convenience, the restaurant offers Wi-Fi and accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Whether you’re stopping by for the popular Lunch Special or ordering a massive family meal, this Farmingdale location offers the perfect blend of easy access and welcoming amenities.

Services Offered

Papa’s Pizza is a full-service Italian eatery offering comprehensive options for dining and catering:

On-Site Dining: Offers comfortable Seating for Dine-in meals, as well as Counter service and accepts Reservations for groups.
Takeout and Delivery: Provides standard Takeout and Delivery, including No-contact delivery and Curbside pickup for maximum safety and convenience.
Extensive Catering: Offers specialized Catering and discounted large-format specials like the BIG GAME SPECIAL and HALFTIME SPECIAL, perfect for parties and events.
Meal Availability: Open for Lunch and Dinner, suitable for solo dining or large family outings.
Family Accommodations: Clearly Good for kids, featuring High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu with options like the Kenzie Special - Chkn Fingers & Fries and various pasta dishes.

Features / Highlights

What sets Papa’s Pizza apart in the competitive Long Island market is its depth of menu and commitment to fulfilling modern dietary needs without sacrificing flavor:

Specialized Dietary Options: Papa's has earned rave reviews for its Cauliflower Pizza crust, which is perfect for Keto-Friendly or low-carb diets. They offer a specialty Cauliflower W/ Vodka pie, demonstrating their commitment to gourmet dietary alternatives.
The 'Slice' Experience: They offer one of the most comprehensive Pizza By The Slice menus on the Island, allowing you to sample everything from the Regular Slice and Grandma Slice to unique options like Rigatoni Ala Vodka Slice and Chk Bacon Ranch Slice.
Authentic Italian Entrees: The kitchen delivers a full range of high-quality Italian main courses, including numerous chicken dishes like Chicken Alla Vodka, Chicken Francese, and Chicken Parmigiana, alongside classic Veal and Seafood options such as Shrimp Scampi.
Diverse Small Bites & Appetizers: The appetizer menu is robust, featuring classics like Baked Clams (8) and Mozzarella Sticks (6), as well as unique items like Drunken Eggplant Parmigiana App and the sampler platter.
Value and Convenience: The menu offers tremendous value, notably with the Lunch Special ($7.00) and a wide selection of generously sized Heroes and Rolls & Pinwheels that make for perfect, affordable take-out meals.

Contact Information

To place your next order for delivery or takeout, or to inquire about catering options for your next event, please use the following contact details:

Address: 199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA

Phone: (516) 586-5600

What is Worth Choosing Papa’s Pizza

For New York locals, particularly those on Long Island, Papa's Pizza is the clear choice when you need a pizzeria that delivers both quality and versatility. It is worth choosing because it truly excels in three key areas critical to the local New York palate.

Firstly, the authenticity of the pizza is undeniable. Whether you opt for the thin, classic Neapolitan Plain Pie or the thicker Brooklyn Upside Down Sicilian, the quality of the crust, sauce, and cheese is considered by local patrons to be "legit" and even superior to many city staples. For anyone who moved out East but still craves that classic taste, Papa's is your new home.

Secondly, Papa’s is exceptionally accommodating to modern lifestyles and dietary restrictions. The enthusiasm from customers on specialized diets, like those following Keto who praised the Cauliflower Pizza with Alfredo Sauce, highlights the kitchen's ability to innovate and provide delicious options without compromising flavor. This inclusive approach ensures that no one has to miss out on the phenomenal food.

Lastly, the menu depth guarantees satisfaction for any need, from a solo lunch to a major family dinner. Where else can you grab a Chicken Parm Slice, a Philly Chz Stk Hero, and a generous Baked Sampler for the table? Add in the multiple available Superbowl and party specials, and Papa’s Pizza becomes the most practical and flavorful option for all your Italian food needs in the Farmingdale area.

Papa’s Pizza Food & drink

Pizza By The Slice
Regular Slice $2.99
Sicilian Slice $3.50
Grandma Slice $3.50
Margarita $3.95
Buffalo Slice $5.06
Garlic Knots $2.76
Beef Patty $3.25
BBQ Slice $5.06
White Slice $4.60
Chk Bacon Ranch Slice $5.06
Rigatoni Ala Vodka Slice $5.06
Lunch Special $7.00
Chicken Caesar Slice $5.48
Garlic Knots (1) $0.46
Upside Down Slice $3.68
Vodka G'ma $3.68
Veggie Slice $5.48
Vodk/Toni/H/H/Slice $5.06
Chicken Parm Slice $5.06
Chx Broccoli Slice $5.25
Meat Lovers $5.59

Rolls & Pinwheels
Chicken Roll $7.95
Buffa Chk Roll $8.95
Sausage & Pepper Roll $8.25
Cheese Calzone $8.95
Pepperoni Pinwheel $3.00
Spinach Pinwheel $3.00
Philly CH Stk Pw $3.91
Spin/Artick Pw $3.68
Mini Panini $3.23
Mini Rice Ball $2.95
Pepperoni Roll $8.95
Eggplant Roll $8.50

Pizzas
Neapolitan Plain Pie $10.95
With cheese and sauce
Sicilian Pie $22.95
Thick crust, homemade Sicilian sauce and mozzarella
Grandma Pizza $22.95
Thin crust, famous homemade grandma sauce, mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil and basil
Margarita Pizza $13.95
Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, garlic and basil
Cauliflower Pizza $12.95
Brooklyn Upside Down Sicilian $23.95
Mozzarella cheese on the bottom, sauce on top, topped off with pecorino romano, fresh oregano and extra virgin olive oil
Cauliflower W/ Vodka $14.95
White Pizza $13.95
Neapolitan pie topped with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese
BBQ Chicken Pizza $14.95
Topped with BBQ chicken and mozzarella cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $14.95
Topped with hot buffalo chicken and cheese
Meat Lovers Pizza $15.95
Topped with sausage, bacon, meatballs, pepperoni, and cheese
Chicken Caesar Pizza $15.95
Topped with romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, creamy Caesar dressing, and grated parmesan
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $14.95
Mozzarella cheese, maple grazed bacon and chopped tomatoes topped with cheddar and ranch dressing
Grandma Vodka $26.95
Sicilian Vodka $26.95
Primavera $14.95
Pizza Alla Vodka $12.95
VODKA SAUCE AND CHEESE
Crostino Pie $29.95
Homemade Garlic Grandma style crust. Topped with Fresh Mozz, sliced tomatoes and fresh basil. Drizzled with Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza $14.95
Rigatoni, homemade vodka sauce and mozzarella
Baked Ziti Pizza $13.95
Topped with penne pasta mixed with tomato sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese
Hawaiian Pizza $14.95
Topped with ham, pineapple, and cheese
Chicken Parm $14.95
Chicken & Broccoli $14.95
Topped with mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, and cheese
Deep Dish $22.95
Chicken Marsala $15.95
Chicken Francese $15.95
Spinach&Artichoke $15.95
Vodka Pie $13.95
Super Deluxe $15.95
Grill Chin Pie $26.95

Heroes
Chkn Parm Hero $11.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Chkn Vodka Parm $12.95
Creamy vodka sauce, breaded chicken, and melted mozzarella cheese
Mtbll Parm Hero $10.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Sausg & Ppr Hero $11.95
Eggplant Parm Hero $10.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Veal Parm Hero $12.95
Sausg Parm $11.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Chicken Milanese $10.95
Sausg & PPR Parm $12.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Papa's Favorite $12.95
Grilled chicken, broccoli rabe and melted fresh mozzarella
Shrimp Parm Hero $12.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Chicken Club Hero $12.95
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayo
Italian Hero $12.95
Salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, red onions, and Italian dressing
Potato & Egg Hero $10.50
Philly Chz Stk $11.95
Chick Milanesa $10.95
Peppers & Eggs Hero $10.95

Soups & Salads
Chicken Soup $7.00
Pasta Fagioli $7.00
Minestrone $7.00
Lentil Soup $7.00
Caesar Salad $10.95
Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, and parmesan cheese served with creamy Caesar dressing
House Salad $9.95
Iceberg/romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onions, shaved carrots, and olives served with Italian dressing on the side
Greek Salad $11.95
Iceberg/romaine lettuce, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, roasted red peppers, red onions, kalamata olives, served with house Greek dressing
Buffalo Chicken Salad $13.95
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, olives, red onions with buffalo fried chicken
Parma Salad $13.95
Cold Antipasto $14.95
Garden salad with salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella provolone, and roasted red peppers with balsamic vinaigrette
Stracciatella $7.00
Tortellini $7.00
Side Salad $5.95

Appetizers
Baked Clams (8) $12.95
Fried Calamari $13.95
Bruschetta $9.95
Mozzarella Sticks (6) $8.00
Drunken Eggplant Parmigiana App $11.95
Vodka cream sauce and melted mozzarella
Chicken Fingers W/ Fries $14.95
Wings $9.95
Hot, Medium, Mild or BBQ
Eggplant Rollatine App (2) $11.95
Fried Zucchini $9.95
French Fries $3.75
With melted mozzarella add 2.00
Mini Riceballs (3) $8.95
Fried Ravioli (6) $11.95
Italian Fries $4.99
Straight cut fries topped with parmesan cheese and garlic
Papas Sampler $16.95
3 mozzarella sticks, 3 zucchini sticks, fried calamari, fried ravioli, marinara sauce
Mozzarella Caprese App $12.95
Layered fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers and basil with balsamic glaze
Garlic Knots $2.76
Garlic Knots (1) $0.46
Garlic Knots W/Cheese & Sauce $3.95
Garlic Bread $3.95

Paninis & Wraps
House Panini $9.95
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce and tomato
Mulberry Street Panini $10.95
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, fried eggplant, roasted pepper, and red onion
Chicken BLT Wrap $11.95
Fried chicken, bacon, mayo, romaine lettuce, tomatoes and melted mozzarella
Italian Wrap $11.95
Genoa salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes with dressing
Classic Wrap $10.95
Grilled chicken, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes with ranch dressing
Chicken Caesar Wrap $11.95
Romaine lettuce, grated cheese, and grilled chicken with Caesar dressing
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Panini $10.95
Potat/Eggs/Mozz Wrap $10.95
Chik BLT Panini $10.95
Srimp Wrap $13.95
Beef Wrap $12.95
Buff Chin Wrap $12.95
Bruschetta Wrap $11.95
Chicken W/ Sauce Panini W/ G O T $11.95

Entrees
Chicken Parmigiana $22.95
Breaded chicken, sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Chicken Francese $22.95
Egg battered chicken in a lemon butter white wine sauce
Chicken Alla Vodka $23.95
Breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, creamy vodka sauce
Chicken Marsala $22.95
Seared chicken and sautéed mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce
Chicken Bruschetta $23.95
Fried chicken, topped with tomato, red onion, and fresh mozzarella tossed in balsamic and oil
Chicken Verdi $23.95
Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, broccoli, and mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Rollatine (3) $19.95
Pieces of fried eggplant, rolled with seasoned ricotta and romano cheese, topped with sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Parmigiana $18.95
Fried eggplant, sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Veal Parmigiana $23.95
Breaded veal, homemade sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese
Gr Chk W/Veg $23.95
Grilled chicken with sautéed spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, tomato, and roasted pepper
Gr Chk/Broc Rabe $23.95
Served with pasta or salad
Chicken Cacciatore $23.95
Sautéed chicken, tomato, mushrooms, onions, and peppers
Chicken Jennifer $24.95
Chicken Tower $25.95
Chicken Piccata $23.95
Seared chicken, capers, and artichoke hearts in a lemon butter white wine sauce
Meatballs Parm $23.95
Chicken Scarpariello $24.95
Sautéed chicken, Italian sausage, sweet bell peppers, onions, roasted potatoes, rosemary reduction (no pasta on side)
Sausages Parm $22.95
Veal Francese $24.95
Chicken Sorrentino $23.95
Seared chicken, topped with prosciutto, eggplant, and fresh mozzarella in a marsala wine sauce
Veal Marsala $24.95
Veal Piccata $24.95
Tender pan seared veal sautéed with capers in a light wine lemon sauce
Veal Sorentino $25.95
Veal Marsala (Copy) $24.95

Sides
Side Tomato Sauce (4 Oz) $0.50
Side Marinara (4 Oz) $1.00
S/O Fried Chkn $7.95
S/O GR Chkn $7.95
Side Sautéed Broccoli $7.95
Side Sausage (3) $7.95
Large Pizza Dough $5.00
Side Sautéed Spinach $7.95
To Stay
Side Meatballs (3) $7.95
Side Broccoli Rabe $10.95
Side Of Pasta $6.95
Pint Vodka $7.95
Pint Mozz $4.00
Small Pizza Dough $3.00
Side Grated Cheese (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Garlic (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Ranch (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Bleu Cheese (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Buffalo (4 Oz) $1.00
Side BBQ (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Vodka 4 Onz $2.00
Side Caesar Dressing (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Red Pepper Flakes (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Oregano $1.00
Forks Knives And Napkins
Pint Tomate Sauce $3.95

Pastas
Spaghetti $9.95
Penne $9.95
Rigatone $9.95
Linguini $9.95
Fettuccine $9.95
Capellini $9.95
Cheese Raviole $11.45

Baked Pastas
Baked Ziti $13.95
Baked Ziti W/Meatballs $16.95
Baked Ravioli $14.95
Meat Lasagna $16.95
Homemade!
Manicotti $14.95
Stuffed Shells (4) $14.95
Baked Sampler $18.95
Stuffed shells(2), cheese ravioli (2), manicotti (2) in tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella
1/2 Order Bak/Ziti $9.95
Labter Ravili $21.95
Bake Ziti Siciliano $15.95

Seafood
Fried Calamari $21.95
Calamari Marinara $21.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Fra Diavolo $22.95
Shrimp. baby clams, and spicy marinara sauce over pasta
Shrimp Francaise $22.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Marinara (6) $22.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Oreganata $22.95
Shrimp Parmigiana $22.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Scampi $22.95
Served over pasta
Calamari Marinara $21.95

Kids Menu
Kenzie Special - Chkn Fingers & Fries $10.95
4 Chicken fingers and fries served with ketchup
Kids Spa W/Meatball (2) $9.95
Small portion of spaghetti with two meatballs
Kids Spag In Butter $8.95
Small portion of spaghetti in butter
Kids Ravioli W/Tomato Sauce (3) $8.95
Kids Spag W/ Tomate $8.95
Kids Spag W/ Chiken $10.95

Desserts
NY Cheesecake $5.00
Cannoli $4.95
Sugar Knots (6) $4.00
Carrot Cake $5.00
Oreo Cake $5.00
Fried Oreos 6 $6.95

Ice's
Ice $2.76
Ice Cream $3.50
Truffle $5.25
Sundae $3.91

PREPS
Mozz $1.50
Tomato $1.00
Red Onions $1.00
Lettuce $1.00
Rstd Pepper $1.50
Extra Olives $1.00
White Onion $1.00
Mushroom $1.00
Sm Broc $2.00
Lg Broc $3.50
On Side
Mayo

Superbowl
FIRST DOWN $35.00
1 LARGE PIE, 12 WINGS 2 LITER SODA
KICKOFF $65.00
2 LARGE REG PIES, 16 WINGS, 12 GARLIC KNOTS, 2 LITER SODA
BIG GAME SPECIAL $69.00
1 LARGE PIE, 1 SIC OR GMA PIE, 12 GK OR SK, 16 WINGS AND 1 2 LITER SODS
HALFTIME SPECIAL $100.00
1 REG, SIC OR GMA PIE. 1/2 TRAY WINGS, 1/2 TRAY MINI PANINI SLIDERS

Pizza By The Slice
Regular Slice $2.99
Sicilian Slice $3.50
Grandma Slice $3.50
Margarita $3.95
Buffalo Slice $5.06
Garlic Knots $2.76
Beef Patty $3.25
BBQ Slice $5.06
White Slice $4.60
Chk Bacon Ranch Slice $5.06
Rigatoni Ala Vodka Slice $5.06
Lunch Special $7.00
Chicken Caesar Slice $5.48
Garlic Knots (1) $0.46
Upside Down Slice $3.68
Vodka G'ma $3.68
Veggie Slice $5.48
Vodk/Toni/H/H/Slice $5.06
Chicken Parm Slice $5.06
Chx Broccoli Slice $5.25
Meat Lovers $5.59

Rolls & Pinwheels
Chicken Roll $7.95
Buffa Chk Roll $8.95
Sausage & Pepper Roll $8.25
Cheese Calzone $8.95
Pepperoni Pinwheel $3.00
Spinach Pinwheel $3.00
Philly CH Stk Pw $3.91
Spin/Artick Pw $3.68
Mini Panini $3.23
Mini Rice Ball $2.95
Pepperoni Roll $8.95
Eggplant Roll $8.50

Pizzas
Neapolitan Plain Pie $10.95
With cheese and sauce
Sicilian Pie $22.95
Thick crust, homemade Sicilian sauce and mozzarella
Grandma Pizza $22.95
Thin crust, famous homemade grandma sauce, mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil and basil
Margarita Pizza $13.95
Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, garlic and basil
Cauliflower Pizza $12.95
Brooklyn Upside Down Sicilian $23.95
Mozzarella cheese on the bottom, sauce on top, topped off with pecorino romano, fresh oregano and extra virgin olive oil
Cauliflower W/ Vodka $14.95
White Pizza $13.95
Neapolitan pie topped with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese
BBQ Chicken Pizza $14.95
Topped with BBQ chicken and mozzarella cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $14.95
Topped with hot buffalo chicken and cheese
Meat Lovers Pizza $15.95
Topped with sausage, bacon, meatballs, pepperoni, and cheese
Chicken Caesar Pizza $15.95
Topped with romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, creamy Caesar dressing, and grated parmesan
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $14.95
Mozzarella cheese, maple grazed bacon and chopped tomatoes topped with cheddar and ranch dressing
Grandma Vodka $26.95
Sicilian Vodka $26.95
Primavera $14.95
Pizza Alla Vodka $12.95
VODKA SAUCE AND CHEESE
Crostino Pie $29.95
Homemade Garlic Grandma style crust. Topped with Fresh Mozz, sliced tomatoes and fresh basil. Drizzled with Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza $14.95
Rigatoni, homemade vodka sauce and mozzarella
Baked Ziti Pizza $13.95
Topped with penne pasta mixed with tomato sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese
Hawaiian Pizza $14.95
Topped with ham, pineapple, and cheese
Chicken Parm $14.95
Chicken & Broccoli $14.95
Topped with mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, and cheese
Deep Dish $22.95
Chicken Marsala $15.95
Chicken Francese $15.95
Spinach&Artichoke $15.95
Vodka Pie $13.95
Super Deluxe $15.95
Grill Chin Pie $26.95

Heroes
Chkn Parm Hero $11.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Chkn Vodka Parm $12.95
Creamy vodka sauce, breaded chicken, and melted mozzarella cheese
Mtbll Parm Hero $10.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Sausg & Ppr Hero $11.95
Eggplant Parm Hero $10.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Veal Parm Hero $12.95
Sausg Parm $11.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Chicken Milanese $10.95
Sausg & PPR Parm $12.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Papa's Favorite $12.95
Grilled chicken, broccoli rabe and melted fresh mozzarella
Shrimp Parm Hero $12.95
Contains Tomato Sauce
Chicken Club Hero $12.95
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayo
Italian Hero $12.95
Salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, red onions, and Italian dressing
Potato & Egg Hero $10.50
Philly Chz Stk $11.95
Chick Milanesa $10.95
Peppers & Eggs Hero $10.95

Soups & Salads
Chicken Soup $7.00
Pasta Fagioli $7.00
Minestrone $7.00
Lentil Soup $7.00
Caesar Salad $10.95
Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, and parmesan cheese served with creamy Caesar dressing
House Salad $9.95
Iceberg/romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onions, shaved carrots, and olives served with Italian dressing on the side
Greek Salad $11.95
Iceberg/romaine lettuce, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, roasted red peppers, red onions, kalamata olives, served with house Greek dressing
Buffalo Chicken Salad $13.95
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, olives, red onions with buffalo fried chicken
Parma Salad $13.95
Cold Antipasto $14.95
Garden salad with salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella provolone, and roasted red peppers with balsamic vinaigrette
Stracciatella $7.00
Tortellini $7.00
Side Salad $5.95

Appetizers
Baked Clams (8) $12.95
Fried Calamari $13.95
Bruschetta $9.95
Mozzarella Sticks (6) $8.00
Drunken Eggplant Parmigiana App $11.95
Vodka cream sauce and melted mozzarella
Chicken Fingers W/ Fries $14.95
Wings $9.95
Hot, Medium, Mild or BBQ
Eggplant Rollatine App (2) $11.95
Fried Zucchini $9.95
French Fries $3.75
With melted mozzarella add 2.00
Mini Riceballs (3) $8.95
Fried Ravioli (6) $11.95
Italian Fries $4.99
Straight cut fries topped with parmesan cheese and garlic
Papas Sampler $16.95
3 mozzarella sticks, 3 zucchini sticks, fried calamari, fried ravioli, marinara sauce
Mozzarella Caprese App $12.95
Layered fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers and basil with balsamic glaze
Garlic Knots $2.76
Garlic Knots (1) $0.46
Garlic Knots W/Cheese & Sauce $3.95
Garlic Bread $3.95

Paninis & Wraps
House Panini $9.95
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce and tomato
Mulberry Street Panini $10.95
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, fried eggplant, roasted pepper, and red onion
Chicken BLT Wrap $11.95
Fried chicken, bacon, mayo, romaine lettuce, tomatoes and melted mozzarella
Italian Wrap $11.95
Genoa salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes with dressing
Classic Wrap $10.95
Grilled chicken, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes with ranch dressing
Chicken Caesar Wrap $11.95
Romaine lettuce, grated cheese, and grilled chicken with Caesar dressing
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Panini $10.95
Potat/Eggs/Mozz Wrap $10.95
Chik BLT Panini $10.95
Srimp Wrap $13.95
Beef Wrap $12.95
Buff Chin Wrap $12.95
Bruschetta Wrap $11.95
Chicken W/ Sauce Panini W/ G O T $11.95

Entrees
Chicken Parmigiana $22.95
Breaded chicken, sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Chicken Francese $22.95
Egg battered chicken in a lemon butter white wine sauce
Chicken Alla Vodka $23.95
Breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, creamy vodka sauce
Chicken Marsala $22.95
Seared chicken and sautéed mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce
Chicken Bruschetta $23.95
Fried chicken, topped with tomato, red onion, and fresh mozzarella tossed in balsamic and oil
Chicken Verdi $23.95
Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, broccoli, and mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Rollatine (3) $19.95
Pieces of fried eggplant, rolled with seasoned ricotta and romano cheese, topped with sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Parmigiana $18.95
Fried eggplant, sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Veal Parmigiana $23.95
Breaded veal, homemade sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese
Gr Chk W/Veg $23.95
Grilled chicken with sautéed spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, tomato, and roasted pepper
Gr Chk/Broc Rabe $23.95
Served with pasta or salad
Chicken Cacciatore $23.95
Sautéed chicken, tomato, mushrooms, onions, and peppers
Chicken Jennifer $24.95
Chicken Tower $25.95
Chicken Piccata $23.95
Seared chicken, capers, and artichoke hearts in a lemon butter white wine sauce
Meatballs Parm $23.95
Chicken Scarpariello $24.95
Sautéed chicken, Italian sausage, sweet bell peppers, onions, roasted potatoes, rosemary reduction (no pasta on side)
Sausages Parm $22.95
Veal Francese $24.95
Chicken Sorrentino $23.95
Seared chicken, topped with prosciutto, eggplant, and fresh mozzarella in a marsala wine sauce
Veal Marsala $24.95
Veal Piccata $24.95
Tender pan seared veal sautéed with capers in a light wine lemon sauce
Veal Sorentino $25.95
Veal Marsala (Copy) $24.95

Sides
Side Tomato Sauce (4 Oz) $0.50
Side Marinara (4 Oz) $1.00
S/O Fried Chkn $7.95
S/O GR Chkn $7.95
Side Sautéed Broccoli $7.95
Side Sausage (3) $7.95
Large Pizza Dough $5.00
Side Sautéed Spinach $7.95
To Stay
Side Meatballs (3) $7.95
Side Broccoli Rabe $10.95
Side Of Pasta $6.95
Pint Vodka $7.95
Pint Mozz $4.00
Small Pizza Dough $3.00
Side Grated Cheese (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Garlic (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Ranch (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Bleu Cheese (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Buffalo (4 Oz) $1.00
Side BBQ (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Vodka 4 Onz $2.00
Side Caesar Dressing (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Red Pepper Flakes (2 Oz) $1.00
Side Oregano $1.00
Forks Knives And Napkins
Pint Tomate Sauce $3.95

Pastas
Spaghetti $9.95
Penne $9.95
Rigatone $9.95
Linguini $9.95
Fettuccine $9.95
Capellini $9.95
Cheese Raviole $11.45

Baked Pastas
Baked Ziti $13.95
Baked Ziti W/Meatballs $16.95
Baked Ravioli $14.95
Meat Lasagna $16.95
Homemade!
Manicotti $14.95
Stuffed Shells (4) $14.95
Baked Sampler $18.95
Stuffed shells(2), cheese ravioli (2), manicotti (2) in tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella
1/2 Order Bak/Ziti $9.95
Labter Ravili $21.95
Bake Ziti Siciliano $15.95

Seafood
Fried Calamari $21.95
Calamari Marinara $21.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Fra Diavolo $22.95
Shrimp. baby clams, and spicy marinara sauce over pasta
Shrimp Francaise $22.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Marinara (6) $22.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Oreganata $22.95
Shrimp Parmigiana $22.95
Served over linguini
Shrimp Scampi $22.95
Served over pasta
Calamari Marinara $21.95

Kids Menu
Kenzie Special - Chkn Fingers & Fries $10.95
4 Chicken fingers and fries served with ketchup
Kids Spa W/Meatball (2) $9.95
Small portion of spaghetti with two meatballs
Kids Spag In Butter $8.95
Small portion of spaghetti in butter
Kids Ravioli W/Tomato Sauce (3) $8.95
Kids Spag W/ Tomate $8.95
Kids Spag W/ Chiken $10.95

Desserts
NY Cheesecake $5.00
Cannoli $4.95
Sugar Knots (6) $4.00
Carrot Cake $5.00
Oreo Cake $5.00
Fried Oreos 6 $6.95

Ice's
Ice $2.76
Ice Cream $3.50
Truffle $5.25
Sundae $3.91

PREPS
Mozz $1.50
Tomato $1.00
Red Onions $1.00
Lettuce $1.00
Rstd Pepper $1.50
Extra Olives $1.00
White Onion $1.00
Mushroom $1.00
Sm Broc $2.00
Lg Broc $3.50
On Side
Mayo

Superbowl
FIRST DOWN $35.00
1 LARGE PIE, 12 WINGS 2 LITER SODA
KICKOFF $65.00
2 LARGE REG PIES, 16 WINGS, 12 GARLIC KNOTS, 2 LITER SODA
BIG GAME SPECIAL $69.00
1 LARGE PIE, 1 SIC OR GMA PIE, 12 GK OR SK, 16 WINGS AND 1 2 LITER SODS
HALFTIME SPECIAL $100.00
1 REG, SIC OR GMA PIE. 1/2 TRAY WINGS, 1/2 TRAY MINI PANINI SLIDERS

Drinks
20oz. Bottle $2.50
Can Drink $1.38
Lg Soda $2.00
Sm Soda $1.50
2 Liter $4.00
16 Oz. Bottled Water $1.38
Juice $2.50
Vitamin Water $2.75
Papa's Raspberry Lime $2.60
Papa's Black Cherry $2.60
Papa's Expresso $2.80
Powerade $2.50
Red Bull $2.95
Coco Vita $2.75
Monster $2.75
Energy Drink $2.60
Smart Water $2.00
Gatorade F/Punch $2.50
Gatorade Glacier Freeze $2.50

Drinks
20oz. Bottle $2.50
Can Drink $1.38
Lg Soda $2.00
Sm Soda $1.50
2 Liter $4.00
16 Oz. Bottled Water $1.38
Juice $2.50
Vitamin Water $2.75
Papa's Raspberry Lime $2.60
Papa's Black Cherry $2.60
Papa's Expresso $2.80
Powerade $2.50
Red Bull $2.95
Coco Vita $2.75
Monster $2.75
Energy Drink $2.60
Smart Water $2.00
Gatorade F/Punch $2.50
Gatorade Glacier Freeze $2.50

Opem Item
Open Item

Opem Item
Open Item

Daily Specials
2 LG Pizzas & 12 Garlic Knots $37.98
2 Large Cheese Pizzas & 12 Garlic Knots
Pizza And Wings Combo $35.95
Large regular cheese pie, 8 wings, and 6 garlic knots. *Cannot be combined with any other offers*
Family Treat $45.95
1 Large Cheese Pie, Choice of Meatball, Eggplant or Chicken Parmesan Hero, Baked Ziti & 12 Garlic Knots
Feed The Family Combo (Most Popular) $51.95
Large Cheese pie, Penne alla Vodka, 1 Chicken Parm Hero & 1 Large Caesar Salad
Monday Special $25.50
3 For 30 $30.00
1 Reg Pie 12 Wings 6 Knots $35.00
Thursday Pie With Coupon Only $14.95

Daily Specials
2 LG Pizzas & 12 Garlic Knots $37.98
2 Large Cheese Pizzas & 12 Garlic Knots
Pizza And Wings Combo $35.95
Large regular cheese pie, 8 wings, and 6 garlic knots. *Cannot be combined with any other offers*
Family Treat $45.95
1 Large Cheese Pie, Choice of Meatball, Eggplant or Chicken Parmesan Hero, Baked Ziti & 12 Garlic Knots
Feed The Family Combo (Most Popular) $51.95
Large Cheese pie, Penne alla Vodka, 1 Chicken Parm Hero & 1 Large Caesar Salad
Monday Special $25.50
3 For 30 $30.00
1 Reg Pie 12 Wings 6 Knots $35.00
Thursday Pie With Coupon Only $14.95

Appetizers
Wings $50.00
Baked Clams $60.00
Fried Calamari $60.00
Calamari Arrabbiata $65.00
Mozzarella Sticks $45.00
Chicken Fingers $50.00

Salads
House Salad $35.00
Caesar $30.00
Greek Salad $40.00

PASTA
Rigatoni $50.00
Spaghetti $50.00
Linguine $50.00
Penne $50.00

Baked Pasta
Baked Ziti $50.00
Lasagna $60.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $60.00
Eggplant Rollatini $65.00

Chicken
Parmigiana $60.00
Marsala $65.00
Francese $60.00
Bruschetta (Grilled Or Fried) $60.00
Sausg + Peppers $65.00
Meatballs $60.00
Half Tray Milanese $55.00
Large Tr Milanese $105.00

Veal
Parmigiana $70.00
Marsala $70.00
Francese $70.00

Shrimp
Parmigiana
Francese
Scampi
Oreganata

3ft Heros
American
Italian
Chicken Parm
Sausg + Ppr
Meatball Parm
Papa's Favorite
Mulberry
Eggplant Parm

Appetizers
Wings $50.00
Baked Clams $60.00
Fried Calamari $60.00
Calamari Arrabbiata $65.00
Mozzarella Sticks $45.00
Chicken Fingers $50.00

Salads
House Salad $35.00
Caesar $30.00
Greek Salad $40.00

PASTA
Rigatoni $50.00
Spaghetti $50.00
Linguine $50.00
Penne $50.00

Baked Pasta
Baked Ziti $50.00
Lasagna $60.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $60.00
Eggplant Rollatini $65.00

Chicken
Parmigiana $60.00
Marsala $65.00
Francese $60.00
Bruschetta (Grilled Or Fried) $60.00
Sausg + Peppers $65.00
Meatballs $60.00
Half Tray Milanese $55.00
Large Tr Milanese $105.00

Veal
Parmigiana $70.00
Marsala $70.00
Francese $70.00

Shrimp
Parmigiana
Francese
Scampi
Oreganata

3ft Heros
American
Italian
Chicken Parm
Sausg + Ppr
Meatball Parm
Papa's Favorite
Mulberry
Eggplant Parm

Papa’s Pizza Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Papa’s Pizza Photos

Papa’s Pizza Location

Papa’s Pizza

New York Nassau County Farmingdale Merritts Road

199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA

Papa’s Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 176 user reviews.

pricesslicesvodkaownergarlic knotspeoplechicken parmrollislandbroccoli

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Finally a legit pizzeria on the Island!! As a born and raised Queens girl who moved out East nearly 10 years ago, it's been a battle to find anywhere comparable to Lucia's... but Papa's takes the prize. And I might even add that they are better!
October 11 · Jina Yoon
Ho-Lee WOW! I am currently doing the Keto diet and so I ordered the Meat Lovers with Alfredo Sauce on Cauliflower crust and it was seriously the greatest food I've eaten since I arrived in Long Island from Utah a week ago. The atmosphere was inviting and the service exceeded my expectations! I cannot wait to return! Do yourself a favor and go get yourself some phenomenal pizza from Papa's Pizza! 🔥🔥🔥
August 18 · Jace Reading
I visited papas pizza a few months ago when I was visiting my parents in New York and man this place was so good. So this week my parents were visiting me in Texas and I asked them to bring some stuff from papas back to Texas for me. Man it was so good. I called a few days earlier and spoke to the owner Orlando and he was very nice. I told him my parents would be packing the food to bring it on a plane for me and he had everything ready nice and packed up for them. He even called me and explained to myself and my parents how to keep it Fresh since they were flying out the next day!! And boy it was still soo fresh. The food was a hit for all my friends in Austin Texas as I always brag about NYC pizza and pizzeria food. We had Buffalo chicken rolls, sausage and pepper rolls, chicken rolls, pepperoni pinwheels and spinach pinwheels , oh and the rice balls. They were gone within minutes of me reheating them. I can’t wait to visit my parents again so I can go back to papas pizza!! And I’ll be sure anytime someone comes to visit me in Texas they bring some food from thetr as well for me .
October 13 · sheldon lamoury
One of the best slices of Sicilian I have ever had… I was doing a delivery, was greeted professionally and they actually cared about the customer, they were out of a drink and attempted to call multiple times… how’s that for service. I walked out of the place and I get a call that I received a positive review. They didn’t have to go out of their way for me at all. In conclusion, the place didn’t even charge me for the slice. Was completely mind blown. Don’t just go to this place for the food, go for the kind service they provide, which is hard to find nowadays… keep it up papas!!!!!!!
June 30 · Christopher Hassel
Papa's is a delightful little pizza spot.I ordered the Veal Parm hero and was quite pleased. The bread was fresh, the cheese was fresh, hot, and generously portioned. The veal itself was delicious and portioned to fill the stomach.My s/o ordered the Shrimp Parm hero and was equally pleased with the hero. The shrimp was fresh and delicious.I will surely be ordering again. I'm interested in trying the Philly Cheese steak hero and the meat lover's pizza!
June 22 · Dennis Pennington