Pizza Italia NYC

- 3593 Bayview St, Seaford, NY 11783

For New Yorkers craving that quintessential, authentic taste of classic neighborhood Italian-American fare, **Pizza Italia NYC** in Seaford stands out as an essential Long Island destination. Located conveniently on Bayview Street, this establishment captures the essence of an "old school" pizzeria, proudly serving the kind of timeless New York-style pizza that truly "brings back memories." Patrons consistently hail their regular cheese pizza as the "best regular slice in Seaford," a testament to their dedication to traditional methods and quality ingredients.

While celebrated for their classic thin-crust and the thick, crispy-bottomed **Sicilian Pizza**, Pizza Italia NYC also excels in an extensive selection of **Gourmet Pizza** variations. From the popular **Square Grandma Pizza** to inventive specialties like **Chicken Marsala Pizza** and **Round Vodka Sauce Pizza**, there is a pie for every preference. Beyond pizza, the menu offers a complete range of Italian **Comfort food**, including savory **Pasta Dishes**, large **Entrees** like Chicken Parmigiana, and beloved **Baked Dishes** such as Lasagna and Baked Ziti.

The atmosphere inside is described as **Casual** and welcoming, featuring a comfortable dining area that is **Family-friendly**. With its commitment to **Fast service**, the restaurant ensures that whether you are dining in, picking up takeout, or waiting for delivery, your experience is efficient and enjoyable. Pizza Italia NYC is a perfect spot for **Lunch**, **Dinner**, or even **Solo dining**, offering a piece of classic New York food culture right in the heart of Seaford.

---

Situated in the welcoming community of Seaford, Pizza Italia NYC is easily accessible to residents and visitors traveling through Nassau County. Its location off the main thoroughfares makes it a convenient stop for a quality meal:

Address: 3593 Bayview St, Seaford, NY 11783, USA

The restaurant has taken steps to ensure a comfortable visit for all patrons:

• **Parking:** Guests will find both a **Free parking lot** and ample **Free street parking** available. However, based on local knowledge, it is worth noting that parking can occasionally be "difficult when the bar/tavern next door is very busy," so planning for peak hours is advisable.
• **Accessibility:** The facility includes a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, prioritizing access for guests with mobility needs.
• **Seaford Community Hub:** Located on Bayview Street, the pizzeria is a popular spot for the local **Crowd**, serving as a reliable go-to for daily meals and special family occasions in the Seaford area.

---

Pizza Italia NYC provides comprehensive service options, catering to the diverse needs and busy lifestyles of the New York metropolitan area:

• **Dine-in and Seating:** Guests can enjoy their meal in the **Casual** and comfortable dining area, with adequate **Seating** and a clean **Restroom** facility.
• **Off-Premise Options:** The restaurant is highly focused on convenience, offering traditional **Takeout** service, standard **Delivery**, and **No-contact delivery** for added safety and convenience.
• **Extensive Catering Services:** A significant part of their offering is a full-service **Catering** menu, ideal for parties, corporate events, and family gatherings across Long Island. This includes everything from **Catering Paninis** and **Catering Salads** to large **Catering Entrees** and **Catering Pasta** platters.
• **Family Specials:** To make family dining simple and affordable, they offer curated **Family Specials** (all priced at $53.00), which typically bundle a pizza (like Plain Cheese, Sicilian, or Grandma) with a large salad, a baked pasta dish (Penne Alla Vodka or Baked Ziti), garlic knots, and soda.
• **Beverages:** The establishment serves **Alcohol** and **Wine**, providing appropriate pairings for the Italian menu. They also offer standard non-alcoholic **Beverages** such as **Soda** and **Water**.
• **Children's Provisions:** The restaurant is designed to be **Good for kids**, featuring a specific **Kids' menu** (including Chicken Fingers, Spaghetti with Meatballs, and more) and providing **High chairs** for comfort.

---

What makes Pizza Italia NYC a local favorite in Seaford is a combination of quality cuisine and exceptional service features:

• **Authentic New York Slice:** The cornerstone of their reputation is the **Regular Cheese Pizza Slice** ($3.75), described by customers as the taste of "classic new york cheese pizza" that is hard to find in a world of "reinvented" pies. The recommendation is to "always order a fresh pie & eat on the spot!!" for the best flavor.
• **The Grandma Pizza:** Their **Square Grandma Pizza** and **Round Grandma Pizza** varieties are a major highlight and a "must" for regulars. The thin, dense, and crispy crust of this popular Long Island style sets a high standard.
• **Gourmet Pizza Creativity:** They offer an impressive array of gourmet options that combine Italian classics with modern American favorites, such as **Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza**, **Baked Ziti Pizza**, and **Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza**. The **Square Grandma With Cup Pepperoni Pizza Slice** ($6.00) offers a premium, spicy experience.
• **Full Italian Menu:** Beyond pizza, they boast a complete selection of homemade Italian **Comfort food**, including over 20 different **Pasta Dishes** (like Homemade Gnocchi Sorrentino and Linguini Pescatore), classic **Hot Heroes**, and unique appetizers such as **Baked Clams** and **Fried Calamari**.
• **Commitment to Freshness:** The high praise for the food suggests a commitment to homemade quality. The availability of multiple scratch-made **Homemade Soups** (Tortellini En Brodo, Pasta Fagioli, etc.) reinforces this dedication.
• **Fast, Professional Service:** The restaurant is noted for its **Fast service** and **Great service**, which, coupled with the **Casual** and clean environment, creates a beautiful dining area and ambiance for guests.
• **Specialty Heroes:** The extensive **Hot Heroes** menu, ranging from the classic **Meatball Parmigiana Hero** ($14.75) to the unique **Potato & Egg Hero** ($11.75) and **Shrimp Parmigiana Hero** ($18.75), provides excellent alternatives to pizza.

---

For a New Yorker visiting Pizza Italia NYC in Seaford, the menu presents many excellent choices, but there are certain items that define the experience and are unequivocally worth choosing.

First and foremost, you must try the pizza. Start with the **Regular Cheese Pizza Slice** ($3.75) to appreciate the authentic, classic New York flavor that locals rave about. Follow this with a piece of the **Round Grandma Pizza Slice** ($4.75) or **Square Grandma Pizza Slice** ($4.75)—a true Long Island specialty that showcases a different style of crust and sauce application.

To explore their gourmet creativity, the **Square Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice** ($4.75) or a full pie of the **Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza** is highly recommended, as these modern twists have become New York pizzeria staples. The **Italia Special Pizza** itself is a strong indicator of their signature pie, which usually combines their best ingredients and techniques, often serving as a premium choice.

Beyond the pizza oven, the kitchen's mastery extends to their traditional Italian offerings. For a satisfying, hearty meal, choose one of the homemade pasta dishes. The **Rigatoni Vodka** ($19.50) is a timeless choice, while the **Homemade Gnocchi Sorrentino** ($22.50) offers a taste of true Italian comfort. Seafood lovers should consider the decadent **Linguini Pescatore** or **Seafood Fra Diavolo Over Linguini** (both $24.00), demonstrating a clear capability with elevated dishes.

Finally, for feeding the entire family or a small group, the **Family Specials** ($53.00) provide exceptional value, pairing a whole pizza with a large pasta dish, salad, and appetizers, making meal planning effortless and economical for the busy Long Island family.

---

For a taste of authentic New York pizza and Italian cooking, or to inquire about their extensive catering options, please reach out using the details below:

Address: 3593 Bayview St, Seaford, NY 11783, USA
Phone: (516) 939-1717 / +1 516-939-1717

Pizza Italia NYC

3593 Bayview St, Seaford, NY 11783, USA