Pizza Shop

- 27 Water St, Newburgh, NY 12550

For New Yorkers craving an authentic, satisfying pizza experience, **Pizza Shop** in Newburgh, NY, stands out as a must-visit destination. More than just a typical pizzeria, this establishment combines the comfort of classic Italian-American cuisine with the excitement of innovative menu items, all served up in a casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere. Located right on Water Street, it's a spot where locals, college students, groups, and tourists alike gather to enjoy generous portions of high-quality food, from classic round pies to hearty entrées and decadent desserts.

The culinary philosophy at Pizza Shop seems to be centered on delivering **comfort food** with a focus on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The menu is extensive, ensuring that there's something to please every palate, whether you're in the mood for a quick, delicious slice or a full, multi-course Italian meal. Their commitment to offering diverse options, including numerous **vegetarian** and extensive **gluten-free** choices, makes it a welcoming spot for diners with various dietary preferences.

Customers consistently praise the quality and size of the servings—a definite highlight that speaks to the restaurant's value. You’ll find everything from their signature **Meatster Round Pie** and innovative **Bee Sting Round Pie** to full pasta dishes like **Spaghetti & Meatballs** and more upscale entrées like **Chicken Marsala** and **Eggplant Rollatini**. Finish it all off with a sweet treat like a **Nutella Deluxe Sundae** or classic **Fried Dough**, and you have a complete dining experience worth traveling for.

***

Pizza Shop is conveniently situated at **27 Water St, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA**. Its location is a genuine draw, especially for those looking for a pleasant dining experience with a view. Several customer reviews mention the appealing environment, including beautiful views along the river and train tracks—a unique backdrop that adds charm to your meal. The setting is described as historic, yet the ambiance remains trendy and inviting, making it a great spot for lunch or dinner.

For those driving, the location offers excellent **parking options**, which is a significant plus in many New York areas. Patrons can take advantage of both a **free parking lot** and **free street parking**. Furthermore, the establishment is dedicated to providing an inclusive experience, featuring **wheelchair-accessible entrance**, **wheelchair-accessible parking lot**, and **wheelchair-accessible seating**. Whether you are planning to dine in or simply stopping by for a quick pickup, accessibility and convenience are top priorities here.

The location also serves as a hub for their prompt **delivery service**, covering a significant area of the Newburgh region. This ensures that their delicious food is not only available for dine-in but can also be enjoyed in the comfort of your own home, making it a favorite for those seeking a reliable 'Delivery Restaurant' option.

***

Pizza Shop provides a comprehensive range of service options designed to fit any schedule or preference. Their operational model prioritizes both a relaxing dine-in experience and efficient off-premises service.

• **Dine-in:** Enjoy your meal in a casual, cozy setting with comfortable seating and **table service**. **Outdoor seating** is also available for a pleasant open-air dining experience, often accompanied by the noted scenic views.
• **Delivery:** The restaurant operates as a dedicated **Delivery Restaurant**, offering fast and reliable service to get your order to you quickly. They also offer **No-contact delivery** for those who prefer an added layer of safety and convenience.
• **Takeout:** For those on the go, the **takeout** option is efficient and allows you to quickly pick up your order and enjoy it elsewhere.
• **Dining Options:** They cater to all major dining periods, including **Lunch**, **Dinner**, and **Dessert**.
• **Group Accommodations:** The establishment is well-suited for **Groups** and is popular for **Solo dining**. They are also considered **Good for kids**, with **High chairs** available and a dedicated **Kids' menu**.
• **Payment Flexibility:** A variety of payment methods are accepted for convenience, including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.

***

Pizza Shop has cemented its reputation by offering several distinct features that set it apart from other local eateries. These highlights underscore the overall positive customer experience.

• **Diverse & Unique Menu:** Beyond traditional large round pies like the **Classic Tomato Round Pie**, they offer unique items like the **Bee Sting Round Pie** and a selection of distinctive **Square Pies**, including the **Vodka Pie Pizza** and **Boom 'Room Pizza**. Their menu extends far beyond pizza to include full entrées like **Chicken Parmesan**, various **Sandwiches** (such as the **Italian Cheesesteak**), and a wide array of **Appetizers** like **Garlic Knots** and **Golden Mozzarella Bombs**.
• **Extensive Gluten-Free Selection:** A major highlight is their dedicated menu of **Personal 10" Gluten-Free Pizza** options, featuring popular choices like the **Gluten-Free Meatster Round Pie** and **Gluten-Free Margherita Pizza**, ensuring diners with gluten sensitivities have abundant options.
• **Quick Service & Hospitality:** The restaurant is highlighted for its **Fast service** and the attentive nature of its staff, often noted as being "the right level of attentive."
• **Exceptional Offerings:** They are highly praised for both their **Great dessert** and **Great coffee**, providing an excellent finish to any meal. Their dessert menu is particularly impressive, featuring shakes, sundaes, and floats, including the **Nutella Deluxe Sundae** and classic **Milkshake**.
• **Beverage Selection:** The establishment provides a selection of beverages, including **Alcohol**, **Beer**, and **Wine**, complementing the wide array of comfort food and Italian specialties. They also serve **late-night food** options.

***

For reservations, takeout, or delivery, you can reach Pizza Shop using the following contact details:

**Address:** 27 Water St, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA

**Phone (Landline):** (845) 565-7467

**Phone (Mobile/International Format):** +1 845-565-7467

It's always recommended to call ahead for the most current operating hours or to place a complex order.

***

Choosing Pizza Shop is choosing a blend of local flavor, high quality, and incredible value, all within the beautiful Newburgh locale. For New York residents and visitors, the restaurant offers an unparalleled selection of pizza and Italian-American comfort food.

The **portion sizes** are a definite draw, often remarked upon as being "huge," meaning you get excellent value for your money—you might even find yourself taking home leftovers! A medium pizza, for example, is noted to be substantial enough to require a takeout box, a testament to their commitment to generous servings. This is perfect for families, groups, or anyone with a hearty appetite. Customer favorites that are well worth trying include the flavor-packed **Meatster Round Pie** and the highly-recommended **Garlic Knots**, which are a must-try appetizer.

Beyond the pizza, the menu depth provides great variety. For a lighter bite, the **Salads** menu, featuring options like the **California Cobb Salad** and **Gorgonzola Walnut Salad**, offers fresh, delicious alternatives. For those seeking a full Italian meal, their **Pasta** and **Entrées** sections, with dishes like **Fiery Shrimp Linguini** and **Chicken Francese**, promise a high-quality dining experience.

Ultimately, Pizza Shop is worth choosing because it delivers a well-rounded and satisfying experience: delicious food with wide variety (including great options for those needing **vegetarian** or **gluten-free** meals), fast and attentive service, and an enjoyable setting with excellent accessibility. It's a true Newburgh gem that provides a slice of authentic, modern Italian-American cuisine for the entire New York region.

Pizza Shop

27 Water St, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA