Prime Time Cafe

- 1319 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10804

For residents and visitors in New York’s Westchester County, particularly in the vibrant community of New Rochelle, finding a dining spot that successfully marries comfort food with strict dietary standards can be a challenge. Prime Time Cafe, located conveniently on North Avenue, rises to this challenge, serving as a pillar of the local kosher dining scene. Certified dairy kosher under the supervision of the Vaad Harabonim of Queens (VHQ), this establishment is much more than a typical pizza place; it’s a trusted source for Italian-American classics, fresh salads, and satisfying Middle Eastern fare, all within a casual and family-friendly atmosphere.

Prime Time Cafe has earned a strong reputation for providing high-quality, fresh, and delicious meals, making it a regular stop for lunch, dinner, and even solo dining. The menu is diverse, spanning from its highly-praised, oven-fresh pizzas to a thoughtful selection of pasta entrées and hearty, homemade soups. While its roots are deeply entrenched in providing exceptional kosher pizza—often cited by long-time patrons as "simply the best pizza in town"—the cafe’s versatility is underscored by its professional catering services, making it a reliable partner for events and gatherings in the greater New Rochelle and Westchester area.

Known for its welcoming vibe where staff and customers often greet each other by name, Prime Time Cafe fosters a sense of community. The focus remains on quick, satisfying meals and efficient service, ensuring that whether you are grabbing a quick slice or planning a large catered event, your experience is smooth and enjoyable.

Prime Time Cafe is strategically located at 1319 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10804, USA. This placement on North Avenue positions it in a high-traffic, accessible area of New Rochelle, making it a convenient stop for local residents and those traveling through Westchester County.

For New York area users who rely on vehicular transportation, the location offers practical convenience. Amenities include a Free Parking Lot, a significant benefit in a densely populated region, as well as the option for Paid Street Parking nearby. Furthermore, the establishment is attentive to accessibility needs, featuring a Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot. While in-person dining was historically available, the current operational focus is heavily on takeout and delivery, meaning its physical accessibility primarily caters to quick entry and exit for pickup. Its proximity to other community institutions in the area further solidifies its standing as a local go-to spot for kosher cuisine.

As a key local restaurant and caterer, Prime Time Cafe provides a range of flexible services designed to meet the busy schedules of New York patrons, prioritizing convenience and quality control in every transaction.

• Takeout: The primary service option, ensuring a hot, fresh meal is ready for quick pick-up at the 1319 North Ave location.

• Delivery: Meals can be delivered directly to homes and businesses, offering a vital convenience for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

• Catering Services: Recognized as a professional caterer, the cafe provides a large selection of party trays perfect for events, Shabbat, or family gatherings, including Baked Ziti, variety salads, and Eggplant Parmigiana.

• Kosher Certification: Certified dairy kosher under the supervision of the Vaad Harabonim of Queens (VHQ), ensuring confidence and adherence to dietary laws for the local Jewish community.

• Dietary Accommodations: The menu includes vegetarian options across all categories and offers dedicated gluten-free choices, such as Gluten-Free Baked Ziti and Gluten-Free Eggplant Parmigiana.

• Multiple Payment Options: Accepting all major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing simple, modern, and quick transaction processes.

Prime Time Cafe’s appeal lies in its reliable quality and diverse, comfort-driven menu. From classic Italian to unexpected Middle Eastern items, the features are tailored for a broad local audience seeking both tradition and variety.

• Acclaimed Oven Fresh Pizza: The pizza is a standout, widely considered among the best in New Rochelle. Popular options include the Classic Cheese, Pepper & Onion, and specialty pies like the Eggplant Rollatini pizza, which allows patrons to enjoy classic Italian flavors on a perfectly baked crust.

• Authentic Falafel: A significant highlight is the quality of the Middle Eastern offerings, particularly the Falafel in a Pita with hummus and Israeli salad, and the Falafel Platter. This inclusion provides a welcome, non-Italian kosher option that is both satisfying and praised for its authenticity.

• Gourmet Pasta Selection: The menu goes beyond basic Italian, offering elevated dishes such as Portobello Ravioli, Penne Alla Vodka, and homestyle entrées like Eggplant Parmigiana and Stuffed Shells, all available for quick takeout or delivery.

• Customizable Salads: Fresh, garden-style salads like Israeli Salad, Greek Salad, and Sweet Mixed Greens offer lighter meal choices, with options to add protein such as a scoop of Solid White Tuna Salad.

• Homemade Soups for Comfort: A rotating selection of comforting soups, including Moroccan Bean, Mushroom Barley, and the elevated French Onion (with homemade croutons and melted cheese), provides ideal warmth and nutrition year-round.

To place an order, inquire about catering services, or learn more about Prime Time Cafe, please use the following contact information. Note that calling ahead for phone orders is recommended, particularly during peak lunch and dinner hours.

Address: 1319 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10804, USA

Phone: (914) 654-1646

Mobile Phone: +1 914-654-1646

Catering Inquiries: Utilize the primary phone number to discuss Party Tray options for your next event.

Typical Hours of Operation (Please verify for holidays):

• Monday to Thursday: Typically open through the afternoon/early evening.

• Friday: Generally open for an early lunch until mid-afternoon.

• Saturday: Closed.

• Sunday: Typically open for lunch and dinner service.

When choosing from Prime Time Cafe’s extensive menu, a clear decision stands out for both first-time visitors and returning local patrons: indulging in their legendary pizza or trying a specialty item that highlights their versatile kosher kitchen.

The most worthwhile choice is their Classic Cheese Pizza. This is the item that has cemented their reputation in New Rochelle for generations, often described by customers as the "best pizza in town." It offers a perfect representation of their commitment to fresh, quality, kosher dairy ingredients. If you are looking for a more gourmet pie, the Pepper & Onion or the savory Eggplant Rollatini pizza slice (if available) come highly recommended.

For those seeking a non-pizza meal, the Falafel in a Pita is a must-try. This item showcases the cafe's ability to execute authentic Middle Eastern flavors with a crisp exterior and tender, flavorful interior—a perfect comfort food for lunch or a quick bite. Pair your choice with one of the hearty Homemade Soups, such as the Mushroom Barley or Moroccan Bean, especially on a cooler New York day.

Finally, for larger family dinners or gatherings, utilizing their Party Trays is exceptionally valuable. Choosing a tray of Baked Ziti or Eggplant Parmigiana ensures a crowd-pleasing, high-quality, and certified kosher meal without the stress of preparation. Prime Time Cafe is, therefore, worth choosing for its unbeatable combination of top-tier pizza, reliable kosher supervision, and the convenience of robust takeout and catering services designed for the fast-paced, quality-demanding lifestyle of Westchester County residents.

Prime Time Cafe

1319 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10804, USA