Sammie's

- City Island Rd, Bronx, NY 10464

For generations of New Yorkers, the mention of City Island immediately conjures images of a quaint New England fishing village, right here in the Bronx, and the delicious aroma of fresh seafood. At the heart of this nautical enclave lies Sammy's, a name that has become synonymous with world-famous fish, monumental portions, and a beloved tradition of quality since Sammy's Fish Box was established in 1966. This is not just a seafood restaurant; it is a culinary legacy, known for "churing out more than one million meals annually" and remaining a pivotal reason visitors “swarm the little island” every summer.

Sammy's—encompassing the original Fish Box, Sammy's Shrimp Box, and related concepts—is celebrated for its simple but effective formula: the seafood is always fresh, and the expansive menu guarantees that leaving with an “overstuffed stomach is almost impossible.” It perfectly blends the unpretentious vibe of a seaside eatery with the dedication to quality that New York diners demand. Whether you're craving a classic Baked Whole Red Snapper, an overwhelming Seafood & BBQ Feast, or the simple comfort of a New England Clam Chowder, Sammy's delivers an experience that is authentic to the City Island heritage.

The experience begins with generous complimentary additions, often including a bread basket and marinated vegetables, setting the stage for the enormous and legendary dishes to come. Sammy's truly is the "king of seafood on City Island," offering consistently high quality and a tradition that has delighted diners for generations.

Sammy's operates from various highly visible locations along City Island Avenue, the main thoroughfare of this unique Bronx community. The primary establishments, including the foundational Sammy's Fish Box, are located prominently on City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA.

For New York residents, getting to City Island can feel like a mini-escape from the city bustle. For those who prefer public transit, the island is served by the local Bx29 bus, which can be accessed by taking the #6 train to the end of the line at Pelham Bay Park and transferring.

A crucial feature for dining in this popular area is parking, and Sammy's addresses this perfectly, recognizing the convenience necessary for its loyal customer base. The restaurant offers extensive Valet Parking facilities, utilizing four huge parking lots surrounding the establishment. Professional parking services are available for customer convenience during both lunch and dinner, ensuring a stress-free start to your meal.

Furthermore, Sammy's is committed to accessibility, adhering to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) standards. Wheelchair seating is offered and based on availability (reservations by phone are recommended to ensure a designated area). The outdoor patio dining and restrooms are generally maintained to be wheelchair accessible, reflecting a commitment to ensuring all patrons can enjoy the waterfront dining experience.

Sammy's offers a full spectrum of services to accommodate every dining need, from intimate meals to large-scale events and home delivery.

• Full-Service Dining: Offering a complete dine-in experience for lunch and dinner with a full array of fresh seafood, steaks, and specialty cocktails.
• Takeout and Delivery: Convenient online ordering and secure payment options are available, allowing customers to easily get their favorite Sammy's dishes delivered right to their door.
• Outdoor Dining: Options like Sammy's Tropical Patio (affiliated with the Fish Box) allow guests to dine *al fresco* and experience the lively summer ambiance of City Island.
• Event Hosting and Group Feasts: Specializing in large format Fabulous Feasts for 2 (or more), which are ideal for groups and celebrations. They include options like the Snow Crab & Lobster Feast and the Italian Feast.
• Full Bar Service: Serving a wide selection of beverages including Red Wines (such as Robert Mondavi and Stags' Leap), and a remarkable list of Tropical Cocktails and Martini's (including the Limon Cosmo and Espresso Martini).
• Diverse Offerings: Catering to various tastes with extensive Surf and Turf options, combining their famous seafood with classic cuts like Chicago Style Bone-In Rib Eye Steak and Prime Shell Steak.

What makes a visit to Sammy's a quintessential City Island experience are the unique features and incredible menu depth that have cultivated its legendary status.

• Decades of Proven Legacy: Sammy's Fish Box was established in 1966, a proven legacy that attests to their sustained culinary excellence and warm hospitality over several generations of service.
• The Feast Platters: The legendary Feasts for 2 are a major highlight, showcasing a monumental spread of lobster, shrimp, clams, mussels, and crab, ensuring that no one leaves hungry.
• World-Famous Signature Dishes: Must-try items include the Sammy's Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper, the hearty Super Fried Seafood Combo Platter Special (shrimp, fillet of fish, scallops, and calamari), and premium shellfish like Oysters Rockefeller and the Hot Antipasto for two.
• Innovative Seafood Preparations: Offering unique flavor profiles such as the spicy PIRI PIRI Shrimp (pan-seared in a blend of garlic, lime, and habanero peppers), BANG-BANG Shrimp (tossed in a creamy spicy sauce), and Cajun Magic entrees like Blackened Salmon and Jumbo Shrimp Louisiana.
• Alder Wood Planked Fish: Continuing a tradition where select fish, including Red Snapper and Salmon, are baked on authentic alder wood planks, imparting a distinct, delicious flavor.
• Tropical Cocktails and Desserts: Known for its great bar menu, featuring unique drinks like the Coco-Locos Martini and the Ultimate Margarita, and finishing with memorable sweets like the Mile-High Chocolate Fudge Cake and various specialty gelatos.
• All-in-One Destination: Sammy's complex also includes Sammy's Smokehouse BBQ & Grill, offering patrons the option of high-quality BBQ—including Full Rack St. Louis Ribs and Brisket Platter—for the ultimate Surf and Turf combination.

For reservations, inquiries about menu availability, or to coordinate a large group, please use the main contact information for Sammy's:

• Address: City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA (Referencing the complex of Sammy's restaurants, including 41 City Island Ave for the Fish Box)
• Primary Phone: (718) 885-0920

For the New York seafood aficionado, choosing Sammy's is an investment in a legendary dining experience. It's not just about the quality of the fish—which is consistently fresh and top-tier—it's about the scale, variety, and the history embedded in every visit. Sammy's Fish Box is a classic Bronx institution, offering the massive, celebratory Feast Platters that few other establishments can match in value or scope.

What truly sets Sammy's apart is its commitment to both the classic and the contemporary. Diners can indulge in traditional favorites like Baked Fillet of Sole Stuffed with Crabmeat or explore exciting, spicy creations like the PIRI PIRI Special Dinner with scallops. The ability to seamlessly pair a delicate piece of Alaskan Salmon Fillet with a slab of Baby Back Pork Ribs from their adjacent smokehouse, creating the perfect Surf and Turf experience, is an unbeatable culinary draw. Furthermore, the convenience of the valet parking and the beautiful, accessible setting of City Island make the entire trip a relaxing and rewarding day out. When New Yorkers seek a true seafood destination that combines world-class fresh fish with an atmosphere rich in local history, Sammy's is the definitive choice.

Sammie's

City Island Rd, Bronx, NY 10464, USA