Sammy's Shrimp Box: City Island's Destination for Seafood, Steak, and Authentic BBQ

Sammy's Shrimp Box Introduce

For New Yorkers seeking a dining experience that combines high-quality seafood with an unexpected twist of authentic Southern-style barbecue, **Sammy's Shrimp Box** on City Island is a must-visit destination. This historic Bronx restaurant has evolved beyond a simple seafood shack into a comprehensive dining establishment, offering an incredibly diverse and extensive menu that truly has something for everyone. From fresh **Live Maine Lobsters** and delicate **Chilean Sea Bass** to tender **Brisket** and smoky **St. Louis Ribs**, Sammy’s delivers a unique culinary fusion right in the heart of the "City Island" community.

Sammy's is celebrated not only for its impressive variety of fresh seafood preparations—broiled, fried, wood-roasted, or scampi-style—but also for its commitment to a full dining experience. With its cozy, romantic, and historically rich atmosphere, it's the ideal setting for a celebratory dinner, a date night, or a memorable family gathering. The restaurant’s blend of seafood classics, dedicated steak selections, and signature **Smokehouse BBQ** menu ensures that whether you're craving the ocean's bounty or premium comfort food, you’ll find an exceptional, hearty meal waiting for you.

The sheer scale of the menu, which includes dozens of specialty combinations, from **Surf & Turf** options like **Lobster Tail & Filet Mignon** to massive **Fabulous Feasts** designed for sharing, solidifies Sammy’s reputation as a top-tier destination restaurant in the Bronx. This is the place where locals book a reservation to enjoy a great meal, superb cocktails, and an overall welcoming atmosphere.

Location and Accessibility

Sammy's Shrimp Box is centrally located on City Island's main thoroughfare, making it a prominent and easily accessible fixture in the neighborhood.

The full contact information is:

64 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Accessibility is a top priority for Sammy's, ensuring that all New Yorkers can enjoy the full dining experience. The restaurant features a **wheelchair accessible entrance**, a **wheelchair accessible parking lot**, a **wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **wheelchair accessible seating**.

For transportation and parking convenience, the restaurant offers **on-site parking** and a **free parking lot**, along with the option for **valet parking**, a significant amenity in the City Island area. While paid street parking is available, the dedicated lot options simplify your visit. The atmosphere is noted as **Casual, Cozy, Historic, Romantic, and Trendy**, appealing to a wide range of patrons, from **Groups** and **Locals** to **Tourists**.

Services Offered

Sammy's Shrimp Box provides a full-service dining model with numerous options designed for comfort and convenience:

Dine-in and Table Service: Offers traditional table service for a relaxed and attentive dining experience.
Reservations Accepted: Guests are encouraged to make **dinner reservations** to secure their seating, reflecting its popularity.
Private Dining Room: Available for special occasions, meetings, or larger private gatherings.
Takeout and Delivery: Offers quick **Takeout**, standard **Delivery**, and **No-contact delivery** options for enjoying their food at home.
Full Bar and Wine List: A dedicated bar on-site with a **Great beer selection**, **Great cocktails**, **Hard liquor**, and a highly-regarded **Great wine list**.
Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner: Comprehensive dining options are available throughout the day.
Catering Services: The full menu, including the specialty feasts and BBQ platters, is available for catering larger events.
Accessibility Features: Fully equipped with wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, restroom, and seating.
Pet-Friendly: Dogs are allowed in the designated **outdoor seating** area.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts all major **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.

Features and Highlights

Sammy's stands out in the New York dining scene due to its unique blend of offerings and the quality of its service:

Signature Menu Fusion: A rare and successful combination of extensive, high-end seafood and authentic, slow-smoked BBQ and steakhouse cuts. This allows for unparalleled combination dishes like **Surf & Turf** and specialty **Brisket or Pulled Pork Combinations** with crab legs and salmon.
Variety of Seafood Preparation: Offers a vast selection of cooking styles for seafood, including Broiled, Fried, and **Wood Roasting**, providing options from light and healthy (**Blackened Salmon**) to rich and traditional (**Jumbo Shrimp Scampi**).
Specialty Feasts: Famous for massive, shareable platters like the **Pit Master Feast For Four To Six** and the **Crab & Lobster Feast For Two**, which are renowned for their generous portions and value.
High-Quality Beverage Program: Recognized for its **Great cocktails** and a sophisticated **Great wine list**, perfect for pairing with both seafood and steak dishes. **Happy hour drinks** are also available.
Accommodating Atmosphere: Known for being **Cozy, Romantic**, and yet entirely **Family-friendly** (**Good for kids**, **Kids' menu**, **High chairs**), making it versatile for any occasion.
Extensive Side Dish Menu: Features over ten side dish options, including classics like **Mac N' Cheese**, **Collard Greens**, and **Tostones**, showing a dedication to both seafood and Southern BBQ traditions.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries, or ordering, please use the following contact details:

Address: 64 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA
Phone: (718) 885-3200

What is Worth Choosing at Sammy's Shrimp Box

With such a vast menu, first-time visitors to Sammy's Shrimp Box should focus on the restaurant's signature strengths and popular combinations:

* For the Seafood Purist: Opt for one of the classic, high-end preparations. The **Whole Broiled or Steamed Live Maine Lobster** (available in various weights) is a traditional favorite, or try one of the chef's specials like the **Wood Roasted Chilean Sea Bass** or the **Sammy’s Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper (Head On)**.

* For the Best of Both Worlds: The **Surf & Turf** section is a must-explore. The **Lobster Tail & Filet Mignon** or the **Snow Crab Legs & Shrimp Scampi** combine the restaurant’s best offerings into one hearty plate. Alternatively, try a specialty combination like the **St. Louis Ribs With 7oz. Lobster Tail**.

* For Comfort Food Enthusiasts: Don't overlook the impressive BBQ side of the menu. Order the **BBQ Combo Platter** and be sure to include the **Brisket**, which is highly praised in reviews for being exceptionally tender. Pair your main dish with sides like the creamy **Mac N' Cheese** or the moist cornbread, which often comes with the feast platters.

* For Starters and Sides: Start your meal with the renowned **Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail** or a serving of the classic **Baked Clams**. Be sure to save room for one of their specialty desserts and enjoy a cocktail from the full bar.

Sammy's Shrimp Box is truly an all-encompassing dining destination on City Island. It’s where you go when you want more than just a meal—you want a feast, with all the ambiance, service, and flavor that New Yorkers expect from a celebrated local spot.

Sammy's Shrimp Box Menu

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Jumbo Shrimp Combinations
Shrimp & Fried Fillet Of Sole $49.95
Shrimp & Fried Chicken $34.95
Shrimp & Sword Fish $48.95
Shrimp & Porgy $39.95
Shrimp & Stuffed Fillet Of Sole $59.95
Shrimp & BBQ Chicken $34.95
Shrimp & Tilapia $36.95
Shrimp & Alaskan Salmon $42.95
Shrimp & Whiting $36.95
Shrimp & Whole Red Snapper $56.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - From the Broiler
Codfish Filet $36.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Whole Baked Red Snapper $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Shrimp & Scallops Scampi Combo $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi $32.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Shrimp Stuffed With Crabmeat $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Scallops A La Scampi $42.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Salmon Fillet $39.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Broiled Baby Lobster Tails $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Starters
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4) $14.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Baked Oysters (5) $19.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Sweet Tender Fried Calamari $19.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Littleneck Or Cherrystone Clams On The Half Shell
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brunswick Beef Stew $12.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Fresh Shucked Oysters $3.50
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Baked Clams (8) $24.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Fried Oysters $24.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Cold Seafood Combo Platter $24.95
3 Jumbo Shrimp, 2 Oysters and 3 Clams. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Pulled Pork
Pulled Pork With 7oz. Lobster Tail $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork With Salmon $47.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork With Whole Red Snapper $59.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork & Fried Shrimp $37.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork With Snow Crab Leg Cluster $46.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork With Sea Scallops $42.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork With Shrimp & Scallops $46.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Smokehouse BBQ Buffalo Wings
Smokehouse BBQ Buffalo Wings
Your choice mild or spicy. All meals come with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - BBQ Combo Platter
Pit Master Feast For One $49.95
Includes : Brisket, Pulled Pork, Baby Back or St. Louis Ribs, Chicken and Sausage. All combo platters and pit master feasts come with coleslaw and your choice of three sides.
Pit Master Feast For Four To Six $124.95
Includes : Brisket, Pulled Pork, St. Louis Ribs, Chicken and Sausage. All combo platters and pit master feasts come with coleslaw and your choice of three sides.
BBQ Combo Platter | Choice Of Two Meats $38.95
All combo platters and pit master feasts come with coleslaw & your choice of three sides.
BBQ Combo Platter | Choice Of Three Meats $46.95
All combo platters and pit master feasts come with coleslaw & your choice of three sides.
Pit Master Feast For Two $79.95
Includes : Brisket, Pulled Pork, St. Louis Ribs, Chicken and Sausage plus. All combo platters and pit master feasts come with coleslaw and your choice of three sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Our Chef's Special Saute'
Tender Scallops Saute $39.95
Shrimp Francese $36.95
Chicken Francese $32.95
Sole Meuniere $42.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Seafood Classics
Traditional Maine Lobsters $39.95
Served hot or cold.
Twin South African Lobster Tails $52.95
2 South African lobster tails. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
South African Lobster Tails (2) $77.95
Stuffed with crabmeat.
Large Snow Crab Legs $57.95
Two Clusters. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Italian Specials
Pot Of Succulent Rope Mussels $26.95
Cooked in a Garlic White Wine or Marinara Sauce. Can be served over pasta or with French fries
Shrimp Francese $36.95
Jumbo Shrimp In Garlic Sauce $34.95
Chicken & Shrimp Parmigiana Combo $34.95
Eggplant Parmigiana $23.95
Breaded and fried eggplant in marinara sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
Linguine With Red Or White Clam Sauce $31.95
Chicken Francese $29.95
Pasta Del Mar In Red Or Garlic Sauce $44.95
A whole Lobster served with Clams & Mussels over a bed of fresh pasta.
Chicken Parmigiana $29.95
Fried breaded chicken cutlet in marinara sauce with melted mozzarella cheese on top.
Sammy’s Shrimp Parmigiana $32.95
Calamari In A Red Sauce, Hot, Sweet Or Garlic $29.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Side Dish
Macaroni Salad $5.95
Roasted Brussel Sprouts $5.95
French Fries $5.95
Potato Salad $5.95
Cucumber Salad $5.95
Corn On The Cob $5.95
Boston Baked Beans $5.95
Tostones $5.95
Mac N' Cheese $5.95
Onion Rings $5.95
Baked Potato $5.95
Collard Greens $5.95
Sweet Potato Fries $5.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy’s Chowders
New England Clam Chowder $8.95
Homemade Cream based clam chowder.
French Onion Soup $9.95
Manhattan Clam Chowder $8.95
Homemade Tomato based red clam chowder.
Lobster Bisque $10.95
Homemade cream based Lobster bisque.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Chef Specials
Alaskan Salmon Fillet $39.95
Sammy’s Broiled Combination $44.95
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi $29.95
Baked Fillet Of Sole $38.95
Alaskan King Crab Legs $129.95
Jumbo Order
Shrimp Florentine $34.95
Chilean Sea Bass (Fresh) $46.95
Traditional New England Split Open Lobster Roll $34.95
Fresh Tuna Steak $39.95
Jumbo Snow Crab Legs $66.95
2 clusters
Caribbean Shrimp Scampi $31.95
Seafood Skewer $44.95
Shrimps Special $15.95
12 pieces of shrimp with french fries or rice. No salad.
Baked Alaskan Cod Steak $29.95
Whole Striped Bass (Head On) $34.95
Fresh Halibut Steak $39.95
Catfish $32.95
Baked Ocean Blue Fish $29.95
North Atlantic Swordfish $38.95
Jumbo Snow Crab Legs 3 Clusters. $79.95
Sammy’s Broiled Combination $47.95
Our House Specialty here at Sammy's Fish Box! This combination comes with Shrimp, Scallops, Fillet of Fish, Baked Clams, Baked Mussels, & 1/2 a Lobster Tail.
Broiled Shrimp & Scallops $43.95
Crab Leg Combination $108.95
Jumbo Stuffed Shrimp W/Crabmeat $54.95
Fillet Of Sole Stuffed W/Crabmeat Or Jumbo Shrimp $54.95
Maryland Lump Crab Cake Dinner $39.95
(2) Large Crab Cakes.
Single 7 Oz. Lobster Tail $27.95
Twin Lobster Tails Platter $56.95
Sammy's Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper (Head On) $44.95
South African Twin Lobster Tail Platter $49.95
Deep Sea Scallops A La Scampi $42.95
Baked Fillet Of Sole Florentine Stuffed W/Spinach & Muenster Cheese $43.95
Wild Tilapia $34.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy’s Fish Market
Catfish $29.95
North Atlantic Swordfish $37.95
Wild Tilapia $32.95
Baked Alaskan Cod Steak $32.95
Piri Piri Whole Red Snapper $46.95
An extremely popular dish throughout Africa, Portugal & Brazil pan seared Red Snapper w/ olive oil, garlic, cilantro, chillies, parsley and lemon juice.
Piri Piri Shrimp $33.95
An extremely popular dish throughout Africa, Portugal & Brazil pan seared Shrimp w/ olive oil, garlic, cilantro, chillies, parsley and lemon juice.
Alaskan Salmon Fillet $39.95
Sammy’s Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper $44.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Signature BBQ Menu
St. Louis Ribs $39.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Texas Style Smoked Sausages $24.95
A blend of beef and spices wrapped in a natural pork casing. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket Platter $37.95
Tender slow - smoked beef. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Baby Back Ribs $39.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork $27.95
Juicy hand pulled pork shoulder. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Smoked Chicken Platter $27.95
Tender, slowly smoked. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - BBQ Sandwiches
Boneless Rib $16.95
100% wood smoked. Tender, flavored rib meat slow cooked and served off the bone with our signature sauce. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
BBQ Chicken $16.95
100% wood smoked. Juicy shredded chicken in our signature sauce. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Smoked Sausage $16.95
100% wood smoked. Grilled smoked sausage mixed with caramelized onions and our signature BBQ sauce. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Pulled Pork $17.95
100% wood smoked. Slow smoked with our signature BBQ sauce. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket Beef $21.95
100% wood smoked. Tender Smokey brisket piled high, caramelized onions with our signature BBQ sauce. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Cold Seafood Section
Clam Bake Special $45.95
succulent platter consisting of whole 1-1/2lb. Maine lobster, *ipswich steamers, baked potato, corn on the cob and piping hot drawn butter * Based on availability or substitute w/littleneck steamers
Chilled Whole Maine Lobster 1-1/4 Lb. $29.95
Cold Shrimp Platter $34.95
Seafood Chiller $75.95
Whole Lobster, Shrimp Cocktail, Clams, fresh Oysters, Mussels, and Calamari salad
Chilled Shellfish Sampler $56.95
A Whole 1-1/4 lb. Maine Lobster, 4-Raw Cheerystone Clams, 4-Raw Littleneck Clams, 2-Raw Oysters & 4-Chilled jumbo Shrimp

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Brisket
Brisket With Snow Crab Leg Cluster $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket With Shrimp & Scallops $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket With Whole Red Snapper $59.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket With Baked Salmon $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket & Shrimp $42.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket With 7oz. Lobster Tail $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Brisket With Sea Scallops $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Famous Fried Seafood Combination
Sammy's Famous Fried Seafood Combination $44.95
Jumbo shrimp, scallops, cod fish, calamari and baby lobster tail. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - From Our Fryer
Fried Oysters $47.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Whole Red Snapper $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Fried Shrimp & Scallops $42.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Tender Fried Calamari Dinner $24.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Southern Style Fish & Chips $32.95
Cod fish. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Jumbo Fried Shrimp $26.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Fried Baby South African Tails $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Fried Day Boat Scallops $42.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
Southern Fried Chicken $28.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Fabulous Feasts!!!!
The Crab & Lobster Feast For Two $179.95
A whole Maine lobster with king crab legs, snow crab legs, jumbo shrimp, catch of the day crab, all served over a bed of Spanish yellow rice.
Seafood & BBQ Feast $179.95
Sammy’s Lobster Lovers Feasts $179.95
Paella De Espana $179.95
Chicken, jumbo shrimp, sea scallops, mussels,chorizo (pork), clams, king crab legs, snow legs, a…
Our Italian Feast $179.95
Whole Maine lobster, shrimp, clams, scallops, mussels, snow crab legs, king crab legs, all served over a bed of fresh pasta. Red or Garlic sauce.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - St. Louis Ribs or Baby Back Ribs
St. Louis Ribs & Snow Crab Leg Cluster $54.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
St. Louis Ribs With 7oz. Lobster Tail $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
St. Louis Ribs & Shrimp $44.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
St. Louis Ribs With Sea Scallops $46.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
St. Louis Ribs With Shrimp & Scallops $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.
St. Louis Ribs With Baked Salmon $49.95
All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Wood Roasting
Wood Roasted Chilean Sea Bass $47.95
Wood Roasted Halibut $39.95
Wood Roasted Salmon $38.95
Wood Roasted Tuna $39.95
Wood Roasted Sword Fish $39.95
Wood Roasted Whole Red Snapper $44.95
Wood Roasted Whole Stripe Bass $34.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Surf & Turf at Sammy’s
King Crab Legs & Fried Shrimp $79.95
King Crab Legs & Filet Mignon $86.95
Snow Crab Legs & Ribs $59.95
Lobster Tail & Filet Migñon $62.95
New York Steak & Fried Shrimp $49.95
Baby Back Ribs (Pork) & Fried Shrimp $39.95
Snow Crab Legs & Lobster Tail $74.95
Snow Crab Legs & Filet Mignon $84.95
King Crab Legs & Baby Back Ribs $84.95
Snow Crab Legs & Shell Steak $69.95
Jumbo Fried Shrimp & Filet Mignon $54.95
Lobster Tail & N.Y. Shell Steak $59.95
Lobster Tail & Fried Shrimp $49.95
Trio's (Your Choice)
King Crab Legs & Shell Steak $89.95
Chicago Rib-Eye & Shrimp $64.95
20 oz. Steak & 5 pieces of Shrimp
Snow Crab Legs & Shrimp Scampi $64.95
Lobster Tail & Baby Back Ribs $49.95
King Crab Legs & Lobster Tail $89.95
Snow Crab Legs & Fried Shrimp $62.95
Chicken Surf & Turf $74.95
served with BBQ ribs or chicken w/ steak, your choice, and fried shrimp.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Steak Lovers
Real Juicy BBQ Chicken $26.95
Chicago Style Bone-In Rib Eye Steak (20 Oz.) $49.95
Filet Mignon $46.95
Chateaubriand cooked to order.
16 Oz. Prime NY Shell Steak $43.95
16 oz New York Shell Steak
Our Famous Baby Back Ribs (Pork) $34.95
King Cut Prime Rib $42.95
Sammy's Famous Sirloin Burger $17.95
Baby Back Pork Ribs With BBQ Chicken $34.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sandwich Platters
Traditional New England Split Open Lobster Roll $34.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Classic Broiled Seafood Combination
Sammy's Classic Broiled Seafood Combination $46.95
Jumbo shrimp, scallops, cod, baby lobster tail, baked clams and mussels. All meals comes with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Fried Specials
Fried Blue Fish $28.95
Fried bluefish fillets.
Chicken Fingers Platter $27.95
Fried chicken tenders over french fries.
Fried Day Boat Sea Scallops $39.95
Fried Sea Scallops.
Choice Of Fried Porgies Or Cod Fish Or Whiting $29.95
Fried Calamari Platter $26.95
Authentic Fish & Chips $29.95
Cod Fish, the best for fish & chips
Our Famous Jumbo Fried Shrimp $27.95
Super Fried Seafood Combo Platter $49.95
Fried Whole Red Snapper $45.95
Scallops (6) Shrimp (4) & Clam Strips $39.95
Fried Baby Lobster Tail $42.95
3 Fried South African Lobster tails 3oz each.
Fried Coconut Shrimp $32.95
Fried Clam Strip Platter $29.95
Fried Shrimp & Scallops $42.95
Fried Fillet Of Sole $38.95
Southern Style Fried Chicken $27.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sammy's Brisket Burger
Sammy's Brisket Burger $19.95
Juicy Beef Tenderloin paddy stacked with lettuce, tomato, pickles and cheese. All Meals come with Coleslaw & your choice of two sides.
Smokehouse BBQ Buffalo Wings
Your choice mild or spicy. All meals come with coleslaw and your choice of two sides.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Live Maine Lobsters
Clam Bake Special $45.95
2 Lb. Lobster Newburg $64.95
Whole Broiled Or Steamed 1-1/2 Lbs. Maine Lobster $49.95
Whole Broiled Or Steamed 2 Lbs. Maine Lobster $59.95
Whole Maine Lobster & Baby Back Ribs $55.95
Whole Maine Lobster & Tender Fried Shrimp $54.95
Shell Fish Extraveganza $85.95
A Whole Maine Lobster, Scallops, Snow Crab Legs, Shrimp, Baked Clams, and Fillet of Fish
Whole Maine Lobster & New York Shell Steak $61.95
Whole Maine Lobster & Shrimp Scampi $54.95
Lobster Special $59.95
Twin (2 whole) 1-1/4 lb. Lobsters. Can be stuffed with Crabmeat or Shrimp for an additional 24.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Kids Corner
Kids Chicken Fingers $15.95
All Kids meals include French fries and vanilla ice cream cake roll.
Kids Hot Dog $15.95
All Kids meals include French fries and vanilla ice cream cake roll.
Kids Mac & Cheese $15.95
All Kids meals include French fries and vanilla ice cream cake roll.
Kids Hamburger $15.95
All Kids meals include French fries and vanilla ice cream cake roll.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Cajun Magic
Jumbo Shrimp Louisiana $32.95
Blackened Salmon $39.95
Blackened Swordfish Or Halibut $42.95
Blackened Chilean Sea Bass $46.95
Blackened Tilapia $34.95

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Sea Treasures (appetizers)
Fried Clam Strips $16.95
Baked Clams Oregenato
Tender Fried Calamari $17.95
Fried calamari tubes ( cut ) served with marinara sauce.
BANG-BANG Shrimp $21.95
Clams In Garlic Sauce Or Red Sauce (Hot Or Sweet) $24.95
PIRI PIRI Shrimp Appetizer ("Spicy Hot") $22.95
Chiller Platter ShrimpCocktail, Clams & Oysters $23.95
Coconut Shrimp $23.95
Mozzarella Sticks $14.95
Fried breaded mozzarella sticks with marinara sauce.
Calamari Salad $18.95
Buffalo Shrimp | Spicy $19.95
Blue Point Oysters Freshly Shucked, Served Individually $3.50
Each
Spicy Buffalo Wings $18.95
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $17.95
5 pcs Jumbo Shrimp ( cold ) with cocktail sauce.
Maryland Lump Crabcake $19.95
Fresh Tender Mussels Cooked In Garlic Or Red Sauce $19.95
Hot Antipasto Served For 2 $36.95
Calamari In Red Sauce $19.95
Sweet or hot.
Maryland Lump Crab Cake $21.95
Littleneck Or Cherrystone Clams Served
Clams Casino (8) $23.95
Fried Calamari $19.95
Oysters Rockefeller (6) Creamed Spinach & Mozzarella $21.95
Soft Shell Steamers (Ipswich) $34.95
Buffalo Wings & Buffalo Shrimp $21.95
Fried chicken wing sections and spicy popcorn shrimp.

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Fresh Fruit Smoothies
Fresh Fruit Smoothies $8.00
Banana - Strawberry - Peach - Mango & Raspberry

All Day Menu - The Bronx - Children’s Menu
Macaroni & Cheese $9.95
English Fish & Chips $14.95
Hamburger Platter $12.95
Fried Shrimp $15.95
Basket Of Chicken Fingers $13.95
Hot Dogs $12.95
Fried Chicken $12.95
Pasta W/Marinara Sauce $9.95
Rack Of Baby Back Ribs (Pork) $14.95

Sammy's Shrimp Box Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Late-night food
Private dining room
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Historic
Romantic
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Locals
Tourists

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Paid street parking
Parking
Valet parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Sammy's Shrimp Box Photos

Sammy's Shrimp Box Location

Sammy's Shrimp Box

New York Bronx County City Island City Island Avenue

64 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Sammy's Shrimp Box Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 3317 user reviews.

lobstertake outcornbreadislandvalet parkingpina coladaappetizerportion sizesyellow riceribs

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Absolutely floored how this is advertised as a meal for 2. Husband doesn't like sea food (I'll eat the ocean if you let me) so we agreed to the BBQ platter. We ate our fill and took home leftovers and easily ate again for lunch AND dinner the next day. Brisket was tender enough to cut eith a spoon. The hot wings had real flavor. The corn bread was moist WITH crunchy edges. Matter of fact, stop reading this review. Go over there and try it for yourself. We had to walk it off for 2 hours just to be able to breathe without a full belly!!
July 31 · Raminess
This is Sammy's smokehouse now. It tasted like everything was boiled, not smoked. The sausage was good, all else was very bland. The sides were tasteless. The beer was cold! The funny thing was, when we walked up to the place, we didn't smell any smoke from the smoker. Until they improve the food, don't waste your money.
August 16 · Noel Damico
Awesome experience!!!! It's always a great time when you can get to City Island 🏝 💯. The food was fresh and prepared perfectly.
July 29 · Adam Arciola
They usually serve live lobster, but mine tasted a bit off. The coconut shrimp, however, was on point. If you're going with family or friends, I’d recommend sticking to the shrimp. I could’ve made a scene, but since I was with family, I decided to skip the Karen drama.
April 25 · Nazmus Saquib (Porag)
We went on a Saturday around 9pm, all the Sammy’s serve the same menu we chose the one with valet parking. I’m going to make this quick, the food was amazing they start you off with bread and salads by the time you get to the entree you’re pretty full lol. They give corn and rice on the side for free with every dinner. The only issue was our waitress could’ve made it more joyful being that it was a birthday dinner for my bf mom. The photographer that was on schedule that night captured a stunning photo memory thank you her energy was definitely welcoming. Great service either way food came out really fast and to end the night our waitress was more joyful towards the end *side eye*. Thank you Sammy’s next time we will try the other location across the street :)
September 07 · Shanelle Vincent