Shepherd's Cup

- 2123 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Shepherd’s Cup, nestled on Avenue U in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood of Brooklyn, has quickly become a standout destination for New Yorkers seeking a combination of exceptional coffee, delicious food, and a uniquely tranquil atmosphere. Far more than just a place to grab a quick coffee, Shepherd’s Cup seamlessly blends the functions of a specialty coffee roaster, a full-service cafe, a dedicated bookstore, and a community hub. For residents and visitors alike, it offers a refreshing change of pace from the city's usual hustle.

This local favorite has earned a reputation for its commitment to quality, roasting its own coffee beans in-house to ensure a fresh and superior brew every time. The menu is a delightful fusion, featuring classic cafe fare alongside authentic Turkish specialties, catering to a diverse palate. Whether you're looking for an all-day work haven, a quiet corner to read, or a welcoming spot to meet a friend, Shepherd's Cup offers a cozy and quiet retreat in the heart of Brooklyn. The overall experience is consistently praised by patrons, who often highlight the friendly staff, pristine cleanliness, and the peaceful environment that fosters productivity and relaxation.

As a multi-faceted local business, Shepherd’s Cup is a true reflection of Brooklyn’s vibrant and diverse community spirit. It's a place where the simple pleasure of a perfectly crafted latte meets the intellectual engagement of a good book, creating a welcoming space that encourages connection and contemplation.

Location and Accessibility

Shepherd’s Cup is conveniently situated at 2123 Avenue U in Brooklyn, New York, within the Sheepshead Bay area (zip code 11229). This location makes it an easily accessible spot for many South Brooklyn residents and is worth the trip for anyone seeking a high-quality cafe experience.

The business is open six days a week, operating from Monday through Saturday between 7:00 AM and 6:00 PM, providing ample time for patrons to visit for an early morning coffee, a mid-day meal, or an afternoon work session. Note that Shepherd's Cup is closed on Sundays.

Accessibility is a clear priority at this location, ensuring that the space is welcoming to all members of the community.

Accessibility Features Include:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

For those driving, parking options in the area include both free and paid street parking. If you are bringing a furry companion, the cafe also accommodates pets, allowing dogs in the outdoor seating area.

Services Offered

Shepherd’s Cup is a dynamic establishment offering a wide array of services that extend far beyond the typical coffee shop, making it a true community hub in Brooklyn.

• Specialty Coffee Roaster: The cafe roasts its own beans in-house, offering superior quality and freshness. Coffee bean varieties are available for purchase, including Espresso Blend, House Blend, Bolivia Apolo, Burundi Gatara, Ethiopia Ardi, and MWP Decaf Sidama.
• Full-Service Cafe & Brunch Restaurant: Serving a diverse menu throughout the day, including breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner options.
• Bakery and Pastry Shop: Offers a selection of baked goods, including authentic Turkish pastries like Poğaça and Baklava, along with items like Kouign Amann and Danish.
• Christian & Religious Bookstore: The cafe space includes a dedicated section offering books, Bibles, and informative religious literature, often available in multiple languages, making it a significant resource for the community.
• Indoor and Outdoor Seating: Provides comfortable seating for dining, socializing, and working, with a pleasant outdoor area for sunny days.
• Onsite Work & Study Space: Features a dedicated back room that customers describe as a "serene oasis," ideal for focused work or quiet study.
• Flexible Service Options: Customers can choose from Dine-in, Takeout, Curbside Pickup, and Delivery services.

Features / Highlights

The charm and appeal of Shepherd’s Cup are rooted in several key features that set it apart in the crowded New York cafe scene.

• In-House Roasted Coffee: The commitment to quality coffee is paramount, with the cafe roasting its own specialty beans, ensuring that every cup, from a simple Drip Coffee ($3.00) to a complex Honeycomb Latte ($6.99) or Turkish Coffee ($6.80), is exceptionally fresh. The baristas are highly skilled, consistently receiving praise for their craft.
• Turkish Cuisine & Baked Goods: A significant highlight is the menu’s authentic Turkish influence. Offerings like the Turkish Breakfast platter, Sucuk Panini ($13.80) featuring Turkish beef sausage, Poğaça ($4.80 - a light and fluffy Turkish bun), and traditional Baklava ($7.20) provide a unique and flavorful culinary experience.
• The Study Room Oasis: A major draw for students and remote workers is the quiet, calm "back room." This dedicated area is celebrated by customers as a perfect environment for productivity and focus, enhanced by complimentary Wi-Fi access.
• High-Quality Tea Selection: Beyond coffee, the cafe boasts a great tea selection, including the traditional Turkish Tea ($2.40), a comforting Turkish Tea Latte ($6.99), and loose-leaf varieties.
• Cozy and Welcoming Atmosphere: The ambiance is consistently described as casual, cozy, quiet, and friendly. It is an environment that welcomes families, solo diners, and those looking for a comfortable space to relax.
• Diverse Food Menu: The cafe offers a wide range of options, including healthy choices like the Avocado Toast ($13.20), Chickpea Tahini Bowl ($16.50), and Quinoa Protein Bowl ($16.50), alongside comfort foods and vegetarian options.
• Friendly and Welcoming Staff: Customer reviews frequently commend the staff for being genuinely friendly and welcoming, contributing significantly to the overall pleasant experience.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or inquire about their offerings, you can contact Shepherd's Cup directly:

Address: 2123 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

Phone: (718) 502-8196

Operating Hours (Subject to change, please confirm directly with the business):

• Monday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
• Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
• Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
• Thursday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
• Friday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
• Saturday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
• Sunday: Closed

What is Worth Choosing

For the discerning New Yorker, Shepherd's Cup offers a unique combination of quality and atmosphere that makes it truly worth choosing over standard chain cafes. The main reason to visit lies in the blend of high-end specialty coffee and culturally rich food.

The Turkish Breakfast platter is a must-try for a truly authentic and filling start to your day, offering a generous spread of traditional elements. For a quick and savory bite, the Sucuk Panini is a local favorite, perfectly blending Turkish flavor with an American cafe staple. Coffee aficionados will appreciate the difference that in-house roasting makes; ordering any of their espresso-based drinks, like the Latte ($7.10) or Spanish Latte ($7.70), provides a taste of expertly sourced and roasted beans.

Beyond the menu, the serene back room and its reliable Wi-Fi make it one of the best spots in Brooklyn for a work-from-cafe day or for a student needing a quiet place to study. If you appreciate a business with a distinct identity and community focus, the integration of the Christian bookstore—offering diverse literature and Bibles—adds a unique, contemplative layer to the environment not found elsewhere. Finally, the consistently clean, cozy, and welcoming atmosphere, bolstered by genuinely friendly service, guarantees a pleasant and productive experience, every time. Shepherd's Cup is not just a coffee shop; it's a quality-focused, peaceful community sanctuary.

Shepherd's Cup

2123 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA