Simply Greekalicious

- 1274 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793

For New Yorkers on Long Island seeking a vibrant and authentic taste of the Mediterranean, Simply Greekalicious on Wantagh Avenue offers a beloved local destination. Positioned as a fast-casual eatery, this establishment specializes in classic Greek street food and home-style dishes, making high-quality, flavorful Greek cuisine accessible and convenient. They are much more than a typical takeout spot; they cover a wide culinary spectrum, proudly operating as a restaurant, a dedicated gyro establishment, and a comprehensive caterer.

The core of the menu revolves around fresh ingredients and traditional preparations, offering everything from savory wraps and signature gyros to robust platters and comforting soups. Whether you are craving a quick, healthy lunch or a full-scale family dinner, Simply Greekalicious provides diverse options. This versatility is highlighted in their ability to serve both individual quick bites and expansive family meals like the Souvlaki Feast Combo or the Family Style catering package, proving their commitment to serving the local community’s varying needs.

The restaurant has garnered a reputation for delivering big, magical flavors, as evidenced by enthusiastic customer feedback. One local raved about a specific item, stating, "After just one bite of this halloumi wrap, I turned to my husband and told him this is what I want to eat every day for the rest of the summer, if not the rest of my life... Absolutely delicious, little building full of big magical flavors. I wish there were more stars." While there has been an isolated concern regarding portion sizes on certain items and a desire for more consistent service, the overwhelming sentiment among repeat patrons focuses on the food’s deliciousness, freshness, and quality, solidifying its place as a go-to Greek spot in Wantagh.

Simply Greekalicious is strategically located on the busy 1274 Wantagh Ave in Wantagh, NY 11793, making it an easy-to-find spot for Long Island residents. Its prime location provides convenient access for quick pickups and dine-in visits within Nassau County. The restaurant is well-equipped to handle the local New York crowd, especially those traveling by car:

• Parking: The establishment offers excellent parking solutions, including a free parking lot, free street parking, and designated on-site parking, which significantly enhances convenience in a bustling Long Island area.

• Accessibility Features: The restaurant ensures that all patrons can access and enjoy their services comfortably. The premises feature a wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and accessible seating, demonstrating a commitment to serving all members of the community.

To accommodate the diverse, fast-paced needs of the Long Island clientele, Simply Greekalicious offers a comprehensive suite of dining and service options. These flexible choices ensure customers can enjoy their fresh Greek meals however they prefer:

• Dining Options: The core service includes convenient Takeout for people on the run, a relaxed Dine-in experience with ample Seating, and pleasant Outdoor seating when the New York weather permits.

• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: For ultimate convenience, the restaurant provides both standard Delivery and No-contact delivery options, perfect for home or office meals.

• Comprehensive Meal Service: The menu and services cover Lunch and Dinner, with a selection of classic Greek Desserts and even the famous Avgolemono Soup, making it a viable option for nearly any time of day.

• Catering and Mobile Services: Specializing as a Caterer and a Mobile caterer, Simply Greekalicious is perfectly positioned to handle events, parties, and corporate lunches across the New York region, offering both Greek and American Sampler catering packages.

• Payment Methods: Modern and easy transactions are supported, with the acceptance of Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

• Family Focus: The restaurant is clearly marked as Good for kids, and includes a specialized Kids' Menu (such as the Souvlaki & Fries Plate), making it a truly Family-friendly local spot.

The menu at Simply Greekalicious is a true celebration of Greek culinary traditions, featuring both classic dishes and innovative twists that appeal to the New York palate. The following highlights showcase the depth and variety of their offerings:

• Authentic Gyros and Souvlaki: The heart of the menu features freshly prepared Gyro Lovers wraps, Chicken Doner Gyro Sandwiches, and various Souvlaki options (Chicken, Pork, Lamb), ensuring genuine Greek street food flavor.

• Unique Fusion Appetizers: Beyond traditional appetizers like Falafel and Spanakopita, they offer creative items such as Greek Tacos (Shrimp, Pork, or Chicken) and the popular Greek Nachos, blending Mediterranean flavors with American favorites.

• Healthy and Vegetarian Choices: Patrons looking for healthier options have plenty to choose from, including multiple salads like the Horiatiki Salad, the Falafel Wrap, the Grilled Veggie Wrap, and small plates, all categorized under Healthy options and Vegetarian options.

• Signature Greek Boxes and Combos: For excellent value and convenience, the Greek Boxes (like the Greek Box Grilled Shrimp or Greek Box Lamb/Beef) provide a complete meal, while the Greekalikious Combos are ideal for sharing, with the Souvlaki Feast Combo offering 10 skewers and sides.

• Desserts and Comfort Food: The restaurant offers classic Greek desserts like Baklava, Revani (Semolina Cake), and Portokalopita, alongside rich Comfort food selections like Moussaka and Keftedakia (Greek seasoned meatballs).

• Charbroiled Angus Burgers: Expanding beyond purely Greek fare, the menu includes high-quality Charbroiled Angus Burgers, such as the Greek Burger Deluxe and the Falafel Burger Deluxe, catering to traditional American tastes while maintaining high quality.

Connecting with Simply Greekalicious for an order, catering inquiry, or checking on availability is straightforward for local New York customers:

Address: 1274 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793

Phone: (516) 679-1313

The business also provides a mobile phone number, +1 516-679-1313, ensuring easy contact for delivery orders, takeout requests, and last-minute inquiries, reflecting their commitment to constant customer communication.

Simply Greekalicious is the superior choice for New Yorkers seeking a flavorful and authentic Greek meal in a fast-casual format. What truly sets this Wantagh establishment apart is its rare combination of authentic Greek culinary skill and outstanding service flexibility. From the fresh-made Halloumi Wraps that inspire customers to ecstatic reviews to the comprehensive Family Style catering packages, the menu is designed for quality and generous selection.

For the local user, choosing Simply Greekalicious means opting for a restaurant that respects traditional recipes while accommodating modern demands for speed, convenience (Takeout, Delivery, On-site Parking), and dietary variety (Vegetarian options, Healthy options). It is an ideal spot for a mid-week quick bite, a satisfying dinner after a long day, or a reliable caterer for a large family function. Despite any occasional service hiccup, the dedication to authentic, delicious food—as seen in staples like the Avgolemono Soup and the unique Greek Tacos—makes it a highly recommendable and worthwhile local dining destination that delivers big, satisfying Greek flavors to the heart of Long Island.

Simply Greekalicious

1274 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA